Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Buying planer and want advice

Featured Replies

I have a small shop with limited space. My project sizes vary from small boxes to large items like mantles, built ins etc. I am wanting to move into the world of milling my own lumber to save cost as well as adding to my enjoyment. I wouln't say budget is a limiting factor but it isn't unlimited either. I plan to add a stand alone shop in the next year or two.

I am about to pull the trigger on a portable planer. The Steel City 40300 with the helical cutter head from Highland Woodworking, the Dewalt 735 both around $500, and the low cost Porter Cable PC305 a little more than half the cost are all under consideration. Of course the PC is much cheaper but would I regret it? How should I evaluate the Stell City helical vs the Dewalt reputation for no snipe? Please add your thoughts and any other things I should consider.

I have a small shop with limited space. My project sizes vary from small boxes to large items like mantles, built ins etc. I am wanting to move into the world of milling my own lumber to save cost as well as adding to my enjoyment. I wouln't say budget is a limiting factor but it isn't unlimited either. I plan to add a stand alone shop in the next year or two.

I am about to pull the trigger on a portable planer. The Steel City 40300 with the helical cutter head from Highland Woodworking, the Dewalt 735 both around $500, and the low cost Porter Cable PC305 a little more than half the cost are all under consideration. Of course the PC is much cheaper but would I regret it? How should I evaluate the Stell City helical vs the Dewalt reputation for no snipe? Please add your thoughts and any other things I should consider.

   Snipe is always going to be !!  I have the 735, I like it a lot, and can control most of the snipe, but no matter what you do, you will get snipe... The cure seems to be, allow 3 to 5 inches of extra board on each end, then remove it as waste, but the off cut is good for staining or finish samples, or sanding samples.   Steel City I have not used, I have however heard several say it's a good planer... the addition to helical head does make it very tempting... A helical head for the 735 cost about $500...  Perhaps you'll get better info from the group here than I can offer!  Good luck!

How limited is your space? A dewalt with helical head is going to run around $1k. For that you could get pretty close to a nice grizzly planer ... Just a thought.

On topic... The dewalt has been rated as one of the top tier lunchbox planers. So can't go wrong there for what it is

I have a small shop with limited space. My project sizes vary from small boxes to large items like mantles, built ins etc. I am wanting to move into the world of milling my own lumber to save cost as well as adding to my enjoyment. I wouln't say budget is a limiting factor but it isn't unlimited either. I plan to add a stand alone shop in the next year or two.

I am about to pull the trigger on a portable planer. The Steel City 40300 with the helical cutter head from Highland Woodworking, the Dewalt 735 both around $500, and the low cost Porter Cable PC305 a little more than half the cost are all under consideration. Of course the PC is much cheaper but would I regret it? How should I evaluate the Stell City helical vs the Dewalt reputation for no snipe? Please add your thoughts and any other things I should consider.

 

This one: Powermatic 15HH. It's not portable but you "wouldn't say budget is a limiting factor" and that you're planning on building a dedicated shop. You're going to wind up with something equivalent anyway, why not skip the internediate steps?

 

I'm not a fan of the "buy your last tool first" theory because a lot of people who start the hobby drop it soon after and sell off the aftermath on Craigslist. And that's good for them, they take a hit cleaning out the garage but it wasn't that big of an outlay initially if they bought entry-level stuff.

 

But it sounds like you're fairly committed to the craft and you have the money. So why not go for the gold? I'll guarantee that if you stay in it for the long run you're not going to be satisfied with a portable planer or a Grizzly or a Jet. The question is whether or not you take an intermediate step in your upgrade path and lose some more money.

 

I started woodworking about 30 years back, lost interest 10 years ago, got back into it around 2010. Bought a Bosch contractors saw and Rousseau setup, $800+ out of pocket. Sold it for $350 after buying a Sawstop. Bought a 6" Grizzley jointer for $350 off Craigslist, spent God knows how many hours tweaking and tuning and building a cabinet for it, sold it for $300 when I upgraded to the 6" Powermatic HH. Sold the 6" Powermatic for a loss of $350 when I finally figured out I really needed an 8" jointer(PM 60HH). Bought the DW735 with tables and base, added the Byrd head, lost another $300 or so on that deal when I bought the PM 15HH. That's just the $ cost, never mind the time and frustration dealing with tools that have to be fussed with every time you use them. I will say the DW 735 and the PM 54HH worked as expected. The Dewalt cut well especially after adding the Byrd head but I never could get past the snipe and the noise. The 54HH worked like a dream, it just wasn't wide enough.

