Jfitz Posted March 21, 2012 Report Posted March 21, 2012 My wife and I are looking at doing some home renovations, including a mud room off the back and a farmers porch on the front. We were pretty sure we would need a zoning variance for the porch because it goes over the setback from the street, and we were unsure about the back because we are on a corner lot and were not sure whether the rear setback or side setback would apply. Out architect contacted the building inspector (who is also the zoning enforcement officer) and he confirmed we needed a variance for the porch, but not for the work on the back of the house since the side setback would apply. Sweet! So my wife went to town hall, and that's when the comedy of errors started. [rant] The woman at the building department gave my wife a very poor photocopy of the application - and nothing else. Apparently there is a packet that is supposed to go with the application, but we did not get it. It looked pretty simple - so we did finally fill it out and she brought it to town hall with the 10 copies of the certified plot plan (done by a local engineering firm). When asked about the certified list of abutters, my wife indicated we did not know we needed it. "it was in the packet"', she was told. Great. Off to another department, where a gum snapping clerk indicated it could take up to 2 weeks to get the list. Apparently they are very busy at town hall. Thankfully, we managed to get it in less than a week. In the meantime, we realized that the certified plot plan had the wrong name in it for our neighbor. They required us to get 10 more copies of the fixed plan. Great. Another delay while the engineering company fixed it. Now, these delays caused us to miss the only ZBA meeting in February, because the second one fell on Presidents day. This also meant that the agenda for the next meeting was already full, so we had to wait till 3/20 (tonight), which is about 6 weeks from when we should have met them. So tonight when our case came up, the Chair of the board read the case and a letter from the planning department, which indicated they supported the variance for the front, but the back was an issue because it appeared the structure we were proposing to build was built 10 years ago. Huh? We went on to explain that the structure was not there, and they did finally accept our word on that. But they indicated that the plan was incorrect because we changed the plan to go another foot over what we planned (and what was built 10 years ago). We explained that we were told we did not need a variance for that since we were told by the building inspector that we did not need it, and any changes in that area would be accounted for in the permitting process, as a by-right entitlement to build. We simply couldn't get them to understand that we did not need a variance in the back. It was like arguing with a rock. I have read the zoning bylaws - we do not need it because the wording explicitly indicates that this part should have the side setback (which is more forgiving), therefore no variance is needed, and therefore they should just grant the variance for the porch and be done with it. One of the board members asked if I remembered what section of the bylaws I was referring - I don't remember which section, and she had the book right in front of her, so I need to do her job for her? The chair also stated that he felt, looking at the plan, that he personally considers it the rear of the lot and not the side. "2 fronts and 2 rears" is how he put it. so we have: Town hall clerks that apparently don't want to help residents get the right information. They also don't talk to each other. Planning board members that somehow think we built a proposed structure 10 years before we even conceived it (and wrote a memo to the ZBA to that effect) A ZBA member that can't find the only section in the bylaws dealing with corner lot setbacks (it's in the index, under "Corner Lot". I looked it up when I got home). A ZBA Chair that doesn't know the bylaws, and basically stated what he *feels* it should be. A ZBA chair who also thinks his interpretation of the bylaws trumps the town's zoning enforcement officer - even though the bylaws state otherwise. If any of you are town or government workers, I do not mean to disparage you by painting with a broad brush. But workers like the ones I describe give you a bad name. If any of you need to deal with small town governments frequently - you have my sympathies. [/rant] Quote
Southwood Posted March 21, 2012 Report Posted March 21, 2012 Sorry about your luck. Lots different here. There are a few places, here and there, that do get mixed into all that stuff. By the whole it is rare for it to happen. Quote
Rapid Roger Posted March 21, 2012 Report Posted March 21, 2012 I have a similar story about a neighbor of mine. He wanted to build a storage building in his backyard for the mower and gardening equipment. I suggested that he just build it and put it in the far corner of his yard. But, he wanted to be completely legal about it and bought a building permit ($50.00) and checked with the building inspector about it. He was told that this small building would require "tie downs" and he needed an engineering plan for them. So he went to the city engineer and requested the requirements for tie downs for his building. The city engineer told him that he knew what it would take but couldn't give them to him because he had signed a "No disclosure clause" with a small building manufacturer a few years back. So my neighbor hired an engineer to write up a paragraph of the requirements (Another $100.00.) and had them approved at the planning department. The planning department also told him that he had to have so many feet (about 12' if I remember right) clearance from the side and rear fences and so many feet clearance from any other structure (about 20' I think) which, when we measured it all up put the storage shed almost dead center of his small yard! So, I helped him build his storage shed in the allotted space and as we were working on it a building inspector came by to check on us. The inspector suggested that having this building would increase his property taxes! I'm not at all sure how much his taxes were increased but, he payed them I'm sure. Two years later, a tax assessor came by and informed him that a small building like that should NOT be included on his assessment and that because the building was on 6" x 6" skids was considered movable, he could have put it any place in his yard that he wanted to! !!!! NOW YOU TELL ME THAT!!!! Besides the cost of the building and three days work, there was an extra $150.00, two months of getting things in order with the "powers that be" and two years of taxes (non refundable) for a small storage shed that didn't amount to a hill of beans and could have been placed anywhere on his property all because of our city employees. I told him in the beginning "Just build the shed where you want it and plead ignorance if an inspector SHOULD show up while we are working on it." and all would have been well. Rog Quote
Jfitz Posted March 21, 2012 Author Report Posted March 21, 2012 Roger - not an uncommon occurrence I'm sure. I know in my town, only 'sheds' above a certain size require a building permit, permanent tie-downs, etc etc. For anything under 120 sq ft (10x12 shed), you can do pretty much whatever you want. A friend wanted to do a bigger one, so he did exactly what you said - built it, and waited for someone to say something. No one ever did, and the house has sold twice since then. An interesting 'workaround' was discovered by another neighbor - if a shed larger than 120 sq ft is built on site, you need a permit. However, if the product is built elsewhere and then delivered intact, no permit is needed as it is considered 'movable'. She she and her husband had a large shed delivered and dropped off the truck - no muss no fuss. Quote
rmac Posted March 21, 2012 Report Posted March 21, 2012 The operative rule in many cases is, "It's easier to ask for forgiveness than permission." -- Russ Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.