Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Educate me (on the value of Festool tools)

Featured Replies

I've been woodworking for a long time, and I have a good selection of tools. I'm a "Normite", I like my tools powered.

I've never owned one, but what makes Festool so darn special? They are cretainly proud of their product (based on price), but are they justified?

I own great tools, DeWalt, Makita, Ridgid, Ryobi, Milwaukee, Delta, Porter Cable... all the major players...

What makes Festool so darn special and why shoud I pay twice as much to get the same job done?

Educate me please..

I wondered the same thing when I was looking into their tools. I ended up just recently purchasing a TS 55 Tracksaw from Festool. This tool is solid, well built, powerful, and amazingly accurate. The tool performs extremely well, is very well designed, easy to use, and most important (to me) is the dust collection.

If you are technology savvy, think of these tools like Apple. You have your one set of tools, and then accessories that can be bought from the same company. They are all designed to work together. For the dust collection, it is almost flawless on all their tools. That is because it is designed to work that way. I watched the video of Marc using the CMS router table, and if I remember he said something like, "This table is as accurate as it is because it was designed to fit only the Festool routers. Other tables are designed to fit as many routers as possible."

I also hear great things about their customer service and quality assurance. I also like the three year warranty that came with my TS 55.

I can probably go on and on, but these tools are worth the money in my eyes. I justified my purchase by the time it saved, and amount of safety it produced for me to lay out a 4x8 sheet of plywood on the ground and cut it up accurately the first try with no splintering.

Innovation and top-notch quality. Ferraris are expensive, too.

Good write-up hhh. But I gotta ask...why on earth do you need five shop-vacs, Festool or otherwise? And what's your beef with the FT jigsaws? I like mine a lot. Granted, I don't use it all that often as the need rarely arises. But when I do, smooth sailing...

We won’t discuss FT’s retail model or their recent legal problems in the EU re restraint of trade/retail pricing…

I havn't heard anything about this issue. Can you elaborate a bit?

I only own the TS55 currently and to sound a bit cliche, my only regret is not buying it sooner. I am more of a carpenter than a woodworker and the TS55 is awesome at saving time and producing a great end result. From cutting corian counters to tapered extension jambs it is so quick to get the job done as near perfect as it gets. And cleanup is awesome with the dust collection. I just cut a corian counter the other day in a clients kitchen and there was absolutely no dust to clean up.

As far as some of the other festool products go I will buy some but have no current intentions of buying certain ones.

I've used the kapex and think it is about the same as my Bosch SCMS but I think if I had a kapex once I got used to it I would give it the nod. The price is double but if you think of it as a long term investment is it really that bad. I've had my Bosch for 5 years and use it almost every day. So as far as I'm concerned when a tool gets used that often price is one of the last deciding factors for me. If I'm going to live with a tool day after day I want it to be the best match for me.

If you really want to know why people drink the festool koolaid just go buy one and see for yourself. If you don't like it you can return it within 30 days, no questions asked. That is probably the best way you will understand.

I only own the TS55 currently and to sound a bit cliche, my only regret is not buying it sooner. I am more of a carpenter than a woodworker and the TS55 is awesome at saving time and producing a great end result. From cutting corian counters to tapered extension jambs it is so quick to get the job done as near perfect as it gets. And cleanup is awesome with the dust collection. I just cut a corian counter the other day in a clients kitchen and there was absolutely no dust to clean up.

As far as some of the other festool products go I will buy some but have no current intentions of buying certain ones.

I've used the kapex and think it is about the same as my Bosch SCMS but I think if I had a kapex once I got used to it I would give it the nod. The price is double but if you think of it as a long term investment is it really that bad. I've had my Bosch for 5 years and use it almost every day. So as far as I'm concerned when a tool gets used that often price is one of the last deciding factors for me. If I'm going to live with a tool day after day I want it to be the best match for me.

If you really want to know why people drink the festool koolaid just go buy one and see for yourself. If you don't like it you can return it within 30 days, no questions asked. That is probably the best way you will understand.

