Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

==>production shops would consider the a helix head a disadvantage

Which is why they go with Tersa, et al... But we're talking apples-and-oranges... He's 300bf/month, not 300bf/day..

 

 

==>northfield 24" with their helical cutterhead

The #7? --- That's a nice unit, but certainly not cheap -- about $35K with their Tersa... But at about 3Klbs+, a bit much for a basement :)

 

Exactly, I go through a lot of lumber for a hobbyist, but i am a joke compared to actual pro shops. That is why i want a balance of efficiency, cut quality, and price. I assume all these machines will plane much faster than my dewalt. For example I probably average 8 passes on rough lumber to get a board trued. EIGHT. If that knocked down to 2 passes with an upgrade then it would quickly pay for itself. I assumed a four post planer would suffice, but I keep seeing the gib style and i had no idea what the advantages were. They seem few and far between for my purposes. Looks like I am on the hunt for a four post in great shape.

 

Yeah, basement at grade with my garage; however, read my jointer thread and you will know I dont have a huge appetite for moving more 1000lb+ machines into my shop.

 

I wanted to add that a compact footprint is important to me. I have space for a 20" machine thats 36" wide, but I dont have room for those oldschool powermatics that are 8 feet wide for 12" cut capacity.

Edited by Pwk5017
added text
Posted (edited)

Your workload is similar to mine, so I understand the requirement. A quality four poster will do you fine, but I’d slant the search toward a heavy-duty four-poster (say 5 or 7.5HP). The only reason you may want a gib setup is if you exclusively process rough mill stock... A 7.5HP gib planer will take the stick-to-stick thickness variance more readily... The only downside is that’s probably going to come from a cabinet shop with high-hours... So if you find a PM 20” four-poster from a hobby shop, you’d be golden... Hummm :

Found the jointer thread... Yea, a 1300lb jointer is one thing – a 3Klb planer would be another :

One thing, there’s not much you can remove from a planer to fit it through that door... Even with the tables removed, it’s still a big, heavy iron cube...

As for processing rough stock... Yea, I see eight passes from rough to final surface is about right for a lunchbox unit... A decent four-poster would get you down to around three per stick... A decent gib unit may get you down to two per stick... That’s the thing about rough – you get the thickness you want, but it's hell on hobby-grade kit... The #7 mentioned above, Don’s Martin, et al would process in one pass per stick...

 

Edited by hhh
Posted

My 15" Grizzly planer has the segmented (NOT HELICAL) cutter, which I believe is your option B. It met my needs, but it's not a real helical head. That said - I love having carbide blades and not having to switch an entire knife if I ding one. And I rarely have tearout issues.

But, if you're after pure bang-for-the-buck, and you're mechanically inclined and not at all nervous about pulling the cutterhead, I would seriously consider upgrading to a true helical head down the line. Such things are beyond my willingness to invest time - but if you DO have the time and inclination, I would say "why not"?

 

Edit: you didn't mention your planned usage, did you?

A lot of grizzly machines they sell Byrd cutter heads for them that are less to buy along with the straight knife on than their segmented cutter head is installed.  Something to think about.

Posted

A lot of grizzly machines they sell Byrd cutter heads for them that are less to buy along with the straight knife on than their segmented cutter head is installed.  Something to think about.

Yes, which I meant to call out explicitly. However, that doesn't account for the cost of time (either yours, or someone else's) to install them. In my case, time is limited, so there's an higher value.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 43 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined