Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Table saw - should it stay or should it go?

Featured Replies

It also boils down to what type of work you do, what you're comfortable using and money. There are a myriad ways to tackle most operations and there is no right or wrong. Ultimately, do what feels right for you.

(null)

Most of the arguements with track saws boil down to space and lack of experience. Most that argue their merit, lack space or experience. The Festool tracksaw is in no way a replacment for a tablesaw its one tool in a system of tools designed for onsite euro style cabinetry. They do what they are designed to do very well and thats onsite frameless cabinetry where the hardwood work is done back at the shop on the real machinery. If you do this as a hobby then a tracksaw is a neat addition to a tablesaw but is not a replacement. Tracksaws are not the best thing for ripping or crosscutting hardwoods, thats why they made the Kapex. Tracksaws dont cut dados, thats why the system employs routers. Tracksaws dont do well with small narrow rips thats one reason for the mft. Tacksaws dont cut tenons thats why they made the domino. Its a system and if you happen to own the entire system there are many operations that can be performed away from the shop but there are many that have to be done at the shop on real machinery prior to getting on the jobsite. For a hobby guy this really means that the track saw is nothing more than a compliment to their other machinery. Hobby folks dont seem to care about time so the whole arguement that a tablesaw is more efficient seems to go in one ear and out the other. For alot of folks sheet goods seem to be the biggest issue what ever the issue may be tiny bench top saw, lack of space or just plain dont have the experience irregardless if you need a tracksaw to cut sheet goods then by all means buy one. So many time folks claim that just the material handling is a better. They claim that lifting heavy sheet good onto a saw is to much of a chore but yet they seem to not have issues with lifting that same sheet onto a workwork bench. I would just not have any dilusions that it is a replacement for a decent tablesaw. FWIW a the litte pc wormdrive saws and a elcheapo guide clamp have more power than the ts55 and will cut the same straight line for half the money and I suspect will last twice as long. With a bucks worth of hardboard any saw can be zero clearance and will cut just as clean. IMO keep the tablesaw and buy a tracksaw or any other like the pc worm drive if you dont want to try cutting sheetgoods on a tablesaw.

Don

Lets say I need to rip about 25, 1x10x24" boards into 1x1x24" strips, that are ready to glue up.

I figure it would take maybe 2-3 minutes, on the ts, including set up (2-3 seconds with a Biesemeyer style fence)

On the bs, about the same time, just to cut, then the cut surface would have to be planed for glue up.

How long would it take with a track saw?

I believe for a home hobby person, a table saw and a shop made saw guide for a circular saw (no, the blade doesn't have to go straight up and down, to get a great cut) is the way to go.

If I had $ coming out the wazoo, and the space for one, I'd still keep the table saw, and buy a track saw.

So, how long would it take to set up the track saw, and cut 25 1x1's to the exact same width?

Pagel, It sounds like you would benefit from visiting a production shop that uses a cabinet style tablesaw. Some I know use an infeed beam, which helps with the weight of a full sheet of material. Even without that, it sounds like you're having difficulty keeping the reference edge against the fence. Once you see someone do it correctly, you'll be amazed at how easy it really is. It's simply a matter of directional force and body position.

Correct ripping full sheets is a simple one handed operation. The problem is folks want to manhandle the sheet and try to have complete control. Standing at the left corner and feeding with just one hand resisting the urge to help make it very simple.

I would have to agree with both of these guys. I am in a wheelchair and I can rip a full sheet of 3/4" ply with proper infeed and outfeed support. Granted, I dont do it very often and it isnt the eastiest thing to do, but if I can do it, then you all should be able to do it no problem. But I did end up getting a track saw to help with this. ANd what can I say, I love it. Will it replace my General, I dont hardly think so. Not in a million years will I get rid of it, unless of course the new Laser saws are out.

I would have to agree with both of these guys. I am in a wheelchair and I can rip a full sheet of 3/4" ply with proper infeed and outfeed support. Granted, I dont do it very often and it isnt the eastiest thing to do, but if I can do it, then you all should be able to do it no problem. But I did end up getting a track saw to help with this. ANd what can I say, I love it. Will it replace my General, I dont hardly think so. Not in a million years will I get rid of it, unless of course the new Laser saws are out.

I find it's so hard to sand out the laser marks :P+1 Sac, and dwacker

You guys who keep claiming that the only reason we don't like to break down 4x8 sheet goods on the table saw is lack of experience, answer this question:

If a beginning woodworker has only a cheap small tablesaw, a single infeed roller, a single outfeed roller, and his shop is only 10x10 with no large door, how is he supposed to safely and easily make a cut along the 8' length of the panel? That's a pretty typical situation for most homeowner/weekend hobbyist woodworkers.

If you're a professional or a very serious hobbyist with a large shop with 8' of supported infeed and 8' of supported outfeed, a top-end cabinet saw, and two decades of experience, I'm sure it's no longer difficult for you to cut a panel down and I'm sure you're set enough in your ways that any other method seems needless. However, you are not a typical woodworker. For every one of you guys, think how many guys there must be that bought a mid-range contractor's saw at Lowes and is really damned proud of themselves for buying the best tool they'll ever buy. Stepping up from that even, compare that to the guy who goes into Woodcraft and buys the cheapest saw they have because that's all he can afford but has to share his "shop" with the fact that it's a 1-car garage and his wife gets to park in there. He doesn't have room to store a full infeed and outfeed table even if he opened the garage door and wheeled the saw right up to the edge of the slab. He's lucky if she'll let him buy 2 stands and keep them around.

I don't think anyone that's sane is going to say that a top of the line cabinet saw with all the room and infrastructure required to support it isn't a viable option; of course it is! The other side of this argument is that a tracksaw is also a viable option and might be a better fit for the guy with less experience, less space, and less money. Once you get down to having a $600 tracksaw vs a $600 tablesaw and not having a big enough shop to leave the tablesaw set up properly, then someone who's in that situation needs to take a really serious look at wither the tracksaw is a better option for them.

Lets say I need to rip about 25, 1x10x24" boards into 1x1x24" strips, that are ready to glue up.

I figure it would take maybe 2-3 minutes, on the ts, including set up (2-3 seconds with a Biesemeyer style fence)

On the bs, about the same time, just to cut, then the cut surface would have to be planed for glue up.

How long would it take with a track saw?

Figure about a minute to set it up and then the same 2-3 minutes to rip all the little bits, which will come off the saw glue ready. That presumes you have the Parallel Guide Extensions and leave them assembled for storage, which I do. If not, you can use the cheaper Parallel Guide (totally different product, stupidly similar name) and do the same thing with a little more care in the same amount of time. Or you could use a cut box if you've already made one. I haven't, since I have the PGS, but you can make one from scraps. The only difference to using a table saw in this case is that you take the piece you just cut off and stuff it around the back side under the rail to continue to support the rail as you keep ripping more sticks off.

You guys who keep claiming that the only reason we don't like to break down 4x8 sheet goods on the table saw is lack of experience, answer this question:

If a beginning woodworker has only a cheap small tablesaw, a single infeed roller, a single outfeed roller, and his shop is only 10x10 with no large door, how is he supposed to safely and easily make a cut along the 8' length of the panel? That's a pretty typical situation for most homeowner/weekend hobbyist woodworkers.

If you're a professional or a very serious hobbyist with a large shop with 8' of supported infeed and 8' of supported outfeed, a top-end cabinet saw, and two decades of experience, I'm sure it's no longer difficult for you to cut a panel down and I'm sure you're set enough in your ways that any other method seems needless. However, you are not a typical woodworker. For every one of you guys, think how many guys there must be that bought a mid-range contractor's saw at Lowes and is really damned proud of themselves for buying the best tool they'll ever buy. Stepping up from that even, compare that to the guy who goes into Woodcraft and buys the cheapest saw they have because that's all he can afford but has to share his "shop" with the fact that it's a 1-car garage and his wife gets to park in there. He doesn't have room to store a full infeed and outfeed table even if he opened the garage door and wheeled the saw right up to the edge of the slab. He's lucky if she'll let him buy 2 stands and keep them around.

You do not need 8ft of infeed and outfeed tables. You dont need any infeed tables and only need about 3 or 4 ft of outfeed even if its a fold down. You dont need a cabinet saw. you only need enough weight to keep the saw from tipping over so most contractor and jobsite saws on a stable stand work fine for sheet good rips. Tracksaws excel in cross cutting cuts over 24" if all you have is a jobsite saw. As already mentioned any circular saw cuts wood and compliments a table saw real nice. Unless you plan on buying into a whole system like Festool, just the tracksaw alone is not a wise investment IMO. If you plan on bucking up to the whole system then you are moving a wee bit closer to the capabilities of a tablesaw but no matter how much you spend on festool its still just a compliment to a tablesaw.

I know a cabinet maker that uses nothing but festool but all he does is frameles cabinets and buys his doors from me. He does very well for himself but still pays to have all hardwood lumber straightlined and s4s. This type of woodworking is exactly what Festool was designed for.

