Recommended Posts

Posted

Ok so now that I have somewhat got my collection going. I was just pondering this ... How many hand sanders are actually needed? I am sure this is just like everything else and depends on what you do but I figured I would still ask.

So I have a porter cable 390 just ordered new. Then I will have a FT 150/3 soon as well - ordering today or tomorrow.

I have my low and high grit finishing covered (60-220). I could always hand sand as well when needed for the tight spaces or rounded surfaces.

Soooo my question is how many sanders are actually needed? Yes you could always hand sand if that's your thing ... But I'm not that crazy so I will use sanders to do my work. Not including the big machine sanders cause that's a while nother can of worms. This also excludes all you people that would just use planes too. Again that's a hole nother area.

I feel I could get almost any project done with the 2 I have coming, but just felt like asking just in case I am missing something?

Posted

I have a ROS , a palm sander and a belt sander. I also have a Rockwell cordless multi-tool that has a sanding head that I use a lot. It works surprisingly well.  I hardly ever use the belt sander, it's too hard to control.

Posted

I feel I could get almost any project done with the 2 I have coming, but just felt like asking just in case I am missing something?

 

I feel you're right.  Trip has done a number of treatise on sanders and may again in this thread, but in general with the two you're mentioning you should be fine.  There may be times when a different one would be slightly better or faster, but they'll be very specific situations and it's hardly worth having another sander to save a few extra minutes sanding on a random project.   With just the 150/3 you're already way ahead of what most people have and can do and you have lots of options for pads and papers through FT.   It's weakest point is the lower grits which you also have covered.  IMHO, you're good to go.

Posted

I have a 3x21 PC Belt sander, a Dewalt 5" ROS, a PC 5" ROS I got for 10 bucks brand new at a garage sale, a Milwaukee 1/4 sheet sander, Makita 1/2 sheet orbital sander, and Festool ETS 150/3. 

 

For the majority of my woodworking I use the Dewalt 5" for 60-120, and the ETS 150/3 for 120 and higher. The half sheet sander is good for large flat surfaces, the 1/4 sheet I've had since I was in high school, and the belt sander I picked up for $15 bucks in excellent condition from an estate sale. 

Posted

As for powered, I'd recommend some way to get into corners that you can't otherwise. For that reason the RO90 will find it's way into my shop at some point. I have a cordless delta to get me by until then.

 

Otherwise, you could totally get by with just the PC. It leaves a good finish all the way up to 320 for me on bare wood.

Posted

You’d better hope you wife doesn’t read this thread… :)

 

I mean it’s got to be at least a dozen, right?… Nod nod, wink wink, say no more…

Posted

Well good glad to hear this. Now I can focus my money on other areas of my shop

I wish I had estate sale or garage sales where people would actually sale tools worth a crap. Mostly it's just lawn tools and cheap wrenches and socket sets

  • Like 1
Posted

I know I have a couple more on my list for this year..  Actually, I have a few FT items on my list this year..  I'm sure I'll post a tool porn thread when they roll in..

Posted

I know I have a couple more on my list for this year.. Actually, I have a few FT items on my list this year.. I'm sure I'll post a tool porn thread when they roll in..

What new additions are you thinking about?

Posted

I get by with:

1/4 sheet sander, 2 ROS palm sanders, belt sander, belt/disc combo machine, multi-tool with triangular pads, and one of those cheap drum sanding kits you use on your drill press. I also have a dremel which has light sanding capabilities, but I seldom use it.

Still need an OSS and a drum sander, but those are not at the top of the list of "must haves".

 

Unlike many I enjoy doing some sanding by hand.

It transports you to a place which can be likened to a Zen-like trance.

Others have described it as akin to how you feel after suffering a concussion.

 

Pay no attention to the arthritis... :)

 

(Edited for spelling)

  • Like 1
Posted

==>I enjoy doing some sanding by hand

 

Just stay calm --- SA is very good self-help group…

 

Remain where you are --- help is on the way…

 

:)

Posted

==>I enjoy doing some sanding by hand

 

Just stay calm --- SA is very good self-help group…

 

Remain where you are --- help is on the way…

 

:)

My name is Dave...and I am a member of SA.

Posted

I get by with:

1/4 sheet sander, 2 ROS palm sanders, belt sander, belt/disc combo machine, multi-tool with triangular pads, and one of those cheap drum sanding kits you use on your drill press. I also have a dremel which has light sanding capabilities, but I seldom use it.

Still need an OSS and a drum sander, but those are not at the top of the list of "must haves".

 

Unlike many I enjoy doing some sanding by hand.

It transports you to a place which can be likened to a Zen-like trance.

Others have described it as akin to how you feel after suffering a concussion.

 

Pay no attention to the arthritis... :)

 

(Edited for spelling)

  Don't know about that Zen stuff, but I really enjoy sanding by hand, It sort of lets me be a part of what I'm building... I'm not seperated from it by a machine.

Posted

I sold off my hand held belt sander, never used it. Same story for 1/4 sheet units.

I have a spindle sander, a 5" RO, and a festool 150/3. May get a 150/5, but not until the distant future. Would like to have a stationary belt sanding unit however.

Posted

 I could see Eric with his two FT ones...pigtail on, pigtail off...pigtail on, pigtail off...

 

Quite accurate and a timely ribbing...

 

I used the 150/5 today for the first time.  Sanded some wenge.  If anything will test a sander it's wenge.  Flawless.  Nary a piggie to be found.  Shiny and smooth.  So we can scratch my technique off the problem list.  I'm gonna try the same pad and same paper on the 150/3 later to eliminate another variable and prove that it's the sander.  It has to be.

 

I LOVE the 150/5 so far, especially with the hard pad on it.  Fast, fast, fast.  Really happy I added it to the collection.

 

To the OP...I think you're set for flat sanding with what you have.  I bought an RO90 recently for coarse-sanding sculpted surfaces, but that's more of a specialty sander.  Not really a necessity but a nice luxury.

Posted

==>with the hard pad on it.  Fast, fast, fast.  Really happy I added it to the collection.

how many times does it come down to the right tool for the job... The trick is the balance -- purchaing the tools you need, while avoiding those you don't...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 45 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined