Recommended Posts

Posted

Would you like to elaborate a bit on your expected uses for the sander?

The Rotex RO90 is a good all-rounder for small surfaces and its larger siblings for larger surfaces and anything from aggressive material removal to polishing.

Then the ETS-series is deemed as the finish sander extra ordinaire and some love the DTS's for corner finishing. Some love their belt sanders etc.

This subject has been debated to death on FOG (http://www.festoolownersgroup.com) so I would suggest try a search there first.

Posted

ETS is a great finishing sander. Wouldn't recommend it for rough work but it sands large flat surfaces wonderfully. Festools Rubrin sandpaper lasts a long time which saves me $$ even at the price they charge for a box. You do need a vac with suction control to best use with one of these sanders. Mine did not have it and I was wearing out the velcro pads. I drilled some holes in the hose fitting and reduced the suction a bit, still picks up all the dust.

Posted

The sander would mostly be used for finish sanding. I have a Ridgid 5 inch random orbit sander, it does a good job at sanding but the dust collection is horrible. Is a Festool sander better then my Ridgid? If so what makes is so much better?

Posted

I use an ETS150/3 for finish sanding with Granat paper. The magic words are: No Dust. (When connected to a CT vac)

Love the nearly non-existant vibrations too :-)

The choise between the /3 and /5 models is a question of taste. The stroke lenght is denoted in mm after the slash.

Some prefer the Mirka Ceros sanders for handling, but I personally don't like the idea of a separate transformer to lug around. DC should be excellent on them too.

Posted

The sander would mostly be used for finish sanding. I have a Ridgid 5 inch random orbit sander, it does a good job at sanding but the dust collection is horrible. Is a Festool sander better then my Ridgid? If so what makes is so much better?

What are you using to collect the dust?

Posted

The sander would mostly be used for finish sanding. I have a Ridgid 5 inch random orbit sander, it does a good job at sanding but the dust collection is horrible. Is a Festool sander better then my Ridgid? If so what makes is so much better?

The real value of Festool sanders are when they are used in conjunction with good dust collection. I bought a DX90, it's a good finish sander that has a 3" round head that can act as a random orbit sander, or put into rotary sander mode for more aggressive material removal. It also has a delta head that's good for getting into corners with. Paired with a good shop vac like the Festool CT series and it makes an amazingly low amount of dust. If you don't have that capability, you might start looking there.

Posted

In my experience, none of the above unless you want to buy a gaggle of them. Festool makes some really nice tools(I own a bunch) but to me their sanders seem to be pretty specialized and overall don't handle any better than their less expensive competition. And(at least for me) how a sander handles is the most important aspect as long as it does a good job of removing stock and preparing the surface. For Festool it seems that this sander does that well but you need another for small pieces, another for aggresive work, another for finishing work, by the way this one is for for detail sanding and you need a bunch of overly expensive pads to carve out to fit that particular profile....

So I went for the more expensive competition(how often can you say that about a Festool product?) and got a really nice handling lightweight all-around sander. The dust collection works just as well or better than the Festool, I don't have to deal with a seemingly infinite number of choices when I buy discs and it works for just about everything. I can deal with hand-sanding the rest, what little there is.(BTW, the Granat discs are really nice in the sub-100 sizes, I like them lots better than the Abranet HD.)

Just 'cause it says Festool on the box doesn't mean it's the end-all be-all in woodworking tools, they have their strengths and weaknesses. You don't hear much about the weaknesses but they're there nonetheless. Go out and play with some, evaluate them, then look at the competition and your wallet. You have to decide what you want from a particular tool, what you're able/willing to spend and the implications for your workflow. If a stack of Festools meets your expectations and budget, go for it. But there are alternatives.

Kool-Aid is nothing but chemicals, dyes and processed sugar regardless of the color. None of it is good for you. Make your own decisions based on your own requirements and experiences. Take some time to know what those are, play around with different choices, discover for yourself what fits your needs.

Just saying...

Best,

Bill

P.S. Marc, WTF doesn't Firefox's speelcheck refuse to work on this forum? :wacko:

  • 1 month later...
Posted

The sander would mostly be used for finish sanding. I have a Ridgid 5 inch random orbit sander, it does a good job at sanding but the dust collection is horrible. Is a Festool sander better then my Ridgid? If so what makes is so much better?

My first post here. I have a Ridgid 5" sander and was happy with it for years. Then after sanding 3 walnut table tops one morning I started to look around. First, it took a lot of work with 80 grit with the Ridgid after 120 on the drum sander and several hours sanding the tops. Second, everything in my shop was covered in fine dust even with an air cleaner and downdraft table.

I ended up getting a Festool ETS 150/5 and CT 26 and love them. Sanding time is cut dramatically and it leaves a better surface. There is no dust when sanding and sandpaper seems to last forever. Also the ETS is incredibly smooth and my hand isn't vibrating when I'm done.

  • 2 months later...
Posted

Mirka looses in longevity and build quality, I was very disappointed.

Don

 

That stinks, I always thought they were good.  I don't own any but that is disappointing.

 

chris

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined