Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Water-Based/Borne Topcoat Survey

Featured Replies

I have another thread on here about sanding a bar top I built in my basement made of birch ply (pictures attached). I plan on gel staining it. It is already built in a fairly enclosed sub-level basement and I would like to avoid the fumes of an oil based topcoat because my wife is pregnant. Spraying is not an option as I don’t have the equipment, experience, and the surrounding room has already been renovated, painted, and furnished. The other issue is that the bar is fairly big…10 feet in length with a total finishing surface area of 100 square feet….and from what I’ve read, most water-based tops typically dry faster than I might be able to work on this.

I’ve been googling all week to find a topcoat product that can be:

- Brushed or Rolled
- Durable Enough for a Bar Top
- Apply Over Dewaxed Shellac
- Dry Slow Enough for a Large Application
- Can be Thinned/Extended
- Resists Water Stains
- Resists Wine/Liquor Stains
- Resists Vinegar Stains
- Resists Coffee Stains
- Resists Cold Bottle Marks
- Resists Hot Coffee Cup Marks
- Resists Most Household Cleaners

After a week of internet only research, below is a list of contenders that I came up with strictly using tech data. Does anyone have any experience with any of these to say whether or not they would be a topcoat solution for my situation?

- GF High Perf
- Zar Ultra Max
- Target EM2000wvx
- CrystaLac Poly Oxide or Super Premium
- Deft Interior Clear Wood Finish Waterborne Acrylic
- Endure-2K Two-Component Waterborne Floor Finish

I have the tech data sheets for all of them for reference.

Thanks,
Evan
 

Bar 1.JPG

Bar 2.JPG

Bar 3.JPG

I have been using water bourne finishes for over 25 years. Very few of them need to be thinned/extended. If they are thinned it is with teaspoons of distilled water at most. The best thing you can do is use a waterbased sanding sealer especially if you are brushing /rolling. Use as few strokes as possible, resist going back and keep playing with it. You will create bubbles and foam. 

Water based sanding sealer usually dries fairly quick and is easy to sand, then you can apply another coat until you have built a smooth base to start putting top coats on. Sanding the top coats is not easy. They must dry longer and they load up your abrasive fairly quick. Lots of brands claim they are self sealing and you only need the finish coat product to do both seal and finish coats. It will work but it is a lot more work and frustration. I strongly recommend using a product that has a compatible sanding sealer !

HVLP spraying is the best way to finish with water bourne finishes. Turbine type provide warm air and the finish dries quicker.

As to which finish on your list to use I can't be of much help. I spray a Pre catalyzed Acrylic finish that is usually not sold to the public, Agualente  by M L Campbell. I have done plenty of foam brush touch up and spot finishing coats and it takes a lot longer to achieve a decent finish that way. It holds up pretty well on tabletops and bars. I have heard good,things about General Finishes water based finishes and stains & dyes but haven't taken the time to try them out yet.

DeWaxed Shellac is a fine base or barrier coat over stains & dyes. Thin coats  work much better.

Good Luck !

I am with wdwerker in that spraying is the best way to apply. If you are not in the market for purchasing a sprayer, you can find them at rental yards and paint suppliers often rent them as well. 

If you have a Sherwin Williams, ML Campbell, or any other finish/paint supplier in your area, I think you may be overlooking one of your greatest resources. They are usually pretty sharp on product knowledge, they have product on hand, and they often rent spray equipment too. 

I hate ordering product that has to be shipped in, I have had it damaged in transit and it just kills the job. I try to buy local if at all possible since it reduces/eliminates a weak link in the chain of events of a project. 

Yes, if you spray, you will have to mask the wall off. I do it all the time as a contractor as I often do at least a final coat of finish or paint in place. But with an HVLP it is not bad. 

 

  • Author

Guys...I hear you about the spraying, and am in agreement.  As much as I appreciate the advice and direction with sprayers...buying a sprayer is not an option right now.  And even if it was affordable to rent one, could I spray in my basement with the bar already assembled, assembled onto stock cabinets that are already finished, and without affecting the rest of the room....painted walls and ceiling, finished floors, new light fixtures installed.  And with me having no experience spraying? 

What is the realistic outcome of the spraying for me?

...or should I just brush it?

Mike.....Would you use the GF High Perf over the Bona?  I only know Bona products as floor cleaning ones.  I did speak to a rep at GF earlier today that gave me a lot of confidence in the High Perf for the project.  He also suggested NOT using dewaxed shellac as a sealcoat with the High Perf, as he said that would add potential for de-lamination of the topcoat down the road.  Thoughts?

25 minutes ago, Evanmac said:

Guys...I hear you about the spraying, and am in agreement.  As much as I appreciate the advice and direction with sprayers...buying a sprayer is not an option right now.  Is it possible to rent one?  And even if it was, could I spray in my basement with the bar already assembled, assembled onto stock cabinets that are already finished, and without affecting the rest of the room....painted walls and ceiling, finished floors, new light fixtures installed.  And with me having no experience spraying? 

What is the realistic outcome of the spraying for me?

...or should I just brush it?

You know, I had been second guessing that myself after I posted and Mike made his post.

One of the tough things is that if you have vertical surfaces to spray, it may be a disaster for you. 

As far as overspray, I still do finish work in houses and rooms with people living in them. (That being furniture is still in the room, not necessarily people standing in the room.) I do cover everything with drop cloths but the HVLP does a pretty nice job of not fogging the room.

For the areas that are broken up, you can finish in sections. For large, unbroken surfaces, you will need to have your game face on and move! It helps to have a good game plan. 

It might help to have someone on both sides of the bar. You could get the top but let the person on the far side take care of the far edge for you. If you get product hanging on the bottom, I keep a wet rag handy to dampen my finger, then I can do a quick swipe while it is wet, the excess material is removed, the product on the surface will level out and "heal" and I can keep moving. 

If your first coat is not as nice as you want, I don't sweat it, I let it dry, sand, adjust my game plan, and go at it again. 

You will learn a lot from the first coat and you can usually get it better on the next one. 

 

 

Here is a job that I pre-primed and painted one coat, installed, puttied and caulked, then finished in place with the HVLP.

You can even see where I test sprayed on the protected wall. I had drop cloths over the furniture, but did not tent off the large living room opening to the dining room and I had no issues with the overspray drifting with latex paint. 

Spraying is a good choice for eliminating disruption of the stain. 

If you were able to get a sprayer from someplace like Sherwin or another paint dealer, they would be able to guide you on setting up the gun and using it. Then you could try it on a test surface. 

You're just gonna need to make the call of which way to go. 

 

IMG_1463.jpg

  • Author

Mike...thanks for all the tips.  I'd probably rule out the floor finish then....I'm sure if it was worthy, it would be more popular than the GF High Perf.  And I plan on using a sample board that I have in the garage as a test bed to divide into sections for trying without shellac, with, and with glaze.

Todd....I'm really apprehensive about the spraying. Having never done it before I can't really have a game plan or get a game face on without ever having played that game.  I appreciate you explaining the steps, but to be honest, I wasn't even able to follow them or understand some of the terms.  My only experience with a compressor is with nail guns and inflating tires.  So I think as much as it might be an easier application....that is if everything goes well and smooth.  If it doesn't, this could be a nightmare, and I have so much invested in this already to screw it up.

Evan - the reference to having you game face on was for the choice of brushing on the finish because of the dragging issues, it just means you have to keep moving. 

If I was brushing your project I would do this: 

brush the underside and edges of the surfaces first. Anything that rolls over onto the top just do a quick wipe with the finger to keep it from being a thick edge of material. 

At this time, you could finish the inside of the cubbies I see under the bar. 

After the edges have dried, you can finish the top and this will allow you to FOCUS on the top.

Pick the direction of work that feels most comfortable for you because it will allow you to move faster. 

As you finish the top, now anything that you brush over the edge, you can feather it out over the edge, but since it is already sealed, you are not focusing on finishing it at the same time as the top. 

Does this help?

 

For the vertical panels under the bar, you can focus on doing just the internal panel and recessed area and then stopping. 

Once again, allow it to dry, then do the outer frame area. What this strategy does is allows you to break up the finishing process so that you are not running fresh finish onto areas that are tacky and cause dragging. 

The recessed and raised areas of your project allow for a natural breaking point in the finish so you can do an area, let it dry, then do the surrounding area so that anything that goes over the edge can either be blended without disturbing the previous surface or the excess wiped off without disturbing the previous surface. 

  • Author

Ohhhh....you see Todd, that's how clueless and a deer in head lights I was with having spraying locked in my mind....

You went way beyond what I would ever thought I would get help wise...thank you so much! You completely just mapped out the entire job for me and in a step-by-step way that makes sense and sounds very simple.  I really appreciate you taking the time for that and alleviating so much of the strategy and brain work on this for me.

Thanks again!

Evan - You bet man, glad it helped. 

With brushing, there is simply an issue created when you overlap the brush and product onto an area that has been brushed only minutes before and it is tacky, but not dry enough to keep from getting drag marks. 

So you have to develop a strategy that will allow you to do an area, take advantage of the natural breaks in the project to let it dry and then come back and do the surrounding area. 

Spraying just doesn't have that issue, but it has it's own potential challenges. 

Evan, one more key piece of advice on finishes, especially for brushing: trust the product to level out. You apply it, brush it even, then leave it alone.

If you keep brushing it 2 problems arise:

1 - you won't be making the progress that you need in order to keep working a wet edge  

2 - you will cause it to have more brush marks because you aren't leaving it alone to settle out.

Pretty much all finishes will level out reasonably well if you get it on, move on, and leave it alone.  

  • Author

Ok, note taken, thanks.  I watched a youtube video that General Finishes put out.  The rep used a painter's pad (with a nylon bootie on it) for large surfaces to make less swipes and covering a large area at one time (below).  It seemed to make sense.  I also saw another video that someone used a thin weenie foam roller.  I'll have to do some testing with a few different things to see what will work best.

 

1 minute ago, Evanmac said:

Ok, note taken, thanks.  I watched a youtube video that General Finishes put out.  The rep used a painter's pad (with a nylon bootie on it) for large surfaces to make less swipes and covering a large area at one time (below).  It seemed to make sense.  I also saw another video that someone used a thin weenie foam roller.  I'll have to do some testing with a few different things to see what will work best.

 

You got the right idea, do some testing...but not on the project!

  • Author

i bought a couple of extra pieces of the birch ply....sanded it all down the exact way I sanded the actual project, divided it into the areas I'll be testing various methods and labeled each area.  Once I kick this flu I'll be down there testing.

I've tried foam rollers as well as  small nap rollers and I botched more than i gained with it. I personally have found sticking to a good brush for the oil/water based clear you using to be the best approach. Hitting the surface with sand paper between coats especially with water based is a must.

Hope you feel better soon.

I think that a good brush is your best bet for the areas that are broken up. A larger brush for the big surface area of the top or an applicator pad might be ok for that. But I would say a roller of any sort probably not going to work for you. 

I hate to be that guy, but....but, what about having someone out to do the job of finishing this wonderful creation for you? If you never pulled the trigger of a spray gun before...never stained something as large as this before....this is not a project to learn on in my opinion. Be proud of what you constructed. Know when to say when and think about having a professional or experienced finisher handle this. 

BUT...by all means, if you're up to the challenge...knock yourself out...

 

ONE WORD OF CAUTION.....if your get into this thing and its not going well STOP WHAT YOU'RE DOING. By pushing on you could make one big mess and make things more difficult to fix.

 

-Ace-    

 

    

  • Author

Any idea...and of course I won't hold you to it, but what would finishing this off run me?  I'm in northern NJ.

I don't know current prices in your area. But here, in Billings, contractors are charging based on $50 to $65 per hour. Even if you did the staining you are going to get charged a full day 8 - 10 hours. 

Some contractors might not agree to let you do the staining since they will not want to be liable for product incompatibility issues.  If you do the staining, and it peels for any reason, all will most likely will say was due to your stain product.  

One of the big issues for a contractor is liability and one of the best ways to control liability issues is to get full control of the situation. It is not to get more money out of the clients, it is to control the situation that can lead to loss due to call-backs and warranty work. 

So there would be labor plus materials. 

  • Author

Ok.  all sensible. finding a good contractor is the toughest part most likely. is there any suggestions for where to start looking or questions to ask when finding carpenter to  do work?

#1 Recommendations from friends. 

OR - I, and other contractors I know, have landed several jobs from clients going to the paint dealer like Sherwin Williams, Columbia, or Pittsburgh Paint and asking for recommendations based on the project. 

Both of those are word-of-mouth recommendations and are the best. I don't know how accurate any of the online services are at recommending contractors. 

 

 

Try calling local painting contractors. Tell them what you have going on. I'm sure they may know someone. 

 

-Ace-

  • 3 weeks later...
  • Author

So I've narrowed it down to three topcoats that I'm going to sample with a brush for the birch ply bar and bar top.  Does anyone have any experience with any of these to give me some tips or a heads up on one vs. the others?

  • GF High Performance
  • Target EM2000wvx
  • Crystalac Poly Oxide

Thanks,

Evan

I've used the High Performance but, only as a spray and really like it!

If you have any nearby dealers of M L Campbell products they sell Agualente Pre Cat Waterbourne finishes. It's usually only sold to pro shops. Maybe they can refer you to some finishers who are familiar with the product. I have been using it for years and it has held up well on tabletops and a couple of bars.

  • Author

I called the ML Campbell rep a couple of weeks ago and asked about Agualente, he said it can't be brushed. So that's not an option. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.