Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

my favorite ICE and Water shield metal roof membrane

Featured Replies

On a current, large, complicated standing seam roof job, I bought one each of every different kind of HT (high temperature for metal roofs) membrane I could find.  All are okay, and some really expensive.   For the best combination of price to quality of product, this one is my current favorite.  It's almost a hundred bucks per 200 sq. ft. roll cheaper than the Grace product.   The Grace product is my favorite as far as quality goes, but this one seems to be the best value.  It's going under the rest of the roof that isn't covered by the various different types I've used so far.

http://alco-products.com/products/underlayments/alco-shield-high-temp.html

I put this in The Shop forum because I thought sometimes woodworkers do build shops with metal roofs, and it might be useful information.

Thanks Tom..  I might have a build coming up so, I'll bookmark this!

  • Author

It's a shame you're so far away.  I've found a great metal panel manufacturer that's 32 miles from my house.  The owner is very helpful, and pleasant to deal with.  They made special trim pieces to my specifications, and on top of that, their prices are little over half of others I've bought from.  That might be because I have no shipping costs built in, but you can deal direct with them.  Standing seam, with built in screw flange for $1.60 a sq. ft. !

I'll try to remember to take a picture of part of the order stacked on my trailer tomorrow.  They crated, and loaded it to suit me, so that I can use it right off the trailer, without having to handle it twice.

Kev, do lots of research on the metal roof option if you are going to build a new shop.  The underlayment that Tom mentions may be a worthwhile investment on the metal roof.  My shop is a 30x40 insulated pole barn with a metal roof and I love the open space for my shop.  One thing I have noticed is in the winter when snow is on the roof and I have the gas furnace running the metal roof will begin to condensate and drip water into my shop.  Not a great thing for cast iron table tops.  I have read up on this and it is very common for metal roofs.  I have not come up with a solution for this, not a big deal as I don't use the shop much in the winter.  The most likely solution would be to add an insulated shop ceiling on the bottom of the trusses keeping the heat from the shop roof.

1 minute ago, Cheeset202 said:

Kev, do lots of research on the metal roof option if you are going to build a new shop.  The underlayment that Tom mentions may be a worthwhile investment on the metal roof.  My shop is a 30x40 insulated pole barn with a metal roof and I love the open space for my shop.  One thing I have noticed is in the winter when snow is on the roof and I have the gas furnace running the metal roof will begin to condensate and drip water into my shop.  Not a great thing for cast iron table tops.  I have read up on this and it is very common for metal roofs.  I have not come up with a solution for this, not a big deal as I don't use the shop much in the winter.  The most likely solution would be to add an insulated shop ceiling on the bottom of the trusses keeping the heat from the shop roof.

If I build, I'll sheet the roof before applying underlayment and metal like I did in the last shop for exactly that reason.  I'll actually sheet the sides and wrap before applying metal as well.  It helps with the condensation as well as the insulation so, just better all around.  A lot more expensive but, tends to pay off in the long run IMO.

I am beginning to see a lot of foam board under metal arrangements for heat bridging elimination. 

Edit: I mean on top of OSB sheathing for structure. 

7 minutes ago, TIODS said:

If I build, I'll sheet the roof before applying underlayment and metal like I did in the last shop for exactly that reason.  I'll actually sheet the sides and wrap before applying metal as well.  It helps with the condensation as well as the insulation so, just better all around.  A lot more expensive but, tends to pay off in the long run IMO.

Absolutely the way to go!

  • Author

Condensation under the metal surface is much more of a problem than most people realize, even over solid sheathing.  I don't build anything anymore, with a metal roof, without this type of membrane under the metal, regardless of what else is under it.  I get more calls than I want to come troubleshoot a leaking roof.  It happens over heated spaces, as well as sheds in the open air.  It's especially a problem on boat houses here.

Always used Ice and water shield on all my shingled roof jobs I did.  The stuff is a bit of a pain to install on a hot day by yourself.   It can stick to itself if your not careful.

  • Author

I don't know how you could do it by yourself.  We use Sharpies.  Roll it out where you want it.  Mark the top location with the Sharpie.  Roll the bottom half back (this with two people-one on each end).  Peel the protection film off the rolled up bottom half.  Peel the film off the previous layer (if this is not the first row) top sealing edge.  Make sure the top is on the marks, and let the bottom roll down into place.  Walk on it some to make sure it sticks well to the lower piece.  Roll the top half down.  Pull the film off, and roll it back down.   Repeat for each piece.

I've seen Ice and Water used for a starter on shingled jobs, but never the whole roof.   I'm talking about doing the whole roof for a metal roof.  I've found metal roofs with the fasteners rusted off under the metal, with the heads and washers still good above the top, but never where there was Ice and Water on just the bottom row.  This stuff is thick enough, that it seals completely around any fastener, whether standing seam screw, or exposed fastener.

Also, don't fail to note that it needs to be HT  (high temperature) for a metal roof.  The regular stuff can melt under metal, and ooze down somewhere you don't want it.

Everyone on the crew I work can easily do this task alone. Top corner gets started and stapled. Roll starts with backing being pulled to roll the roll. Once the top is done and cut, the bottom is pulled from under. 

  • Author

I'm too lazy to use fasteners.

Can you lay multiple rows, without getting puckers by yourself, and still have it aligned with neat overlaps by sticking it down as you roll it out?  I have to satisfy my perfectionism.  I can see where it wouldn't matter much if you are just doing the bottom edge-just trim it past the drip edge.

The key is alignment of the first ten feet. Unless it is hot sun heat, (don’t plan to run it at 2:00 in summer) you can lift that ten feet and reposition...particularly if you only have half the sheet pealed. Puckers will happen occasionally since no roof is dead flat. We slice, lay flat, and then overlay. It helps to realize that in summer we are running almost every third day at a minimum. 

  • Author

Thinking about this today, I think we're talking about two different things.  The bituminous membranes are a lot easier to roll out than these polymer HT membranes especially made to go under metal roofs.  This particular membrane doesn't unroll easily, as it's a lot stiffer than the black type to start with, and then being lopsided from packaging, the 61 pound roll is a little aggravating to handle any kind of way.  The reason I like the Grace HT better is simply that it's easier to handle, but for a hundred bucks difference per roll, I'll deal with 30 seconds of aggravation.

If you use this membrane for metal roofs, that I am recommending, I'd suggest to go with my method, using a helper, when putting it down.  Folding it up lengthwise, in the process of removing the thin film on the back of it, helps to flatten out the kinks anyway.  I'm pretty sure if you tried unrolling it by pulling the film, that the film would simply break.

  • Author

i had forgotten that I said I'd post a picture of the roofing panels on the trailer.   This is about half of all the panels.   The manufacturer is saving the other half for me until we use these up.  I have them stacked so we can get to them in the correct order, so we don't have to handle any of them twice. 

Each length is in its own crate, with faces of alternating panels facing each other, with foam strips between them, so we'll be able to get them installed with zero scratches.  The crating was included in the buck sixty a square foot price, and they were plenty patient with loading them like I wanted them too.  Crates are completely put together with screws, so no trouble to take them apart, as needed.

The ugly house, on the great lot, is in the background.

This is a 20 foot gooseneck trailer.  The stacks of crates are three across.  The longest panels are 23-1/2 feet long, and stick out the back some between the ramps.

CIMG2320 (1280x960).jpg

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.