Recommended Posts

Posted

I was just curious how many people have planers bigger than the standard 13" model? I was thinking about upgrading to a larger unit from my 13" planer if finances allow.

Can anybody vouch for a 15" or larger planer? This should help me begin my preliminary reserch.

I'm not sure a 15" planer is worth the extra money, as it can plane only 2" more than a lunchbox style.

What about the helix heads? They seem to get excellent reviews. Can anyone provide first hand info on things like tear out?

Posted

It's not necessarily the 2" although they come in handy. When you move up to a 15" or more, you're also getting at least a 3 HP induction motor rather than the universal motors you get on a lunchbox planer. This means more power and a much longer lifespan.

Posted

It's not necessarily the 2" although they come in handy. When you move up to a 15" or more, you're also getting at least a 3 HP induction motor rather than the universal motors you get on a lunchbox planer. This means more power and a much longer lifespan.

Valid points. Thanks.

Posted

I've used several Grizzly 20's and 24's and they're great. Also a Powermatic 24 and I liked that. My favorite was an antique 36" Bus planer. Now that was a planer. Of course it weighed in at over a ton and was three phase, but you could make some really nice table tops with it.

Posted

I'm curious, what is everyone doing that a 13+ planer is needed? The tables, blanket chests and headboards I have done did not need a planer that wide but the wide drum sander was a big help. Plane the narrower boards, glue them up carefully and run them through the sander.

BRuce

Posted

For me it wasn't so much the max width as power, capability and speed (more specifically time required to mill the lumber). Making the jump to something larger than 13" also meant a jump in power supply (220v). Planers of this sort are wood shaving machines. I always had to take light skim cuts with my old dewalt when I was working with 10"+ wide stock (and half the time I would trip the internal breaker). My larger delta can take twice the thickness cut and not even grunt on the same width or more..

Posted

Stepping up from a lunchbox to a stationary planer gets you a vastly stronger chassis. More than anything you can do with in- and outfeed support, a sturdy frame is really the key to preventing snipe as the board enters and exits the machine.

Have you been dissatisfied with the planer you have now? Is your current lunchbox planer holding you back?

Posted

For me, its the noise. The number one reason that I am planning on upgrading. I know that the larger machines are still loud, but its a different kind of loud. Not that screaming whine that comes with the lunchbox planers. Size, weight, solidity second.Then width is number three. My decision is, do I go for the 15" or the 20"? And I am a Grizzly man. It will be green with a spiral head..

Posted

I have also been considering a larger planer but the 2 inch increase is not that attractive. I see your point

same material + heavier machine = easier plane. I settled on a compromise with a performax 25x2. I only use my sander for glue ups and finishing and never for a planer, but I do have 24 grit paper if I run into a 13+ board. Im still looking if a deal on a planer ever comes my way.

Posted

For me, its the noise. The number one reason that I am planning on upgrading. I know that the larger machines are still loud, but its a different kind of loud. Not that screaming whine that comes with the lunchbox planers. Size, weight, solidity second.Then width is number three. My decision is, do I go for the 15" or the 20"? And I am a Grizzly man. It will be green with a spiral head..

I have the Grizzly 15" planer with the spiral head. I've worked it hard and it does a great job.

Posted
For me, its the noise. The number one reason that I am planning on upgrading. I know that the larger machines are still loud, but its a different kind of loud. Not that screaming whine that comes with the lunchbox planers. Size, weight, solidity second.Then width is number three. My decision is, do I go for the 15" or the 20"? And I am a Grizzly man. It will be green with a spiral head..

If you can swing the price sac get a 20. I made some cabinet door panels a while ago that were 18" wide. With your big jointer you would be styling and profiling.

-Jason

Posted
I'm curious, what is everyone doing that a 13+ planer is needed? The tables, blanket chests and headboards I have done did not need a planer that wide but the wide drum sander was a big help. Plane the narrower boards, glue them up carefully and run them through the sander.

BRuce

Is changing the paper a long process? I don't have a big sander like that so I don't know. I would think that changing the paper 3 or 4 times on a job would take a long time.

-Jason

Posted

Is changing the paper a long process? I don't have a big sander like that so I don't know. I would think that changing the paper 3 or 4 times on a job would take a long time.

-Jason

Not particularly. It takes a bit of time, but depends on what you're trying to do. I don't tend to change the paper in mine all that often, and depending on how much you're planing you may not need to change it at all.

Posted

For me, its the noise. The number one reason that I am planning on upgrading. I know that the larger machines are still loud, but its a different kind of loud. Not that screaming whine that comes with the lunchbox planers.

One thing about the stationary unit noise to keep in mind is how the addition of the dust collector will affect it. My unit sounds okay by itself, but the air passing over the blades when the DC is on introduces a higher pitched whine (though not as bad as the lunchboxes). Fortunately you may be able to take some of that out with adjustment of the chip collector on the inside. I've often wondered how a spiral head would effect the noise level as well.

Posted

changing paper on a non-velcro drum can be a pain. So I usually make sure to sand everthing I can in the range on the drum before I switch. I wish I had a wide belt sander paper changes take less than 5 secs.

Posted

I appear to be falling behind in the discussion, so I will try and catch up. The noise is not a problem for me, I use hearing protection all the time. 28 to 30db. Faster planing? I guess I have not built a full bedroom suite but I don't spend that amount of time planning for any project I have done so far. 6 maybe 8 10" wide boards at 8 feet long. Doesn't take that long.

I use just 100 grit in the sander, once it is smooth and even, I switch to ROS. I may upgrade to the performix since it appears people have more success with it but unless my planner fails catastrophically I won't upgrade it.

Changing paper in the sander is not a problem for me, just keep it tight and wind evenly. Just takes 10 minutes

Posted

Stepping up from a lunchbox to a stationary planer gets you a vastly stronger chassis. More than anything you can do with in- and outfeed support, a sturdy frame is really the key to preventing snipe as the board enters and exits the machine.

Have you been dissatisfied with the planer you have now? Is your current lunchbox planer holding you back?

No, not really. Just thought it would be nice to be able to plane wider material without having to do a separate glue up up everytime I want a panel larger than 12" or so. I also would like a machine with better DC, and a helix cutter head. Figured if I want all these features, I better look at a bigger class of planer.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined