rodger. Posted October 29, 2016 Report Posted October 29, 2016 Just bought a new TV, as well as a new soundbar. Well, in fact I bought 2 soundbars, but the first one had a firmware issue and was not fully compatible with my TV. Anyways, the new soundbar has only one HDMI port, which is an out via ARC to the TV. So, connect "soundbar out" to "TV in ARC". Works great! Now, I would like to get a PS4. Here is where the issue arises. Since there is no "HDMI in" on the soundbar, I must connect the PS4 to the TV via HDMI (using an alternate port of course). Will I lose lossless audio on Blu-ray when i do this? I understand that connecting a device to the soundbar first (if possible) retains the lossless audio. Not sure if sending it to the TV first will compress it in someway. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted October 30, 2016 Report Posted October 30, 2016 If it is all HDMI, which I understand is a fully digitized signal, it shoudn't matter where it goes first. There would only be a loss if the audio was converted to analog and back to digital. 2 Quote
rodger. Posted October 30, 2016 Author Report Posted October 30, 2016 so ARC can handle lossless audio? Quote
Tpt life Posted October 30, 2016 Report Posted October 30, 2016 ARC might only support two channel FYI. You need to find the answer to that question with your specific TV. 1 Quote
ClassAct Posted October 30, 2016 Report Posted October 30, 2016 Wtnhighlander is right. A couple of concepts are being used interchangeably when they're not really equivalent. * "Lossless" means that the signal has been compressed with an algorithm that uncompressing it will result in an exact image of the original. This is easy to do with pure digital information but difficult to do with analog information. * Nearly all consumer gear does some form of conversion from digital to analog or analog to digital. Ideally there are as few conversions as possible along the path from source device to speakers. * Different chips use different conversion methods to convert digital to analog or analog to digital. What this means for the average consumer is that you want to use the best conversion chip along the signal chain, e.g. if your Blu-ray player has the best chip, you want to use the analog outputs (if any) on your Blu-Ray. If your TV has the best chip, then use the TV's chip. It's highly unlikely your Playstation has 5.1 analog outputs as that's an "audiophile" feature. If your soundbar has 5.1 analog inputs on the back, you can try two cable arrangements to see which produces the sound you like. First, connect your PS to your TV using HDMI, then connect the TV to the soundbar using HDMI. Play a Blu-Ray movie that you're familiar with and take a few notes on what you like and what you don't. This arrangement uses your soundbar's DAC (digital-to-audio converter) chip. Then, remove the HDMI cable between your TV and your soundbar and connect the TV's 5.1 audio outputs to the soundbar's 5.1 audio inputs. Play the same movie and take notes. Which one do you like the most? Use that setup. This will not be true "lossless" audio, but in reality there is no such thing and for now I'd use your system for a while and enjoy what it can do. Audiophiles spend bazillions of dollars in pursuit of perfect audio reproduction at levels unmeasurable and imaginary. I've pulled back from that madness and my life is much calmer now, and as a result I have more money to spend on woodworking. 2 Quote
Tpt life Posted October 30, 2016 Report Posted October 30, 2016 Hit up a tech forum sometime OP. Lossless is a tail chase now as most don't have the ear to distinguish between CD and MP3, much less other compression formats. The CD contains more info than your ear can hear, IF your system could even fully represent it. The diminishing return is rapidly reached with modern formats, but hotly contested with regularity. It can be fun to watch.., Quote
AJ_Engineer Posted October 30, 2016 Report Posted October 30, 2016 Does the soundbar have an optical input, possibly labelled SPDIF? If that is the case you can get an optical cable that carries only the audio signal and that will go from the TV to the soundbar. Then for whichever input you have in to the TV it will get the audio. Quote
rodger. Posted October 30, 2016 Author Report Posted October 30, 2016 4 hours ago, AJ_Engineer said: Does the soundbar have an optical input, possibly labelled SPDIF? If that is the case you can get an optical cable that carries only the audio signal and that will go from the TV to the soundbar. Then for whichever input you have in to the TV it will get the audio. I do have optical on this unit, but I enjoy the convenience of arc for single remote use. My understanding is that HDMI is preferable to optical, but I could easily be wrong. Quote
Cochese Posted October 31, 2016 Report Posted October 31, 2016 I think you'd have to do the research on your particular tv to see if it will passthrough audio on that format. AFAIK, optical doesn't have lossless capability. Your sound bar only has an HDMI out, not an in? I would think it would be the opposite. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted October 31, 2016 Report Posted October 31, 2016 In the end, "Real Housewives of New Jersey" won't sound any different, no matter how you make the connections... 2 Quote
Tpt life Posted October 31, 2016 Report Posted October 31, 2016 17 minutes ago, Cochese said: I think you'd have to do the research on your particular tv to see if it will passthrough audio on that format. AFAIK, optical doesn't have lossless capability. Yes and no. TOSLINK will do two channel lossless. It is great for stereo audio formats for this reason. It is less desirable for video as we move to audio formats that require more than two channel in video applications. Quote
MisterDrow Posted November 11, 2016 Report Posted November 11, 2016 ARC is a convenience thing but, unless something has changed in the last year, does not carry lossless 5.1 or 7.1 audio. @C Shaffer is also correct that TOSLINK will only do 2.1 lossless audio. If you want to retain full 5.1/7.1 lossless, you will need a separate connection to your soundbar and your TV from the source. Out of curiosity, what is the brand/model of your TV and soundbar? Quote
rodger. Posted November 11, 2016 Author Report Posted November 11, 2016 Its a Sony htct390 I went with arc, and it works well. The bar only does 2.1, so 5.1 lossless is not an option anyways. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.