Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Help! Used wrong cleaner on table, can this be fixed??

Featured Replies

My gf recently got a new dining room table (store bought) and used a cleaning wipe on it.  Now, there are streaks in the finish and we aren't sure if we can get them out.

 

My first thought was Murphy's Oil Soap, but that didn't work.  I'm thinking a buffing compound/wet sanding might work, but I wanted to run this by folks with more experience than me.

 

When she called the store, they said that the alcohol in the cleaning wipe likely corroded the finish and there may not be a way to restore the finish.

 

I've included a few pictures, they aren't great but you should be able to see the streaking.

 

Any help/product suggestions would be hugely welcome!  Thanks! 

 

Chris

 

post-7983-0-76424200-1378584722_thumb.jppost-7983-0-44674700-1378584723_thumb.jppost-7983-0-15195400-1378584724_thumb.jppost-7983-0-09200100-1378584725_thumb.jppost-7983-0-75907800-1378584725_thumb.jppost-7983-0-41852300-1378584726_thumb.jppost-7983-0-08908900-1378584727_thumb.jppost-7983-0-75297400-1378584727_thumb.jp

My janitorial but not woodworking background:

"Clean" the bottom in a small region. Try an amonia (Windex) or vinegar cleaning solution because this looks like residue to me.

If it truly is finish that is that susceptible to alcohol, it should repair well with an alcohol finish such as shellac because you should get good chemical burn in. For polish finishes I'll leave you to the experts.

==> dining room table

==> they said that the alcohol in the cleaning wipe likely corroded the finish

 

it's unusual today for a dining room table to be damaged by alcohol -- after all, what happens when someone spills a glass of wine?  folks usually don't finish dining tables in shellac anymore...  

 

Did they tell you what it's finished with?

Iron it. I know it sounds crazy but give it a shot. Ive seen it work many times. Put down a slightly damp rag between the table and the iron. Keep the iron moving and then lift the rag to check progress.

Moisture can get trapped under a softened finish from alcohol, excess moisture, or any other solvent or cleaner.

==> iron it

Charles Niel just did a video on this -- he either uses the iron approach or goes all-in and pores/ignites alcohol... Now I understand what he's doing -- and it sure looks scary -- but It works for blushing and other trapped moisture situations.... Now before trying this for real, I'd sure practice it some first....

You essentially used alcohol on plastic and it burned. If it was moisture amalgamator solvent is the easiest fix. Your factory table was most likely sprayed with a baked acrylic basically plastic.

Agree with the others. Appears to be the wax or furniture polish was smeared on the surface.  Should be no damage. I like the windex idea and simply rewax.

 

-Ace-

Windex and other household cleaners are worse for a finish than most realize. You dont see the damage as much with clear finishes.

 

Here is a good example. A cabinet sprayed with 2k urethane, more chemical resistant than conversion varnish. 

 

The first shot is the towel wiped with windex, notice the finish lifted. The second pic is the finish wiped with lacquer thinner, note there was no lifting what so ever. The last pic is the cleaner squeezed out of a clorox wipe and wiped off with the blue towel so you can see the lifting.

 

 

 

 

I was wise enough to suggest trying on the underside first. I have not had issues with lift off nearly as much as dye leaching. We were never approved to use dyed rags.

I was wise enough to suggest trying on the underside first. I have not had issues with lift off nearly as much as dye leaching. We were never approved to use dyed rags.

My comment was not a response to yours it was just household cleaners in general. Folks dont realize the damage because they can't see it. With that white I could make most people believe that windex has no affect just by spraying on a very thin coat of the same finsh over the white in clear. If they can't see it on the rag they don't know it happening. Factory finishes are so thin the chemicals destroy them quick. Here is a cabinet door from a major respected manufacturer. I bought it and purposely cleaned a section with windex then wiped down with a damp sponge. The part that was wiped with windex is rough and the finish is buckling. I use this to show people the difference in finish qualities.

My comment was not a response to yours it was just household cleaners in general. Folks dont realize the damage because they can't see it. With that white I could make most people believe that windex has no affect just by spraying on a very thin coat of the same finsh over the white in clear. If they can't see it on the rag they don't know it happening. Factory finishes are so thin the chemicals destroy them quick. Here is a cabinet door from a major respected manufacturer. I bought it and purposely cleaned a section with windex then wiped down with a damp sponge. The part that was wiped with windex is rough and the finish is buckling. I use this to show people the difference in finish qualities.

attachicon.gifimage.jpg

 

So you are saying a cheap finish doesnt hold up to windex, but high quality ones do??  :unsure:

So you are saying a cheap finish doesnt hold up to windex, but high quality ones do??  :unsure:

 

Nope. Even the high quality finishes dont hold up to household cleaners. If you look at the last photo I posted that is a very high quality 2k poly finish. The issue there is they spray it so thin it fails real quick, the damage in the photo was a single cleaning. The point is that you dont see the lift off unless its a finish other than clear that you can see. With clear I can claim all I want that it holds up great, all I have to do is lay down enough finish that it would take a long time for you notice you've been wiping it off with household cleaners.

You would think if the finish is applied to thin. Anything applied to clean the finish is going to cause problems. Diluting would make matters worse. By diluting you lessen the evaporation of the product causing the grain to swell. The key is to not over wet or soak the finish with anything. Get your desired cleaner on and wipe it off as quickly as possible to get the job done.

 

Thats just me. :)

 

-Ace-

 

Whats in Murphy's oil-soap anyway?

You would think if the finish is applied to thin. Anything applied to clean the finish is going to cause problems. Diluting would make matters worse. By diluting you lessen the evaporation of the product causing the grain to swell. The key is to not over wet or soak the finish with anything. Get your desired cleaner on and wipe it off as quickly as possible to get the job done.

 

Thats just me. :)

 

-Ace-

 

Whats in Murphy's oil-soap anyway?

 

Obviously you want to dry the surface not leaving it wet. Diluting will not make matters worse as long as you used common sense and followed up with a dry towel. Diluting prevents lifting over time. Take a little off here and there eventually you are left with nothing. Dont know whats in Murphy's but it wont lift finish and it cleans up funk.

==> that 2% will get your every time

 

The devil is always in the details --- Just look for the OEHHA Prop 65 labeling...  Of course, almost everything has that these days...

 

Actually, my wife uses Murphy's all the time... We rarely use Windex on anything other than windows... You're not even supposed to use it on kitchen appliances any more...

 

As a side note: the 'non-shop-built' (read as, gasp, purchased) furniture that we have around the place (mostly Thomas Moser) came with care pamphlets specifically warning against Windex, Formula 409, Fantastic,  ammonia-based cleaners in general, etc.  However, they did say Murphy's was OK along with general lemon oil-based cleaners...  Each piece came with a 'care-kit' -- bottle of lemon-oil, tin of Liberon Black-Bison wax, white Scotch-Brite, bottle of leather conditioner (for seating) and some other stuff that I forget...

If it says clean with lemon, use vinegar. Same pH and much less expensive. Don, I see the same finish damage all the time on doors that are not Windexed but rather have hairspray drift on them. You see long thin failure parallel to the grain where the finish does not successfully impede the moisture. FWIW, not contradictory to anything you have said.

OP, have you tried anything? Success or failure (especially the type of failure) can help guide further discussion.

  • Author

So far we tried the vinegar, no luck.

 

The table is brand new.  < 2 months old.

 

She said she was going to try the ironing idea tonight.  We're testing on small sections using the middle leaf since there's an extra leaf we can swap in, worst case.  Unfortunately, one end is also impacted.  :(

 

Based on what I've read so far, I think I'm going to try to call the store/manufacturer to see if we can figure out the exact finish on the table if the ironing doesn't work.

==> try the ironing idea tonight.  

 

==> store/manufacturer to see if we can figure out the exact finish on the table

 

i'd find out what's on the table prior to trying any fixes...  1st rule, do no harm....

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.