Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

A&C Finishes - Limbert vs Stickley

Featured Replies

I've had a hard time getting the kind of finish on A&C pieces that make my wife happy. I have a formula that gets me very close to an older Stickley finish:

Transtint reddish brown #6003 (this is nearly a cherry red) wiped on with water;

General Finishes Spiced Walnut oil stain - wiped on and then wiped off;

waxed down with Briwax dark brown wax.

I find this gets pretty close to older Stickley.

But even though it matches the traditional Stickely stuff, my wife never really likes it.

Today, we were at an A&C antiques dealer who had several pieces of Limbert - My wife said "that's the color I want".

It appears to me that the Limbert is redder, but it's also quite a bit "warmer" almost a cherry look to it.

Anyone here have a good formula for getting closer to Limbert and that cherry/reddish look instead of the Stickley look?

i say rather then try and match exactly which is hard because they use alot of chemicls then that are no long used for several resons like toxic, or expensive. make a sample board and mix up several different finishes. keep your exact steps for each finish and then ask her which one she likes then you just follow your recipie and mix what you need. after that you can pull out your sample board and recipies and make a finish custome for your clients.

  • Author

duckkisser,

This "mix it up on your own and decide" is exactly what I am trying to avoid. There are so many different products out there that woodworkers often get lost in confusion, spending lots of money on cans and bottles of stuff that doesn't work for them.

I view the purpose of this forum to encourage us to share specifics so that knowledge can be transferred and not hoarded. This is why I spelled out my EXACT formula for getting what I find to be a close to original finish.

I'd love it if others could say "I use the following products in the following manner". Without details, we call can get derailed.

And I'm not singling you out specifically, but this is a general problem I see around finishing; lots of general hand waiving, not a lot of very specific product and method.

Addendum: Josh_N thanks, that's actually one of the PDFs I consulted when I was doing my original testing of products. very valuable.

The Jewitt document that Josh shared is fantastic...

I've used it myself for years.

Make a sample board using the schedule closest to the finish your wife liked, show her ONLY that. _IF_ she doesn't like it out of the gate, remind her that wood is a natural product varying in color, then modify as necessary. Modify by starting with the closest finish, and making strips with different measured tints added to the finish. Think "paint strip", or "exposure test strip" if you ever developed B&W prints, but made of wood. You can tint by either dyeing the raw wood, or adding dye to the clear. Dyed wood is far easier to touch up or repair.

For example, you might but seven kerfs on an 18 x 6 board. The first is no dye, and each strip might be dyed with a red (or what ever tint she suggested) dye one drop per measure stronger than the last. Finish all eight portions the same after dyeing. There will be a significant difference between strips, and they will be dead easy to duplicate.

Tip: After getting preference info through conversation, never show a client or relative more than two or three choices at once. Limit this to two, if they're tint strips.

morgan the problem is that no forumula is the same. it depends on the wood, the ingredients, set up time, humidity, temperature, moisture of the wood, age of the chemical, if its exposed to sunlight, ect...... and honestly there is no do no wrong forumula book that showes you exactly how to do perfect finishes. its a matter of experience, and playing with dye's and preferences. for example i dont much care for stain especialy general finishes.

i like to do smaller projects and use different pieces of wood to create different feelings with the different colors. so i usualy end haveing lots of different pieces of wood for example i have a box of oak 1x4x4 for some projects i was making where i was cuting the 4x4 into circles of different shades of red oak. there is probably 40 different shades that i spend a year picking out. its more time consuming but it more rewarding for me. i spend very little time working with finishes and dye's. what stains and finishes i do use is usualy just what feels right at the time...hmmmm this should be more red or this would look better with a mat finish rather then glossy

if you realy want to talk about forumula's and matching up then talk with a furniture restor or a furniture historian they usualy have shelves of dyes and chemicals and spend hours matching up a particular finish for a restoring job.

  • Author

duck,

agreed that there is no "do no wrong" finish - and that's a really important point. The difficulty is that, without formula to serve as a starting point, I think lots of people get caught up not even trying, or worse, being incredibly disappointed because they bought a can of "finish" and thought that it would "finish" the work.

You also raise a good point about the difference for restorers or historians - that's another level beyond.

In your own post you talk about working with "what feels right at the time" but that's based on considerable experience - I'm confident that you have a go-to starting point, and then you deviate from there. So what I'd like from you (and others) is: "here's what I use to get an A&C finish - mine tends towards the brown" or " here's the steps I take, mine trends red" etc. etc.

This is not about the perfect, but rather about good starting points, and what are the data points in terms of color and temperature that are produced.

  • Author

Cessna,

Yeah, I love me some transtint. I am using water, even though I know lots of folks who like mixing it with alcohol. what's your experience with dyes? Water or spirits?

Morganew, I noticed on the info that Josh shared that their colors/formulas, etc. were for use with white oak and that to change the wood would change the appearance. What wood are you trying to finish and what wood is your wife looking at to match?

I use the same finish for all my white oak pieces and adjust the dye and/or stain to adjust the color. I have a pile of test boards that have a wide range of color. WD Lockwood has the best selection of dyes and cheapest prices I've seen and they used to send out samples to new customers. My schedule is similar to Jewitt's

- Lockwood water based dye

- Zinnser Sealcoat dewaxed shellac

- Varathane oil based stain as glaze

- Waterlox original wiped on

- 50/50 mixture of Waterlox oringal and satin

I wipe the varnish on to keep it thin and really like the results.

IMAGE_D4DB3F9A-F80B-4795-9D49-65905FE5D1C4.JPG

  • Author

estes,

That's a beautiful look , do you recall which color of lockwood and Varathane you used for the one in the picture?

And to the earlier question - the assumption I am making is for QS White Oak. While you have Greene and Greene with mahogany, and modern stuff in cherry, if feels like the vast majority of A&C is QSWO.

estes,

That's a beautiful look , do you recall which color of lockwood and Varathane you used for the one in the picture?

I used WD Lockwood early American maple honey tone amber water dye and Varathane gunstock (used to be called mission brown) oil stain.

  • Author

Thanks estesbubba, It has a nice warm look to it. I'll give a run through and try and post some comparisons.

Any others you got in your drawers?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.