Recommended Posts

Posted

The recent posts about sharpening have made me want to throw in my recent experiences.

I have several sharpening things around my house. I have a set of oilstones (rather small) that I found at the Scout Shop back when I was a scout leader. They work pretty well but I need to get some bigger ones if I stay with oil-based stones. They are made by Smith and are probably not the best but they do work reasonably well. I may not get bigger ones since I don't like getting my hands all oily and don't like the smell (although I saw Christopher Schwartz use olive oil on TV so I guess I could switch oil types to change the smell.)

I have also used sandpaper on a marble floor tile which has worked the best of all but I wanted a system that didn't require a stock of consumables so I bought a duo-sharp fine/extra fine diamond plate. Just today I realized that my blades are just not getting as sharp with that as they do when I use oil stones or the sandpaper. Pretty disappointing.

I hesitate to spend a ton of money but it's looking like from everyone's experience that Shapton water stones are a good investment - as are some nice oil stones. I've never heard of the sigma ceramic stones before but I read the previous post with interest.

I read recently that you should just pick a system and stick with it and I'm OK with that. I guess I'm just hesitant to spend the money that is required. I guess I just need to do it. I don't like the idea that I have to flatten waterstones regularly but that might be preferable to washing oil off my hands (in a shop without a sink).

Anyway... I enjoy reading about everyone's experiences. It helps me decide. I live pretty close to the part of Arkansas that produces the stones; maybe I should make a road trip.

Posted

Im very happy with my norton combo stones that i got at peachtree. And they didnt break the bank. I agree shaptons are probably a superior stone but the nortons work great for me. I will not wear them out in my lifetime thats for sure. just my 2 cents.

Posted

Just adding my recent experience...

I just bought a set of Coarse, Fine, and Extra Fine DMT dia-sharp bench stones. I tested them yesterday on a 1" X 2" hand plane that I wanted to flatten. So far I hate these products, and feel like I completely wasted my money. I called DMT and told them my issues and they said to rub them against each other to smooth out the anomalies. I haven't tried it yet, but will update this post if it works.

I found that the coarse was coarse for about 10 min (even with cleaning). The Fine has rough spots and put deeper scratches than the Coarse did. The Extra-Fine Rated at 1200 grit, is quite a bit rougher than a piece of 600 grit wet/dry paper.

It is going to take me hours to undo the scratches from the fine stone. I would have been better off 50$ on sand paper than 150$+ on these stones.

Despite being very disappointed with the stones, the DMT customer service was great. The woman I spoke to was very nice, and said that if the suggested fix didn't work that they would replace them with new stones.

Posted

Since you are already familiar with oil stones already you might consider them. A set of Arkansas stones are inexpensive and will get your tools really sharp. I am considering moving to oil stones. There are things with water stones I find to be annoying, strictly a personal set of annoyances. I dont like soaking the stones or flattening stones.

Posted

I started out with the Norton Waterstones, and they worked very well. I now use the Shapton stone. I wouldn't say the Shaptons are "superior" to the Norton (or any other) waterstone. Both types of stones give you a very nice edge. I would easily recommend Norton to anyone who didn't want to spend the money for Shaptons. I only use the Shaptons, because they are more convenient and less "messy". I haven't use oil stones before, but they seem to be having a comeback. I hear if you buy oil stones, they are likely to last a couple generations of woodworkers.

Mike

Posted

OK, here's an update. Since I have the day off, I dropped by my local Woodcraft store (lucky that we have one). They had a set of Arkansas stones at half the cost of the water stones so I figured that I could not go wrong by buying a set.

Since they are new I also figured I could lubricate them with water (the guy at the store told me that). So I've just redone a 1" chisel and my smoothing plane iron and I have to say the edge is much superior than before. I did the usual "shaving the hair off my arm" test but also the "split the paper" test that I saw in Popular Woodworking magazine - that may have been the latest issue. I then of course tried them out on actual wood. All three tests seem like the edge is better so I'd call this a good investment.

The jury is still out on the lubricant but I figure that the purpose is to float the swarf away and anything liquid will do that. Water evaporates and so I will stick with that until somebody can give me evidence to the contrary.

For the record I bought a soft Arkansas and a hard (black) Arkansas. I'll go sharpen everything else again and see how things turn out. I'm hopeful.

Posted

That's a fascinating (and short) article. I find myself vindicated in my use of water although perhaps I should add a touch of detergent.

Posted

The Shaptons aren't that pricy if you only go up to 8000 grit. The higher grits and the lapping plate are the big ticket items for the glass stones. When it comes time to replace my 1000 grit stone, I'll seriously consider finding a Sigma Power 1000. This isn't the Power Select II that Lee Valley sells. It goes out of flat faster than the II, but it supposedly cuts faster than any other 1000 stone, so I've read from several posters that use many different stones.

Posted

That's a fascinating (and short) article. I find myself vindicated in my use of water although perhaps I should add a touch of detergent.

If you don't get Popular Woodworking, the full article had more great information in it. You can order just that issue if you don't have it.

Mike

Posted

Hi Greg

You have not mentioned the most important feature - are you comfortable with the method you use to sharpen?

It does not matter whether you do this freehand or with a guide. What does matter is that the method you use reliably produces a good edge.

The foundation of all sharpening is the primary bevel. The critical element here is that you create a wire edge when you do so, and then create a wire edge with each successive grit. It you do this you will always have a sharp edge - regardless of the medium you use.

Regards from Perth

Derek

  • 1 month later...
Posted

The Shaptons aren't that pricy if you only go up to 8000 grit. The higher grits and the lapping plate are the big ticket items for the glass stones. When it comes time to replace my 1000 grit stone, I'll seriously consider finding a Sigma Power 1000. This isn't the Power Select II that Lee Valley sells. It goes out of flat faster than the II, but it supposedly cuts faster than any other 1000 stone, so I've read from several posters that use many different stones.

Actually the Select II goes out of flat faster than the Sigma Power Ceramic, which is the faster cutting stone. But the Sigma Power 1000 is a fantastic stone for sharpening. It is highly dish resistant, produces a smooth, almost mirror polished edge, and cuts very quickly--much more so than the Ark stones, the Nortons, Kings, Super Stones, plus several others. BTW Stu Tierney did a study on ceramic stones and various steel types: check them out at http://www.toolsfromjapan.com/wordpress. You'll have to sort through several months of back issues for the six part series, but if information is what you seek, Stu has provided it.

I'm very happy with moving to the newer, improved ceramic waterstones. They are fast and produce fantastic results. I've used my Sigma stones (power ceramics not Select II) to flatten about 50 blade backs and bevels. They've provided excellent service, as has my Chosera 1000, which I got used (as a fluke). Both these beat (hands down) the Besters, Arashiyama, Nortons, and Ark Oil stones that I've tried. Fact is, all of these work; more specifically, some work slower, dish faster, use up sooner, and make bigger messes than others--but they all work and produce quality edges for chisels and plane blades!

Fear not, to use Japanese Waterstones...unless of course the water's freezing!!!!

Arch,

Near NOLA, where it's nearly always warmer

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

And yet another update...

I decided to try olive oil on my oil stones. It's something I had laying around.

It seems to work fine. I'll have to report back on whether there is every any bad smell or other after effects but as far as the sharpening goes, it worked fine. I decided to do this when I discovered that the roller on my honing guide was getting a bit stiff due to the water getting in there. So I decided to switch lubricants.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.