00101 Posted January 27, 2013 Report Posted January 27, 2013 Well for a class I decided to make a bowl. Quite frankly, my instructor doesn't know a lot about turning, so I didn't get much help from him, and now I come to you. I'm turning a small bowl out of hard maple and I used angled ring construction to glue it up. I know that the bowl is very slightly off center in relation to the sacrificial mounting piece as I had to re-glue it after it popped off when I attempted to put paper in between them for easy removal later. My problem stems from the fact that I cannot for the life of me get the roughing gouge to cut. I'm not entirely sure if it stems from a problem in my technique (900-1000 rpm, the gouge about perpendicular to the support with the support about .5" away from the bowl), the material, or the tool. The gouge just gets knocked back and forth by the bowl and doesn't really end up doing anything. A few times now the gouge has jammed and caused the bowl to stop, which needless to say the lathe's motor did not like. I've had my friend who had not been having any problems with his handle try his hand at it with more or less the same results (he jammed it too). I've tried three different gouges, one of which I saw just hog off walnut with out complaint. Nothing. So I don't know what to do about this whole thing. Quote
mikem Posted January 27, 2013 Report Posted January 27, 2013 First, make sure you are using a bowl gouge. A spindle gouge is not appropriate for bowl turning. Next, make sure your gouge is sharp. You will need to sharpen often while turning. As for holding it, the angle you hold it at changes as you turn, and I am guessing this is why you are getting most of your catches. Below is a couple links to a video (part 1 and 2) that was done by another forum member, RogerT. This was from a live session he did awhile back so it is long, but there is a LOT of valuable information in it. Quote
00101 Posted January 27, 2013 Author Report Posted January 27, 2013 I'll definitely watch the two videos, but unfortunately the shop that the class uses does not have any bowl gouges. I don't have a lathe, so I'm certainly not going to go out and buy a bowl gouge. I do need to finish this project, however. Maybe watching the videos will provide an answer to my dilemma. And at the very least I don't have to worry about tapering the outside or inside nor do I have to worry about hollowing it out from a solid block. So maybe that will improve my chances of success with undesirable tools. Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 Please tell me you did not pay for this class!! Quote
00101 Posted January 28, 2013 Author Report Posted January 28, 2013 Thankfully not. It's only a high school course and really isn't worth much in the way of learning stuff. Anything that doesn't have a replaceable blade in there needs a complete tune up. I asked the instructor if he could have a chisel sharpened one day, and he came back from the bench grinder and gave it back to me and said "Try that on for size" with a grin on his face. The bevel had at least 6 different planes in it with the leading edge all wavy. The turning tools are just as abysmal. One of the skews literally was rounded over. It feels good to vent sometimes. Anyway, is there really a good option to getting this bowl done? Quote
Hybrid-woodworker Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 First, STOP using other tools, you are going to hurt yourself or others! Your shop instructor should lose his job for not understanding the tools you are using and the risks associated with them. The best way to finish your bowl is to contact your local woodturning club and ask for help. Almost any of the members will help you learn the rigt way to turn this bowl and at no charge. Also a segmented off center mounted bowl is not the best first project. You might as well chuck it in a vise and hollow it with a chain saw ( also NOT recommend ). BRuce Quote
00101 Posted January 28, 2013 Author Report Posted January 28, 2013 How would I go about finding such a club? Any good places to start the search? Quote
sbarton22 Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 If you fill out your profile, specifically location, we could help you locate a club. http://www.woodturner.org/ is also a good place to start. Quote
duckkisser Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 what state do you live in? that might be a start. how do you feel about teaching the teacher a few things? ok since you dont have a bowl gouge you can go a couple routes are you against making your own tool? i can walk you through making a tool for about 10-15 dollers this tool http://www.easywoodtools.com/ this is a fairly easy tool to work with and you can get blades dirt cheap http://globaltooling.bizhosting.com/products/carbide-insert-knives.html you just need a piece of wood for handle, square stock bench grinder/angle grinder, drill press and a tap. second if you want to just use what is in the shop you can build a guide fairly easily out of scrap http://aroundthewoods.com/sharpening01.html this will allow you to make a even sharp edge quickly with minimal work. let the teacher know that lathe tools especial for bowl turning you need a even beval to ride on the wood to act as your guide. and in a single class you guys could make this for the shop to make his tools pefectly even. third i would not use a standard gouge you are asking for it to catch you would be better off useing scraping tools some might disagree with me but i have had little trouble useing a scraper to cut on the lathe then i do with standard gouges. please let the teacher know that expierence turners advise against turning without sharp tools and the right tools because of the end grain if you use the wrong tools it will catch and send the wood flying strait into your face............and oh god please tell me he knows enough to use a face mask.. this kind of story frustraits me since i am a shop teacher and have spent last two years on my lathe learning what to do and what not to do. since i have no information on the actual situation and i dont know if he is teaching you wrong or if you are make a critical error my best advise if you cant find someone to help you then you need to study lots of videos on bowl turning like the above video. you might also want to skip the paper and glue method and just go with strait glue since you have a possibility of the wood catching and throwing on you and you might want as much glue as you can get. was. was your friend making a bowl out of walnut as well? or a spindle because if he was using a spindle gouge on his and then you both tried a spindle gouge on a face turning you would both run into the same problem. lastly dont get so frustraited that you quite and never step foot in the shop class again. a wood shop is a great experience but like any class if the teacher cannot teach the lesson you cant learn the lesson. 1 Quote
