Tony Wilkins Posted June 3, 2012 Report Posted June 3, 2012 There's a list of stuff I feel I 'should' make myself... Bench hooks (already bought, $45) Shooting board ($130 - ouch) Marking gauge ($89) Panel Gauge ($85) Saw Benches (haven't found to buy but my two tiny saws aren't up to the task so yet another expense) mallet (could get a chester plane adjusting for $57 and a Chris Schwarz approve in-fill mallet for $185) moxon vise - $389 straight edge - $$$ for a metal one as long as I could make from wood winding sticks -$30 square - $179 for 3" partridge with optional pear tree - priceless ...but am intimidated because I don't feel I have the right tools yet or the skill. I can see where you could buy your way into this and spend quite a bunch without developing the skill to make these bench accessories etc. So where do I start?!?!?! Quote
rmac Posted June 3, 2012 Report Posted June 3, 2012 So where do I start? Same answer here I think as for the one about which tools you need: 1. Pick a project you want to build. 2. Build whatever shop "stuff" you need to build project. 3. Build project. 4. Go to #1. -- Russ Quote
nateswoodworks Posted June 4, 2012 Report Posted June 4, 2012 Most of the stuff on your list is great projects for you to built. It will not only save you a ton of money but help your skills progress at the same time. Get yourself a nice square. I spent over 15yrs with engineers squares and after dropping one about a year and a half ago I had enough and bought a Starrett combination square, spendy but when you look at what I spent on other squares ($20 or so every year or two!!) The marking gauge is a personal choice. I have mad a couple but I still prefer my Veritas. All the rest on your list , except the sawbenches-don't have or really personally need them, I built and would suggest you may really want to consider doing the same. Moxxon vise would be nice but I am goint to make a shopmade version in a couple months. Straight edges, saw benches, mallets, shooting boards, and winding sticks are all easily built and you can make them as basic or complicated as you wish as learn a lot as you go. Just my opinion. Quote
Popular Post Bob Rozaieski Posted June 4, 2012 Popular Post Report Posted June 4, 2012 There's a list of stuff I feel I 'should' make myself... ...but am intimidated because I don't feel I have the right tools yet or the skill. ...So where do I start?!?!?! What's your goal? If you just want to acquire the tools/appliances, then just buy them and be done with it. Let me ask a question though. You mention that you feel you don't have the skill to make these objects. If you were to buy them, would you then have the skill to make them? Would you then have the skill to use them to make something more complicated, like a piece of furniture? I think you see where I'm going with this. Be honest with yourself about what you really want to get out of woodworking. There are A LOT of folks that get into this hobby mostly to collect pretty tools and create a shrine to those tools. And I'm not judging those folks. If that's what a person wants, then by all means that's what they should do. However, if your true goal is to learn the skills to work proficiently with those tools, then the only way you are going to do that is to work with those tools. Building shop appliances lets you practice critical skills on non critical items that require little investment in lumber and little loss when you screw up, which you will do. Mistakes are inevitable. I've been involved in the craft for over 20 years and I still make mistakes on a daily basis. But you learn from them and you move on. You are never going to avoid making boards for the firewood pile. It's part of learning, because if you don't use the tools, you can't learn the skills. But personally, I'd prefer to screw up on a $5 piece of scrap for a shop appliance rather than a $50 piece of mahogany for a furniture part. Here's a hypothetical example using your $30 winding sticks, which are simply a pair of small boards with parallel edges. If you just want to acquire a pair of winding sticks, you could go spend the $30 and be done with it. However, here are a few skills you could learn and practice by taking that $30, going to the lumber yard to get a piece of wood and making your own:hand sawing to a lineplaning rough lumberreading grain directionusing marking and gauging tools correctlyplaning 2 boards to identical dimensions Every one of these skills takes practice to learn. A pair of winding sticks will require a very small piece of that $30 board (probably 25% or less). If you get them right the first time, you have 75% of the board left to use for other things. If you screw them up, you can toss them, cut a new piece from what's left of your board and practice some more. In the end, even if you go through the entire board and only end up with a single pair of good winding sticks, you're still ahead of the game because you haven't spent any more money than you would have if you bought a pair, but you've practiced and learned valuable skills along the way by screwing up the first few pair; skills that you can and will use when you build other projects in the future. Not to mention you've probably had some enjoyable shop time working wood in the process. So which sounds more appealing to you? 4 Quote
pagel Posted June 4, 2012 Report Posted June 4, 2012 I just had a similar question about a router table - For me the issue is needing a router table to do a bunch of projects over the summer and wanting to spend that time building those projects rather than on shop tools and jigs. I love building my own tools and jigs but this time around I need the time more than the perceived money savings. I seem to ask these type of questions with the decision pretty much made, looking for that more experienced woodworker to convince me otherwise. Quote
HoboMonk Posted June 4, 2012 Report Posted June 4, 2012 What Bob said... Acquire skills, not tools. 1 Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 4, 2012 Author Report Posted June 4, 2012 My goal is definitely to build things and not to just acquire tools (though that impulse is there sometimes). It's the not acquiring tools that's giving me pause. Let's continue with the winding sticks. Seems so simple. I have "The New Traditional woodworker" book and he shows how to make it - but I don't have a jointer plane yet so I put that project on hold until I get one eventually. I think my first project is going to be a mallet. I have a plan I found and now need to get some wood. Is a 2x2 turning blank a good size to start to make the head out of? If not, what is a good way to get the wood I need for it? Thanks for all the responses so far. Tony Quote
Bob Rozaieski Posted June 4, 2012 Report Posted June 4, 2012 For a small mallet, a 2x2 turning blank might be OK, but for a large, heavy joiner's size mallet, it's too small. I made a mallet out of Home Depot 3/4" oak (top one in the picture). No joinery cutting required. Just cut the parts to size, glue together and then plane it all to clean it up. The head is laminated from 4 pieces. Two long pieces for the outside faces, two short pieces for the inside. Glue the short pieces between the long pieces to leave a tapered mortise in the center of the head. Then plane a handle to fit the tapered mortise. You could build this with nothing more than a single hand saw, a block or smooth plane, a pencil, a ruler and a couple of clamps. Lumber requirements are a single 1x4 or 1x6 piece of oak from the home center. You'll have leftover wood to make other things from too. Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 4, 2012 Author Report Posted June 4, 2012 Good idea on the 3/4 HD stock. I had come up with doing it that way from this plan: http://www.craftsmanspace.com/Free%20projects/Wooden%20Mallet.pdf and laminating in stead of chiseling out the tapered mortise. The oak would probably be cheaper than the walnut I was thinking about getting from a local hardwood yard. BTW @ Bob Rozaieski: Been enjoying you blog and videos, very informative. Wilbur linked the bench without a bench video to me a few days ago. Quote
wilburpan Posted June 4, 2012 Report Posted June 4, 2012 Let's continue with the winding sticks. Seems so simple. I have "The New Traditional woodworker" book and he shows how to make it - but I don't have a jointer plane yet so I put that project on hold until I get one eventually. Just so you know, you can make a winding stick that is flat with a tiny block plane. A jointer plane makes it easier to make a flat surface, but it's not a necessity. One of the first things I ever did with woodworking was get a pine board from the borg that was 12" x 36", which had a decent cup in it, being borg lumber. Then I took a #4 plane and flattened it, then tried to get a smooth surface on it. That day I started working on the board after lunch, and by the end of the afternoon I had learned just about everything I needed to know about how a plane works, even though many would consider a #4 to be too small for flattening a board like that. Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 4, 2012 Author Report Posted June 4, 2012 Well, as an update. On my little rough box I’m making: ripped the second side and now have two even boards with 6 edges true, flat and even - all with my 210mm ryoba and a 48mm $30 kanna. I’m feeling pretty good so I might try the straight edge with a long thin piece of poplar I have. Quote
theapprenticeshand Posted June 5, 2012 Report Posted June 5, 2012 There's a list of stuff I feel I 'should' make myself... Bench hooks (already bought, $45) Shooting board ($130 - ouch) Make this for $20 Marking gauge ($89) Lee valley for $45 Panel Gauge ($85) Saw Benches (haven't found to buy but my two tiny saws aren't up to the task so yet another expense) About $10 for the BORG lumber to make two of em mallet (could get a chester plane adjusting for $57 and a Chris Schwarz approve in-fill mallet for $185) Get a small 4oz ball peen hammer for plane adjusting and a regular wood mallet can be made quite easily moxon vise - $389 straight edge - $$$ for a metal one as long as I could make from wood winding sticks -$30 two pieces of aluminum channel for real cheap square - $179 for 3" square shouldn't cost more than a $15/20. You are going the rolls royce route when you could go the toyota route and accomplish the same thing. Quote
Vic Posted June 5, 2012 Report Posted June 5, 2012 Build what you want to build, buy what you'd rather buy. Just be honest and true to yourself. By the way, my winding stick are two pieces of 1x4 primered mdf trim with a sharpie highlighting the top edge of one of the sticks. Scrap = free. Maybe two minutes to complete. (null) Quote
Tom Conover Posted June 14, 2012 Report Posted June 14, 2012 Well, I had more money than brains... I had always wanted to be a "woodworker" so when I retired I just started buying "stuff". It wasn't until I startted reading David Charlesworth, Chris Schwarz, Roy Underhill, etc. that sanity finally took over. By now I had a pretty nice collection of tools but little skill to match. I purchased Schwarz's "The Anarchist's Tool Chest" and used that as my guide. I made a bench hook, a shooting board, winding sticks, two saw benches and am now working on building a Roubo workbench out of southern yellow pine 2x10x10s and 4x6s. I started to rip the 2x10s by hand but after ripping 3 of those 10 footers I swallowed my pride and got out the contractors saw and the rip guide and ripped the others. I'm also going to use my router and a sled (ala Marc Spagnuolo) to level off the top. While I would like to stop with the power tools, somethings are way too labor intensive to not use them. I have come a long way with my sawing skills but my skill with planes and chisels is a work in progress. When my bench is complete I would like to build a Frank Lloyd Wright style entertainment center for my daughter but first, I will be building and leaning on benches and boxes. Tom Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.