Midtone Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 I am new to woodworking and am struggling with this and what it means. Over the past few months I have been collecting hand tools and building things. I do own a radial arm saw, scroll saw, and router and the usual assortment of small power tools. I know I can give up the router no problem. The radial arm saw is nice, but I could get by with out it. The scroll saw fun but not at all necessary. A bandsaw, table saw, and drill press are the 3 items I keep going back and forth on. There are so many hand tool people that still use these. Personally I do not care for the noise and mess of any power tools. I guess I am having a spiritual crisis. Can I make a living going totally Neanderthal? What if i had to make 10 chairs by next Tuesday? Could it be done. I know it is not a sin to run machines but I just don't want to. Ah well.. Quote
rmac Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 Can I make a living going totally Neanderthal? What if i had to make 10 chairs by next Tuesday? Could it be done. I know it is not a sin to run machines but I just don't want to. So don't run machines. If the truth be known, it's really hard to make a living as a woodworker any way you do it. So do all the handwordk you want as a hobby and just don't quit your day job. If you get lucky and find a moneymaking niche, great ... go for it. If you don't and just enjoy woodworking as a hobby, also great ... you'll have plenty of cutting boards to give away at Christmas. -- Russ Quote
duckkisser Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 dont care for all the noise eather but my hand cuts arent as acurate as my machine cuts so i find myself going to the machines more often then not. as for making 10 chairs in a week dont think so. maybe you should think about going into fine work like inlay, turning, carving ect.....alot of those tool are a quiet machines. most days i can have my lathe going and have people in the room and dont know that im cuting on it. and most carving is done with hand tools and carving burs that have a steady hummm but its not like the decibels that come from a planer. honestly i think its imposible to go one or the other and iliminate the other side for long. hand tool yes but you lose time because a hand saw cant rip's as fast as table saw no matter how great you are at it. and machines just dont get the fine cuts and shapes that a hand tool produces. Quote
Fricasseekid Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 Norm Abrams pees on his leg just a little every time Roy Underhill walks into the room. Don't even get me started on Chris Schwarz... Quote
HoboMonk Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 Why do you have to choose sides? Why must you label yourself or others? 2 Quote
theapprenticeshand Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 I am new to woodworking and am struggling with this and what it means. Over the past few months I have been collecting hand tools and building things. I do own a radial arm saw, scroll saw, and router and the usual assortment of small power tools. I know I can give up the router no problem. The radial arm saw is nice, but I could get by with out it. The scroll saw fun but not at all necessary. I can't give up the router. Too useful. Radial arm saw could be ditchable quite easily. And unless you are doing marquetry/inlay, the scroll saw isn't of much use. A bandsaw, table saw, and drill press are the 3 items I keep going back and forth on. There are so many hand tool people that still use these. Personally I do not care for the noise and mess of any power tools. Bandsaw is crazy useful in a hand tool shop. Table saw is nice for rips and sheet goods, but if you aren't using those, then you could ditch the tablesaw. Drill press could be tossed though. Those are great if you are into toolmaking, but other than that aren't necessary I guess I am having a spiritual crisis. Can I make a living going totally Neanderthal? What if i had to make 10 chairs by next Tuesday? Could it be done. I know it is not a sin to run machines but I just don't want to. Can you? Maybe. Would you want to? Likely not. If I have to make 10 chairs, I'm going to want jigs that help me make the same parts repeatedly. If I am instead making one-off pieces, that's where the hand tools shine. Still wouldn't want to give up a planer. That would be the last tool to go. The screaming demon is a siren's song. Quote
areynoldsre Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 Why do you have to choose sides? Why must you label yourself or others? I am with you - what's the need to pick a side or a label. What ever happened to, "The right tool for the right job"? When you need a power tool, use a power tool. Have the spiritual need to spend the afternoon with a hand plane - grab the plane. Making a living with hand tools means you likely need to move to more art gallery quality work rather than 8 chairs by Tuesday. Quote
dwacker Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 I guess I am having a spiritual crisis. Can I make a living going totally Neanderthal? What if i had to make 10 chairs by next Tuesday? Could it be done. I know it is not a sin to run machines but I just don't want to. Ah well.. Sounds like you have future hopes of doing this as more than just a hobby. Although I think the handtool folks have some great skill but I dont see making a living with just hand tools. First its hard on your body, you dont want to end up like me being forced to retire. Second you need to push some real volume. Your ten chairs by next tuesday senerio is not likely to happen with just hand tools. The thought process would need to be how can I make ten chairs ready for finish by tomorrow afternoon? If you want to get serious about doing one off stuff with just hand tools then keep your day job. Get some stuff into some of the high end galleries and see how it goes. Don Quote
Midtone Posted May 15, 2012 Author Report Posted May 15, 2012 I am not really trying to choose sides, just wondering how practical it would be to ditch all the machines. I am ready to sell off all my machines right now to get just a bandsaw. It seems like the one that even the most die- hard hand toolers have in their shop and I can see why. Still, I am reluctant. I could use a bow saw. Maybe. I would like to move into gallery work or find a niche where I could use nothing but hand tools. I give the 10 chair example as I am wondering about replication and consistency with hand tools. I am young and I have the strength to do the amount of work necessary, but at what point does it become not worth it? And will I be able to maintain consistency? If I make a dinning room table it is a spendy item that can be replicated, but it is unlikely I will make 10 of the same one. I guess in the old days if you were making 10 chairs you either had a shop with several people or king Louis understood they would not be done for 6 months.. Quote
Fricasseekid Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 My understanding is that once a wood joiner reaches a certain level of expertise the only way to challenge oneself is to switch over to hand tools. When one has practiced a craft for 30-40+ years, the only thing left to do for a true purist is get back to the grass roots of wood working culture. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 Why do you have to choose sides? Why must you label yourself or others? Two thumbs up on that! 2 Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 If you have power in you shop at all you can't be a Neanderthal But labels are just labels and don't mean much (unless it says high voltage, then it might hurt a might). Use the tools you enjoy and don't use the ones you don't enjoy no matter what the inclination you have (power or unplugged). Quote
areynoldsre Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 I give the 10 chair example as I am wondering about replication and consistency with hand tools. I am young and I have the strength to do the amount of work necessary, but at what point does it become not worth it? And will I be able to maintain consistency? Why do all 10 exactly the same? Make each with a variation. Artsy people like that kind of thing - in fact purposely make the table and chairs with 10 very different chairs. and you can get consistency in hand tools the same way we do with power tools - jigs and fixtures and patterns. Quote
Midtone Posted May 15, 2012 Author Report Posted May 15, 2012 Thanks Andrew. That is encouraging thought. I can see where one could make a number of chairs with little differences yet still hold the same design. Not every Louis XV chair is the same. At any rate i am still learning and I would indeed like to make a career out of it using as little power tools as possible. Quote
Eric. Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 I think Don got to the crux of your question... If you're wanting to make a living woodworking and using only hand tools, you're gonna have to break into the galleries, the "art world," so to speak, and make a name for yourself somehow so you can make big money on few pieces. Not an easy thing to do. How many little league baseball players make it to the big leagues? I'd say that's about your chances of becoming a successful designer/craftsman. There's a reason we all dream about that...it's just a dream, for the VAST majority of us. You gotta have serious talent and artistic vision, and then you have to get lucky or know the right people on top of it. There are a lot of amazing woodworkers out there who we've never heard of because they don't have any connections to the scene. On the other hand, if you're planning to get into production work to make a living, it ain't gonna happen without power tools. So I'd advise holding onto them until you make that decision. If you decide to keep it as just a hobby, there are no rules. Do what makes you happy. Quote
JMort847 Posted July 8, 2012 Report Posted July 8, 2012 I consider myself to be a hybrid. I started with power years ago, but have been learning about and enjoying hand tools for the last two years. I think both have their place and time, which leads to more learning and fun in the shop. As others have said, efficient production requires power, but there are times when a hand saw, hand plane or bit and brace can be quicker - and with practice, just as accurate. Sometimes ya "feel the need for power" and sometimes ya just gotta "unplug"... Quote
Hybrid-woodworker Posted July 15, 2012 Report Posted July 15, 2012 I agree with woodwork guy. Use the right tool for the job. The right tool is the one you are comfortable with, does the job correctly and in the time necessary. I have watched Norm and Roy for years , I would not to work 100% either way. I turn a lot but don't use a treadle or spring poll lathe. I use the bandsaw a a lot because it leaves more time at the lathe.. I use my block planes and chisels almost every time I am in the shop. I'm learning to use a hand saw but doubt that I will give up either my Table or miter saw. Have fun for a years and develope some skill and perhaps even some local following before goings in full time. 1 Quote
Tom Conover Posted July 16, 2012 Report Posted July 16, 2012 Wow, this post sure drew the input!! I am a fan of Schwarz, Underhill AND Abrams AND "The Wood Whisperer" I try to do most of my work with hand tools but I sure wish I had had access to a timber framer's power mortiser (neat video on Schwarz' blog) when I was doing the 6x6s for my workbench. While I have never seen Roy use a power tool, Chris seems to be very pragmatic about the subject. Why rip 20 2x12s or a 4x8 sheet of 3/4 plywood with a hand saw? Quote
HoboMonk Posted July 24, 2012 Report Posted July 24, 2012 I strictly adhere to the principles of the Japano-Appalachian Neo-Neanderthalic Normite style of woodworking. Thank goodness my clients don't feel that I must adhere to some external cult-like labeling. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.