Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Hand saw recommendation

Featured Replies

I am getting ready for the build and from Marc's first post where he recommends the necessary tools he included a hand saw. I don't have a high qualit hand saw so I am using the build as a good excuse to get one. I was looking at the hand saws at lie Nielsen. Do you guys have any recommendations for whether a dovetail' carcass' crosscut or panel saw would make the most sense for the outbound build. Also any other brand recommendations. I was looking at bad axe saws and they look awesome but the lead time is too long for the build.

Thanks

I'm no hand saw guru, so others will surely respond with more guidance about brands, tooth set and other details. But I will point out that the mortise and tenon work on the bench is very large scale compared to most furniture projects. A typical dovetail saw with only 1 1/2" of saw plate depth would be pretty useless for this project. A more useful saw for this would be a tenon saw with 4+ inches of depth. You'll have to decide whether this is going to be a useful saw for your shop beyond the bench build.

Like most other tools for woodworking, there's a lot of personal preference.

I've bought vintage Disstons, Simonds, and Atkins saws (panel saws, dovetail, carcass, and tenon), as well as a few Adria saws. The Adria are seriously sharp, have no issues to rehab, and are made (like all other modern ones) with thinner plates. That's good and bad. If I had not used the thicker plates to learn, I would have kinked a thinner plate saw. Beware, thinner is not always better.

I cut dovetails with 8, 10, or 12" back saws. The wood doesn't care. Rip is rip! I'm actually more comfortable with a 12" saw length but do quite well with a 10", too. Though I have 14" and 16" tenon saws, I sometimes cut big timber with my panel rip saw. Again, the wood doesn't care. Only what matters is your ability to cut to the line--and that takes a bit of practice!

As a minimum, I'd suggest a 12" rip backsaw (a little more versatile than the 10"), a 14" (or, 16" but that's kinda a lot saw to manage) crosscut, and 2 handsaws (24-28" range--one crosscut (8 tpi is average, with 10-12 finer and slower) and the other rip (5 tpi works well for me but 4 or 4 1/2 is faster, especially in wet wood).

For the backsaws, you have several fine makers--each with its advocates--Gramercy, Adria, Lie Nielson, Bad Axe, Wenzelof, and LV Veritas. Three LV backsaws can be purchased for the cost of just one from the previous quality makers. But the quality saws are indeed very nice to own and use!

For the handsaws, look for Daryl Weir or MarvW on Woodnet or SMC. There are a few other rehabbers, tuners, and sharpeners out there. You might be able to buy a rip and crosscut pair for $200 or so. To start from scratch with your own $20 *bay purchase, plus vise, files, DVDs on sharpening is actually not that bad either--all saws must be sharpened eventually! So, learning on the front end lessens the entry cost but lengthens the time to achieving quality saws. Which do you have more of--time or money. Oh, and to buy the best first and learn from that what sharp and perfect is, is indeed, a wonderful way to start. Otherwise, one can flounder for a while (:D) trying to discover just what the end goal is.

Hope this helps!

Arch

The LN dovetail saw is nice. I was just at a handtool show this weeekend and LN and Gramercy tools were on hand. Both sell very nice saws. If you have the resources in your area to try some of these out and how they perform that would be a major plus. Lumping down in excess of $120.00 without knowing how these tools feel in your hand and how they perform is alot to ask for someone that is getting into handtooling. Read up on how different rake, fleam, set and etc. effect your cuts, comfort and so on. Talk to the guys over at Bad Axe toolworks about these subjects. I'm sure they would be more than willing to help and in my experience they know just as much if not the most on handsaw geometry and achieveing a saw that is fit to your usage and liking.

Since this project is on larger scale then most of the work I anticipate doing, laying down the money for something like the lustworthy Roubo Beastmaster didn't make sense for me. Instead I opted for the 300mm Gyokuco Ryoba at $44. Since you're in the bay area, head over to Japan Woodworker or Hida Tool and check them out.

Also, Ryoba are a bit different to use than your typical western saw. I live in Oakland and would be happy to give you a quick hands on intro if you want to stop by some weekend.

Konkers... thanks for asking this question and those who responded as this is my exact situation. I have to get a good saw for doing the dovetails but was not sure where to start. This stream has got me pointed in a few good directions. I am off to Lea Valley next weekend to see what they have ans suggest but typically they are top end pricing.

Konkers... thanks for asking this question and those who responded as this is my exact situation. I have to get a good saw for doing the dovetails but was not sure where to start. This stream has got me pointed in a few good directions. I am off to Lea Valley next weekend to see what they have ans suggest but typically they are top end pricing.

I tried the lee valley saws at a woodworking show. They are a very good saw for the money. You can buy all 3 saws for the same price as some of the boutique saws and they perform extremely well. Also look at crown tools western style dovetail saw. At I think $65.00 it is a very good performer. Adria tools makes a very good dovetail saw too.

I Aaron brings up a very good point that a saw used to build a massive workbench is not necessarily the saw that will get used a lot on future furniture projects. I understand that the bench is the "excuse" to get a saw but take care to figure out what you will be needed a saw for? For hand saws (backless saw 24" and up) and panel saws (backless saw 24" and under) these are not really joinery tools. While they can be pressed into service for this purpose the lack of a stiff back can result in some precision issues. So you need to think about whether you will do any hand sawing to dimension and break down stock in the future. If not, then I would go the back saw route.

Bad Axe makes the best saws out there in my opinion and Mark's new "hybrid" small tenon saw is an outstanding utility player. I have cut dovetails, tenons, half laps, and miters all with this saw alone. However I understand the lead time issue can be a problem.

A carcass saw might be a great option for someone just getting into hand saws. This saw will be filed crosscut but it will certainly make rip cuts too, albeit slower. A carcass can be used to cut boards to length at the bench and to cut just about any joinery you throw at it. However, the carcass saw generally will not be large enough to handle the beefy joinery of a Roubo style workbench. The depth under the back is the limiting factor. Again, bench building isn't really the norm as far as tooling capacity goes.

If budget is tight and your acceptance of hand tools isn't a given then go with a Lee Valley carcass saw, or Erik's great suggestion of a Japanese saw. If you find yourself reaching for the saw more and more then you can diversify and add different saws and/or greater quality. (not that the Veritas saw isn't a great quality saw)

In hand tools I don't think the old adage of "buy your last tool first" applies. Hand tools are awesome but they are not for everyone. The last thing you want to do is drop a lot of cash on tools and wish you had bought a bandsaw or table saw instead. Sorry little off topic here at the end.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.