Pwk5017 Posted September 17, 2015 Report Posted September 17, 2015 Not sure where to go for answers to these questions, but I am in the midst of upgrading my 735 planer to something much larger and more robust. However, this brings up a lot of extra detail questions that seem mildly insignificant to me, but are pointed out as enormously important by others with experience. For example, I assumed the only difference between the 15" GO453Z and the 20" GO454Z was 2HP, some weight, and 5" of capacity. Wrong! Apparently most 20"ers come standard with pressure bars, which I am lead to believe add considerable surface improvement over non-pressure bar planers. Not sure why, but I am on board with the concept. Next, you get into segmented chipbreakers, segmented infeed rollers, knurled vs smooth steel outfeed rollers etc. etc. The list is longer than you would think. Of course, my ignorance forces me to continue to read and research more on the subject, and I come to the realization that the $3,000 spiral head planer I thought was top of the line actually sucks. It sucks because of XYZ reasons inherent to all "light duty" four post planers. This leads to my final point of misunderstanding between the four post planer design versus the next step up planers such as the GO5850Z. Does someone know of a magazine/blog article that explains all the advantages of each upgrade? I want to buy a quality machine, but the world of planers is certainly more complex than I originally anticipated when buying my DW735. I want to buy used, and I keep coming across ancient four post planers and planers that are in the more industrial class design like the GO5850. Please educate me, friends. I used grizzly as an example just because they happen to manufacture a model for each class of planer. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted September 17, 2015 Author Report Posted September 17, 2015 Lol exactly! I think it was either don or HHH who planted the seed of "what you think is awesome, actually sucks". I took the info with a grain of salt and thought, "well, maybe, but I wont be planing for 12 hours straight and X machine will be good enough for me"; however, I am seeing more opportunity for used planers that are the step above the four post planers for roughly the same price or a couple hundred more. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 17, 2015 Report Posted September 17, 2015 Well one of those may actually answer. Quote
Trip Posted September 17, 2015 Report Posted September 17, 2015 What a tough bunch... Last year, didn’t I impose a fee for answers? Maybe that was just for Eric -- Yea, that was it... Hmmm, maybe Marc could tie it to sponsored memberships... But Eric still has to pay... The subject of planers is huge. We could talk segmented feed systems (which are really great), but if you don’t intend to spend $15K, they are not really worth discussing... To that end, we should bound the thread a bit...How many bf per day/week/month do you intend to process? Is this a hobby environment, one-man hobby-come-home-business, small cabinet shop or what? Are you working the machine alone or is there a helper involved (gang milling & segmented feeding)? 3p available? Budget range? Primarily process high-figure stock? Some sort of drum/panel/whatever sander to post process? Are you willing to go used?That should start us going...==>either don or HHH who planted the seedThere were a couple threads like that... And it was both of us... I believe Don's sons upgraded his shop's milling kit to Martin -- I think they went Tersa and segmented feed setups -- so we're talking $20K+ for 550mm planer. 1 Quote
Vyrolan Posted September 17, 2015 Report Posted September 17, 2015 What a tough bunch... Last year, didn’t I impose a fee for answers? Maybe that was just for Eric -- Yea, that was it... Hmmm, maybe Marc could tie it to sponsored memberships... But Eric still has to pay... To be honest I was stoked when I saw the OP because I knew you would probably drop some amazing info on us and I love to learn. Even when it's stuff that will never actually matter to me (like Don would get into a lot), I still love it due to insatiable curiosity and just wanting to know. I'm sure I'm not alone in saying your efforts on these forums are most definitely appreciated. Drinks on me if you're ever in Chicago. 2 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted September 17, 2015 Report Posted September 17, 2015 ^^^ What he said, yeah! Quote
davewyo Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 To be honest I was stoked when I saw the OP because I knew you would probably drop some amazing info on us and I love to learn. Even when it's stuff that will never actually matter to me (like Don would get into a lot), I still love it due to insatiable curiosity and just wanting to know. I'm sure I'm not alone in saying your efforts on these forums are most definitely appreciated. Drinks on me if you're ever in Chicago. I couldn't agree more...plus you never know where you'll end up. What seems "over your pay-grade" today becomes useful tomorrow. And I'll bet that if you took all of us up on it you could travel the country from drink to drink for quite some time... Quote
Janello Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 hhh just needs your current location, your desired destination, if you wIsh to avoid tolls, weigh stations and road construction and he will gladly map you out a plan. Nevermind....thats triple a. Triple h is for everything else. 1 Quote
Trip Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 Let's see now... Fee structure in place for Eric... Maybe we can add one or two more members to that list... Quote
Janello Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 Kidding aside, I think we all respect your broad scope of knowlege and learn so much from your input trip. Don't change a thing...we all reap the benefits of your knowledge passed on! Quote
Chet Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 (edited) Trip is definitely a Renaissance Man when it comes to the knowledge that resides inside his head. Edited September 18, 2015 by Chet K. Quote
Tpt life Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 "Judge Wapner"Savants in pop culture for $200. (Trip's game is my favorite?) Quote
wtnhighlander Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 "Judge Wapner"Savants in pop culture for $200. (Trip's game is my favorite?) I think Dustin Hoffman was just being himself. Five minutes to Wapner! Quote
wnaziri Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 Well, this is a timely thread. I am in the midst of a search for a nice planer also. I was not aware of the encyclopedic knowledge of Tool Savant "HHH", but I am now eagerly awaiting his pontifications. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted September 18, 2015 Author Report Posted September 18, 2015 What a tough bunch... Last year, didn’t I impose a fee for answers? Maybe that was just for Eric -- Yea, that was it... Hmmm, maybe Marc could tie it to sponsored memberships... But Eric still has to pay... The subject of planers is huge. We could talk segmented feed systems (which are really great), but if you don’t intend to spend $15K, they are not really worth discussing... To that end, we should bound the thread a bit...How many bf per day/week/month do you intend to process? Is this a hobby environment, one-man hobby-come-home-business, small cabinet shop or what? Are you working the machine alone or is there a helper involved (gang milling & segmented feeding)? 3p available? Budget range? Primarily process high-figure stock? Some sort of drum/panel/whatever sander to post process? Are you willing to go used?That should start us going... ==>either don or HHH who planted the seedThere were a couple threads like that... And it was both of us... I believe Don's sons upgraded his shop's milling kit to Martin -- I think they went Tersa and segmented feed setups -- so we're talking $20K+ for 550mm planer.I don't know what a segmented feed system is. I'm absolutely looking used, I hate dumping tons of money on new tools. I think we will all agree that tools of a certain caliber are capable of enduring decades of use--even more at the level I use them. One man come home home business! Haha you nailed me with that one. I go through 300bdft a month. I typically work alone, but sometimes I have help. I also wouldn't mind having this machine be something I can grow into seeing as I've upgraded several tools 2-3 times each in the last 18 months. No 3 phase available, we are still stuck in my basement. I want to keep it to 5hp max on a 30-40amp circuit. I'm around $2500 for a used machine. I don't really handle anything out of the ordinary, but I feel like I want a helical cutter head on this machine so I don't have to deal with setting blades. I have a 37" dual drum sander. From what hat I am seeing, I can buy used Grizzlies/jet 20" machines for $1500 and spend $1200 on a Byrd head, or I can step up to machines like the grizzly 5850, bridgewood 508 or delta/invicta planer of similar design for $1500-2500. These usually have a 5hp main motor with a 1-2hp feed motor. I guess that is what I was asking about originally. What are the main differences between these style planers and the generic four post planers? Is having a separate feed motor a huge deal? Are there other notable features that are worth the extra grand? What is special about the bed design differences? All these questions may vary from model to model, but I'm curious what the step up gets me. Quote
Popular Post Trip Posted September 18, 2015 Popular Post Report Posted September 18, 2015 (edited) If we focus on four-post design, your question becomes: why are most low to medium-end planers four-post and higher-end gib? Or more succinctly, what’s wrong with four-post design that gib fixes? Yes?First things first: A well-implemented four-post design with high-quality parts and attention to quality control will outperform a cheap implementation of a gib design. If you see a suspiciously-low priced gib planer, then walk away – with stationary tools, you tend to get what you pay for... Same goes for separate motors --- if something with a ‘better design’ is offered suspiciously close to the price point of something without – just avoid...The issue with four-post implementation is non-uniform deflection. Why? There is slop in each post and the slop is non-uniform. While stock is passing under the head assembly, pressure is applied to bed and the table deflects – this is OK. Because the pressure can be non-uniform, the deflection tends to be non-uniform – this is not OK. Non-uniform pressure occurs while planning rough stock, stock with a taper, passing stock on the left side of the bed, vs the center, vs the right and many other circumstances.... The more non-uniform the pressure, the more the deflection becomes non-uniform – this is bad... So instead of getting a stick with parallel surfaces and of uniform thickness, you end-up with a stick of irregular cross-section and non-uniform thickness both along the length and across the width. If your planer has a digital thickness gauge, you’ll typically see deflection as it occurs - a deflection of 1/64th (0.015) is not uncommon. Note: using high-quality parts reduces the slop in the table height assembly and makes the slop more uniform (and therefor more predictable), but does not eliminate it...If the deflection were uniform and predictable, this would not be an issue... Keep the planer settings the same and run the stick again... But the deflection may not be uniform, which can be bad... You can see this yourself by taking a high-quality caliper along the length and across the width of the freshly planed stick...So, how do those with four-posters get around the deflection issue? You make a 'rough pass' close to the desired thickness, then a second 'final pass' with a slight cutting depth and the column-locks torqued down and stick centered on the table... This works, but requires one or more additional operations to surface just one stick... If you have a large batch of sticks of non-uniform starting thickness, then it becomes a real pain... One other point, the 'final finish' pass should be one stick at a time centered on the table -- more time... There is a more subtle problem... Four-posters of lower-quality tend to have more slop in the table mechanisms to begin with (therefore deflect more non-uniformly), and unfortunately, the slop tends to increase over time. Again, this can be overcome with multiple passes and using the column locks...A gib implementation beds the table more securely to the frame and permits less non-uniform deflection. There is still deflection, but it tends to be much less and more uniform...Since both designs work AOK, why does it matter? The answer is: for most – it doesn’t... That's a pretty important point, so I'll repeat it... For low-volume hobby shops, it doesn't matter...So, when can it matter? If you work in rough stock, run hundreds of bf at a batch, want to run multiple sticks in parallel (gang milling), vary the position of the sticks on the table to even-out knife use, etc. For example: Say you’ve got 100bf of rough Hard Maple to process (this is today’s task in my shop) and want the first pass to be 17/16th (my goal). With rough stock, you have about twenty-thirty sticks which range in thickness from about 17/16 to about 20/16 with a few outliers... A four-poster would probably require several passes with each stick to get your there... With a gib setup, just punch-in 27mm and feed the stock... With segmented feed, just stuff as many sticks in parallel as you can fit on the table... So, with a gib setup, you can process the twenty-thirty sticks in 7-15 total feeds (two or three sticks in parallel per feed)... With a four-poster, it's probably between 40 and 80 feeds -- that's a lot more work... Again, for a hobby shop, who cares? But when time is money, it would accumulate in a production environment...In a shop that only processes rough stock, it maybe worth it... maybe... If you process 300bf/month and all of it's rough and you pay a helper... maybe you'd save a few hours per month... but if you keep the planer for 20 years?Why a separate feed motor? Primarily improves performance when processing rough stock... With a single motor design, the power tapped from the cutterhead varies as the stick is processed and can adversely affect planning. Does this matter? For you and me, no. If you’re a flooring contractor processing hundreds of rough sticks a day... Yes... The other case is variable feed rate... Some implementations allow the operator quickly vary the feed rate over a wider range to optimize planning performance. Again, more for a production environment. I really don't see this one paying-out for a hobby shop at all... Why a helical head? If you can’t afford one of the disposable systems, then a true helical head makes a lot of sense in a planer. Notice I say ‘helical’ and not ‘segmented’, ‘spiral’, et al... A true helical (e.g. Byrd) is of utility. The ‘sounds like helical, but not really helical’ is riding helical’s hype cycle... Hope some of this helps... Edited September 18, 2015 by hhh 3 Quote
Vyrolan Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 Trip's response basically says to me that a 4-poster is fine, but quality is still relevant, and if I want to spend more expecting better performance and/or user exeprience, spend that extra on true helical head.Great info as always Trip...thanks for the insight. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted September 18, 2015 Author Report Posted September 18, 2015 Yes, very helpful. One, I finally learned what the other style of planer is called--gib! Also, thank you for the explanation behind lower end planer designs versus the top shelf models. When do you start to get away from substantive non-uniform deflection? The euro models? Ok, separate feed motors are negligible additions then? Do gib bed planers typically have better quality cut/feed? Are the chipbreakers better? Infeed/outfeed rollers better? Yes, without a question I was going for a true helical head with the byrd. I didn't know other generic options existed for a retrofit? Would you rather game:I realize you might not be intimately familiar with all machines, but would you rather buy a usedA) buy a used straight knife G1033/G454 for around $1200 then upgrade it with a byrd head2) cant use b without it turning into an emoji... buy a used G1033z with the grizzly version of the byrd, not their silver spiral head for $2000C) buy a straight knife G5850, Delta DC-580, Bridgewood 508 for $2000-2500 and retro it with a byrd 3-6 months down the road.D) buy a SCMI or some other euro 20" planer at auction with a 3phase motor and retro new motor and byrd head..probably to the tune of $2500 if I can pick up the machine for less than a grand. Quite a few IF's in scenario D, but it could be possible. I am leaning towards B and C. All scenarios are using numbers and machines that have come and gone in the last 3-4 months, and machines that are currently for sale. Quote
TheFatBaron Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 (edited) My 15" Grizzly planer has the segmented (NOT HELICAL) cutter, which I believe is your option B. It met my needs, but it's not a real helical head. That said - I love having carbide blades and not having to switch an entire knife if I ding one. And I rarely have tearout issues.But, if you're after pure bang-for-the-buck, and you're mechanically inclined and not at all nervous about pulling the cutterhead, I would seriously consider upgrading to a true helical head down the line. Such things are beyond my willingness to invest time - but if you DO have the time and inclination, I would say "why not"? Edit: you didn't mention your planned usage, did you? Edited September 18, 2015 by TheFatBaron Quote
Pwk5017 Posted September 18, 2015 Author Report Posted September 18, 2015 Yeah, I most likely wouldn't be doing the cutterhead swap myself. I leave that crap to the pros--cost me $250-300 or something close to it and save myself the complete PITA. Also, it would be done right, which I cant say the same for my own workmanship. Planned usage is about 300bdft a month. It isn't a ton of lumber, but I usually turn my planer on 2-3 times a month to chew through that amount, so we are talking more work than what the dw735 was designed to do. Like I mentioned, I have upgraded my jointer 3 times in the last 15 months-- 6 to 8 to now 12. My table saw was upgraded 3 times in 18 months--dewalt benchtop to delta contractor to unisaw. Every new addition from here on out needs to last me atleast a year before being swapped out for something else! Moving all these tools and reorganizing the shop is annoying. It is why I held out for the best/biggest drum sander I could fit, because I knew I would outgrow a 24" dual drum model in a second. The dewalt 735 is a great planer, but I don't want to go to a 15" and find it isn't that impressive, then to a 20" four post, and then end up with a 20" gib 12 months from now. They really aren't that far off in price. Quote
Trip Posted September 18, 2015 Report Posted September 18, 2015 I’d love to say, “Option X is the best”... But I can’t... Sorry...First of all, I’ve got no experience with Grizzly kit... None...Second, so much valuation of used gear depends on usage... On one hand, you can find amazing deals on high-quality low-hour hobbyist gear... I've seen the 20" PM planer for $1900 bucks... But on the other hand, you find cabinet shops that run their kit into the ground, and then dump it. The unit may look clean and well maintained, but could easily have 10K hours on it and is at end-of-life... That same 20" PM planer from a cabinet shop maybe $1500, but I wouldn't touch it...Couple points for consideration...Is the unit still in production (most companies’ stock parts to end-of-life plus three years)? If a unit was discontinued 10 years ago, I’d stay away unless you’re quite handy.I’d be careful of phase swaps – the motor is easy, it’s the controls that could be a problem...Also, some gear uses funky motor mounts... It’s why some used kit is so favorably priced – parts are unavailable and/or the motor mount is funky... Make sure you check that out...Does Byrd sell the head with bearings installed for any of the used units you’re looking at?If you see a used unit you like, seek input on that exact model from folks who have one...Your usage at 300bf/month or 100bf per batch usage? A good-quality four-poster would be AOK... But if that 300bf is all rough stock, you might be happier with a gib setup... If your usage plans to climb to 500bf/month rough, then I’d look past the four-poster... If you intend to process primarily S2S, then a four-poster should be fine – I’d put the money into a good head...One thing, 20” gib jointers weigh in excess of 1Klbs – you’re in a basement? Quote
andrew-in-austin Posted September 19, 2015 Report Posted September 19, 2015 Some production shops would consider the a helix head a a disadvantage as their cut capacity per run is lower than regular heads. Probably not an issue for you unless you want to take off a big chunk at a time. My dream planer would be a northfield 24" with their helical cutterhead (different from a helix head). However I have a 4 post 20" and am very satisfied with it. I upgrade from a lunchbox and their is no comparison between the two. Quote
Trip Posted September 19, 2015 Report Posted September 19, 2015 (edited) ==>production shops would consider the a helix head a disadvantageWhich is why they go with Tersa, et al... But we're talking apples-and-oranges... He's 300bf/month, not 300bf/day.. ==>northfield 24" with their helical cutterheadThe #7? --- That's a nice unit, but certainly not cheap -- about $35K with Terminus (Tersa) setup... But at about 3Klbs+, a bit much for a basement Edited September 19, 2015 by hhh Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.