Don

You do not need 8ft of infeed and outfeed tables. You dont need any infeed tables and only need about 3 or 4 ft of outfeed even if its a fold down.

OK, you still need 8' of infeed and 8' of outfeed space plus a foot or so for the saw. How do you do that in a shop who's longest dimension is less than 17'?

Unless you plan on buying into a whole system like Festool, just the tracksaw alone is not a wise investment IMO.

If you're getting into woodworking, you're buying a whole system no matter what. You might buy it all with the same paint on it, you might not. There's no project of any complexity that you can take from start to finish with just one tool. I agree that the tracksaw alone does not a workshop make. Neither can you have a complete workshop out of just a tablesaw. You are going to buy supporting tools no matter what. I've bought a lot of stuff that says Festool on it, sure, but I've also bought a lot of stuff that says Ryobi, Rikon, Delta, Craftsman, Bosch, etc. Regardless of the labeling, it all works together as a system.

If you plan on bucking up to the whole system then you are moving a wee bit closer to the capabilities of a tablesaw but no matter how much you spend on festool its still just a compliment to a tablesaw.

I find this a hilarious statement considering how many people get by without a tablesaw. I get by just fine without one. There's literally nothing I want to do in woodoworking that I could do with a tablesaw that I can't do with other tools. I've already made it clear that I don't do coves, ever, which are about the only thing any of us in this thread could think of that's truly tablesaw-specific. You can absolutely do without a tablesaw. A tablesaw is a convenience item in that it allows you to do a lot of jobs with one tool. However, it's only convenient if you've got the space and money for it. If you don't have the space and money for a good tablesaw, then a tracksaw can be a really good solution to the problem. If you do have the space and money for either, then you should decide based on what you want your workflow to be, not what old fogies traditionally use. Hell, I thought I had to have a tablesaw because my Dad had a tablesaw and his dad before him. I've actually got my grandfather's tablesaw stored in the basement. Then I started out on my own and didn't have a permanent place to set up and leave a tablesaw. So I researched options and found people using the tracksaw in combination with other tools to replace everything a tablesaw can do (except coves :rolleyes: ) while being light enough to carry with a herniated disc and small enough to pack away at the end of each day's work. It's a viable alternative and doesn't require a tablesaw to make the whole system function.

He does very well for himself but still pays to have all hardwood lumber straightlined and s4s. This type of woodworking is exactly what Festool was designed for.

I make larger furniture without a tablesaw, jointer, or any other heavy in-place machinery. I start from rough sawn stock. Straightline it with the Festool tracksaw. Surface joint it with a Festool router. Throw it through a Ryobi planer. Cut it to final dimensions with the tracksaw again. Cut the joinery with whatever tool is correct for the task. Glue it up. No tablesaw ever involved. No desire to have one. I do wish I had a big jointer though!

A tablesaw-free workflow is not for everyone. However, it isa viable option that's capable of working just as well as a workflow involving a tablesaw. You guys need to stop pretending that tablesaws are the One True Way.

There is no ONE way. Capabilities of different tools can be argued, but let's stay respectful of each other and how we wish to approach different tasks. A person's choice can't be berated here. It is not allowed. Everyone has different capabilities and comfort levels with a variety of tools. Whatever works for you is OK. Just be safe and enjoy the journey.

(null)

Although I would never get rid of my own table saw, when I first started makeing cabinets/furniture I was in my 20's, and my needs where many, but my buget was small. Me being a carpenter I had all the basic hand tools+ a model 77 skill saw, and I built some very nice projects some of which are still with me today 30 years later. My point is you don't need a table saw to be a good woodworker, and if a table saw scares the crap out of you than don't buy one. There is more than one way to skin a cat , when I watch Roy Uderhill I'm facinated with how they use to do things without all the modern power tools, and how fast they where able to turn logs to a finished project. I have a nice array of power tools in my shop, and i'm capable of running full sheet of ply/mdf through my table saw, but more times than not I brack them down with you guessed it the old model 77 skill saw it will always have a spot in my shop. A skill saw costs $160 a Track saw $700 I'm not saying the track saw isn't worth the money, but I'll bet if you make a simple jig out of a couple pieces of ply wood you will have a very accurate tool with just an ordinary circular saw.

post-2926-0-74072000-1305825391_thumb.jp

This is a very simple jig, and you'll need to use a couple clamps to hold it in place with this, and a good blade, some inginuity you can produce some remarkable projects I use a skill saw every day in my duties as a carpenter, but it's no table saw.

A skill saw costs $160 a Track saw $700 I'm not saying the track saw isn't worth the money, but I'll bet if you make a simple jig out of a couple pieces of ply wood you will have a very accurate tool with just an ordinary circular saw.

