Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello, I'm new to woodworking and I recently bought a hand saw at eBay. I was advertised as a Disston 4,5 TPI Rip Saw. Now, I am not good at saw filing, and therefore I'm not good at understanding what this saw really is. Is it rip filed? Or is it cross cut? Or has it just suffered poor filing?

I might be rip filed with point slope and a lot of set, but I really don't know. I'm hoping that one of you more seasoned woodworkers might know

 

Here are some pictures, In the first, the heel is up in the picture. In the last two the heel is down in the picture.

 

http://imgur.com/a/jobMn

 

Thank you!

 

/Oscar

Posted

It's a ripper, with the most set I've ever seen on a handsaw.  The rake varies a lot too on opposite sides. The owner may have been using it on green wood.  For dry wood, you're going to need to file it several times to get the set back down to a reasonable level.  If you try to change the set, you might break off some teeth.

Posted

It's a ripper, with the most set I've ever seen on a handsaw.  

 

Pshaw... my grandfather used to put more on his stuff.  (Fortunately, we've filed most of it away now.)  I thought for years that the set had to be triple the width of the blade.  Now, I use a service to correct my... tendencies. 

Posted

Thanks for the answers!

How do you reset the set of the teeth. You mentioned filing, is that the way to go? Seems like you would have to remove a lot of steel from the teeth to get rid of the set.

Can you use a saw set for the task? Or are they not designed to reset the set?

Posted

Thanks, I'll try that. I just have to get the tools for the job. There's always another tool ;)

C Shaffer: I did. But i didn't understand what I should do. I have never owned a proper hand saw, so at the moment I have no idea what i'm doing. Sorry if i posted an unecessary question, and thank you all for helping.

Posted

Mike Wenzloff talks about a technique for reducing set in backsaws.  Obviously these are saws with a much finer set so I'm not sure how it would work when you have this much set.  Basically he clamps the saw plate in a vise with a piece of tissue paper folded over the toothline.  This essentially reduces the set to the thickness of the paper.  With so much set the risk you run here is that bending the teeth back so far would weaken the steel.  Think about what happens to a credit card when you bend it once then bend it back...it snaps.  I think if you go slow you might be okay.  One the other hand Willy's suggestion of a heavy jointing then refiling would be a good way to go as well.  Oscar keep asking questions if you are unsure, no such thing as dumb questions and there is a lot of terminology in saw sharpening for a realtively simple task.  There are a few good videos on shaw sharpening on the web that might help you to visualize what people are saying here, but don't hesitate to ask additional questions.

Posted

I was not trying to be a butt. Did you edit that last post? I would have responded sooner if I saw that portion of your post. The more the steel is hardened, the more it is resistant to bending. Unless you can anneal, the outer side of the curve now has thinner layers of material. When you go to bend back the other direction, you run the risk of creating a neck when the thin spots in the layers line up on both sides of the plate. This spot is prone to fracturing. This is a crude look at the why of Renaissance's post. I apologize for leaving your reply unanswered for so long.

Posted

Thanks for the additional answers and explanations. It would be a sweet solution to the problem to be able to bend them back to a lesser set. I'm sure it works fine in some instances. But holding my saw and seeing the set I'm not sure I'll be able to pull it of. There's a lot of set and I think I'll snap the teeth straight off. But on the other hand, as I said, I know nothing. I think I'm going to take the safer, albeit the more cumbersome, route and joint the teeth followed by filing. That way I might even get some filing practice.

 

I did edit it, I didn't see your post until i posted the original version and I just wanted to apologize. The reason I did that is that I'm new to this forum and didn't know how the "climate" here was. If it was forgiving towards newbies or not. I'm pleased to see that it is and I'll continue to ask questions. I didn't think anyone was rude, I just wanted you to know that I was asking questions because I didn't understand, and not because I hadn't read the previous posts. No need to apologize to me.

 

Thanks again! 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined