Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Tearout in figured woods

Featured Replies

Using curly maple for the first time. When I joint the edges, I'm getting a ton of tearout. I'm relatively new at woodworking and wanted to know if this is normal? It doesn't seem to matter which way I run the boards. The grain on the ends runs almost horizontal (flat sawn?) Should I be using hand planes to joint the edges maybe?

The Blades of my jointer are almost new so I don't think that they are the culprit. I am only taking about 1/64th at a time. Don't notice much when I plane one side flat, just when I joint the edges.

Thanks

The blades on your jointer are the culprit...but not because they're dull. :)   Tearout on figured woods is totally normal on the jointer and planer with traditional knives.  Sharpen your longest plane and take a few passes to clean up the tearout, or buck up the dough for a Shelix head on your planer and jointer.

Straight knife machines can do a job on curly maple edges.

 

I usually do my match jointing with my bevel-up #7 and a 62 degree cutting angle.   Edges that won't be glued get machined slightly oversize and finished with a high angle smoother (Bevel up or down, but high angle)

 

I plan for it.  The same can happen with quartersawn white oak.

  • Author

Thanks I was afraid I would have to use a hand plane. Gonna have to practice,practice,practice.

Spray the edge of the board with water, then take a rag and quickly wipe the water from your board an run it.

 

-Ace-

The blades on your jointer are the culprit...but not because they're dull. :)   Tearout on figured woods is totally normal on the jointer and planer with traditional knives.  Sharpen your longest plane and take a few passes to clean up the tearout, or buck up the dough for a Shelix head on your planer and jointer.

Sort of. Only normal with the wrong grind. Most folks just buy jointer knives not caring about the grind. 15* grind will perform as well as as a shelix on curly wood. Tersa / terminus are straight and cut even better than the shelix.

Didn't know that...interesting.  Is there any disadvantage to a 15* grind?  If not, why don't they just manufacture them all that way?

Didn't know that...interesting.  Is there any disadvantage to a 15* grind?  If not, why don't they just manufacture them all that way?

Who knows probably because 30* is more of a universal grind. Some come in at 45* 15-25* nets the cleanest cuts.

Any advise on surface planing?  I had the same problem as Dimar last night when I was surface planing a piece of curly maple with my #4 plane.  Tons of tear out.  I ended up using a card scraper to clean it all up. 

Sort of. Only normal with the wrong grind. Most folks just buy jointer knives not caring about the grind. 15* grind will perform as well as as a shelix on curly wood. Tersa / terminus are straight and cut even better than the shelix.

The reason they may cut better is more knives are hitting the wood surface. Traditionally on a 4 knife cutter, 1 maybe 2 knives hit the surface per rotation. With Tersa knives they are held in place with centrifugal force, thus more accurate in creating a perfect cutting radius.

The reason they may cut better is more knives are hitting the wood surface. Traditionally on a 4 knife cutter, 1 maybe 2 knives hit the surface per rotation. With Tersa knives they are held in place with centrifugal force, thus more accurate in creating a perfect cutting radius.

Not really unless your knife height adjustment is off. If your adjustment is right then all 4 knives are cutting. Tersa cut better because they are driven at the proper angle to rpm ratio. US jointers lack the engineering. They seem to use random cutter angles and speed with no regard to chip load.

  • 2 weeks later...

Not really unless your knife height adjustment is off. If your adjustment is right then all 4 knives are cutting. Tersa cut better because they are driven at the proper angle to rpm ratio. US jointers lack the engineering. They seem to use random cutter angles and speed with no regard to chip load.

What I am referring to is on a micro scale.  You can set up your knives all day long and still only have 1-2 knives cutting per rotation of the head- its just the way it is.

 

The only way all 4 knives on ANY cutter are functioning is when you use the jointing system with a hydro head setup.  This is major wood manufacturing technology so it isn't really a solution but more of a point I'm making.  Explained in better detail below:

 

A jointed moulder has a built in apparatus on each spindle that allows you to joint the heads. Running a jointed head allows you to run faster than a regular (single knife finish) moulder. When you "joint" a head, all you are doing is lowering a chalky abrasive stone down onto the knives when they are spinning at full speed. When they contact the knives, it precisely grinds all the knives' diameter virtually exactly the same. You must be running hydro cutter heads as well for this to work. For every knife in the head that is jointed you can run an additional 32 ft per minute. There are usually a minimum of 3, and in some shops (not fun) may be 6-8 knives in the head.

A non-jointed moulder can usually only go about 30 feet per minute and produce a quality finish. A non-jointed moulder head usually has two knives. Although both knives help with chip removal (if they are closely ground), only one of the knives produces the finish. There are exceptions of course, but this is the general idea.

Basically the benefit of a jointed moulder is speed. 30 ft per minute compared to 180+ feet per minute. If you think you'll be doing serious production, 20,000 lineal feet of moulding per day, jointed may be the way to go. Realistically most companies have to build up to levels of that nature. The rest of your shop must be able to handle levels like that too. (Dust collector, storage space, ripsaw, etc.)

Also, running a moulder correctly can take a good bit of practice and skill. The faster you're running means the faster you can make a mistake. For example, 5" cherry crown at 180 feet a minute. A two minute mistake would cost over $750.00 in lumber alone.

 

Sean, that makes sense.

I thought the way the Tersa R2000 System worked, it made up for the knives being slightly off from micro level.

What about knife angle?  I guess if it sharpens the knives while in place it would take care of that too.

 

Why isn't this wider known?  Seems to make a lot of sense.

 

 

 

The jointing system is actually only for serious  production use, molders for example take an average of an hour just to set up.  So with that information, the fewer cutter changes = better productivity= more output=more $$$

 

The system doesn't sharpen the knives, it actually dulls them, however with all the knives at the exact same height, they all touch the surface and this provides a superior quality cut with more knife marks but they are closer together and more shallow.

 

Lets say we are making crown molding, 50000 lineal feet for example, after it comes out of the molder, right inline there is usually a machine called a profile sander

which is like a cutter with knives except made out of sandpaper and bristles. These sandpaper cutters are shaped to match the profile and their job is to get rid of knife marks in the crown molding of baseboards or whatever profile.  So with knife marks that are more shallow=less sanding required by this machine.  I have only seen this in large furniture making factories

 

The Tersa system is the next best thing for people with home shops with the exception of spiral/helix head cutters that are very expensive.

Not an economical choice, well maybe on a thickness planer.

 

As for knife  angles think hand planes

A steeper angle is suitable for softer woods and allows you to hog off more material

 

Anything close to or  under 20 deg. will increase quality, the downfall is it might dull a bit faster, no big deal in the long run

What I am referring to is on a micro scale.  You can set up your knives all day long and still only have 1-2 knives cutting per rotation of the head- its just the way it is.

 

The only way all 4 knives on ANY cutter are functioning is when you use the jointing system with a hydro head setup.  This is major wood manufacturing technology so it isn't really a solution but more of a point I'm making.  Explained in better detail below:

 

A jointed moulder has a built in apparatus on each spindle that allows you to joint the heads. Running a jointed head allows you to run faster than a regular (single knife finish) moulder. When you "joint" a head, all you are doing is lowering a chalky abrasive stone down onto the knives when they are spinning at full speed. When they contact the knives, it precisely grinds all the knives' diameter virtually exactly the same. You must be running hydro cutter heads as well for this to work. For every knife in the head that is jointed you can run an additional 32 ft per minute. There are usually a minimum of 3, and in some shops (not fun) may be 6-8 knives in the head.

A non-jointed moulder can usually only go about 30 feet per minute and produce a quality finish. A non-jointed moulder head usually has two knives. Although both knives help with chip removal (if they are closely ground), only one of the knives produces the finish. There are exceptions of course, but this is the general idea.

Basically the benefit of a jointed moulder is speed. 30 ft per minute compared to 180+ feet per minute. If you think you'll be doing serious production, 20,000 lineal feet of moulding per day, jointed may be the way to go. Realistically most companies have to build up to levels of that nature. The rest of your shop must be able to handle levels like that too. (Dust collector, storage space, ripsaw, etc.)

Also, running a moulder correctly can take a good bit of practice and skill. The faster you're running means the faster you can make a mistake. For example, 5" cherry crown at 180 feet a minute. A two minute mistake would cost over $750.00 in lumber alone.

Sort of but not. Funny Ive had two guys this quarter in class use this exact same quote taken from woodweb. Cut per revolution is always the same with any knifed head irregardless if its a jointed machine or not. Cut per inch is what a hydro head excels at. Cuts per inch at very high feet rates requires jointed heads to get a perfect cut but only due to the high feed rate. Slow hand feed rates would not see any benefit with a jointed head. Slow feed rates remove the scalloping caused by knife irregularities. If you could feed at 100 + fpm by hand you would see the . 001 scalloping but that is very unlikely. If you did happen to have the desire to slow a hydro heads feed rate down to hand feed speed it would it would only improve the cut quality by a few microns. Hydro machines excel at 300-600 fpm well beyond that of a hand or powerfed machine.

Sort of but not. Funny Ive had two guys this quarter in class use this exact same quote taken from woodweb. Cut per revolution is always the same with any knifed head irregardless if its a jointed machine or not. Cut per inch is what a hydro head excels at. Cuts per inch at very high feet rates requires jointed heads to get a perfect cut but only due to the high feed rate. Slow hand feed rates would not see any benefit with a jointed head. Slow feed rates remove the scalloping caused by knife irregularities. If you could feed at 100 + fpm by hand you would see the . 001 scalloping but that is very unlikely. If you did happen to have the desire to slow a hydro heads feed rate down to hand feed speed it would it would only improve the cut quality by a few microns. Hydro machines excel at 300-600 fpm well beyond that of a hand or powerfed machine.

 

I don't think you quite understand what we are talking about here.  The thread was created to address tear out in figured wood.  I simply wanted to show some of the home wood workers what technology is out there in the industry.  Mostly for arguments sake- not as a viable solution

and as for your quote Slow hand feed rates would not see any benefit with a jointed head- you are correct machine burn would occur well before an increase in quality

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.