Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello Fellow Wood Workers,

 

I am about to embark on my first project after creating a workshop.  I am going to build large desks for an office area.  An overhead sketch is attached.  Based on costs at local home store I have decided to do a 1X4 laminate project.  Using prefab counter tops would run me over $300.  Using Grade A plywood would be $250-300.  Grade B plywood would be $200-250.  Common pine 1x4 would run me $125-150.  I can use some of the price difference and pick up a thickness planer so the lamination is nice and even.  Not sure on how I will join the boards together so they don't separate.

 

The intended project is for 5 large sections to be bolted together.  2 of the corners areas will be cut out and a sliding keyboard tray will be installed.  The 5th add on will be for my wife's scrap booking.  I will probably do drawers, possibly file cabinets, end shelves and maybe hutches.  

 

If anyone has links to similar builds please share.  Any advice on laminating 1x4's into 24" slabs, please feel free to share.

 

 

Tools I have access to:  10" miter saw, 10" table saw, 8" drill press, circular saws, plunge router, block plane & antique Stanley #4 & #5 and possibly a 13" planer if I buy one.  No room/$$ for a jointer.

 

Thanks!

 

post-14170-0-09944400-1375396724_thumb.p

Posted

Without a jointer, you are going to need some way to cut flat, square edges of the boards you glue up into panels. A router table or hand plane can do the trick. From your description, it sounds like your lumber may be S4S stock from a big-box store. If so, I recommend getting the widest boards you can, then ripping them to obtain the most stable grain. Wide pine boards are likely to be cut from the middle of the tree, so if you cut out the heart, or 'pith', you end up with 2 narrower boards that have quarter-sawn grain, which is the least likely to distort with changes in humidity. These cuts may not be the most interesting to look at, but in a wide glue-up, they are more likely to stay flat.

Posted

With your tools and no joiner I would use 2x material. If you get a decent grade of 2x4 and hand select them for the straightest ones in the pile then run all 4 faces thru a planer you might get some reasonable joints glued up. Glue up pieces that will fit through the planer and flatten them before you glue up the final width.

This seems like a lot of work to save a little money. Also think about wood movement. A 24" wide solid wood top can move over 1/2" with changes in humidity. What is that going to do with your corner joints? How are you going to cut miters that wide?

Posted

I don't know if any local lumberyard source yet,,, I will have to investigate that.  Box store is having a big sale so its 19.9 cents a board foot.  As far as doing this to save money, well that's part of it but I want the learning challenge.  Making plywood desks is easy.  I want to learn how to laminate boards into large surfaces, plus an excuse to buy table top planer.

 

OK as far as jointing... I've read plenty of blogs on you can use a table saw to joint ends and even sides.  You 'can' use a sled to joint the edges in a planer.  I can pick up a planer to smooth out the surfaces. As far as making large miters, I don't see a problem with a straight edge and a circular saw, I've done that in the past with good results.  Also I have access to my neighbors 10" table saw that has a large top and is cast iron, should make nice cuts.

 

I've decided I am going to go a pattern with the tops.  I will make it look like a wood floor, having shorter pieces alternating in spacing.  It will be more work, but what a great learning experience.  Not sure on how I will join them yet.  I've read that I can dowel, biscuit, or some sort of routed 'tongue and groove'.  Leaning towards routing, it will force me to build a table for my plunge router.

 

I'm not sure I understand the 2x4 thing.  I would be wasting a lot of material to mill it down to 3/4" in a planer.  Ripping it in half is no good because I would be left with 1/2" boards after planing and ripping.  As far as ripping 1x12's, not sure that's needed.  These desks will be torn apart in a few years when we leave the rental and get a house.  I'd have to remake them at that point anyways, so not worried about wood movement.

 

No worries, I really do appreciate the input.  It will make me think about this some more.   :)

Posted

So a little reality check.....

 

Just got back from the box store.  I checked out the 1 x X stock.  The 1 x 4's are just terrible.  1 x 8's seem to be the sweet spot, but still some warping going on.  So I think where I know where Steve is coming from.  I could take a  2 x 4 even if warped, rip the sides for a rough cut and then plane to a perfect flat board.  So one 2 x 4 I could rip/plane into a true 1 x 3.  This would give me a thicker top and perfect flatness.  Looking at the 1 X stock..... I'd have to plane it down and be less than 3/4" thick, which wont provide enough strength.  

 

I must ponder this.....

Posted

The idea was make the top as thick as possible with the 2x4 as a start. Flatten the sides glue it up, flatten that, glue up the full size and flatten it. Might end up with 1 inch maybe more , maybe less.

Posted

Ok so what I am leaning towards... use table saw to true up all 4 sides... glue into ~12" sections and use a table top planer, then glue two of those together for the 24" depth im looking for.  Im thinking using 2-3 boards  with 2-3 legs on the backs for each section.   Possibly doing a mortise and tenon since I have never done that before. Legs to table tops,,, not sure on that one yet. Sections will be bolted together by metals strips underneath 

 

Hope to pick up a truck full of 2 x 4's tomorrow......

Posted

OK so this is my before shot.  Pile of wood and a messy office area.  We shall see if the final product is what I have visioned in my head and brings order to chaos.  

 

post-14170-0-88790200-1375563074_thumb.j

post-14170-0-26224000-1375563091_thumb.j

 

 

I came up with another idea.  The keyboard trays, make those out of end grain cuts.  Should look nice.

  • 1 month later...
Posted

Project is slated to be done but has been on hold because life poked its head out and stole my budget.  I should be on track soon, so I need to make some decision on where to spend my money.  I'll need clamps, lots of them.  HF has their pipe clamps on sale all the time, I will stock up on those.  As far as joining the boards together,  I feel the most cost effective way will be a biscuit joiner.  I am leaning towards the Ryobi biscuit cutter.

 

As far as smoothing and jointing.  I do not have room for a jointer, but I could purchase a hand jointer (veritas looks nice).  I was thinking I could hand plane for jointing.  I do have room for a 'portable' planer, I am eyeing the Ridgid 3 bladed planer.  I am thinking of doing 12" boards assemblies, planing them to the same thickness and joining them to make 24" tops.  I picked up a ryobi orbital sander (I like so far) and I have 2 other palm sanders, plus tons of sanding bars.  I have a plunge router to do a round over of the edges.  

 

My neighbor has a decent cast iron table saw that I will use for ripping n such.  I have roller stands to assist with the long boards.  I also have a cheap SCMS that I can use for cross cuts.  Other than that I think I am set for tools....

 

I could use advice on how to go forward and get the best bang for my bucks. I really appreciate everyones input!!

  • 1 month later...
Posted

54 boards cut into 2 foot sections.... that took a lot of time....

 

I picked up a ryobi biscuit cutter to join all this together.  Not sure of the next assembly step.  I was thinking of joining them back into boards (6' and 8'), then ripping them 3" width. Then I will laminate in groups of 4 to make 12" wide boards.  I am figuring I can plane them at that width.  (At the end of the month I am planing on picking up a Ridgid 3 blade thickness planer.)  After that I can join 2 sections together to make the final 24" width.  

 

My other thought is to rip them and plane them as is, then assemble them.  I would then probably do a final plane to make sure its all smooth.

 

Thoughts?

post-14170-0-76143300-1383529710_thumb.j

post-14170-0-87259300-1383529719_thumb.j

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 39 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined