Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Drawer repair

Featured Replies

We had a lively discussion going that did not match the OP so I am jumping here.

The question surrounds drawer bottoms that are slid in at the end of drawer box construction rather than captured by construction. I have repaired so very many bottoms that did not stay put when inserted rather than captured. I was asked if the drawers were of sufficient quality in general or if the quality was poor. The two most common repairs I have made are sliding bottoms, and missing or crappy guides/slides. I have not needed to repair many drawer carcasses themselves or cabinet carcasses. With this experience (admittedly limited) I am wary of recommending a slide in drawer bottom. Am I missing a key component for success? What is your experience,

I suppose I started the degradation of the original thread....

 

My question relates to underlying failure mode for drawers with captured -vs- removable bottoms ---

 

A- On drawers that have failed, why?

 

quality of the construction,

usage pattern,

inherent design,

abuse?

or some other factor?

 

 

B- If surviving antiques demonstrate a preponderance of removable-bottom drawers, how did we get to captured bottom?

 

modern mass-production methods favor captured-bottom drawers? (two sets of identical parts)

captured bottom drawers are inherently stronger, so cheaper materials can be substituted?

captured bottom drawers are inherently stronger, so faster/cheaper joinery can be substituted?

perhaps the abuse pattern of modern kitchen/utility cabinet drawers are a special case?

 

 

 

Observations... I've only seen failed drawers in low-quality construction drawers (captured bottoms or not).  On high-quality bespoke pieces, I've never seen removable bottom drawers that failed, even in pieces 200 years old.  Now obviously the're a certain Darwinian process inherent in antique furniture (the abused/damaged/poor-quality are discarded along the way), and the pieces were not subject to modern kitchen usage patterns...  Further, kids/utility/secondary furniture is rarely preserved across generations, so our view-point can be skewed by surviving examples of high-quality non-utility furniture...   Maybe there were more captured drawers in kids/kitchen/utility/etc furniture in the 18th c, but we don't have representative samples in the surviving population...

 

Recognizing that captured bottoms are inherently stronger, can drawers with removable bottoms be inherently 'strong enough' for most applications?  Maybe for everything except daily utility applications?

 

As a side note, I have access to rectory dining tables, farm kitchen tables, etc with drawers that are almost 300 years old and the drawers were all removable-bottom...  Obviously, those got daily utility use.  Now one or two do show signs of repair -- but unfortunately there is no provenance on the repair job.

  • Author

Trip, how does drawer width and bottom thickness interact. In a slide in bottom, how do you span an unsupported wide width with only nails.

3h dont get down on yourself been following that post seems that particleboard fella gets under the skin

 

Yep he does. :) I jstated my opinion which is based on many years of building and finishing kitchen cabinets which is what the Op was finishing. 

Antiques were made the way they were for a reason. My guess is that failure was common with solid hardwood bottoms. Many would split down the the center but were easily replace. In the days before controlled temperature, insulation, HVAC wood went through a bunch of changes over the course of its life. We dont deal with these issues today nor do we use solid wood for drawer bottoms in our kitchens. 

 

Every cabinetry trade organization in the industry keeps a watchful eye on trends. Failures are among these trends. Drawer bottoms were a sore spot for most of the 70's and 80's until manufacturers stepped up and started making captured bottoms with reasonable box joinery. The back staples or nails failed allowing the bottoms to sag and eventually destroy the boxes. Today industry standard is captured bottoms and the problems of the past are gone and a whole new set of issues are cropping up. Finish failures are #1, MDF Door failures at the hinge are also up there on the list of issues. 1/4" backs and 1/2" PB nailers are also being addressed by pretty much every manufacturer that cares about quality. The industry is still evolving and always will as long as finishes and materials continue to evolve. 

 

Attached is AWI stadards for premium cabinets.

 

==>  Many would split down the the center but were easily replace.

 

interesting observation.  I've seen quite a few pieces where the drawer bottom was in two parts (ship-lapped) to address this issue.  Again, it may come-down to the quality of the examples I have ready access to...

 

==> Every cabinetry trade organization in the industry keeps a watchful eye on trends. Failures are among these trends.

