Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 I have this magnetic switch on my 110v contractor table saw. I've had it on for roughly 9-10 months. Yesterday I was ripping a 2x4 and the saw turned off. It didn't trip a breaker and the motor didn't overheat. I've had issues before with the connectors coming loose on the switch so I checked them, replaced the connectors on all four wires and reconnected them to the switch. Prior to doing this I noticed that the saw would start but wouldn't stay switched on. I can hold the on button and it will continue to run. But as soon as I take my finger off the on switch, it turns off. It's like the off button is stuck or the magnetic part, don't know the technical terms, failed in the switch. As a side note, I never tried to run the saw while holding in the power switch. In the past whenever I'd plug the saw in, I'd hear a small click in the switch. I no longer hear this click when I plug it in, which leads me to believe that I need a new switch. I'm pretty confident that the motor is getting enough power because it starts right up quickly. I'm wondering if this switch failure timeframe is normal or if there's something that may have caused it to fail prematurely. Also, is there a sure fire way to check with a voltmeter if it is indeed a switch failure? Proverbs 16:20 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 Also, is there a sure fire way to check with a voltmeter if it is indeed a switch failure? I think the fact that you need to keep your finger on the switch pretty much proves it. If the saw runs fine plugged directly into an outlet, without using the switch but using the saw's built in switch, but it doesn't run using the switch, I think that clinches it. Quote
..Kev Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 Sounds to me like you just got a bum switch.. Fortunately, they're not too expensive. Quote
Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Author Report Posted June 3, 2015 I never actually ran the saw with my finger on the switch. Proverbs 16:20 Quote
Immortan D Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 Since the saw runs while you have the ON button pressed, what has failed is the OFF switch or the mini contactor (the magnetic part) inside the switch box, probably overheated at some point. You need to buy a new switch. Make sure you get one rated for your saw's HP. That Woodstock switch is rated for 1/2 HP. 1 Quote
Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Author Report Posted June 3, 2015 Hmm maybe that's why it stopped working so soon. Mine is 3/4 hp. Proverbs 16:20 Quote
Immortan D Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 This one, also from Woodstock, is rated for 2HP. Quote
Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Author Report Posted June 3, 2015 This one, also from Woodstock, is rated for 2HP. Thanks. This is the one I will be getting. Proverbs 16:20 Quote
drzaius Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 Just a note on terminology. The switch in the Woodstock link is not actually a magnetic switch, but rather a mechanical one. A magnetic switch has contacts that are closed by an electromagnetic actuator. The electromagnet is controlled by the on/off push buttons. Hope I'm not being too pedantic. Quote
Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Author Report Posted June 3, 2015 Yes. I realized there are two different switches. I had researched my switch and found a comparison on lumberjocks and posed my question there as well. I am going with the mechanical switch this time. The one that failed was a magnetic one. Proverbs 16:20 Quote
Immortan D Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 I didn't realize the link I posted was to a mechanical switch. Says nothing about that in the product description. I do not like mechanical switches for table saws (or for any other stationary tool). They are unsafe. If the power goes down while using the tool, when it comes back the tool will resume operation, resulting in serious kickbacks or even amputations. With magnetic switches, when the power comes back the tool will NOT start until you press the green button again. Quote
Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Author Report Posted June 3, 2015 Where then can I find a magnetic paddle switch that can handle a 3/4 hp motor? Proverbs 16:20 Quote
Immortan D Posted June 3, 2015 Report Posted June 3, 2015 Where then can I find a magnetic paddle switch that can handle a 3/4 hp motor? Proverbs 16:20 Grizzly sells a variety of safety switches as replacement parts for their equipment. Quote
Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Author Report Posted June 3, 2015 I've decided to go with a mechanical switch. My saw is 1hp and I am not about to spend more on a switch than I did on my saw. Proverbs 16:20 Quote
Joshua Luther Posted June 3, 2015 Author Report Posted June 3, 2015 I did check out grizzly's selection of switches and they are more than I want to spend for a switch able to handle 1 hp or more. Proverbs 16:20 Quote
drzaius Posted June 4, 2015 Report Posted June 4, 2015 I didn't realize the link I posted was to a mechanical switch. Says nothing about that in the product description. I do not like mechanical switches for table saws (or for any other stationary tool). They are unsafe. If the power goes down while using the tool, when it comes back the tool will resume operation, resulting in serious kickbacks or even amputations. With magnetic switches, when the power comes back the tool will NOT start until you press the green button again. I agree completely Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.