Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey fellers. My next big machine will be a 20" planer with a helical head. I am considering three brands.

Grizzly

Powermatic

General International

I looked for reviews and found nothing. I am leaning towards General International. General Intl has great local service in the Los Angeles area (Eagle Tools).

Any thoughts? Ah ... this machine will get quite a workout.

 

Option two ... second hand machine ... with a spiral head (shelix)

Posted

==> I think option 2 will be your best bet. 

+1

 

If you've got the room in your budget, go with PM.  BTW, you know it weighs about a 1000lbs --- hope you're not in a basement shop -- or you have a some pro linebackers for friends :)

Posted

Friends. What makes Powermatic superior to General International? I am OK with going with the best tool but want to make a good educated decision. This will be a huge investment for me.

Posted

Off the top of my head i know you can get the pm with the byrd head in it. Grizzly makes their own version of both spiral and helical, not sure about general intl. i have a grizzly helical in my jointer and i am happy with it.

Posted

So, am I right that you will buy a new Griz, PM, or Gen with standard knives or look for a 20" with a spiral head?  Or do you have your eye on a particular 20", w/spiral head now? What brand? If you have one in mind that has the nice spiral head but it has too many negatives, I wouldn't do it. Example, it has a spiral head, that's great... but it came from a production shop, or it's really old and worn, or in really bad shape like it's been in the weather....stuff like that.  If it's between the new PM and one like that, I'd go with the new PM and upgrade to a shelix later - again if I've heard you correctly

Posted

Either option with a spiral or shelix type head. With this kind of investment I will not even consider doing it with that kind of head. No tear out for figured wood.

Another way was to look at a used machine with standard knives and upgrade but, as you well put it, there can be some baggage involved and I am lazy and want to be a woodworker and not a mechanic.

 

So, am I right that you will buy a new Griz, PM, or Gen with standard knives or look for a 20" with a spiral head?  Or do you have your eye on a particular 20", w/spiral head now? What brand? If you have one in mind that has the nice spiral head but it has too many negatives, I wouldn't do it. Example, it has a spiral head, that's great... but it came from a production shop, or it's really old and worn, or in really bad shape like it's been in the weather....stuff like that.  If it's between the new PM and one like that, I'd go with the new PM and upgrade to a shelix later - again if I've heard you correctly

Posted

==> spiral or shelix type head

 

​Just a note: Not all spiral/helical heads are the same...

 

Lot's of tool mfgs hopped-on to the 'spiral' bandwagon after the Byrd product got such rave reviews.  However, there are less-capable spiral-head designs (read as cheaper to make) that quite a few mfg's use --- hoping that folks won't notice the difference...

 

So just because a Mfg puts 'spiral' on the marketing literature/website/etc, doesn't mean that it's a helical head...

 

I don't know which heads the Gen or Griz use.

 

I do know that the PM uses the Byrd head...

Posted

Thank you so much for this. It is early in the process and I am putting money aside for this major investment. I am not emotional or brand crazy. Since this will be probably the only planer I ever buy, is important to make it count.

 

The fact that PM is available with the best spiral type ... Byrd .. head is very important.

 

 

==> spiral or shelix type head

 

​Just a note: Not all spiral/helical heads are the same...

 

Lot's of tool mfgs hopped-on to the 'spiral' bandwagon after the Byrd product got such rave reviews.  However, there are less-capable spiral-head designs (read as cheaper to make) that quite a few mfg's use --- hoping that folks won't notice the difference...

 

So just because a Mfg puts 'spiral' on the marketing literature/website/etc, doesn't mean that it's a helical head...

 

I don't know which heads the Gen or Griz use.

 

I do know that the PM uses the Byrd head...

Posted

==> best spiral type ... Byrd .. head is very important

 

While Byrd is a very respected helical head for the small-shop market, it's over-reaching to use the phrase 'best'....

 

There are commercial and light-industrial head technologies that are 'better', but cost considerably more.  For instance, if you happen to have an additional $15K, you could get a MiniMax with a Tersa / MBM monoblock head...

Posted

In the mid 90's I sold Newman Whitney planers with a quiet cut ... that is a whole different class.I am looking for the moment for a light duty small business machine. If I ever move up ... my instinct today would be to go for the Martin brand but that is soooooo far out of my reach that I don't even look at that.

From the results of this forum I am looking at now # 1 Powermatic and # 2 General Int'l.

I am no longer considering a used machine

Plus it looks like the brand of Powermatic is popular and if I ever need to sell this machine, I will be able to do that.

==> best spiral type ... Byrd .. head is very important

 

While Byrd is a very respected helical head for the small-shop market, it's over-reaching to use the phrase 'best'....

 

There are commercial and light-industrial head technologies that are 'better', but cost considerably more.  For instance, if you happen to have an additional $15K, you could get a MiniMax with a Tersa / MBM monoblock head...