And that Model 77 has much more power, is built better and will last much longer.

Don

I used a worm drive Skil and a guide for a long time. That and a good blade will cut nice clean lines.

(null)

Most of the arguements with track saws boil down to space and lack of experience. Most that argue their merit, lack space or experience. The Festool tracksaw is in no way a replacment for a tablesaw its one tool in a system of tools designed for onsite euro style cabinetry. They do what they are designed to do very well and thats onsite frameless cabinetry where the hardwood work is done back at the shop on the real machinery. If you do this as a hobby then a tracksaw is a neat addition to a tablesaw but is not a replacement. Tracksaws are not the best thing for ripping or crosscutting hardwoods, thats why they made the Kapex. Tracksaws dont cut dados, thats why the system employs routers. Tracksaws dont do well with small narrow rips thats one reason for the mft. Tacksaws dont cut tenons thats why they made the domino. Its a system and if you happen to own the entire system there are many operations that can be performed away from the shop but there are many that have to be done at the shop on real machinery prior to getting on the jobsite. For a hobby guy this really means that the track saw is nothing more than a compliment to their other machinery. Hobby folks dont seem to care about time so the whole arguement that a tablesaw is more efficient seems to go in one ear and out the other. For alot of folks sheet goods seem to be the biggest issue what ever the issue may be tiny bench top saw, lack of space or just plain dont have the experience irregardless if you need a tracksaw to cut sheet goods then by all means buy one. So many time folks claim that just the material handling is a better. They claim that lifting heavy sheet good onto a saw is to much of a chore but yet they seem to not have issues with lifting that same sheet onto a workwork bench. I would just not have any dilusions that it is a replacement for a decent tablesaw. FWIW a the litte pc wormdrive saws and a elcheapo guide clamp have more power than the ts55 and will cut the same straight line for half the money and I suspect will last twice as long. With a bucks worth of hardboard any saw can be zero clearance and will cut just as clean. IMO keep the tablesaw and buy a tracksaw or any other like the pc worm drive if you dont want to try cutting sheetgoods on a tablesaw.

Don

Amen, brother! Well said!

I have a typical Festool setup, TS55, MFT, couple of the routers, parallel guides, Kapex, LR32, guide rails out the wazoo, they're all great and have their uses. I also have a Bosch tablesaw mounted in a custom table with an Incra fence. Big sheet goods get ripped to rough size on sawhorses with the TS55, wide pieces crosscut on the MFT, small stuff crosscut on the Kapex. Almost everything ends up going through the crap-tastic Bosch before it's all said and done.

Set the fence to 10", the work comes out 10". No tape measures, no bumping guide rail or worrying about whether the TS55 has new or old blade, how many mm is 10" ? on the parallel guides, squinting to line up their pointers, I just set the fence, it locks in and I get a 10" rip +- 1/128"(about all I can see on my dial caliper). Stack a 4" rip on top of a 6" rip next to that 10" rip, I can't feel a difference. If I want to do it again tomorrow, next week or next year it's all the same. It doesn't matter how many cuts I've made in the meantime, that 10" is still 10". "Precise repeatibility" in spades, over time. I can't get that with eyeball, pencil marks and tape measures.

I love my Festools, wouldn't live without them but they have their limitations. For on-site work or rough-cutting sheet goods they can't be beat. But I'm not putting my tablesaw on Craigslist anytime soon...

Just MHO,

Bill

  • 4 weeks later...

Wow. I had no idea this topic was so polarizing. I liken it to the Harley or Metric motorcycle argument (Harley, of course) :)

I followed this thread as I have a table saw but am considering buying a track saw. Even Marc, who loves Festool, says he uses his table saw on every project. I love the idea of a track saw for breaking down sheet goods. Once they fit on my table saw safely they can be dimensioned efficiently and then I can use a variety of tools for joinery such as my router table, miter saw, etc. For me, it's about safety, efficiency and end result. I have an MJ splitter, two Grippers, and an Incra 5000 sled to boot, for my table saw. I use my Woodpeckers PR-2 router table with a PC 7518 for shaping - including cove molding which I just made with it for a bookcase project. The idea of running a piece of lumber across the blade of the table saw at the angle to make cove molding makes me cringe. I love my bandsaw for narrow stock, but use my table saw as well, WITH the Grippers. I plan to learn how to use hand tools such as planes later this year (wish I had learned from my grandfather, but I was too stupid when I was a kid to know how much it would have changed my life).

IMHO, whatever system works best for you, as long as you're safe and are pleased with the final product, that's the right system.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.