Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust Collection

Featured Replies

I have to come to the conclusion that I finally need a real dust collector, my shop vac and Dust Right Vortex just isn't getting the job done but I have some limitations. I would like to stay around $500 and it has to run on 110v. My whole garage is wired on a single 20 amp breaker, there is no way around this. I have to be able run a power tool and the D/C at once. I know this limits me to 1 HP and maybe 1 1/2 HP collectors and this maybe be pushing it. Here is what I am looking at:

-This Grizzly and adding a Thien separator but I am worried that the separator will reduce the CFM significantly.

-I am also thinking about going with the infamous HF extractor, adding a Wynn canister and Thien Separator.

 

I am only going to connect to DC to a single tool using the Rockler Dust Right quick connect fittings. 

 

Any insight into either of these options or something completely different.

 

Thanks!

  • Replies 65
  • Views 13.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Well, this is what I went with. Hopefully Don is right and my 220v option is a simple as he made it seem. Fortunately my wife is out of town for the next 2 weeks, which should give me enough time to f

  • davestanton
    davestanton

    John, no. I am using flex grey plastic which is remarkably smooth on the inside. I laid it under my cabinets with a removable kickboard to get to it if needed.

Posted Images

Anything will help. Personally I wouldn't mess with the separator. Just grab a collector and one of those rockler stretchy hoses and move it from machine to machine.

  • Author

Anything will help. Personally I wouldn't mess with the separator. Just grab a collector and one of those rockler stretchy hoses and move it from machine to machine.

That works for me. Thanks Don!

The Delta 50-760 is well tested an reviewed. It runs on 110, has an 11 inch impeller, and pulls enough CFM to meet bill pentz's recommendations as long as it goes from tool to tool with a 5 inch hose. It also comes standard with a 1 micron filter bag. Wynn filters will fit, but need some modifications.

  • Author

The Delta 50-760 is well tested an reviewed. It runs on 110, has an 11 inch impeller, and pulls enough CFM to meet bill pentz's recommendations as long as it goes from tool to tool with a 5 inch hose. It also comes standard with a 1 micron filter bag. Wynn filters will fit, but need some modifications.

I looked at this Delta but there is one big problem, it has to run on the same circuit as my other tools. I am almost certain that when I turn my table saw or jointer or bandsaw on and the this Delta DC is running at the same time my breaker will pop. That is why I am interested in the Grizzly I HP unit with a 9 amp draw. 

Do you have the option of getting an electrician to have a look at your situation and ask if your wiring will support a larger circuit breaker?

Yeah, I gotta agree with Dave here, James.  I think I remember you saying you'll be moving in a couple years? and that's a pretty good reason not to sink a ton of money into electrical upgrades.  But I'd rather spend a little money running another circuit out to the shop, or a little more money running 220...than buying a bunch of tools that you're gonna want to upgrade in the future.  That'll end up costing you more in the long run.

 

I bought a small DC...2HP wired 220.  It pulls the bulk of the chips away, but it's wholly insufficient for fine dust, especially at the bandsaw and tablesaw, even with some clever modifications.  Granted, my system is now plumbed with a labyrinth of PVC throughout the shop, and that's largely the reason for the mediocre performance.  But I started out rolling it around from machine to machine, and immediately realized how much that sucked.  So I decided to make it a permanent system with duct, and since I had already bought a small unit, I was stuck with it unless I wanted to sell it for nearly a complete loss.

 

I regret the decision, and if I could go back and do it again, I'd just bite the bullet and buy one of the big boys...5HP probably.  You just can't beat the ClearVue prices.  Ask yourself: are you really gonna want to roll your DC around for the rest of your life, especially in your future shop?  Surely you'll eventually want to create a permanent system with duct and blast gates.  You're wasting your time trying to create a permanent system with anything smaller than a 3HP unit, if true *dust* collection is what you're after.  If you're hard up for cash and just need a cheap temporary solution, then never mind this entire spiel.  But I think you have a little too much green in your shop to plead broke.  :D

 

I think it's worth the extra up-front cost to pay an electrician to run a single 220 circuit out to the shop, and the extra cost of a big cyclone that is super efficient.  Don't make the same mistake I made.  Dave's blog title is befitting...life is not a rehearsal.  It's something that I've learned to embrace, at least with tool purchases...go bigger and better from the get-go...having less than you need is always more regrettable than having more than you need.

 

Just trying to help you think long-term.  :)

  • Author

Dave and Eric,

You both have good points but extra wiring just isn't an option. I am in the Navy and live in base housing and the company that manages the properties for the Navy does not allow for electrical upgrades. I have no idea what my shop setup will be in the next 3 -5 years nor do I know how much space I will have. My tools are very closely located so I would just be moving the hose from machine to machine. Not the most ideal setup but should be fine for the next few years. 

James, first, thank you for your service.

 

Second, I'd seriously consider going cheap. I'm in a rental now, with a plan to buy a new house in 2-3 years. I can't run a 220 line either, so I planned to go as cheap as I can, and when I have a house, I'm all about the ClearVue.

 

I just bought the 2HP HFDC. It's on sale for May for $199 and with the 20% off coupon, you're at $160. The cheapest Wynn Environmental filter for it is $109. And you can add this separator lid: http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2004310/8981/trash-can-cyclone-lid.aspx for $32, and another $20 for the steel trash can from Wally World.

 

So you're at a 0.5 micron filtered DC with a chip separator for $322 plus local taxes and some shipping. Many say that the HFDC is a completely different machine with the Wynn filter, with significantly improved air flow. I have one friend in Michigan with a PVC plumbed small shop running off that setup. 

 

And when you're done, you could easily get most of that back on Craigslist and get yourself a ClearVue when you're in a permanent location.

James, are there any other outlets even remotely nearby which coudl be used?  I'm thinking especially an electric dryer outlet, which could be repurposed via a heavy duty extension cord, specifically for a DC.

  • Author

James, first, thank you for your service.

 

Second, I'd seriously consider going cheap. I'm in a rental now, with a plan to buy a new house in 2-3 years. I can't run a 220 line either, so I planned to go as cheap as I can, and when I have a house, I'm all about the ClearVue.

 

I just bought the 2HP HFDC. It's on sale for May for $199 and with the 20% off coupon, you're at $160. The cheapest Wynn Environmental filter for it is $109. And you can add this separator lid: http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2004310/8981/trash-can-cyclone-lid.aspx for $32, and another $20 for the steel trash can from Wally World.

 

So you're at a 0.5 micron filtered DC with a chip separator for $322 plus local taxes and some shipping. Many say that the HFDC is a completely different machine with the Wynn filter, with significantly improved air flow. I have one friend in Michigan with a PVC plumbed small shop running off that setup. 

 

And when you're done, you could easily get most of that back on Craigslist and get yourself a ClearVue when you're in a permanent location.

 

This is exactly what I am thinking but not sure on the HF DC just yet. I might go with a Grizzly DC instead.

James, are there any other outlets even remotely nearby which coudl be used?  I'm thinking especially an electric dryer outlet, which could be repurposed via a heavy duty extension cord, specifically for a DC.

There is a dryer outlet in the right behind the garage but my wife said absolutely no extension cords into garage from the laundry room. I have to pick and choose my battles and this is one not worth fighting. 

 

James

Yes

 

There's your 220....you just need to find a way to get to it....

I looked at this Delta but there is one big problem, it has to run on the same circuit as my other tools. I am almost certain that when I turn my table saw or jointer or bandsaw on and the this Delta DC is running at the same time my breaker will pop. That is why I am interested in the Grizzly I HP unit with a 9 amp draw.

Do you want me to do a test? I can plug them both into a 110 v outlet and see what happens. I currently run a dedicated 20 a for my dc, and other dedicated circuits for my machines, but it would be easy to move them about.

Yes

 

There ya go. Remove the outlet and drill through the wall just that simple. Add a surface mount sub panel or even just an outlet. Either can be removed when you move out and just patch a tiny hole. :)

  • Author

Do you want me to do a test? I can plug them both into a 110 v outlet and see what happens. I currently run a dedicated 20 a for my dc, and other dedicated circuits for my machines, but it would be easy to move them about.

I was actually going to test it myself by running my table saw and band saw at the same time.

  • Author

There ya go. Remove the outlet and drill through the wall just that simple. Add a surface mount sub panel or even just an outlet. Either can be removed when you move out and just patch a tiny hole. :)

 

 

 

Yes you make it sound very simple and maybe in theory it is. I will have to look more tomorrow when I have time and possibly post some pictures. 

Yes you make it sound very simple and maybe in theory it is. I will have to look more tomorrow when I have time and possibly post some pictures.

I ran a brand new line, hooked it up to two outlets, and installed a brand new breaker for my 220 line. If I can do that, you can run to the other side of the wall :)

But, how often is that dryer on? Will the dryer and DC trip the breaker?

The HF DC is widely considered to be one of their "Hidden Gems".  I have one in a small shop, and it is fantastic.  It would not support a ducted shop that is supporting 10+ machines, but it works great for a handful of ducted machines, or the 25' flexihose thing from Rockler with the quick connect system.  

 

I use a 55 gallon steel drum as a separator, and it work great.  This is mainly to divert things I didn't really intend to suck up when cleaning the shop.  

 

At $160-$170 with 20% off coupon, it is an excellent interim solution if you don't want to shell out for a 3+ hp unit.  

 

If you are intending to be in the 2-3 hp power range, this unit is a great value.  

That HF unit has indeed gotten a lot of press.  It seems to be a good value for the money, but it definitely is not as capable as other units in the same HP range (but also more $$).

 

I found a good review here http://www.woodworkingtalk.com/f24/harbor-freight-2-hp-dust-collector-31876/

 

Note the comment about the fine dust - "The 5 micron bag does allow very fine dust through. The toolbox I have sitting next to the dust collector gets covered in a very thin layer."  I strongly suggest upgrading to a 1.0u or 0.5u filter. 

 

 

  • Author

The DC is going to be moved from machine to machine. I am leaning toward this Grizzly. I ran my bandsaw and my table saw last night without blowing the breaker but the real test will be when I run the saw and dc at the same time. 

I had a jet dc650..roughly same CFM. It had a lot of trouble with my cabinet table saw. Worthless on my jointer. Kept getting clogged at the inlet. Maybe get something bait bigger.

Adam

  • Author

Well, this is what I went with. Hopefully Don is right and my 220v option is a simple as he made it seem. Fortunately my wife is out of town for the next 2 weeks, which should give me enough time to figure this out before she gets home.

Don- I am probably going to need your help if you don't mind. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.