Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't have a lot of experience with planes in general and would like to start with a block plane. I was just wondering if I should get a low-angle or standard angle. Also, any thoughts on the different brands is welcome as well.

Thanks.

Posted

Really like my Lie-Nielsen low angle, I suggest you get the best plane your budget will allow and then sharpen the iron well prior to using it. Bought my first plane, Bailey, roughly 30 years ago and tried using it right out of the box, it was a frustrating experience and that plane sat on a shelf for a long time afterward. I learned how to properly sharpen hand tools and got some higher quality tools, what a difference!

Do yourself a favor and get you best tool you can afford, sharpen and set it up correctly and you'll have a tool that's a pleasure to use the rest of your woodworking career.

Posted

My choice, for sure, for a first block plane, is an old, Stanley 60 1/2 block plane. The favorite of my planes.

I see a lt of them on Ebay.

I found the 60 1/2 (low angle plane) works great on end grain, as well as with the grain.

  • Like 1
Posted

I think you should get a rabbeting block plane (iron goes out to the sides) as you can use it as a regular block as well as rabbeting, shoulder/tenon trimming, etc.

If I were buying one today, I'd get the new Veritas: skew, mouth adjustment, ability to add a fence, a side knicker, blade set screw, Veritas quality.

Posted

I'd recommend a low-angle block. They are nice for end grain work. If you find that you aren't doing much end grain the iron can be honed at a higher angle, making it act like a standard block for long grain work.

The correct block plane for you is a very personal choice. It all comes down to whether or not your hand likes the plane. I own both Veritas models, but if I had another chance I'd choose Lie-Nielsen. I find them far more comfortable.

Posted

What about the Lie-Nielsen rabbet block planes (both low-angle and skew)? For once they seem cheaper than Veritas. (I have been thinking about buying one, so I'm really curious if anyone has a reason why the Veritas versions are superior).

Cheers,

Brian

Posted

Why I'd get that Veritas is because it has this:

- rabbeting blade goes to edge

- knicker

- adjustable mouth

- fence attachments

I have the LN rabbeting block; at the time they didn't have the knicker available, now they do. It does not have an adjustable mouth. I rarely use it now that I have other blocks with adjustable mouths.

The skew is a nice feature. Sure you can skew the blade by hand and I nearly always do, but if the blade itself is skew, you have more to register on the stock (assuming you are planing the edge) and you get the benefit of the skew when rabbeting.

I like that there is a blade set screw to position it and keep it there. Love that feature on my other Veritas blades, but it is admittedly a 'nice to have' not a deal-breaker.

The fence is nice to have. I have a fence available on a couple of my other block planes and like it. The Veritas fence is wood so you can make your own, like a 45º or 22.5º fence for nice chamfers; not needed for just 'breaking an edge', but if you want a fairly large chamfer, this makes easy work of it.

In my case, I don't have this Veritas... instead I have a bunch of block planes that each have some features that this one has all in one package. That's why I'd pick it. Likely it is more expensive than the LNs because none of those have the full set of features. Machining an adjustable mouth for a skew blade is a different setup than all the square blade mouths that are scaled versions of each other.

Posted

Thanks for the comprehensive response. (Incidentally LN skew block plane (now?) has a fence as well, but still no adjustable mouth, and is a bit more expensive in bronze and a bit less expensive in iron).

Cheers,

Brian

Posted

Most of your answers are above, but I wanted to add a thought on low angle vs standard. Essentially the standard angle block is like having a really small bench plane (#1 or #2). It can be nice for tight spaces and smaller work but the low angle block will treat you better in the tough end grain side of things so if you are thinking about getting a block for the more "traditional" reasons then go low angle. If you just want a smaller smoother, go standard.

Posted

Most of your answers are above, but I wanted to add a thought on low angle vs standard. Essentially the standard angle block is like having a really small bench plane (#1 or #2). It can be nice for tight spaces and smaller work but the low angle block will treat you better in the tough end grain side of things so if you are thinking about getting a block for the more "traditional" reasons then go low angle. If you just want a smaller smoother, go standard.

I have a standard and low angle block plane so I just switch between them. Would it be reasonable to say you could get the low-angle plane and an extra iron you re-grind so bevel-up it is back to a standard pitch? If you have an adjustable mouth, it seems to be pretty easy. But I don't know on the blocks referenced in this thread.

Posted

I have a standard and low angle block plane so I just switch between them. Would it be reasonable to say you could get the low-angle plane and an extra iron you re-grind so bevel-up it is back to a standard pitch?

Or you could take a standard angle block plane (assuming the bevel angle on the blade is 25º) and skew it 30º, which will effectively turn it into a low angle plane. Then you only have to buy one plane, and you don't have to worry about swapping blades. Ron Hock did an article on this.

Posted

Thank you everyone for the info. The Veritas skew block plane looks interesting. Still reserching.......so many tools and so little time.

Posted

I bought the standard Veritas block plane and the adjustable mouth kept creeping back onto the blade after a few passes. It could have been a bad one so instead of exchanging it I returned and bought the next one up, the DX60, it has the set screw to hold the mouth back. I do like this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 67 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Lenny2
    Newest Member
    Lenny2
    Joined