Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Of Chisels, Handplanes & Ripsaws

Featured Replies

I'm in the process of acquiring a decent set of hand tools as I advance steadily towards the Dark Side, and have a few questions before I spend anymore money.

 

1-I already have a set of seven bevel-edged Narex chisels. Lee Valley currently has a deal on some new Narex firming chisels, a set of five for $109 (good until 15 Dec or until stocks last). Are firming chisels and important thing to have in a hand tool work-space, or are they more of a luxury item that I substitute the bevel edges for?

 

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=71290&cat=51&ap=1

 

2-I'm currently reading "Woodworker's Guide to Handplanes" by Scott Wynn. He has a chapter on how to make your own traditional wood-bodied planes, with planes for a set consisting of a jack, fore, jointer, panel, and smoother planes. I already have a jack and a smoother, but I could use a joiner planes.

http://www.amazon.com/Woodworkers-Guide-Handplanes-Choose-Workshop/dp/1565234537/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1386127837&sr=8-1&keywords=woodworkers+guide+to+handplanes
 

A-Is making your own planes something that a beginner could reasonably attempt? (ie, can I expect it to work)

B-Wynn's suggestion for wood is, in descending order, beech, birch, oak, walnut, cherry, or mahogany. I have access to some white ash that I can use for free; any idea if it would be suitable?

C-Wynn's directions all involve a hollow chisel mortiser, which I don't have. Would mortising chisels work instead?

3-I'm in the market for a rip-filed panel saw. I've searched eBay for Disstons a couple of times, and prices seem to range from $5-$250. If I am looking for one in reasonable condition (sharpening required, some rust, but with handle and blade straight & solid), how much should I expect to pay? Alternatively, are there any other brands I should be looking for? Consensus here seems to be the Sandvik is also good, but are there other brands of which I am unaware?

Thanks in advance for the advice, as I know that these diverse and technical questions.

Can't speak to the chisels or saws, but I'll take a shot at the plane:

 

Yes, a beginner can make a plane that works just fine.  I built a jointer out of wood scraps and a Hock blade four years ago and I still use it today.  I happened to have Padauk on hand but Ash would work just as well.  I'm not sure why Wynn prescribes a hollow chisel mortiser.  I went with James Krenov's design:  Rip the blank apart, chop the bed at whatever angle you want and then glue it back together.  Drill for the crossbar, fit the wedge and the rest is decoration.

Hi Doomwolf,

 

Chisels in the link are paring chisels rather than firmer chisels. Do you need them? Up to you, for the job shown in the link a shoulder plane would work better or angle a short chisel. If you really do want them get just one, maybe a 3/4"

 

Making one could be fun, I would like to take a shot at that one day. Rob rightly points out the easiest method for making one. How about a vintage woodie from e-bay? I have an old school trying plane and enjoy using it. If you want to make it traditional style chopping with mortice or general purpose chisel will be fine.

 

On saws, buy a cross cut if needs be a re-file. Other brands to look for, spear & jackson and just general panel saws. If the handle looks nice chances are it's good steel. If you get a bad one on the cheap put it down to experience and practice your filing.

  • Author

I suppose a better way of phrasing the chisel question would be, what kind of work do you use a parring chisel for? The next projects I want to build are some Mission-style end tables, the Guild Shaker table, the Dutch tool chest in the Oct Popular Woodworking issue (whenever the hell my back order arrives, it's been 5 1/2 weeks, grrr....) and either a chest of drawers, or a pattern I have from Fine Wood Working (Shaker blanket chest with a drawer in it).

 

As for the plane, and I am taking your responses as a giant green light. I will try and get some wood set aside the next time I am able to visit my Dad's barn.

 

Filing a crosscut as a rip cut - my understanding is that saws, esp panel saws, have different TPI counts for ripping and crosscutting. Would this not cause problems?

I'm a newbie so take what I say with a huge grain of salt, but I've made similar choices recently and here's what I decided:

 

- I have the Narrex bevel edge chisels too and love them so far. I briefly considered the new paring chisels but I really can't think of exactly when I'd use them so I decided against them for now. I can see buying one 1/2" chisel at some point to use for fine paring but I'll probably go with something premium for this, either a Veritas pvm-11 or perhaps a Japanese chisel which I've heard can get ultra-sharp.

 

- I won't say either way about building a plane. Seems doable, but I opted to buy a Stanley #7 off ebay and have been quite happy with it.

 

- For the rip saw you should be able to find a 26" Disston ~5 tpi rip saw on ebay for a reasonable price. I got one that is in decent shape for around $30. I've sharped it myself and it cuts pretty well. Your point about the crosscut is valid, I haven't seen any crosscut saws in the 5/6 tpi range. 

 

I'd looked for one that had a nice old handle that had smooth curves as well as brass nuts. Sometime after WWII the handles got squarer and uglier. The ones with thumbholes go for a lot, but if you're patient and stalk ebay for a few weeks ("watch this item" is your friend) you'll definitely find a decent D7, D8, or D23. Also look for other brands like Spear & Jackson or Atkins.

 

Hope this helps some!

On saws if the issue is you cant find a rip for reasonable money a rip filed saw with slightly more teeth would be fine. If you are looking for a panel saw these are finer tools and stand apart form what is referred to as a rip saw or a crosscut saw, both of them used for coarser work.

 

If you are looking for a panel saw I am not aware any of them had thumb holes, big grizzly rip saw yes, smaller refined panel saw no. Perhaps you could let us know what you want to use the saw for?

Google Nice Ash Planes - ash is a good enough wood for planes that they are available commercially, absolutely no reason for you not to use it if it is cheap/local/available.  Ash is actually very close to the hardness and stability of beech, works well.   There are probably some reasons why beech is better, but you will probably have to become a very good planemaker to make it matter.  

 

Merely the fact that Wynn's list does not have any of the commonly used alternatives maple/pear/apple tells me it is not that authoritative, while the inclusion of mahogany is odd.   It was seldom used for that purpose because it is not that hard, even the Honduran/Cuban types that are no longer generally available.

 

Within a range of different wood choices, the saw pattern is arguably more important than the wood species.   Quartersawn will give better results than flatsawn, but if you are picking through a firewood pile or similar, you can riftsaw your blanks which is the ideal.

 

For making a plane, I would recommend David Finck's book as a detailed discussion of the process.  Some of his comments on sharpening etc seem a bit odd, but it is a great walkthrough for building a plane.

  • Author

For a saw, I'm looking for something I could use to rip boards to length with. I live in an apartment and don't want to annoy the neighbours with power tools, because if they call the landlord and he finds out I am building furniture, he will flip. My understanding is that a "panel saw" is the correct term for a saw with a 20-30" blade. As far as saws go, I ordered a Veritas Crosscut saw (16tpi) during their Cyber Monday sale, and I have a cheap Mastercraft backsaw for general use, so I need something that can handle cutting through long pieces.

 

Thanks for the additional plane-making resources, I will have to take a closer look at them. 

Panel saws are on the shorter end of the bigger group of handsaws at 16" to 24".  Most of the Panel saws are 20" and most of the bigger 'handsaws' are 26" though can be found longer.  You can look at somewhere like Bad Axe or Darryl Weir ( http://home.grics.net/~weir/Saws_for_sale.html ).  On the new market is LN or if you are lucky Wenzloff and Sons.

 

If you are open to Japanese Saws then you can get a 270mm Ryoba for less than $50 that will do both cross cuts and rips with great results.  They do require a different body mechanics to use but it's worth a try being so inexpensive.

For ripping boards to length, you will want a full sized handsaw with 4-1/2 to 5-1/2 teeth per inch.  I never really understood exactly what a panel saw was for, other than fitting in a toolbox easier.  I don't know that you can even buy a good new one these days. Even some of the high dollar ones aren't taper ground.  The thumbhole D8 was intended to use both hands on.  The left hand thumb goes in the hole.  The D8 is a good, heavy bladed rip saw.

 

Rip saws are the easiest to sharpen.  When learning how to sharpen, don't skip any of the steps in any of the online info and videos you will find.  There is no shortcut to doing it right, but it's not really that hard, and is easy to get it screwed up if you skip any of the steps to the setup.

 

Rake of the tooth is important. Zero rake will give the fastest cut, but unless you are strong and athletically co-ordinated,  I'd suggest going with 4 degrees of rake to start with.  To start the saw, back it up across a corner until you have a flat big enough for 2 or 3 teeth to rest on, and then go forward.  Reluctance will be the biggest hindrance.  You need to really go after it, with the board well supported.  Don't try to go so fast that you can't stay on the line.  Mark the line while deciding which side of it you want to cut on.  Either stay right beside the line, or take the whole line but no more.  I use a sharp no.3 or 4 pencil with a straightedge.  A nice, straight sawed line will save time and effort jointing the edge.

 

Once you are used to it, a sharp rip saw will surprise you with how fast it will cut.

 

Speaking of Reluctance, I was at a talk that Bob Ballard gave once.  He was talking about taking Prince Charles diving in the North Sea.  Prince Charles was sitting on the edge suited up, and they were putting a 110 pound weight belt on him.  He had on a thick wetsuit inside a drysuit.  Prince Charles said in a concerned voice, "But I did the calculations last night, and I only need 60 pounds to overcome buoyancy."  Bob Ballard told him, "Yeah, that first 60 pounds it to overcome buoyancy.  The other 50 pounds is to overcome reluctance."

 

Here's one that might go for a reasonable price:  http://www.ebay.com/itm/SIMMONS-KEEN-KUTTER-5-1-2-POINT-RIP-SAW-MODEL-K-88-SIMILAR-TO-DISSTON-/131061463694?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item1e83df3a8e

I have a thumbhole Disston D8 (26").  Even though it's not the sharpest saw in the quiver I'm still in love with it.  I can wait until I get it sharp!

  • Author

A bid is in on the saw, as suggested. I'm getting resigned to the fact that it does not seem to be possible to get one off eBay without spending atleast $25 in shipping/handling. 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.