Nick2cd Posted August 1, 2013 Report Posted August 1, 2013 I read a few years ago that SawStop was in development of a complete line of woodworking tools. I just checked the site and it still says the same thing. Well.....I'm still waiting. Where are these new tools? Step it up SawStop! Quote
dwacker Posted August 1, 2013 Report Posted August 1, 2013 With the death of 2218 I dont think your going to see alot of movement except from other manufacturers like PM which in my opinion is a good thing. 1 Quote
Nick2cd Posted August 1, 2013 Author Report Posted August 1, 2013 Don, I don't know what 2218 is. Please elaborate Quote
dwacker Posted August 1, 2013 Report Posted August 1, 2013 CA power saw safety bill, more Gass politics to force their technology on the consumer. Quote
woodwhisperer Posted August 1, 2013 Report Posted August 1, 2013 Where are these new tools? In development. Duh! Quote
BuilderBill Posted August 1, 2013 Report Posted August 1, 2013 Just heard an interview on the FWW podcast with their marketing guy, they're planning to put their portable saw out for testing later this year or early next year. Takes time to develop these things. Bill Quote
Nick2cd Posted August 2, 2013 Author Report Posted August 2, 2013 In development. Duh! Wise guy, huh? Why I oughtta......nyuck nyuck nyuck nyuck Quote
Nick2cd Posted August 2, 2013 Author Report Posted August 2, 2013 Just heard an interview on the FWW podcast with their marketing guy, they're planning to put their portable saw out for testing later this year or early next year. Takes time to develop these things. Bill I'm hoping to see a bandsaw, jointer, miter saw. I think the technology is great and would love to have more options with it. A router would be impressive but I don't think it's realistic unless u don't mind routing with something the size of an old CRT television. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Just heard an interview on the FWW podcast with their marketing guy, they're planning to put their portable saw out for testing later this year or early next year. Takes time to develop these things. Bill I used to work for this company who was in the process of developing a new line of products, let's call them widgets. They had about 7 different sizes of these widgets to develop. The first one came out in 2005, then there was supposed to be one a year until 2012, when all 7 sizes would be fully released. Today, they have 2 of the sizes finished. It's now kind of a running joke in the industry. In my 25 years of working in the world of manufacturing the one thing I've learned is that process schedules almost always slip. Quote
dwacker Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 I used to work for this company who was in the process of developing a new line of products, let's call them widgets. They had about 7 different sizes of these widgets to develop. The first one came out in 2005, then there was supposed to be one a year until 2012, when all 7 sizes would be fully released. Today, they have 2 of the sizes finished. It's now kind of a running joke in the industry. In my 25 years of working in the world of manufacturing the one thing I've learned is that process schedules almost always slip. I dont see Sawstop as a tool company. I see them as a company that makes a few table saws. They have not lost focus on the original goal, that is evident by recent their recent attempt at legislation. They have been around long enough to have a complete product line just like PM, Griz and all the the others that come out of the Chiu Ting factories. In the years that Sawstop has been around PM, Jet, Griz, Shop fox, General, Laguna and Oliver have added, revamped or replaced their entire product line. There are some machines that just plain will never need flesh sensing technology like planers, bandsaws, drill presses, drum sanders, and jointers. There will always be a need for well made high quality machines and Sawstop has already proven that they can make a good machine. So I ask why cant sawstop just become an honest tool company and make tools like every other tool company? Cut the crap and just come up with a good well made product line to compliment an already great product. The stuff would sell like hot cakes. Quote
mds2 Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Last check their stuff was selling like hotcakes. At my local woodworking store SS outsells every other brand at about 4 to 1. Why cut corners and be "like every other tool company" when you'd lose your huge competitive advantage? Saying they aren't an "honest tool company" (whatever that means) is biased based on personal politics. 1 Quote
Tpt life Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Mds2 i have nothing to add to this conversation but this. It must be regional. I have never seen a SS in the flesh. Quote
dwacker Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 I own a Sawstop, It is a great machine. If they sold planers, jointers, or bandsaws that were as well-built, designed, and packaged I would buy one. Even if the motor does not stop itself. Sawstop should leverage the positive aspects of its brand (quality and innovation), drop the negative aspects (a money grubbing lawyer trying to dictate what goes in your shop), and do for machines what Festool has done for portable power tools. People will still hate them, but that is ok. People will always hate on the premium brand. Exactly my line of thinking. There is no reason they could not have already had a complete high quality product line. Their saws come out of the same factory as everyone else's and they are good quality. There is no reason they cant do it with other machines. What is holding them back is their business model. Eventually every one that wants a sawstop saw will have one. When that time comes sales will be in the toilet. Gass has two choices, force his product on people or diversify. To date he has taken the low road. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Woah, slow down, PB. "Taken the low road". Let's be fair. I've met Gass two times in my life. I don't know if he's a perfect person, but he seems to me to be legitimately concerned about Woodworkers and woodworking. The first time I met him was for about 15 minutes and during that time literally dozens of people came up to him to thank him for saving their fingers and hands. They all had a story to tell him how their saw stop saved their digits. He listened to everyone of them and seemed like a great guy. People treated him like a rock star. The second time I met him, I was one of those people with a finger save story. The thing people gloss over... which truthfully I don't like to bring up because I sound like a SawStop homer. When Gass first came up with his concept he brought it to every TS manufacturer out there thinking they would love to adopt it. Not only did they say "no", they slammed the door in his face and got on the phone with their lawyer. If you want to talk about the "Low Road" as you call it, remember the big manufactures initially boycotted any tool event or show that allowed Gass to display his technology. The local woodsmith store in Des Moines confess to me that they like many other woodworking stores were initially told that they would lose the right to sell other machines if they carried SawStop. That happened all the way up until 2010! When the big boys finally let Woodsmith sell SawStop along with their tools. Which is not to say I'm a big fan of legislating anything, but this has been a dirty war from the start with the big boys doing as many underhanded things as anyone. Nobody has played "fair" from the start. Again, I'm not Gass's brother or anything, but I see him more like Tucker and less like this demon trying to take away your tools. 2 Quote
dwacker Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 "The thing people gloss over... which truthfully I don't like to bring up because I sound like a SawStop homer. When Gass first came up with his concept he brought it to every TS manufacturer out there thinking they would love to adopt it. Not only did they say "no", they slammed the door in his face and got on the phone with their lawyer." That is in NO WAY true. At the time the technology could not be used in jobsite saws. Ryobi considered it for their larger craftsman contractor saws but it was cost prohibitive for a single product. They did not see it beneficial for a single product line. They did not shut the door on his face the technology did not fit they instead started The Bosch Guardian project which is a collaboration of multiple manufacturers to come up with a system that would actually work in a job site saw. They already developed the technology that is supposed to be superior to SS and are in the implementation phase. These rumors of Ryobi just rejecting the idea is BS, it just plain did not work in their market. Companies like WMH didnt wast their time with an unproven technology. They have net sales of over $700 million a year. They could just buy SS with pocket change. Their sales are more before lunch on any given day than SS sells in a year. It is nothing more than a race for the dollars. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 PB, I have my information from multiple sources at Multiple companies. Jobsite saws were not the question. Gass was and is a woodworker. He developed his technology for cabinet saws. The makers of cabinet saws feared future lawsuits if they didn't retrofit their equipment and they tried to block the technology from ever getting to the market place. The Ryobi thing happened several years later. I agree with you about nothing more than a race for dollars. But isn't that what every company does? Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Woodsap, I agree with you totally. I can just tell you that the company I used to work for acquired a company that owned one of the biggest names in the TS business (follow that?) Anyhow, in the acquisition we got a VP from the acquired company. (This is early 2000's.) I travelled extensively with this guy throughout the US and Europe. He and I both being woodworkers naturally we talked a bunch about the SawStop thing. I can tell you that this big TS manufactures held meetings at the CEO level to discuss Gass as a threat. They literally feared future lawsuits if they didn't retrofit. They planned to systematically block the technology from reaching the market-place, using ... lawyers. Anyhow, my guy doesn't feel badly about what they did. My current company does similar stuff. If you are a big player in the market you try to crush or buy the smaller competition. That's what you do. Again, I don't think Gass is a martyr. I'm just saying that woodworkers often play him out to be "Taking the low road". Or I've heard "plays dirty pool." My point is that in any business of any consequence most companies compete feverishly using what ever means they have. Lawyers, engineers, what ever the law will allow. Quote
dwacker Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 PB, I have my information from multiple sources at Multiple companies. Jobsite saws were not the question. Gass was and is a woodworker. He developed his technology for cabinet saws. The makers of cabinet saws feared future lawsuits if they didn't retrofit their equipment and they tried to block the technology from ever getting to the market place. The Ryobi thing happened several years later. I agree with you about nothing more than a race for dollars. But isn't that what every company does? Sorry that is in no way true. The ryobi thing you refer to started in 2009 (the moron that sued). Ive read the court documents and depositions. My little brother is the engineer / inventor for techtronics that own's the patents for parts of the ryobi job site saws. The idea for SS came to Gass in late 1999. The working prototye was introduced in Aug 2000 at WWF and in Nov of 2000 SS first meeting with ryobi. Gass started negotiating with ryobi from day one to use the technology in all their saws including job site. They ended negotiations in January of 2002 when ryobi decided it was not a good idea and ended negotiations. They along with others started the Bosch guardian project this is where the race for the dollar and law suits started. This is not second hand heresay, this is straight out of the court documents. On a side note nobody tried to block SS form introducing the technology. They just had smarter lawyers knowing that if it were a joint venture they would be better protected in the event of a technology failure. Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 As saw stop is a new concept to me I have a few questions. Has a saw stop ever failed to deploy? Has it deployed in error? Do people see a saw stop as more important than a riving knife & crown guard? Does the saw stop damage the saw when it deploys? Quote
dwacker Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 As saw stop is a new concept to me I have a few questions. Has a saw stop ever failed to deploy? Has it deployed in error? Do people see a saw stop as more important than a riving knife & crown guard? Does the saw stop damage the saw when it deploys? It has a disposable brake. It does not have a high false trigger rate. I doubt folks see as more important than a riving knife or guard. I would hope not anyways. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Sorry that is in no way true. The ryobi thing you refer to started in 2009 (the moron that sued). Ive read the court documents and depositions. My little brother is the engineer / inventor for techtronics that own's the patents for parts of the ryobi job site saws. The idea for SS came to Gass in late 1999. The working prototye was introduced in Aug 2000 at WWF and in Nov of 2000 SS first meeting with ryobi. Gass started negotiating with ryobi from day one to use the technology in all their saws including job site. They ended negotiations in January of 2002 when ryobi decided it was not a good idea and ended negotiations. They along with others started the Bosch guardian project this is where the race for the dollar and law suits started. This is not second hand heresay, this is straight out of the court documents. negociations.jpg Guardian.jpg On a side note nobody tried to block SS form introducing the technology. They just had smarter lawyers knowing that if it were a joint venture they would be better protected in the event of a technology failure. liability.jpg Actually it is true. My source is as rock solid as can be. Dude was VP at one of the major TS manufacturers. If you look up acquisitions of TS manufactures you can probably figure it out. They tried to "BLOCK HIM" their words. They threatened to boy-cot shows in which he displayed his technology. They threatened to pull their product from stores that sold his. They lawyered up like crazy. My above mentioned friend is a member of this forum. If he chooses to reveal himself that's his choice. I'm not going to mention his name or the company he worked for. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Graham, There's a really interesting magazine article in which they try to get a SawStop to Nuisance trip. I'll see if I can find the issue. Quote
dwacker Posted August 2, 2013 Report Posted August 2, 2013 Actually it is true. My source is as rock solid as can be. Dude was VP at one of the major TS manufacturers. If you look up acquisitions of TS manufactures you can probably figure it out. They tried to "BLOCK HIM" their words. They threatened to boy-cot shows in which he displayed his technology. They threatened to pull their product from stores that sold his. They lawyered up like crazy. My above mentioned friend is a member of this forum. If he chooses to reveal himself that's his choice. I'm not going to mention his name or the company he worked for. Competition is a whole different story that is just simple business. I dont doubt that manufactures want exclusivity within retailers that is no different than your local grocery store. But your comment about slamming the door on him are truly false. He negotiated with ryobi and emerson black and decker right from day one and once they rejected him and started their own gig the lawsuits started and the legislation crap went flying. Not once did any tablesaw manufacturer file a law suit attempting to bar the technology. The manufacturers all agree that the technology is a great idea but want it on their terms and not forced by Gass. Thats all there is to it plain and simple. When a change to safety device and product liability is concerned there is safety in numbers. Meaning in general companies get together and co-invent. Gass decided he could go against the grain and be the loan wolf and just get rich. When it came time for riving knives and better guards they all did it at the same time working with each other as an entire industry rather than the lone ranger. The PTI is a good old boys club and Gass tried to join with being invited. Quote
rodger. Posted August 3, 2013 Report Posted August 3, 2013 It has a disposable brake. It does not have a high false trigger rate. I doubt folks see as more important than a riving knife or guard. I would hope not anyways. Yup. Flesh sensing technology doesn't prevent kickback. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.