Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm wanting to buy a new table saw and am currently working with a crappy 10" Craftsman Job Site saw in a very confined space. I find the saw never stays in blade alignment and I'm constantly having to mess with the stops and adjustment screws. Is this typical with these "contractor job site" saws? If I get a contractor saw from Delta or Sawstop will these problems disappear? The prices on the Sawstop contractor saws are fairly reasonable (although they are only 1.75 motors) and seem pretty good, or should I just go for a Uni? Any comments on this?

Posted

From my experience both will get the job done and a contractor saw will cut all but the thickest and hardest wood cutting just fine , especially with a thin kerf blade. A few points to consider is that dust collection on a contractor saw can more challenging. also you don't save all that much space with a contractor saw with the motor hanging off the back of the saw. From my perspective If cost is an issue I would focus on the quality of the fence and getting cast iron wings

Posted

A good contractor saw will ABSOLUTELY do nice work. I used a Jet CS for 6-7 years before moving to a cabinet saw. That same cabinet saw was recently replaced by a SawStop cabinet saw.

My reasons for changing had nothing to do with the contractor saw's ability to cut. It was mainly about the saw not moving when cutting sheets of ply without help, dust collection in my basement shop, and the fact that my Jet CS did not have a Biesemeyer style fence, 52" rip capacity, or cast iron wings.

There have been many articles written, online and in print, describing methods to add weight, build the saw into a table system, etc... As Kevmc pointed out, if money is an issue, go for the cast-iron winged, Biesemeyer clone fenced contractor saw and have at it. The saw will be as accurate as you can work... :rolleyes:

Posted

I have an older craftsman contractor saw that i have had a lot of good luck with I got through a Craigslist ad. It came with a real crappy fence that would only travel over half of the saw, had stamped steel wings. That by itself was worlds better then my craftsman jobsite saw. I did put on a Delta T2 Fence, put some shop made wings made with two layers of MDF, put a ZCI plate on it, and keep the cast iron top in good shape. This table saw performs really well now, and will use it until it quits.

Posted

If the Uni is in your budget then that would be my choice over a contractors saw. The differences are night and day. 1.75 is ok and will cut wood but is tougher on blades, slower cutting and usually light weight. A contractor saw is just that its made for its reduced weight and lack of need for accuracy. A cabinet saw is not named for its enclosed base. The name came from cabinet makers saw and was shortened and somehow redefined for marketing over the years. 3-5 hp is optimum for blade life and feed rate for 4/4 with a person manualy feeding from a single positon. 7-10 hp is optimum for a walking feed rate of 4/4 material. 12-14hp is perfect for power feed rate to achieve maximum chip load of a combo saw blade.

Posted

I too used to have a craftsman contractor saw. I too was plagued with inaccuracy and poor cut quality. I upgraded to a sawstop contractor and it's a night and day difference. Actually that statement doesn't do it justice. It's a 1000% improvement over the craftsman. I honestly couldn't be happier with it. I know it is only 1.75hp but I've fed everything through it without so much as a hiccup. I don't see a need for any more horsepower (keep in mind I'm just a hobbyist not a production shop). The sawstops are built like tanks so they can withstand a blade stop incident. That's a lot Of momentum to stop in a fraction of a second, hence the super beefy parts. I personally upgraded mine to the cast iron wings and upgraded the fence/rails. It is just as accurate as the day I got it. I'm not trying to push a sawstop on u by any means but I do feel that their contractor saw is just as accurate if not more accurate than a lot of the cabinet saws on the market. I personally wouldn't own any other brand. The safety feature alone is worth the cost to me. Just my 2 cents worth

Posted

If you're very short on space, I'd go for a hybrid or hybrid style contractor saw with an inboard motor vs a traditional contractor saw with the motor hanging out the back. That extra 12" or 13" isn't huge in a big shop, but in a small it can sure make a difference.

Posted

I have used the Ridgid TS3650 for years. It is technically a contractor's saw, but it is very accurate and well made. It is out of production now, and has been replaced by a far cheaper model. Look at kijiji for used saws and you may find a good deal!

Posted

I own said far cheaper Ridgid saw, the R4512. Home Depot will generally take a Harbor Freight coupon, and I managed to get mine for under $400 out-the-door (25% 4th of July HF coupon). That's not bad, not bad at all considering it comes with a lifetime warranty. The R4512 is more like a hybrid in the respect that it doesn't have the motor hanging out the back. The stamped steel wings and table mounted trunnions tell you it's cheap, but you won't find a better saw new for under $800 out-the-door.

Posted
I own said far cheaper Ridgid saw, the R4512. Home Depot will generally take a Harbor Freight coupon, and I managed to get mine for under $400 out-the-door (25% 4th of July HF coupon). That's not bad, not bad at all considering it comes with a lifetime warranty. The R4512 is more like a hybrid in the respect that it doesn't have the motor hanging out the back. The stamped steel wings and table mounted trunnions tell you it's cheap, but you won't find a better saw new for under $800 out-the-door.

I'm not sure I agree that the R4512 is "far cheaper". Both are Chinese made saws aimed at an entry level price point for full size stationary saws. The steel wings are certainly a downgrade on the R4512. The fence is similar but possibly not quite as good as the 3650's, but the design under the table is very similar with the exception of the R4512's motor location which has a number of advantages. The legs on the R4512 are certainly sturdier than those on the 3650. It also has a riving knife. I'm not trying to knock the well proven 3650, but there are pros and cons with each. The good news is that the cheap wings on the R4512 can be upgraded down the road.

Posted
I too used to have a craftsman contractor saw. I too was plagued with inaccuracy and poor cut quality. I upgraded to a sawstop contractor and it's a night and day difference. Actually that statement doesn't do it justice. It's a 1000% improvement over the craftsman. I honestly couldn't be happier with it. I know it is only 1.75hp but I've fed everything through it without so much as a hiccup. I don't see a need for any more horsepower (keep in mind I'm just a hobbyist not a production shop). The sawstops are built like tanks so they can withstand a blade stop incident. That's a lot Of momentum to stop in a fraction of a second, hence the super beefy parts. I personally upgraded mine to the cast iron wings and upgraded the fence/rails. It is just as accurate as the day I got it. I'm not trying to push a sawstop on u by any means but I do feel that their contractor saw is just as accurate if not more accurate than a lot of the cabinet saws on the market. I personally wouldn't own any other brand. The safety feature alone is worth the cost to me. Just my 2 cents worth

That is....."stopsaw" :)

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

You don't mention what your typical woodworking is but I am a hobbyist/home owner and most of my cutting is 3/4" or narrower cabinet grade ply and 5/4 and less hardwood (mainly maple and cherry) plus some pine. My contractor saw (Rigid TS3650) has done very well by me over the last 7 years or so however there are a few areas that it could use improvement (dust control, sound, riving knife, 2 piece blade guard, etc) Power hasn't been an issue with a good blade.

Where Sawstop is concerned I would look at the Hybrid (PCS) for better dust collection and lower sound volume and pass on the contractor saw unless you need to bring it to job sites or something. It's well made but as far as contractor saw prices go it's very expensive and by the time you add on all the stuff to make it work as well as the hybrid (cast iron wings and whatnot), you're near the hybrid price anyway and at the moment they give you a free mobile base or dust collection blade guard with the hybrid.

If you have the budget, space and 220V power available you can get into a really excellent tablesaw (Unisaw is really awesome as is the Powermatic 2000 and SawStop ICS) but they might be overkill for what you do. I know space and power (and money :) ) are constraints for a lot of us...

-Jim

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined