Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Another dc ?

Featured Replies

I have a 1 1/2 hrs jds with a 5" port that is 1250 cfm. I can't find 5" PVC for the main duct. I'm leaning toward running 6" main and making a donut adaptor at the machine. Is this all good?

It is best to run all the same diameter pipe, in your case (and mine) that is 5 inch. You can get 5 inch smooth walled flex, as well as 5 inch metal duct work.

If you have to reduce, the worst place is right at the DC intake port. The best place is at the machine ports.

Isn't five inch too big for a horse and a half collector?  I use six inch for a three horse, and some shavings still stay in the bottom of the horizontal duct in some places.

Isn't five inch too big for a horse and a half collector? I use six inch for a three horse, and some shavings still stay in the bottom of the horizontal duct in some places.

As long as the run is short, it works very well. I have a1.5 HP delta 50-760 and use a 5 foot run of 5" smooth walled flex hose. It collects everything no problem.

Single stage dust collectors that are in this range of HP are not central dust collectors and should not be treated as such. You cannot park a DC in the 1.5 HP class in the corner and run miles of duct work. It will not work, as the machine is not designed to handle this task.

  • Author

Well dang. I have to make the collector work for now and look forward to upgrading in the future. I would hate to have to run all new piper later. It would be great to just roll out the old and pop in the new collector.

I chatted with the fellas at jds and they said they make that collector with a 6 " now and its all good. Now I'm second guessing this. I ran the math to the best of my understanding and it sounded all good.

Well dang. I have to make the collector work for now and look forward to upgrading in the future. I would hate to have to run all new piper later. It would be great to just roll out the old and pop in the new collector.

I chatted with the fellas at jds and they said they make that collector with a 6 " now and its all good. Now I'm second guessing this. I ran the math to the best of my understanding and it sounded all good.

Can you roll your collector around to your major tools? I have read bill pentzs website a hundred times, and know that a 1.5 HP collector with a minimum of an 11" impeller, 5" hose diameter, and a max of 5-6 feet of hose collects 100% of the dust (fine and coarse). I changed some of my machine ports to 5 inch so I would not have to drop down to a 4 inch port.

Even a 6 inch hose on 1.5 HP collector will not be suitable for long runs if duct work. You really need a bigger machine to park in the corner.

  • Author

Dude this terrible news. My collector is 1250 cfm at 12 static pressure. I did the math for all my fittings and runs for 1 machine at a time. I never exceed my static pressure. I'm gonna close my eyes and cross my fingers and toes and pray. There might be an upgrade in the not so distant future.

Thanks for all the insight.

Dude this terrible news. My collector is 1250 cfm at 12 static pressure. I did the math for all my fittings and runs for 1 machine at a time. I never exceed my static pressure. I'm gonna close my eyes and cross my fingers and toes and pray. There might be an upgrade in the not so distant future.

Thanks for all the insight.

"One test is worth a thousand expert opinions" , as they say! Though, I certainly don't consider myself an expert.

We are talking about fine dust collection here as well. Your setup may do a good job of collecting chips and regular saw dust. Just make sure you wear a respirator if you wish to avoid the really small stuff (1 micron and smaller).

==> 1250 cfm at 12 static pressure

 

for a 1.5HP, that would be miraculous...  Maybe a 7.5HP...

  • Author

Hhh, for real? What's the average static pressure for 1250 cfm 1.5 hp?

Those are the specs on the machine from jds.

I'll keep you guys posted. Blast gates will be here next week.

Hhh, for real? What's the average static pressure for 1250 cfm 1.5 hp?

Those are the specs on the machine from jds.

I'll keep you guys posted. Blast gates will be here next week.

That's max SP not 1250@ 12 its 0 @ 12. 1250 is likely at 0 sp

If you look carefully, the JDS 1.5HP unit says: 1250CFM and 12" static pressure, but it does not link them on a fan curve...

 

I strongly suspect the unit can achieve neither 1250CFM or 12InH2O without artificial testing conditions...  Not to worry, it's just modern woodworking marketing in action -- sort of like HP has become more of a marketing spec over the past decade -- when it comes to fan curves, everybody lies... The fan curve for a typical 1.5HP unit would top-out at about 950CFM @ 1.8InH2O.

If you have to reduce, the worst place is right at the DC intake port. The best place is at the machine ports.

 

Just to be clear, are you saying that

 

machine → 6" port → 6" to 5" reducer → 5" hose → 5" DC intake

 

is better than 

 

machine → 6" port → 6" hose → 6" to 5" reducer → 5" DC intake

 

I would think it's better to keep the hose as wide as possible for as long as possible. This is assuming that your DC can handle 6" hose/pipe, which I understand may be an issue with a 1-1/2 HP single stage DC.

If you

Just to be clear, are you saying that

 

machine → 6" port → 6" to 5" reducer → 5" hose → 5" DC intake

 

is better than 

 

machine → 6" port → 6" hose → 6" to 5" reducer → 5" DC intake

 

I would think it's better to keep the hose as wide as possible for as long as possible. This is assuming that your DC can handle 6" hose/pipe, which I understand may be an issue with a 1-1/2 HP single stage DC.

If you reduce right at the DC port, you choke the collector and get less performance. It's better to run all the same diameter hose and ports if possible. If you need to reduce, it should be done right at the tool, and not at the collector intake port. It is superior to change out your machine port if possible, so the hose never has to be reduced.

So
 
machine → 5" port  → 5" hose → 5" DC intake
 
is better than 
 
machine → 6" port → 6" hose → 6" to 5" reducer → 5" DC intake?
 
That seems counterintuitive to me. 

machine → 6" port → 6" hose → 6" DC intake is better if your DC can handle a 6" intake.

 

machine → 5" port  → 5" hose → 5" DC intake is better if your DC can only handle a 5" intake.

 

If your DC can't handle a 6" intake and you hook it up to a 6" duct, you may get buildup and clogging.  In that case,

machine → 6" port → 6" hose → 6" to 5" reducer → 5" DC intake is bad because it will clog right in front of the DC, at the reducer.

If you need to connect a 6" machine to a 5" DC, it's better to use a 5" port, or put the reducer right at the machine (effectively making it a 5" port).

==> If you reduce right at the DC port, you choke the collector and get less performance. 

 

 

Correct.

 

 

 

==> It's better to run all the same diameter hose and ports if possible. 

 

 

Well....  Yes and no...  It's more a matter of velocity...  If you have a non-trivial setup (say two or more branch lines connected to a central trunk), the trunk line needs to be reduced in diameter as branches are added to maintain velocity...  If you have a simple setup, then you can consider the constant-diameter approach...

 

For example, if you have a non-trivial setup, your central trunk may start at 8”, but will be reduced to 7”, 6” and finally 5” over its run as branch lines are added…

 

Maintaining constant duct diameter from inlet to point-of-use is an easy solution, minimizes design/install effort and indeed works for simple setups... But that approach requires over-provisioning the DC to get performance at the tool for a non-trivial setup.  That’s why spending the $200 for a ductwork design is worthwhile for anything beyond a trivial DC setup -- you get it back in cost/performance for the system.

There is no problem with clogging utilizing an eccentric reducer. Put the flat run down with the taper up and reducing at the DC is a non issue. The problem (how big a problem is evaluated system by system) is that pulling air through the 5" collar will pressurize and reduce the flow (read CFM) possible through the entire system. You gain very little in using 6" runs except that some material can accumulate and still allow full flow through the system. (Also you would not have to repipe if you ever upgrade your DC.). Do it however you prefer just invest in an eccentric reducer wherever you reduce if you reduce downstream.

==> If you reduce right at the DC port, you choke the collector and get less performance.

Correct.

==> It's better to run all the same diameter hose and ports if possible.

Well.... Yes and no... It's more a matter of velocity... If you have a non-trivial setup (say two or more branch lines connected to a central trunk), the trunk line needs to be reduced in diameter as branches are added to maintain velocity... If you have a simple setup, then you can consider the constant-diameter approach...

For example, if you have a non-trivial setup, your central trunk may start at 8”, but will be reduced to 7”, 6” and finally 5” over it's run as branch lines are added…

Maintaining constant duct diameter from inlet to point-of-use is an easy solution, minimizes design/install effort and indeed works for simple setups... But that approach requires over-provisioning the DC to get performance at the tool for a non-trivial setup. That’s why spending the $200 for a ductwork design is worthwhile for anything beyond a trivial DC setup -- you get it back in cost/performance for the system.

Good point here. I was assuming single stage collector without long runs of dedicated hose.

==> I have a 1 1/2 hrs jds with a 5" port that is 1250 cfm. I can't find 5" PVC for the main duct. 

 

Have you considered metal?  if it's a short run, inexpensive snap-together metal really won't be that much more than 6" PVC.

 

 

==> That seems counterintuitive to me. 

 

At one point, Bill Pentz and Oneida both had airflow calculators on their sites.  I'm not sure they are still up, but you can learn a lot about ductwork by playing with the values...

 

 

==> I was assuming single stage collector without long runs of dedicated hose. 

 

Yea, a very simple single-run system can certainly go constant-diameter (ex. 6-inch PVC) and still function OK, albeit sub-optimally.  But even a moderately-complex system will incorporate diameter reductions to optimize flow and minimize DC unit size...

 

For example, attached is a design for a small hobby shop (under 1000 sq ft) that's reasonably straightforward.  The main trunk is only about 30 feet with most branches about 10 feet.  Notice the reductions in the main-trunk diameter as branches are added-in...  same with the branches -- they reduce in diameter over the run to maintain velocity (4000FPM branches and 3500FPM main-trunk).

 

This is one drawing from a ductwork design package.  The design, drawings and parts list was delivered for about $200.  You can click the thumbnail for expanded view.

 

 

Note: This drawing is the main-trunk/w branch attachments (plan view).  The drops (elevation view) and tool connections are a separate series of drawings.

Note: The tools in this shop are 5", 6" and 2x4" inlet -- and yet the optimized design allows for just a 3HP cyclone

Note: This design allows you to run any two tools concurrently or run any single tool with three open blast gates with a 3HP cyclone or any combination desired with 5HP.

 

As you can see from the diagram, this type of design is not DIY....  And while we're on the subject of DIY (and a bit beyond the OP at this point), it's actually more cost effective in the long-run to pay for a professional design:

 

a - firms that do design often credit-you-back the design cost if you purchase the ductwork through them

b - you'll be able to purchase the properly-sized DC unit for you shop's requirement -- with a DIY and/or constant-diameter ductwork approach, you'll have to over-provision the unit

c - if you avoid over-provisioning the DC unit through design, you'll save more than the design cost when purchasing the correct-sized DC

d - a properly-sized DC will be cheaper to operate than an over-provisioned unit)

e - and most importantly, avoid problems with shop DC that are down to poor duct design/install.

 

Unfortunately, most folks approach shop DC ass-backwards -- they pick a DC unit's brand/size/features/etc, then worry about the ductwork as an afterthought. Proper shop DC setup starts with gathering your actual airflow requirements, then getting a DC design that hits the mark.  The brand and features of the DC unit itself is a secondary consideration. 

 

To get a ductwork design you need to:

 

a - pull-together a shop layout including existing physical constraints -- Existing Heating/AC ductwork; support columns; waterheater, windows; drum kit, etc

b - photos of same

c - locate existing tools on shop diagram and specify inlet size and CFM rqmt

d - locate any planned tools (even if far in the future and even if it's only a possibility)

e - send data to a DC/ductwork design service

f - pay the $200 for a pro duct/DC design and requirements fit

 

For your hard-earned-dollars, you'll receive a detailed design package, parts list, assembly diagram and, most importantly, the required fan curve (ex. size of cyclone) to support the design (i.e. 3500FPM over the length of the main and 4000FPM on each branch).  This allows you to properly select/size your DC purchase to meet your performance needs.  Let me say this again: you gather the requirements, get the system designed and then select the DC unit after you receive the fan curve needed to drive the ductwork... Not the other way around.... 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.