Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm making a repair and needed to get about 8 linear feet of 1.25" thick red oak. Of course, my local hardwood supplier was already closed, so I hit up my local big blue box (one of them happens to actually take care of its wood) and got some S4S 1x4" boards that were actually S4S.

 

After doubling up, that gave me 1.5" thick pieces (two 36" x 3.75" and one 24" x 3.75").

 

The easiest way to remove that excess quarter inch would be to drive out to the workshop I have a membership at and run it through the planer, or buy a lunchbox planer, but I'm trying to do this, by hand, without spending extra money. So, in the hour or two I had between finishing the yardwork and it getting dark tonight, I tried a different way of removing the excess on each piece (using a 2x8 across sawhorses outside, since my kid was getting put to bed for the night).

 

Technique #1: Hand planes, all the way. Obviously this is tough - take a shaving thick enough to actually make reasonable progress tended to pull the board out from under me without a plane stop. (My workbench's improvised stop are boards of varying thickness anchored by heavy carriage bolts to the top [which is probably 2" of plywood]. Effective but unimpressive). This is probably the most reliable, but man - it's slow going, and tough  on a bad shoulder.

 

Technique #2: Using a chisel to split the oak as far down as possible. It actually worked pretty well, particularly with my heavy hickory mallet driving the chisel. Of course, once you get more than a few inches in and have to go bevel down, that doesn't work so well. I still feel like I have to leave a decent safety margin in case of grain weirdness, so there's still planing to be done.

 

Technique #3: Using the rip side of my ryoba to cut down the length. I still have to leave a safety margin to plane away, and I feel like I've almost snapped the blade half a dozen times. It's slow going, and feels like a great way to give myself tendonitis in my good elbow/shoulder. Plus, trying to maintain a consistent, square cut over 36" is NOT happening at my sell level right now, so I have to stop every 6" and start a new cut.

 

Other thoughts? Is there something I'm missing (besides anaerobic endurance and patience)? Given how well the chiseling has worked, I was thinking about splitting off excess on the both ends of each board, then chiseling out chunks across the grain (crosscutting with the saw as needed to sever the grain, then cleaning up the face with a plane -since that seems the most efficient method.

Posted

What type of handplanes are you using? A scrub plane, followed by jack, a jointer, and smoother will get you there, and flat, in a decent time frame. Still, it's a lot of work though.

Make sure you are clamping your workpiece with dogs, or at least are using a planing stop and taking cuts that don't make the work jump all over the place. Of course, sharp irons are a must.

If it were me, I would run it through the planer. Is there a reason you don't want to go to the shop? You mention keeping costs down, but are you not a paid member already?

What's the project? It may be better to place the material in to your repair at close to final dimension And then handplane it flush.

I would double check the squareness of any s4s material. You may need a quick run over the jointer as well.

Posted

High TFB,

 

I would stick with hand planes. Set up a gauge line as a thickness reference point. If you are removing a lot of stock down to a thickness make sure your blade has a heavy camber and work across the grain. In the ideal world you would use a Jack plane to do this. Breakout can occur as you are working across the grain but this can be reduced by skewing the cut and also by applying a chamfer close to the gauge line on the exit side.

Level off with the grain using a straight iron in the plane with the edges eased. Ideally you would use a jointer/try plane for this.

The final tidy up would be with a smoother.

I did not have dogs to support my work so I used little plastic fixing blocks screwed top the bench top.

Posted

Technique #1: Hand planes, all the way. Obviously this is tough - take a shaving thick enough to actually make reasonable progress tended to pull the board out from under me without a plane stop. (My workbench's improvised stop are boards of varying thickness anchored by heavy carriage bolts to the top [which is probably 2" of plywood]. Effective but unimpressive). This is probably the most reliable, but man - it's slow going, and tough  on a bad shoulder.

Do this, but take the time to make a proper plane stop. It will make this project much easier, and it's not like you're never going to use a plane stop ever again.

Posted

A follow up, and a couple points to clarify:

 

I found out I'd need even more space than previously thought, so I ended up just using 4/4 boards, without doubling up. It's more than strong enough - the thicker board was primarily for appearance.

 

Back to the subject, I have a #5 (set for a coarser cut) and a #4 (set for a finer cut), so yes - upon further reflection, I agree - that's probably the best.

 

Franklin - the shop is an hour away, more with traffic :( It was not in the cards to drive there anytime soon - especially not for 5 minutes of work. Plus, I pay per use since I'm not there often enough to use a better plan.

 

Wilbur - I couldn't use a plan stop because I was working outside on sawhorses. My current workbench is build from 2x4s and plywood (built by the previous owner, with a piece of 3/4" birch ply laid over top by me to get a clean/smooth surface. It's sturdy, but unremarkable. As I said, the total thickness is probably 2". Most planing stops seem to call for a front vise of some sort in combination which bench dogs or a hand clamp on the opposite end. My only vise is a machinist's vise on one end of my bench, so I'd be limited to clamping a piece across my bench with hand clamps, which I don't think will be significantly better than my current setup.

 

Right now, I have 2 .5" holes drilled in the top, with carriage bolts that drop through and pin in a piece of wood that has matching predrilled holes (i've got a couple different thicknesses, depending on what I'm planing). It's essentially the same thing as a plane stop, just bolted instead of clamped.

 

 

And if you're reading this and thinking "you should just build a new workbench"... yes. I should. It's on the to-do list.

Posted

I was mainly going by the description of "take a shaving thick enough to actually make reasonable progress tended to pull the board out from under me without a plane stop." If your plane stop is working, this really shouldn't happen, even with taking thick shavings.

 

Can you be more specific as to what is happening? This should be pretty easy to troubleshoot.

Posted

 

Franklin - the shop is an hour away, more with traffic :( It was not in the cards to drive there anytime soon - especially not for 5 minutes of work. Plus, I pay per use since I'm not there often enough to use a better plan.

Fair enough. I would certainly go with the handplanes then.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Do you really want to plane off a quarter of an inch?  Wouldn't it be easier to cut off some of that with a saw, then plane square?

 

or is 1/4" too thin to reasonably cut over that long a piece?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.