 

Just my experience, you pays your moneys and takes your choice. How many times you want to pays your money is entirely up to you. ;)

 

HTH,

Bill

  • Author

Good advise. Sounds like builder bill has been down this path. The space, a little less than 300 sq ft layed out in a weird L shape, is too limited for the standalone. I could make it fit but would have to sacrifice space that I don't want to dedicate to a single purpose. The path I currently have mapped would be to "get by" with upper low end( what an oxymoron) tools like porter cable, dewalt, etc till I get the space and then sell or trade in areas that I feel need upgraded. I am happy with my PC table saw. Plan on adding a portable planer and bench top jointer, a bandsaw and a scroll saw or lathe. I know everyone says buy the bigger jointer, but I will probably avoid bigger projects or use workarounds(my favorite part of the hobby anyway) till I build my shop.

How much difference does the helical cutt with carbide blades make? I am familiar with the difference carbide vs hss in metal working, is it the same in wood?

I have a "lunchbox" planer, and I also bought a used Grizzly 12 or 13" (don't remember exactly) planer/molder off of Craigslist for about the cost of a new lunchbox.  It really doesn't take up much floor space, and being on castors is actually a lot easier to roll into place to go to work with it.  It does a great job of planeing, and gets the call when a job has a couple of hundred pieces that can be micrometered to the exact same thickness.  If you can find one of these for 500 bucks, I'd suggest getting it instead of the lunchbox.

 

I do this for a living, but woodworking varies,  and don't have any helical cutterheads, but the planer might not get used for more than a thousand or two lineal feet per year.

The DW 735 is the cream of the crop for lunchbox planers right now.  I have a Grizzly that's been great to me but, as soon as I kill it I'll replace with a 735.

My Dewalt and I have a love, love relationship. I put wood in it and it comes out nice!

I have just recently ventured into milling my own stock and I went as cheap as one can go because of my very diverse collection of hobbies and a already ridiculous collection of stuff. I bought a 12-1/2" harbor freight planer and it has done an outstanding job to this point (about 200 board ft to date) I bought an extra set of blades and I have not even turned the first set over yet. It is not a power house but if you take reasonable cuts it leaves a reasonable finish and by putting the boards through end to end and putting back through for a second pass at the same setting you can all but eliminate the snipe. I do believe I will upgrade, but 300 bucks to test the waters, priceless 

Good advise. Sounds like builder bill has been down this path. The space, a little less than 300 sq ft layed out in a weird L shape, is too limited for the standalone. I could make it fit but would have to sacrifice space that I don't want to dedicate to a single purpose. The path I currently have mapped would be to "get by" with upper low end( what an oxymoron) tools like porter cable, dewalt, etc till I get the space and then sell or trade in areas that I feel need upgraded. I am happy with my PC table saw. Plan on adding a portable planer and bench top jointer, a bandsaw and a scroll saw or lathe. I know everyone says buy the bigger jointer, but I will probably avoid bigger projects or use workarounds(my favorite part of the hobby anyway) till I build my shop.

How much difference does the helical cutt with carbide blades make? I am familiar with the difference carbide vs hss in metal working, is it the same in wood?

 

The 15HH takes up about 2'+ more space front-to-back than the DeWalt 735 in the stand, width is negligible. My shop is about 270 sft. but I have room in the back of the basement for the planer, jointer, Kapex and drum sander which get rolled out as needed. I have to maintain a walkway to the rest of the basement and the stairs going up so I lose around 50 sft of shop space to travel space. Here's what my shop looks like:

 

shop_zps25ed34d3.jpg

 

When you get in there and start working it's tighter than Dick's hatband, doing almost anything requires moving stuff around but I live with it. The Dewalt planer and the little jointer had to be rolled out from the back so there's not a big difference in time and effort, the larger tools just work more efficiently.

 

Like I said, you pays your money and takes your choice. Pay now, pay more later, spend your time trying to unload stuff you outgrew at a loss, it's up to you.

 

And if you ever use a helical cutter on a jointer or planer there's no going back. Period, end of story. You're ruin't. ;)

 

HTH,

Bill

I have the helical head in my planer, I'll never go back to straight knives. My models are way above the level you are looking for but buy the best you can afford. Dustin 

  • Author

Chose the Steel City because of the Helical Cutter.  If I have to upgrade at a later date I will have 3-4 years at a minimum.  I may regret passing up the 735 but I guess I role my dice and takes my chances.  Thanks to everyone for the advise.  The comments on the helical cutter made the decision.

 

I'll wait anxiously for my new planer, run some boards and provide my first impressions into this thread. 

Good luck and we look forward to a review of the machine!

Good luck and we look forward to a review of the machine!

 

I, too, will be interested in a firsthand review!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.