Tony Wilkins Posted June 27, 2013 Report Posted June 27, 2013 I was looking through all the ceramic water stones on toolsfromjapan.com and got a hankering to upgrade my set up. I currently have only a Hida house brand 1000 and a King S3 6000. I didn't know there were such a wide variety of stones and concepts behind them. Got me thinking what would be best. I'm really drawn to some of the stones in the Suehiro Gokumyo series. If money were no object, what would be your ideal water stone sharpening set up? bonus question: what do you use to 'grind' a new edge - very coarse water stone or other? TIA, Tony Quote
Eric. Posted June 27, 2013 Report Posted June 27, 2013 DMT Dia-Flat 120 Shapton 1000 Shapton 5000 Shapton 8000 2 Quote
Trip Posted June 27, 2013 Report Posted June 27, 2013 ==> what do you use to 'grind' a new edge - very coarse water stone or other? Tormek - with aftermarket Japanese waterstone ==> If money were no object Establish New Primary Bevel Angle / Grind New Tool: Tormek T-7 with aftermarket Japanese waterstone Establish/Hone Secondary Bevel: Natural Japanese Waterstone - say an Oohira Range Suita Finish Stone / Polish: Natural Japanese Waterstone - say an Nakayama Maruichi Kan Kiita Total price: about $4K. Now we could substitute pre-war stones and add a couple of grand Quote
Eric. Posted June 28, 2013 Report Posted June 28, 2013 Those are some big words, H3...do you really think you could tell the difference in the final result compared to the Shaptons? What makes those stones so amazing that could possibly make them worth 4K? Quote
Trip Posted June 28, 2013 Report Posted June 28, 2013 ==> Those are some big words, H3 Question was "cost no object" ==> could tell the difference in the final result compared to the Shaptons? As for telling the difference, I'm staying away from that one There are entire books/websites/blogs/etc covering the differences between natural stones and the synthetics -- some in minute detail w/ electron micrographs... It's practically a religion -- Zen in the Art of Sharpening... ==> What makes those stones...worth 4K? Rarity, mining difficulty, etc sets the high-cost-of-entry. The stone's mineral composition, strata recovered (typically depth-related), strata location (mt range), stone's hardness, size of stone, uniformity of surface, etc sets the price of the individual stone. In general, the better stones are from older mines and deeper strata. The best stones are pre-war (safety concerns closed some of the oldest and deepest strata after the war)... ==> What makes those stones so amazing...? Good natural stones produce a honing slurry upwards of 40K-60K grit --- many times what can be produced by today's commercially-available synthetic stones... Pre-war stones report a honing slurry to 80K grit... Some folks are willing to pay top whack to get those numbers.... again, Zen in the Art of Sharpening... Leonard Lee has a whitepaper on the different edges left by natural -vs- synthetic stones. He also explains why one type of edge slices wood fiber bundles more efficiently than another... It's about the most understandable tome on the subject - complete with electron micro-graphs... Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted June 28, 2013 Report Posted June 28, 2013 My setup, which makes so happy I need to wear Depends, is a Dia-Flat, XC-C & F-XF DMT's, a 4000 grit and 8000 Norton, with a $15 guide and setting jig built from Lie Nielsen plans. The XC-C and F-XF DMT's are double sided. I use the DMT's, including the DiaFlat as an XXC, to flatten backs and shape bevels, and the 4000 and 8000 to hone microbevels. For extreme bevel changes, I have a grinder with an 80 grit friable wheel. I own a Tormek, but usually use it on carving and turning tools only, and household items, like scissors, as the setup above ^^^^ is far, far, faster. My carving and turning is rare, so the Tormek is not used often. I'm not a competitive sharpener (Yes, there ARE sharpening contests!), or an electron microscope guy, and this really works well enough for me with woodworking tools that I don't plan to spend more. IF the Norton's wear out, I'll probably buy no-soak Shaptons as replacements, but not until they wear out. Quote
Tom King Posted June 28, 2013 Report Posted June 28, 2013 With what you have in the middle: These to grind: http://www.d-waytools.com/tools-diamond-grinding-wheels.html Probably at least 20 times faster than wet wheels. With Lee Valley tool rests. You have to make the cutout larger. http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=45938&cat=1,43072 These to finish: http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=68943&cat=1,43072 I've been tempted to spend bucks on more fancy water stones too, but I'm glad I didn't. Quote
rodger. Posted June 28, 2013 Report Posted June 28, 2013 I use a norton 220, then 1000, 4000, and 8000 imanishi stones. I was considering buying another, higher, grit. Then I read this: http://www.theunpluggedwoodshop.com/how-sharp.html Quote
wilburpan Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 If money were no object, what would be your ideal water stone sharpening set up? Atoma 400 diamond plate for flattening waterstones: $90 Shapton Pro 1000: $50 A high quality aoto (natural Japanese waterstone, about 3000 grit): ~$200 A high quality natural Japanese finishing waterstone: ~$1000 Total cost: about $1400. I have the Atoma diamond plate and the Shapton Pro 1000. I also have an OK quality aoto and finishing waterstone. bonus question: what do you use to 'grind' a new edge - very coarse water stone or other? The Atoma 400 diamond plate, or a Tormek. Depends on the tool being ground. Quote
Eric. Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Hey Wilbur, the Atoma diamond plate is about half the price of the DMT Dia-Flat. What makes you choose the Atoma over the DMT, since price is no object? (Only assumption I can make is the Dia-Flat only comes in 120 and 160 and you prefer a higher grit for flattening? Or are there other factors?) I'm about to spring for a Dia-Flat and wondered if the Atomas were comparable. Quote
rodger. Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Hey Wilbur, the Atoma diamond plate is about half the price of the DMT Dia-Flat. What makes you choose the Atoma over the DMT, since price is no object? (Only assumption I can make is the Dia-Flat only comes in 120 and 160 and you prefer a higher grit for flattening? Or are there other factors?) I'm about to spring for a Dia-Flat and wondered if the Atomas were comparable. I use a 220 diasharp and it works great! It's far cheaper than the diaflat. I paid about 50 dollars for a 220 diasharp, and the diaflat comes in over 3 times that. The diasharp is guaranteed to be flat over the entire plate at a tolerance of 0.001". Quote
wilburpan Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Hey Wilbur, the Atoma diamond plate is about half the price of the DMT Dia-Flat. What makes you choose the Atoma over the DMT, since price is no object? (Only assumption I can make is the Dia-Flat only comes in 120 and 160 and you prefer a higher grit for flattening? Or are there other factors?) I'm about to spring for a Dia-Flat and wondered if the Atomas were comparable. Everything that I like about the Atoma can be found here. Quote
Dan S Posted July 2, 2013 Report Posted July 2, 2013 With what you have in the middle: These to grind: http://www.d-waytools.com/tools-diamond-grinding-wheels.html Probably at least 20 times faster than wet wheels. I have been watching the electroplated wheel technology develop for a while now, and as soon as someone starts selling a wheel above 400 grit I'm going to bite the bullet. metalworking is another hobby of mine, and I have been wanting to make my own custom grinder for years, and a high grit electroplated plated cbn wheel is the last piece of the puzzle. my system will be this eventually. 1) custom variable speed (VFD controlled) 8" grinder with a 180 grit wheel on one side, and a 400+ grit wheel on the other. 2) homemade tormek style tool rests 3) homemade honing guide that works in conjunction with the tool rest 4) 1000 to 10,000 plus grit waterstones (got these aready) 5) atoma 400 to flatten my stones (got this to) with this set up i can sharpen everything i want to sharpen, my non carbide metalworking tools, and all my woodworking tools. It would be fast, precise and allow for razor sharpness. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.