Posted

I haven't used any of them, but looking at them, here's my thoughts...

 

They all appear to be the same set of castings, and are very close in weight.   The PM has 4 possible speeds, in two pairs, the GI and Grizz have two.   The PM uses a genuine Byrd head, with the most cutters, and is a different color.  :D

 

With the better cutterhead, and it's easy to find "name brand" inserts, I'd most likely choose the PM.  To me, the GI looks just like the Grizz, with a PM price to spiff the dealer.  If you've got local support that you find valuable, I might choose the GI second.  I've dealt with General in Canada, and their customer service was about a 5/10, on a good day...  I loved my General (not International) table saw for 12 years, but the original setup was not what it should have been, support-wise.  Grizzly stuff usually seems to either work just fine, or go horribly awry, and it's the least expensive of the three. I might be tempted to choose it over the General, and pocket the dealer spiff.

 

My only reservation about Powermatic is that today's PM is not yesterday's PM, or the PM before that, and the brand was very recently sold to a private equity firm.   

Posted

Your comment about the equity firm makes me worried ...

Bir

I haven't used any of them, but looking at them, here's my thoughts...

 

They all appear to be the same set of castings, and are very close in weight.   The PM has 4 possible speeds, in two pairs, the GI and Grizz have two.   The PM uses a genuine Byrd head, with the most cutters, and is a different color.  :D

With the better, and it's easy to find "name brand" inserts, I'd most likely choose the PM.  To me, the GI looks just like the Grizz, with a PM price to spiff the dealer.  If you've got local support that you find valuable, I might choose the GI second.  I've dealt with General in Canada, and their customer service was about a 5/10, on a good day...  I loved my General (not International) table saw for 12 years, but the original setup was not what it should have been, support-wise.  Grizzly stuff usually seems to either work just fine, or go horribly awry, and it's the least expensive of the three. I might be tempted to choose it over the General, and pocket the dealer spiff.

 

My only reservation about Powermatic is that today's PM is not yesterday's PM, or the PM before that, and the brand was very recently sold to a private equity firm.   

Posted

==> Your comment about the equity firm makes me worried ...

 

​Quite frankly, it really shouldn't...  These entities are bought/sold all the time...  WM purchased PM around 2001 (can't remember exactly what year)...  PMs been around about 90 years, doubt it's going anywhere soon...  I bet Tenex only holds them a couple of years, then sell it on to another tool maker...  PM's brand identity has value...

Posted

==> Your comment about the equity firm makes me worried ...

 

​Quite frankly, it really shouldn't...  These entities are bought/sold all the time...  WM purchased PM around 2001 (can't remember exactly what year)...  PMs been around about 90 years, doubt it's going anywhere soon...  I bet Tenex only holds them a couple of years, then sell it on to another tool maker...  PM's brand identity has value...

 

Hopefully...

 

PE companies, and corporate holding companies, have really messed up some companies, too...   Remember Pentair? 

 

If PM is allowed to continue to come up with products like the new bandsaw and lathe, higher priced machines that earn the value of the price, I'm sure they'll prosper.    If they head in the direction of gold painted Grizzly tools at a higher price, of which there are a few, the PE firm will strip out all the cost (talent), and resell what's left of the nameplate.

 

An unfortunate fact is the small shop woodworking industry is not growing, and CNC  for small shops is improving and getting cheaper every day.  The industry doesn't share many sales stats, and a PE firm will probably not share much financial data, but I'll bet that most sales of small shop woodworking machinery today are replacing an existing machine of similar capability, not adding capacity. 

 

In general observation, it seems like an awful lot of the "growth" sales of woodworking machines go to Grizzly, or in the case of table saws, SawStop...  To sell a machine that replaces an existing machine, the potential buyer, who is willing and able to pay, has to soundly believe the replacement machine offers features and capabilities that the old machine did not.  I really think the number of folks who are brand loyal are small and continue to shrink.   

 

Let's hope for more examples of the new bandsaw and lathe with the new owners at the helm!   We know they CAN build great stuff...

Posted

What differences do you see in the older vs newer Powermatic?

 

 

 

My only reservation about Powermatic is that today's PM is not yesterday's PM, or the PM before that, and the brand was very recently sold to a private equity firm.   

Posted

What differences do you see in the older vs newer Powermatic?

 

It depends on the machine...  

 

Some current PM machines are pretty similar to average imported Jet, Grizzly, or General International,equipment, but marked up and painted gold.  Others show glimmers of the old school quality and thought process that made the name famous.  Similar to several other machinery manufacturers, the company itself has changed hands as the industry has changed.  AFAIK, PM has been the only one to attempt a custom paint program...   :D

 

As with many things today, you have to look at products individually, and can't assume a brand name or higher price automatically means quality.   I think we have to look to compare each machine to it's competition, and make our own choice.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 56 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined