Jasahan Posted August 30, 2013 Report Posted August 30, 2013 So our shop just started mass producing items (tables and chairs for a cafe we're opening). It's all mortise and tenon joinery. I like using a router for mortises, because they're nice and clean and can be very consistent (with some skill and sense). However, it's not conducive to mass production with people of varying skill levels. So we bought a very basic mortiser off craig's list. It's easy to set up a jig with stops and brings a decent amount of consistancy. But then we have to clean them out, which is annoying and time consuming. I'm certainly willing to accept that a good mortiser could fix issues. But... Is there a machine that is basically a movable head mortiser, but has a router bit? And you could just slowly plunge with each pass? Seems to me it'd be the best of both worlds. And kind of sounds like a CNC, I guess. And maybe I'm just lazy. Quote
mikem Posted August 30, 2013 Report Posted August 30, 2013 Sounds like you are looking for an over-arm router. I don't know of any that are still being made unfortunately. Grizzly/Shopfox had them for a long time, and Shop Smith had one for awhile as well. Quote
T-astragal Posted August 30, 2013 Report Posted August 30, 2013 Ballestrini Micron. $16k That's one bad to the bone mortiser. I just got one to replace an invicta mortiser. I'd sell it at a fair price btw. The ballestrini oscillates the spindle side to side and slowly advances the table. The invicta head plunges in and out and the table move side to side. Other than those, I believe the Laguna $5k is a good machine too. It's head moves in 2 dimension with a single joystick. And once you have used a real mortiser you will cringe at the thought of using a router. Same goes with shapers. Steve 1 Quote
T-astragal Posted August 30, 2013 Report Posted August 30, 2013 Perhaps or or No disrespect, but if you are mass producing don't go this route. The Laguna a step up is what you want. It's worth the money. Steve Quote
G S Haydon Posted August 30, 2013 Report Posted August 30, 2013 I would agree Steve, just depends how mass the production is. That ballestrini is quite a tool We only really use an HCM, or on windows and frames we also use tenoning discs too. Quote
Jasahan Posted August 31, 2013 Author Report Posted August 31, 2013 I would agree Steve, just depends how mass the production is. That ballestrini is quite a tool We only really use an HCM, or on windows and frames we also use tenoning discs too. What is an HCM? Quote
Jasahan Posted August 31, 2013 Author Report Posted August 31, 2013 I probably could have figured that iut had I thought about it. Mass production being 20-40 chairs at a time, and 10-20 tables. We will end up making aroung 100 chairs for us. Each as 22 mortises. Quote
T-astragal Posted August 31, 2013 Report Posted August 31, 2013 That's a tough one. Many different sizes? How ya making tenons? Flat sided parts? Steve Quote
Jasahan Posted August 31, 2013 Author Report Posted August 31, 2013 That's a tough one. Many different sizes? How ya making tenons? Flat sided parts? Steve Tenoning jig on a table saw. And for the tenons with angled shoulders, router, with some assist from the bandsaw. Only 2 widths (3/8 and 1/2) and three lengths. All 3/4 tall/deep/whatever. Quote
T-astragal Posted August 31, 2013 Report Posted August 31, 2013 Tenons are 3/4 long and how wide? You'd need to go to a floating tenon to take advantage of most mortisers. Steve Quote
pghmyn Posted August 31, 2013 Report Posted August 31, 2013 How about the Domino / Domino XL? At that quantity, it could pay for itself quick. Quote
T-astragal Posted August 31, 2013 Report Posted August 31, 2013 How about the Domino / Domino XL? At that quantity, it could pay for itself quick. Not bad, but I'd be trying to "idiot proof" the process. Dedicated jigs and stationary machines will do it better at that quantity. Nothing is worse than trying to be precise with hand tools over abs over again. Domino might be a decent interim choice though Steve Quote
Jasahan Posted August 31, 2013 Author Report Posted August 31, 2013 Tenons are 3/4 long and how wide? You'd need to go to a floating tenon to take advantage of most mortisers. Steve They are 3/8" or 1/2" wide (as in chisel size for the mortises). I'm not sure what you mean by "You'd need to go to a floating tenon to take advantage of most mortisers." Also, I haven't looked into it, but I gather that the Domino is essentially a tool that cuts mortises for floating tenons. Is that correct? Quote
..Kev Posted August 31, 2013 Report Posted August 31, 2013 Yes, the domino does floating mortise/tenon joints and does them very well and quick. However, check the pricing on this tool as it's not cheap! Quote
wdwerker Posted August 31, 2013 Report Posted August 31, 2013 Both Domino machines are not as expensive as commercial stationary machines. With a few jigs you can achieve almost anything with one. However without a skilled operator you might be safer with stationary equipment. Cut 2 mortices and assemble with a floating tenon. That approach should be faster and possibly more accurate than cutting a tenon on the ends of your parts. I make my own Domino tenon stock for the medium and wide settings in 3 ft sticks then cut pieces as I need them. 1 Quote
Rick LoDico Posted August 31, 2013 Report Posted August 31, 2013 Or you can go with an FMT. Cut your mortise and an exact fitting tenon. Quote
dwacker Posted September 3, 2013 Report Posted September 3, 2013 You can buy the cheaper Laguna for about a grand. It works just fine and with birds mouth cutters you can go as deep as you will ever need. If you want to spend a bunch more money look at the Grizzly overarm routers this would pick up the pace. I would move the tenoning operation over to at least a shaper. Quote
Jasahan Posted September 4, 2013 Author Report Posted September 4, 2013 You can buy the cheaper Laguna for about a grand. It works just fine and with birds mouth cutters you can go as deep as you will ever need. If you want to spend a bunch more money look at the Grizzly overarm routers this would pick up the pace. I would move the tenoning operation over to at least a shaper. What would be the benefit of doing tenoning at a shaper? Quote
T-astragal Posted September 4, 2013 Report Posted September 4, 2013 A shaper with a good sliding jig would make tenons, but they would be the width of the part. Also being that chair parts are rarely flat or even straight, it makes it even harder. Looks like a job for lots of jigs and precise hold down fixtures. OP's project is the classic, " too big but not big enough" problem. Too many precise parts to just skillfully make them and not enough to really buy the proper equipment. A 4 axis CNC would be great if you have a spare 150 grand! Look up ballestrini pico. You might find one used for $10-15 k and I think it might be what you need, just hope you can sell more chairs to spread out the cost. Chairs are tough! There is no easy way out of it. If you don't have the right equipment and processes you will triple the assembly time and have to fair in lots of joints. Steve Quote
dwacker Posted September 4, 2013 Report Posted September 4, 2013 Being realistic a shaper will cut all 4 sides on most tenons in two passes quickly and accurately. Quote
Jasahan Posted September 4, 2013 Author Report Posted September 4, 2013 Being realistic a shaper will cut all 4 sides on most tenons in two passes quickly and accurately. Are you aware of any videos demonstrating this? Quote
Tpt life Posted September 4, 2013 Report Posted September 4, 2013 Long, lots of fluff and the cutter is more than just a tenoner but this is basic spindle tenoning. Quote
Jasahan Posted September 4, 2013 Author Report Posted September 4, 2013 Chairs are tough! There is no easy way out of it. Steve I'm starting to think that's the bottom line. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.