 

agreed.  but it's also a high-volume / low GM domain.  So I suspect there is a Quality/GM trade-off consideration in many of the trends....  Sort of like Henry Ford used to send his Mfg Engineers to junk yards with the goal of buying-up junked Fords to see which parts lasted the longest, then re-engineer that part so that it was cheaper to mfg and would fail at the same time as the rest of the car...  It's a COGS-vs-Quality world.

==> 3h dont get down on yourself

 

no worries... Don and I approach woodworking from different avenues...  it's a big space with lot's of cats to skin...

==>  Many would split down the the center but were easily replace.

 

interesting observation.  I've seen quite a few pieces where the drawer bottom was in two parts (ship-lapped) to address this issue.  Again, it may come-down to the quality of the examples I have ready access to...

 

==> Every cabinetry trade organization in the industry keeps a watchful eye on trends. Failures are among these trends.

 

agreed.  but it's also a high-volume / low GM domain.  So I suspect there is a Quality/GM trade-off consideration in many of the trends....  Sort of like Henry Ford used to send his Mfg Engineers to junk yards with the goal of buying-up junked Fords to see which parts lasted the longest, then re-engineer that part so that it was cheaper to mfg and would fail at the same time as the rest of the car...  It's a COGS-vs-Quality world.

 

 

 

==> Every cabinetry trade organization in the industry keeps a watchful eye on trends. Failures are among these trends.

 

agreed.  but it's also a high-volume / low GM domain.  So I suspect there is a Quality/GM trade-off consideration in many of the trends....  Sort of like Henry Ford used to send his Mfg Engineers to junk yards with the goal of buying-up junked Fords to see which parts lasted the longest, then re-engineer that part so that it was cheaper to mfg and would fail at the same time as the rest of the car...  It's a COGS-vs-Quality world.

 

I dont see that that has anything to do with it. AWI standards for drawers changed a few years back in response to folks buying "premium" grade and having the bottoms fall off. Economy and custom can have relieved backs but you charge less for those quality levels. Usually with those levels the rest of the cabinet will follow the economy level. Most manufacturers are going to premium drawer box to prevent their own warranty issues even if they are sticking with the economy standards for the rest of the box. Walzcraft and every other major player has moved this direction. There is no reason what so ever for a small shop not to produce drawer boxes at the premium level, it actually easier and more productive.

Antiques were made the way they were for a reason. My guess is that failure was common with solid hardwood bottoms. Many would split down the the center but were easily replace. In the days before controlled temperature, insulation, HVAC wood went through a bunch of changes over the course of its life. We dont deal with these issues today nor do we use solid wood for drawer bottoms in our kitchens. 

 

Every cabinetry trade organization in the industry keeps a watchful eye on trends. Failures are among these trends. Drawer bottoms were a sore spot for most of the 70's and 80's until manufacturers stepped up and started making captured bottoms with reasonable box joinery. The back staples or nails failed allowing the bottoms to sag and eventually destroy the boxes. Today industry standard is captured bottoms and the problems of the past are gone and a whole new set of issues are cropping up. Finish failures are #1, MDF Door failures at the hinge are also up there on the list of issues. 1/4" backs and 1/2" PB nailers are also being addressed by pretty much every manufacturer that cares about quality. The industry is still evolving and always will as long as finishes and materials continue to evolve. 

 

Attached is AWI stadards for premium cabinets.

 

attachicon.gifawi bottoms.jpg

 

drawer bottom split or crack with the grain grain in solid wood drawer bottoms are installed with grain running front to back if they cracked of split the botton would still stay ing the box frame

drawer bottom split or crack with the grain grain in solid wood drawer bottoms are installed with grain running front to back if they cracked of split the botton would still stay ing the box frame

 Only if there is a nail in the piece that is spit off otherwise it would fall out. We are talking about relieved backs vs captured. If it split in a captured frame it would never fall out.

  • Author

Please document that solid wood drawer grain runs front to back. I have never seen this in any piece I have worked on or examined.

c shaffer any woodworker worth his salt knows grain run front to back because of expantion contraction if i could docment i would its common knowledge

 

particle man not sure how old drawer bottom fall out usually nailed in back and locked in if not thick bottoms were hand planed or tapered to fit grove in sides locking in

c shaffer any woodworker worth his salt knows grain run front to back because of expantion contraction if i could docment i would its common knowledge

 

particle man not sure how old drawer bottom fall out usually nailed in back and locked in if not thick bottoms were hand planed or tapered to fit grove in sides locking in

 

I think your out of line Ive seen them running both directions. Running parallel to the face undersized pegged in the back and fixed to the face for expansion was very common. Running front to back was also very common when nailed. The wood would split generally at the nails and the pieces would fall out that is just the way it was. The very small amount of expansion with the grain caused the nails to be a splitting wedge.

 

Irregardless none of this has anything to do with how we build kitchen cabinets in this century. Even today Stickley voids the product warranty on solid wood bottom drawers, there is a reason.

thought and know are 2 different things any good woodworker know to run the grain front to back in them old days some werent such good builders either just old farmers with nothing else to do

thought and know are 2 different things any good woodworker know to run the grain front to back in them old days some werent such good builders either just old farmers with nothing else to do

 

So you would consider James Krenov and many other greats that ran their drawer bottoms parallel with the faces just old framers with nothing else to do? 

We had a lively discussion going that did not match the OP so I am jumping here.

The question surrounds drawer bottoms that are slid in at the end of drawer box construction rather than captured by construction. I have repaired so very many bottoms that did not stay put when inserted rather that captured. I was asked if the drawers were of sufficient quality in general or if the quality was poor. The two most common repairs I have made are sliding bottoms, and missing or crappy guides/slides. I have not needed to repair many drawer carcasses themselves or cabinet carcasses. With this experience (admittedly limited) I am wary of recommending a slide in drawer bottom. Am I missing a key component for success? What is your experience,

C, sorry to ask but are we talking chipboard drawer boxes or traditional dovetail drawers or both?

 

FWIW, I'm no cabinet maker and have made virtually no drawers in the traditional way. But without researching this I would, if using solid timber, making a traditional drawer box, I would have grain running parallel with the face of the drawer. I would secure it a the back with some slot screws allowing for movement. Having grain running front to back would mean any expansion would potentially push the drawer sides off. I would think it unwise to make a captured solid timber bottomed drawer.

 

If I was machine making drawers I would use a captured ply base.

 

Capture Ply - Modern production environment 

 

Loose Wood - Traditional Old school  build

 

Any failure would then be down to poor workmanship or use beyond the scope of the design.

I don't build kitchen cabinets, so my opinion doesn't mean much if this conversation relates only to kitchen cabinets, but...

 

When I build drawers, I use solid wood and captured bottoms about 90% of the time...I leave enough space for the bottom to breathe and use a dab of glue at the centers of the end grain sides to keep it from moving around.  I like using primary wood for drawer boxes and bottoms in "fine" pieces...I don't think the drawer is any less important than any other part of the piece.

 

As for the grain orientation of the bottom...I didn't realize there were any hard and fast rules.  I decide which way to run the grain based on what looks best, and usually that just means the grain will run in the same direction as the longest dimension of the drawer.  If the drawer is square, it's a toss-up, and usually it will run front to back.  But no way am I gonna run the grain front to back if the drawer is wider than it is deep...that would just look stupid, rules be damned.  And ultimately, as long as you build with wood movement in mind, I don't see how it matters at all.

 

And I agree with Ace...this thread... :huh:  :blink:    I also wish I had some editing powers so I could go in and fix the grammar...not to be that guy, but boy, it's bad here.  Spell check and a quick proof-read before posting, fellas...makes it so much better for the reader.  :)   Carry on...

  • Author

Yes Graham, traditional. With a traditional dovetail design and hide glue attachment, my traditional training has been to heat and disassemble to repair captured timber bottoms. I have never owned a piece of furniture, fine or otherwise that was not captured and existed without failure. This makes me think there is some secret I am missing. I do know enough to realize when Norm proposes slide ins that he is almost certainly using ply for his drawer bottom. Even this I question due to my experience, but I don't know everything. Again, I hesitate to call it wrong but I have been trained to ask this question: Would I do this in my own home? I am not sure I would.

Thanks C,

 

Don't feel I can go much deeper than I have, don't make enough drawers. I would just use eric's intuitive method.

 

BTW "that guy"  :P, sorry if my English is not so hot, perhaps you can be my spell check

:D 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.