modela Posted August 23, 2013 Report Posted August 23, 2013 I picked up a used Grizzly 3 phase shaper a while back and am ready to take the next step--buying shaper bits and using it. Seeing the suppliers and the forums I almost feel like they are becoming obsolete. I would like to know what woodworkers who use both find the shaper most useful. Jim Quote
mikem Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 I don't believe the shaper is at all obsolete, just the target audience is different. A shaper tends to be a bigger upfront investment then a router table. The benefits of the shaper is a bigger motor, bigger and more robust cutters, and can be ran in reverse. They are much more common in pro shops. For a hobby woodworker, the cost of getting a base router table setup can be much less then a shaper, and bits are easier to come by. Quote
dwacker Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 I would have a shaper over a router any day. I have both and the router never gets used. Routers are essentially an improvised shaper. There is very little you can do with a router that a shaper can't. One the other hand there are many things you can do with a shaper that a router can't. Once you have a shaper and learn to use it a router is nearly unnecessary. Shapers with the right cutters cut many times better than any router. The list can go on and on. Learn to use it and your entire work flow changes for the better. No shapers are not just for pro shop, they are for anyone willing to spend the money and take the time to learn. For a hobby person you can get into a small 1.5hp shaper for less than a good router table. Even the little shaper will out perform any router hands down. Cutter are the key. With 3 hp and over you have more choices than you could imagine and if you can't find it just have it made for next to nothing. Any questions just ask. Don 1 Quote
Jfitz Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 Just curious, what would the reason be for running a shaper in reverse? Is that for when took too much off and want to put some of the wood back on? 2 Quote
dwacker Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 Just curious, what would the reason be for running a shaper in reverse? Is that for when took too much off and want to put some of the wood back on? Yes they are magic. Climb cutting and switching grain direction. Picture template routing a curve. Quote
Dominic58 Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 If I knew then what I know now I would have invested in a shaper and been farther ahead, however since my investment has been made no point in going back now. You can buy a spindle adapter to except router bits and have the best of both worlds! Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 24, 2013 Report Posted August 24, 2013 Shapers Rule. They will never be obsolete. A personal fave - The Wadkin EQ 1 Quote
Jasahan Posted August 26, 2013 Report Posted August 26, 2013 So what are the things you can do on a router and not a shaper? Quote
dwacker Posted August 26, 2013 Report Posted August 26, 2013 So what are the things you can do on a router and not a shaper? Dado's, mortices, dovetails. Pretty much any thing that requires a small diameter router bit off the edge.. Shapers will run router bits but not small dimmer bits very well they turn to slow. On the other hand dado's are easier with a dado blade anyways. Quote
T-astragal Posted August 28, 2013 Report Posted August 28, 2013 Shapers poop router tables! Steve Quote
Slick218 Posted September 8, 2013 Report Posted September 8, 2013 With a feeder and depending on work piece size running dados on a shaper beats table saw Quote
Huckleberry Posted September 10, 2013 Report Posted September 10, 2013 My first post, so "Hi!" My apologies for the long-winded post below, but, when I got my shaper, I found it hard to find this kind of info online, so... I'll share my "clueless noob" experience with a shaper as it might be useful to some. I bought one of the often maligned and somewhat malignant Craftsman "hobbyist" (PN 113-239291) shapers built back in the '80's. These have a 1/2" spindle and are NOT adaptable to router bits. I think they originally came with a 1/2HP induction motor? Anyhow, this one has a 1HP motor installed on it and it came with little in the way of safety features. So, for several months, I would walk over to it, turn it on, and then back away and count my fingers. These low HP shapers turn up on EBay and C/L often and I got this one cheap. I needed to to build a couple of doors for the old house I'm restoring and, though I have a router table, it seemed like the shaper would be the way to go and would save wear and tear on my 2-14HP router. So, I gradually accumulated the safety equipment and dust collection attachments and the nerve to use it. Shaper bits are pricey, esp. for the entry door sets. I found a set of 3/4" entry door cutters on C/L and the appropriate bushings and I put these on the spindle. In this configuration, I call it "The Tasmanian Devil", as the stack of cutters is about 2-1/2" wide X 2-1/2" high and it spins like a maniac. I also installed a reversing switch on the motor. Reversing is useful because shaper cutters can be inverted on the spindle to change the cut profile and to prevent blow out on door rails and other such pieces. You cut from one direction, stopping short of the end of the piece, invert the spindle, reverse the motor direction, and cut in from the other direction, so, no blowout. Effective dust collection is important because routing a 1-3/8" profile on a 7 foot door generates dust and chips like a jointer. The wise men on here and elsewhere will tell you that 1HP is too small a motor (3-5HP is more like it) and that you need a power feeder to "do it right" with a shaper and they will assert that you need a much bigger spindle as well. All of which is probably true, but successful cuts can be done on these old clunkers with push sticks and extreme caution and some greater sacrifice in wood, I also had to build a coping sled as the big cutters tend to "pull" the rail pieces into the bit and screw up the profile. In all, using this shaper has been a learning experience. I see mine as useful for door and window profiles in Pine or Fir as well as for dadoes and large rabbets. Quote
dwacker Posted September 10, 2013 Report Posted September 10, 2013 Although those little machines resemble a shaper in some ways they are more kin to a router based on their limitations. The 2.5" cutters your using are tiny by shaper standards so your 1/2" spindle is fine. 2.5" is the max those machines could use. What you have is more so a router with an induction motor rather than what most would classify as a shaper. Quote
Huckleberry Posted September 10, 2013 Report Posted September 10, 2013 Ah, thanks for putting me straight on that. I'll call it a router from now on. Quote
dwacker Posted September 10, 2013 Report Posted September 10, 2013 Ah, thanks for putting me straight on that. I'll call it a router from now on. Id stick with "The Tasmanian Devil" Quote
T-astragal Posted September 10, 2013 Report Posted September 10, 2013 I raise 1 5/8" thick panels for entry doors both sides in one pass. That is what a shaper can do. The cutters and spacers probably weigh 25 lbs and are 6-7" in diameter. So when comparing shapers to routers, this is the kind of things that separates the two. Few hobby shops need this kind of power, but don't go less than 3hp 3/4 shaft. Anything less is not worth the money over a decent router in my opinion. Steve Quote
Trip Posted September 10, 2013 Report Posted September 10, 2013 ==> Id stick with "The Tasmanian Devil" you know, my dad got one of these for Xmas... I can remember him opening it with expectation... then he got another look on his face... then it went back to sears... let's face it, this wasn't the most inspired piece of kit Craftsman offered... Quote
Huckleberry Posted September 12, 2013 Report Posted September 12, 2013 ==> Id stick with "The Tasmanian Devil" you know, my dad got one of these for Xmas... I can remember him opening it with expectation... then he got another look on his face... then it went back to sears... let's face it, this wasn't the most inspired piece of kit Craftsman offered... Very true. Risk-wise, it makes a radial arm saw look like a box of kittens. I added a set of hold-downs and a shroud over the cutter head but I still "approach with caution", even when doing shallow passes. Perhaps i make too much of its hazards, but I think it's better to make too much than too little of such issues. Quote
Trip Posted September 12, 2013 Report Posted September 12, 2013 ==> Risk-wise, it makes a radial arm saw look like a box of kittens. yea, that's what I remember.... it was a scary beast... Quote
lighthearted Posted September 13, 2013 Report Posted September 13, 2013 Great question btw-- I was asking this just yesterday! Thanks for all the shaper info Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free Quote
chopnhack Posted September 23, 2013 Report Posted September 23, 2013 Shapers Rule. They will never be obsolete. A personal fave - The Wadkin EQ I like the picture of the hands with all the fingers in the background.... must be a mental image preparation thing before using this beast pictured above. I can not imagine putting my hands anywhere near the business end of that thing, glad you have a power feeder G! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.