00101 Posted January 28, 2013 Author Report Posted January 28, 2013 what state do you live in? that might be a start. how do you feel about teaching the teacher a few things? ok since you dont have a bowl gouge you can go a couple routes are you against making your own tool? i can walk you through making a tool for about 10-15 dollers this tool http://www.easywoodtools.com/ this is a fairly easy tool to work with and you can get blades dirt cheap http://globaltooling.bizhosting.com/products/carbide-insert-knives.html you just need a piece of wood for handle, square stock bench grinder/angle grinder, drill press and a tap. second if you want to just use what is in the shop you can build a guide fairly easily out of scrap http://aroundthewoods.com/sharpening01.html this will allow you to make a even sharp edge quickly with minimal work. let the teacher know that lathe tools especial for bowl turning you need a even beval to ride on the wood to act as your guide. and in a single class you guys could make this for the shop to make his tools pefectly even. third i would not use a standard gouge you are asking for it to catch you would be better off useing scraping tools some might disagree with me but i have had little trouble useing a scraper to cut on the lathe then i do with standard gouges. please let the teacher know that expierence turners advise against turning without sharp tools and the right tools because of the end grain if you use the wrong tools it will catch and send the wood flying strait into your face............and oh god please tell me he knows enough to use a face mask.. this kind of story frustraits me since i am a shop teacher and have spent last two years on my lathe learning what to do and what not to do. since i have no information on the actual situation and i dont know if he is teaching you wrong or if you are make a critical error my best advise if you cant find someone to help you then you need to study lots of videos on bowl turning like the above video. you might also want to skip the paper and glue method and just go with strait glue since you have a possibility of the wood catching and throwing on you and you might want as much glue as you can get. was. was your friend making a bowl out of walnut as well? or a spindle because if he was using a spindle gouge on his and then you both tried a spindle gouge on a face turning you would both run into the same problem. lastly dont get so frustraited that you quite and never step foot in the shop class again. a wood shop is a great experience but like any class if the teacher cannot teach the lesson you cant learn the lesson. I don't intend to quit woodworking anytime soon; I like it a lot, and besides, I've got waaay too much money tied up in it . About the teacher, frankly he doesn't really teach us much of anything. He more or less just pointed to the lathe, said that's a lathe, told us to chamfer the corners off, and said go. He doesn't really explain how to do stuff, thankfully I have my own shop and home and know how to do most operations, so I haven't really been struggling much. Our shop also does not have any face shields, which is why I'm quite frankly rather scared when I start pushing the gouge into the bowl. Thankfully when I re-glued it I just went with straight glue after I sanded the paper off of both pieces. And I'm in Wisconsin in the Fox Valley. Quote
duckkisser Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 dont turn right now and dont let anyone else in the class. tell the teacher he need face masks now! i had one block come lose when i first started it hit my face sheild and nocked me on my ass more out of surprize then anything. but if the mask was not in place best case i would have had broken nose and front teeth. but i have heard of turners in some of the local clubs who died. if the teacher does not get them for the class then go buy one before you do anything. Quote
duckkisser Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 http://www.woodturner.org/community/chapters/LocalChapters.asp here you go should be able to pull something up right away if you want to turning here is the advise i just gave someone else most of the information i have goten Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 As a father I can't begin to tell you how mad I'd be if my child came home and told me about the complete lack of safety in this high school class! I understand that the school is on a tight budget and can't afford the greatest tools but to not provide safety equipment is appalling and maybe even criminal. Quote
sbarton22 Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 Lowe's has a face shield for $14. I wouldn't get within 10' of a lathe without one. Quote
Chris H Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I have to concur with the other posts. There is no reason for a lathe to be plugged in if you don't have a face shield. I got distracted and accidently left the chuck key in the chuck on the lathe after mounting a bowl. Thankfully I just had to deal with a loud thud. Without a shield on, there is no doubt, that missing teeth would have been the least of my concerns. As for learning, definatley take some time to check out some video's on youtube. It certainly isn't as good as hands on training, but its much better than just winging it. Quote
00101 Posted January 28, 2013 Author Report Posted January 28, 2013 Well I've got some pictures of the bowl that I'll post later. I also did find an old slightly yellowed face shield in a cabinet filled with garbage. So there's that. I did ask my teacher, just in the event that it was in a never used cabinet--like the face shield, if we had a bowl gouge. We didn't, he sharpened the spindle roughing gouge and told me to try that. Well it cut, but when it would catch on the bowl with the slightest provocation. I did stop shortly after because I just did not feel anything close to safe turning it. Quote
DaBear Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 If it's yellowed, I'd be very cautious about it being old and brittle (and thus no use to you). If it were me, I'd turn my back and hit it with something (while NOT wearing it ) to see if it shatters... It should be able to take a pretty hard knock without anything other than a scratch.. Normally I'd advise you to get your instructor to do this, but sounds like he's pretty much useless.. In the end, I'd still vote to buy a new one of your own as being the best idea.. Welcome to the fraternity My 2cents.. Quote
mikem Posted February 18, 2013 Report Posted February 18, 2013 Do NOT use the spindle gouge on the bowl. This is a very dangerous combination. The flutes are very likely to catch on the end grain in a very bad way, and the tang of the tool likely isn't made for that type of turning operation. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.