Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Matching screws - how important?

Featured Replies

Hi All,

I'm attaching my hinges and hardware to the blanket chest that I am building, and have just run into a screw issue. All my hardware is solid brass, so I am also using solid brass screws (besides, they make installation more fun, right! <smile> )

Anyhow, my chest has a box-style lid, and I've installed L-corner brackets on each corner. These have slotted brass screws (ie. flat-head). Ditto for the brass lid support.

Now... on to the piano hinge. The hinge I bought did not come with screws, and apparently nobody in all of Chicago carries 5x5/8" solid brass screws (that I've talked to at least). So, I can order them online, but that's where it gets tricky.

I can easily buy these screws in a phillips style online, but the rest of my screws on the other hardware, as I mentioned, are slotted. I like the idea of phillips because I think they will be easier to install, but then they won't match the other hardware. I could always swap out those other screws for phillips too, but they are different sizes and lengths, which makes everything much more complicated (because of course you can only buy the screws in large packs online).

OR, I could just order slotted brass screws for the piano hinge, but then I'd have to get them all the way from Lee Valley in Canada, and they'd be more likely to get scratched on the install.....

So, I guess the question is - how critical do you think it is to have the same type of screws throughout the piece?

I personally have been thinking that it's very important, but everyone I've asked (non-woodworker family and friends) have said that they would never notice the difference.

Any thoughts? Many thanks.

- EG

Matched. No question. You can't ask non-woodworkers for advice. They know nothing. :)

  • Author

Matched. No question. You can't ask non-woodworkers for advice. They know nothing. :)

Thanks, Eric and others. Yes, this is the direction I was leaning toward - I knew I could count on you all to set me straight after talking to my non-woodworking friends.

So then, the remaining question is: How much easier will it be to use phillips vs slotted solid brass screws? Do you think that it's worth switching out the other screws so that all of them can be philips, or do you think that the slot screws that came with the hardware will go in fine? I'm just concerned about the difficulty of putting these slotted solid brass screws into red oak without getting scratched up, etc. (I've never put solid brass screws into hardwood before...). Obviously I will be pre drilling as well as pre-threading steel screws in the holes and testing on scrap wood, too. But I'm not sure if phillips will even make that big of a difference anyway...

Best,

EG

furniture = slotted...

The key (besides wax, pre-drill and driving steel screws) is using the correct blade size for the screw. There can be no play in the slot. if you have worn screwdrivers, then regrind or purchase a new screwdriver and keep it aside for brass hardware. Just hand driving for brass screws -- leave the battery-powered toys for drilling holes...

Dude? Its all good. You cant beat yourself up over this. Part of woodworking is knowing "when it matters and when it dont". You'll run in circles chasing perfection.

All the screws that show should match. Then all the screws that show on the inside can match each other and blend with the rest.. Its not like your sinking a zinc square head in there.

If its not a big deal to match up all the screws, do it. But if its that big of a pain, let it go. Only if this was a commissioned piece would it be necessary.

You make the call

Match dem screws. Even if nobody else notices, it will tear at your immortal soul if you don't.

-- Russ

Or you could go for the eclectic look and use a different screw for every hole

And to reach the next level grasshopper you must master the art of clocking your screws. All the slots should be lined up the same way. Run a steel screw the exact same size in first, then replace it with your brass screw and carefully tighten to line up the slots. Same thing applies to Phillips heads.

It is a little detail that a lot of people will overlook at first, but especially with premium hardware it shows an attention to detail that signifies pride in a job done well.

On a imported plated piano hinge cut to length with a hacksaw, why bother...... I have my standards, you get to pick yours.

To Me.... Depends on what the blanket chest is used for, and if said screws will be visible, AND how hard would it be to change out the offending screws. If not that hard I would swap them out. You are talking about two different components here. It would bother me if you had mixed head screws on the L brackets, but not as much the way you are describing.

Of course, if the blanket chest was a commission or gift, then I would say make them all the same, but for something at the end of my bed, for my use, I wouldn't care that much.

While I applaud wdwerker for his standards about screws, I view that as kind of OCD. I guess I have some work cut out for me to reach the next level.

While I am pretty OCD in my work as a home inspector, it hasn't trickled down to the screw head placement in my woodworking.

Now I won't be able to install screws the same way ever again - THANKS STEVE!!! :-)

It is all about context! Screws on drawer slides, who cares! Screws on a box you spent hours sanding and many more hours finishing, match the screws and clock them.

Over 30 years ago my grandfather saw a box I built for my locksmith tools. I had used a row of Phillips screws to join all the corners. He grabbed a screwdriver and clocked one short row to show me how it looked. I did the rest a bit at a time. Clients noticed. I would clock the screws on expensive Baldwin brass mortice locksets as a finishing touch.

Low bid jobs, unseen hardware, and cheap hardware I just grab the screw gun,set the clutch and let her rip. Although I often replace the cheap screws packaged with imported hardware with better steel screws I keep a selection of. I can work faster and with more confidence that the screw heads won't strip out.

When I needed brass screws (and bolts) for another project I'm working on I got them from Bolt Depot in MA. They don't care how large (or small) an order you place and will ship 1 screw if that's what you need. If matching is important, I'd find the screw that fits the job or replace the ones that came with your other hardware. You mention that they're different sizes - I would just order as many of them as I needed of that specific size from Bolt Depot.

Good luck! Hope that helps.

  • Author

Or you could go for the eclectic look and use a different screw for every hole

HAHAHA now you're on to something!! <smile>

And to reach the next level grasshopper you must master the art of clocking your screws. All the slots should be lined up the same way. Run a steel screw the exact same size in first, then replace it with your brass screw and carefully tighten to line up the slots. Same thing applies to Phillips heads.

It is a little detail that a lot of people will overlook at first, but especially with premium hardware it shows an attention to detail that signifies pride in a job done well.

On a imported plated piano hinge cut to length with a hacksaw, why bother...... I have my standards, you get to pick yours.

You are killing me Steve!!! But seriously, this is a very good point that I have never thought of. I will do my best to "clock" the screws properly... thanks for mentioning it!

When I needed brass screws (and bolts) for another project I'm working on I got them from Bolt Depot in MA. They don't care how large (or small) an order you place and will ship 1 screw if that's what you need. If matching is important, I'd find the screw that fits the job or replace the ones that came with your other hardware. You mention that they're different sizes - I would just order as many of them as I needed of that specific size from Bolt Depot.

Good luck! Hope that helps.

I already ordered the screws, but thank you Byrdie. I will keep Bolt Depot in mind for my future needs, for sure.

- EG

==> slots should be lined up the same way

​funny, i did not think of it, but I always do it out of habit.. or maybe just ocd... All screws are clocked -- and in the orientation of the hardware.

==> Most brass hardware comes with crap screws anyway

I get my hardware from Horton brass... Their screws are pretty good. I usually order an extra packet of screws for a project, then when the inevitable scratch occurs, I can replace like-for-like.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.