I am going to be putting in some more laminate flooring at a relative's house, and this time I can use my TS55 instead of an old Craftsman circular saw. I am actually excited to put this saw to work. The amount of dust that is spewed from laminate wood flooring is unbelievable, especially when making a rip cut. Also, cutting around floor vents and such with the plunge cut option is going to be much safer that what I had done before. I do not own a jig saw, so it had to be done with the circular saw.

==> But I gotta ask...why on earth do you need five shop-vacs

1 - Oneida UDD for general shop-vac

2 - Boom Arm for around Roubo Bench

3 - Dedicated Kapex

4 - Boom Arm w/ 27mm hose around sand/assembly/finish station (sanders, domino, etc).

5 - Garage/DIY (my wife refuses to let me use the Electrolux in the garage anymore after i ruined the last one)

I'll PM you on the jigsaws.

Well that certainly sounds ideal. I'd love to have a dedicated CT for the Roubo and one for the sanding station. I have my Kapex hooked to my central DC...not as perfect collection as it is on a CT, but good enough and way cheaper. :) I use an old Craftsman beater for the DIY and miscellaneous use. I covet your FT collection...

FT got fined e8.2MM in August for price fixing and vertical market control. Sets the stage for a larger EU probe. Will probably come across the pond in CY13. If you know about FT sales agreements, then you know what their legal problems are... here is a link...

http://www.bundeskar.../2012_08_20.php

thanks!

  • Author

Thanks for all the feedback guys, very interesting reading.

Please keep the commentary coming.

Thanks.

HHH that's a heck of a write up. Obviously you have some passion for this subject. I agree with a lot of what you said. One thing I would like to contend is I have the original Hitachi 12" sliding compound miter saw and I think it blows the Bosch SCMS out of the water. The Hitachi is the only one I'm aware of with the bars pointing forward so they don't stick out the back. My Hitachi will sit closer to a wall behind it than the Bosch "Transformer-Style" SCMS, and it has equal length of cut. I don't think it could be more accurate, but it is at least as accurate as the Bosch or Capex. Plus it is tough as a boiled owl. Which I've heard is the Capex's Achillies heel. When I bought it the Bosch hadn't come out but it was 850 less than the Capex.

However, where I agree with you is that I saw the "new" Hitachi 12 inch sliding compound miter the other day and it sure seemed a lot lower quality than what I have. The design "seemed" the same, but it just didn't "feel" the same.

But my Hitachi is one of 3 tools in my shop I don't ever see me up-grading again. The other 2 being the Clearvue, and the SawStop ICS. They'll have to pull all 3 from my cold dead hands.

Here's my dumb question. Back when I looked at the FT routers they were all only marked in Metric. Anyone know if that is still the case?

To me - and this goes for anything from powertools to household appliances and items - it seems like the stuff you get in department stores are always trying to cut corners and quality on something, treated as disposable, or just simply not well thought out. Maybe that wasn't the case once (as already suggested by that drill), but these days it's all about low price and targeting the average consumer who seeks price rather than quality.

Though as already stated on power tools, you still do have good choices in DeWalt, PC, etc. Still, often times they seem to just cover the basics and call it a day. My Makita router is technically a solid router and does the job, but a lot of things pissed me off about it: difficulty to hooking it to a dust collector, cord/hose shooting off in different directions, to the plunge base requiring TIGHTENING A SCREW to lock the unit to a base. Not a good user experience.

Which is why I like Festool, they are quality tools, excellent dust collection and put thought in the little things. Here is what the critics with any popular expensive brand don't understand. If you spend a lot of money on something and walk out disappointed, then you are going to regret spending that money and bash the product/company to hell. (Especially on the internet.) Little makes consumers more angry than feeling ripped off.

But if the company makes an item that provides a very positive user experience, then you won't mind and are far more likely to buy another one of their products because the company has your confidence. You may even go so far as to 'spread the word.' Others who don't understand all this simply dismiss it as a "kool-aid / cult" effect.

Not to say that Festool is a goose that lays golden eggs all the time, not all their products have impressed me and simply seems to be paint-by-numbers or even poorly thought out. I don't know what they were thinking with the very limited depth in the horizontal base of the MFK700, I took it back for that. I also tried out a Kapex about two/three months ago and that immediately went back, there were some definite flaws in the unit that I was even able to replicate on a second Kapex at WoodCraft (to the astonishment of the employees).

But it boils down to this with anything: are you perfectly happy with your current things? If they do the job and using them is satisfactory, then no need to buy anything else, you got exactly what you need already. But if not, then that's when I'd invest in something more. "The bitterness of low quality remains long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten."

This is a great thread, but one distinction that is important in your decision is wheather you are a hobbyist or pro. How many hours are you going to clock on the equipment? How much will you really benefit from some small effeciency gains?

If I had to pick one word to describe Festool vs All other brands, it's simply effeciency or maybe synergy. They work flawlesly with their other tools. You need to clock a lot of time in a shop in order to make those effeciencies worth the price difference, at least on paper. There are many soft benefits that are different for each person, and you unfortunatley have to figure out if they are worth it for you!

Another consideration is that a hobbyist is a paying for the tools with post-tax, disposable income. A pro is purchasing the equipment as a business expense (pre-tax, business funds). Going no further into a financial analysis, we are already talking about 15%-35% real money difference, depending on your tax bracket.

I understand that many pro's view their salary as whatever is left, and would envision the purchase as money out of their pocket, but any accountant or financial professional will disagree.

What is the point I am making? Festool is without arguement a brand targeted at pro's. Yes, hobbyists can use it, but that isn't thier target market, and that isn't a concern for their pricing model. They aren't focusing on the hobbyists, happy to get those they can, but not pricing to. DeWalt, PC, Makita, etc are all jokying to be the "Premium Hobbyist" tool, they are also an economical choice for a Pro. Different business model, different quality, different goals.

I don't know if you live near a Rockler store or not, but if you can get to one, stop in and ask your question to one of thier staffers. I have, on more than one occasion, asked and been given a private showing of a tool I was interested in. Most stores have rooms in the back that they use for demo's and classes, and they'll take you back and let you test drive a few different things, while highlighting some of the big differences.

  • Author

Chris H said ===> "This is a great thread, but one distinction that is important in your decision is wheather you are a hobbyist or pro. "

Agreed, I'm glad I posted the question. I've learned a lot, thanks everyone.

I'd classifiy myself as more than a hobbyist but less than a pro.... Where does that leave me?

Hobbyist or Pro isn't as much a distinction of passion or skill as it is a tax reporting issue. Technically if you are paid to do something, you are a pro, and you should report your earnings and expenses as such.

A lot of people don't want to go through the hassle of reporting money making hobbies to uncle sam. Because of my profession, I am obligated to tell you that you shoud seek professional help from someone who can evaluate your specific situation.

That said, a hobby that generates revenue, but doesn't earn a net profit can be a good thing, potentially reducing your personal tax burden, or future tax liabilities. Reporting earnings from work on the side doesn't have to always be a bad thing.

That said, a hobby that generates revenue, but doesn't earn a net profit can be a good thing, potentially reducing your personal tax burden, or future tax liabilities. Reporting earnings from work on the side doesn't have to always be a bad thing.

Amen to that. You are right about that, but I'm pretty sure that's a different thread.

I'm a professional cabinet maker with 20 years experience and I have survived and thrived just fine without any Festool equipment and I've been around enough Germanic machinery and tool Co's to know how they do business compared to the Japanize, Italians, and the Americans and I don't like how they do business. Because of that am not inclined to ever do business with Festool. Their tools may not stink but their price fixing and arregant attitudes do. So I'm not buying any of their stuff just on principle alone. If everyone stopped paying the outrageous prices they ask then they would either go out of business , lower their prices, or more likely stop marketing in the USA. If you have a large cache of Festool equipment you need to come to grips with the fact that they "got you" with their marketing, much like Mr Dyson did with all those who bought into his overpriced vaccum cleaners. You can believe what you want to believe but it won't change the fact their are plenty of other high quality tools on the market that do the job without having to spend two, three, or four times as much for a Festool. God bless America and free enterprise !

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.