Recommended Posts

Posted

I've got a PorterCable ROS, a Buffalo Electric palm sander (knock off of an HF knockoff I got at an automotive store... slightly larger than quarter sheet but still mostly usable) and a rotary tool similar to a Dremel.  (The Dremel died, and I could only afford an HF replacement.)

 

I use the ROS in the centers, the palm sander on the ends and edges, and the rotary on curved pieces.  Once I started this route, I've noticed exponentially fewer splinters.  (Who knew?)

 

I'd say you're fine with what you have.  If you want to start talking larger pieces/equipment, that's where the issues will come up.  It all kind of relates back to what work you are doing, though.  If I started to do more curved work, I'd need to change the sanding/ smoothing setup I have... So, by June, if plans go right.

Posted

I find I'm able to get away with 3 different sanders; a 6"Fein DA, a 1" Makita belt sander and a newly acquired Ridgid belt / spindle sander.  I hate sanding and avoid it at all costs; problem is half of my "job" involves it....

 

EDIT:  Actually now that I think about it, add 2 more.  A 6" and 3" pneumatic wet sander for finishes <_<

Posted

Ok so now that I have somewhat got my collection going. I was just pondering this ... How many hand sanders are actually needed? I am sure this is just like everything else and depends on what you do but I figured I would still ask.

So I have a porter cable 390 just ordered new. Then I will have a FT 150/3 soon as well - ordering today or tomorrow.

I have my low and high grit finishing covered (60-220). I could always hand sand as well when needed for the tight spaces or rounded surfaces.

Soooo my question is how many sanders are actually needed? Yes you could always hand sand if that's your thing ... But I'm not that crazy so I will use sanders to do my work. Not including the big machine sanders cause that's a while nother can of worms. This also excludes all you people that would just use planes too. Again that's a hole nother area.

I feel I could get almost any project done with the 2 I have coming, but just felt like asking just in case I am missing something?

 

I use two: a Porter-Cable 4x24 belt sander and the Mirka Ceros 6". I have a few more that don't get used. I'm not sure why you would need the PC 390 if you have the Festool?

Posted

I use two: a Porter-Cable 4x24 belt sander and the Mirka Ceros 6". I have a few more that don't get used. I'm not sure why you would need the PC 390 if you have the Festool?

The 150/3 does not do the best with lower grits. So I picked up the 390 to cover that area.

Posted

The 150/3 does not do the best with lower grits. So I picked up the 390 to cover that area.

 

I can see that. I just prefer to use one sander with one disc pattern. Call me lazy. ;)

 

Seriously, I'd suggest you find a dealer where you can try out the Ceros, you'll be amazed. I've used a lot of sanders in the last 30 years and it's at the top of the heap excluding the top-line air sanders that need a compressor that takes up a closet and it's pretty close to those. And the dust collection is great, especially with the Abranet discs.

 

I'm a big Festool fan and have a lot of their tools but their sanders are aren't in my collection, they're too range-limited. As you mentioned, the ETS 150/3 doesn't do well with rough surfacing so you need another sander to cover that range. With the Ceros and the appropriate discs I don't. I can go from the HD40 discs up to the Abranet 1000 on the same sander and beyond up to 4000 grit in the Abralon pads.

 

You pays your money and takes your choice.

 

HTH,

Bill

Posted

I have 4 sanders, all Festool. I have the RO90, RO150, ETS150/3 and the RTS 400. I hated sanding until I tried Festool, and never had a second thought or regret buying a Festool sander.

That's a great lineup of sanders you got there!!

The RO150 looks nice for stock removal quickly. Just not sure I'm there yet in needing such a beast. And that price tag too for just starting out too makes it tough till I know for sure if I need it or not

Posted

That's a great lineup of sanders you got there!!

The RO150 looks nice for stock removal quickly. Just not sure I'm there yet in needing such a beast. And that price tag too for just starting out too makes it tough till I know for sure if I need it or not

Thanks. The RO90 I bought used with a full assortment of paper, the RO150 is probably my favorite, it removes stock quickly and can also be used as a finish sander and a polisher, so I know the cost is high, but it really is an all around beast.

This is a video I did for a Festool Video Contest. In it I am taking a really rough piece of lumber and using the RO150 to a not quite finished but reusable piece.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KV8d15tiGZQ

Posted

I have a 5"DeWalt that I seldom use now that I have a Festool 150/5 that seems to cover everything I need on furniture type projects. I love my RO 90 for shaping and smaller items. The triangle pad comes in handy at times. I also have a DeWalt 5" disk sander (it has dust collection built in) that I've used for shaping after power carving with a turbo plane. I recently added an Arbor Tech Random Contour Sander for carving projects. (Marc's videos have inspired me). Lastly there are times where only hand sanding really works. A good playlist on your music player helps make sanding less of a burden.

Posted

Thanks. The RO90 I bought used with a full assortment of paper, the RO150 is probably my favorite, it removes stock quickly and can also be used as a finish sander and a polisher, so I know the cost is high, but it really is an all around beast.

This is a video I did for a Festool Video Contest. In it I am taking a really rough piece of lumber and using the RO150 to a not quite finished but reusable piece.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KV8d15tiGZQ

Oh wow! That is impressive!! I like that

Posted

Actually need? Depends on the application...

 

For the shop, maybe five or so: medium and fine stroke CEROS, FT's 1/2 sheet, FT's fine detail sander + a Dynabrade or two (don't get much use anymore)...

 

DIY, maybe another five: FT's DTS 400 and RTS 400, the course-stroke CEROS, a Makita palm sander or two, a PC-lp, FT's RO90...

 

Boat yard, maybe another four: 8" PC rotary sander, a big PC palm sander, a big sander+polisher, a Makita belt sander, plus some others I forget

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 58 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined