Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi Guys.

Had a play with the new Domino 700 joiners for creating knock down furniture and for benchtop joining, the applications are pretty cool. BUT, the bad boy I was looking forward to was the HK 85 with the trenching head fitted. Took a couple of photos and one of the other guys there held the video camera for me for a few seconds while I plowed out a slot using the parallel rip fence to guide me. Threw it all together as a video. Have a look if you want to, it is only 45 seconds without adds.

https://youtu.be/7PxN7yBklcc

 

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, wtnhighlander said:

Just more chisel cleanup to do than with a routed groove.

But for a long groove, stopped or not, I think this might be the more efficient choice.

The first comment contradicts the second.  A router would be more efficient for a stopped groove.

And since it can only do through grooves (efficiently) I see no reason not to stick with the dado stack.

It's a cool looking tool...I don't see where the advantage is.  I'd love for someone to enlighten me.

Also, how do you vary the width of the groove?  Looked like carbide cutters...do you have to change the cutters to change the width of cut?  That would be extremely inefficient and limiting.

Posted
18 minutes ago, Eric. said:

The first comment contradicts the second.  A router would be more efficient for a stopped groove.

And since it can only do through grooves (efficiently) I see no reason not to stick with the dado stack.

It's a cool looking tool...I don't see where the advantage is.  I'd love for someone to enlighten me.

Also, how do you vary the width of the groove?  Looked like carbide cutters...do you have to change the cutters to change the width of cut?  That would be extremely inefficient and limiting.

This all needs more research. Can the circ mounted tool cut deep in one pass? If so, it might soundly beat the multiple pass router. Then again, the deeper the groove, the more chisel work there would be. 

Posted

You need to remember this is not really a shop tool. This is a jobsite tool. Since this is a circ saw that accepts a dado its has two functions so you wouldn't need a router on site. Most guys would prefer to have the circ saw that they already use to be able to cut the occasional groove than have to bring a router to the jobsite.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
44 minutes ago, shaneymack said:

You need to remember this is not really a shop tool. This is a jobsite tool. Since this is a circ saw that accepts a dado its has two functions so you wouldn't need a router on site. Most guys would prefer to have the circ saw that they already use to be able to cut the occasional groove than have to bring a router to the jobsite.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Shane, read with salt as there is no offense intended. 

On the job, I did not see routers but rarely. Circ rip three wide and bust out with a chisel. Slide the circ back and forth...three rips on a TS then bust out with a chisel...Amish chisel (hammer claw.") Forstner in a drill...but rarely a router. Even timber framing is several cuts followed by a chisel. If things need a stopped groove, it is almost always shop built. The elaborate custom built-in furniture is shop built. The shop just moves to the site. All this to say, I am not sure the site vs shop really holds up well unless you envision using this for exact width single pass stuff that is encountered by a sub in repetitive installs. So, who was this made for? 

Posted

I am getting hold of one of these saws in November and will do an in depth review then. To answer a few questions. The minimum width is 16 mm due to the blades being 14 x 14 mm and tilted to create a slice rather than a chop (similar to helical heads on jointers) ...hence 16mm wide min. The 2 mounts that hold the blades lap over each other so when they are stacked, no difference in width of cut. The kit comes with a few spacers that are .5, 1, 2 and 3 mm thick. These separate the blade mounts. to create the wider groove up to 25mm.

The saw is capable of a full 35mm cut depth in one pass. Note that like all dado heads, the diameter is less than the standard saw blade.

The saw will run on all festool tracks as well as the HSK tracks with the dado head and also the 230mm dia saw blade that delivers an 85mm deep cut.

It is ideal for site work. Applications for the dado head could be door jamb head trenching, letting risers into the underside of treads in a staircase, slotting the underside of a handrail to take balusters, half lapped joints for wall frames, tilt the head and clamp a set of rafters together and notch out a series of birdsmouths (although the guard would need to be removed for that application). So anywhere a through slot is required would be ideal. Stopped slots can still be achieved but you would need to incorporate a forstner, speed bore and or a chisel.

Posted
4 hours ago, C Shaffer said:

Shane, read with salt as there is no offense intended. 

On the job, I did not see routers but rarely. Circ rip three wide and bust out with a chisel. Slide the circ back and forth...three rips on a TS then bust out with a chisel...Amish chisel (hammer claw.") Forstner in a drill...but rarely a router. Even timber framing is several cuts followed by a chisel. If things need a stopped groove, it is almost always shop built. The elaborate custom built-in furniture is shop built. The shop just moves to the site. All this to say, I am not sure the site vs shop really holds up well unless you envision using this for exact width single pass stuff that is encountered by a sub in repetitive installs. So, who was this made for? 

Lol, no offense taken at all, Carus. 

I agree, we have all trenched with a regular circ saw with multiple passes and then smashed the leftovers with our hammers and then chsieled it flat. The hk85 with the dado head would replace this nonsense. I agree that a router is the ideal tool for the job for a stopped groove but like you said, not a lot of stopped grooves on a jobsite. 

With a cutting depth of almost 3 1/2" and with the dado block attachement I can see this saw being a big hit with timber framers. I dont think there is much of an arguement that this is a carpentry saw and not a shop saw.  

I think the hk85 with the dado head would be a better option than drop cutting a tenon like this LOL

 

Posted
1 hour ago, shaneymack said:

  I think the hk85 with the dado head would be a better option than drop cutting a tenon like this LOL

 

I don't see that as a solution. The drop cut demonstrated is used because of the depth of cut a 10-14" circ saw can achieve. What's 35mm, 1.5"? On a 10x10 sill it is nothing to have a 2" tenon making 4" of removal from one or both sides. I still see this as a one trick pony. Use it. Prove me wrong and I will own it. I just don't see it gaining widespread use but rather decorating a lot of shelves. 

Posted
8 minutes ago, C Shaffer said:
I don't see that as a solution. The drop cut demonstrated is used because of the depth of cut a 10-14" circ saw can achieve. What's 35mm, 1.5"? On a 10x10 sill it is nothing to have a 2" tenon making 4" of removal from one or both sides. I still see this as a one trick pony. Use it. Prove me wrong and I will own it. I just don't see it gaining widespread use but rather decorating a lot of shelves. 

Not a lot of situations I could see myself using the dado head. The saw itself with the 3 1/2" cut capacity i would use though and a lot of framers also.

Like I said, I think this saw (with the dado head) would be great for timer framers, which I am not.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
46 minutes ago, C Shaffer said:

I don't see that as a solution. The drop cut demonstrated is used because of the depth of cut a 10-14" circ saw can achieve. What's 35mm, 1.5"? On a 10x10 sill it is nothing to have a 2" tenon making 4" of removal from one or both sides. I still see this as a one trick pony. Use it. Prove me wrong and I will own it. I just don't see it gaining widespread use but rather decorating a lot of shelves. 

An 1,1/2" removal from both sides allows a pretty large tenon. 7 inch wide tenon on a 10 inch beam, allowing a very clean splinter free visible joint. I think it will get wings and fly.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 63 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined