Recommended Posts

Posted

Hadn't seen that one before... Thanks. Love this sort of thing...

 

This was shot prior to the 24fps standard. Playback speed was the judgement of the projectionist... Movies were specified in feet, not length...

 

Those guys look like they had an efficient workflow and worked fast... If I had the time, I'd pull the footage into PremierePro and normalize playback speed to see just how fast those guys really are...

Posted

I would *love* to see that at normal speed. Can you manage some translations while you're at it?  ;)

 

One of the things I was looking at was the sit-upon (for lack of a better term) that one of the chairmakers' was using. The idea of a usable bench consisting of slab+4 legs that I could hide under a drop cloth is appealing, given that I live in a second-story apartment; fortunately the downstairs neighbour was not bothered my mortise-and-tenon experiment earlier today. 

Posted

If you are careful you notice some lingual patterns. Hall, specializes or specialist, product are all recognizable. I see the rhythm in their work and think that most clips, while not exact are reasonably paced. One or two are odd outlying and advanced far too quickly but most could be close. This is the pace I see in the competent old timers. This reminds me of the conversations about not having time to stop and admire your work.

Posted

==> I would *love* to see that at normal speed.

 

I'm just sitting here watching, "A Touch of Frost"... So I've got some free time...

 

I've captured the video, it's being processed and pulled-in to the NLE. There are quite a few jump-cuts and some out-of-sequence splices... I'll have to re-cut to get something close to the actual linear sequence. There are some background visual hints that will help establish correct frame rate...

 

​PS: did you catch the 1923 for Swedish Television? :)

Posted

"The Spoon" sequence is done. Came-out pretty good.

It's not quite dialed-in. I've got some tools to refine the frame rate, but I won't get to it until tomorrow...

 

<edit> Video is now dialed-in.

Posted

I’ve finished work on the Spoon footage… Posted above...

 

The frame speed has been corrected using motion cues (track falling objects and correct for 32ft/sec/sec)… While not obvious, the original film editor (1932) performed some slight-of-hand in placing jump-cuts where they would be least noticeable to make it look like the spoon is made faster than it actually is… I’m looking at this frame-by-frame on an editing suite, so I can clearly see the cuts. Point is, the footage runs about 2:30. But I suspect it took closer to five minutes to make the spoon...

 

I'll tackle the Clogs footage next…Upfront, it’s got a rather obvious problem… For whatever reason, the original film editor repeated two segments and shortened one part of the workflow… I’ll work on it tonight…

 

 

I'll tackle the Chair footage last...

The editor made several significant timeline changes to the footage. It'll take me a bit of time to unwind it...

Posted

==>^^^

My other hobby... Always been interested in photography (got the bug from Dad who got it from Granddad). After years of land-based photography, got board and decided to move my hobby underwater. Got hooked on underwater imaging... Started filming/editing shorts about a decade ago...

 

The Chair sequence is going to be difficult. I've run through the footage twice. There are some big jumps backward and forward in the workflow. If I had to guess, there may have been some technical problem during the original shoot (not surprising for 1932) so they filmed two different chair sequences and spliced them together for a single narrative. Unfortunately, it appears part of the workflow is missing. I'm making a story-board of the workflow from the footage, then I'll re-edit the sequence to match the story-board. I may just insert a title card describing the missing parts of the workflow. 

Posted
The original film editor of Clogs was not a woodworker… Several of the workflow steps in the 1932 film are out of sequence...
 
First thing's first, the original footage was cut into eight workflow operations, then re-spliced into a workable sequence…
 
There’s also quite a bit more editing-magic in Clogs compared with Spoon. The impression is given that you can go from having your feet measured to walking away with new set of Clogs in about four and a half minutes…There’s quite a bit of slight-of-hand going on…
 
To make a long story short, the original editor shaves time from each operation by hiding the time-squeeze within a jump-cut. In essence, as the viewer watches, he/she perceives the operation completed even though it's not actually on screen -- it's a common technique...
 
Watching the cuts frame-by-frame you can see that each operation is only about 2/3 complete at the cut... The biggest time-squeeze occurs during the second hollowing-out operation – it’s only shown for one clog and only about 2/3 of the operation. The shaping, fettling and fitting steps are shown for one clog only…
 
The corrected timeline is about 5:30 – give or take. I suspect it took about twenty minutes to make the pair – which is still about twenty hours faster than I could do it… :)
 
Note: the lighting was all over the place in the original – I normalized the lighting (where possible) and added a sepia tone (because I liked the look)… The final render took an hour of CPU time…
 
I'll work on Chair next. It took about three hours to unravel Clogs, so I suspect I won’t finish Chair before the weekend.
 

Posted

As with Clogs, the original film editor was clearly not a woodworker…

 

With few exceptions, the workflow steps in the 1932 film are out of sequence...

 

First thing's first, the footage needed to be unpacked and re-cut from scratch. The four minutes of source footage required 38 cuts to isolate work steps. The cuts were then re-arranged to create a single end-to-end workflow.

 

Unlike Spoon or Clogs, there was very little slight-of-hand. The footage was so scrambled that the editor probably couldn’t follow the workflow, so there was little incentive to get cute.

 

The time-corrected timeline is about 4:45 – give or take.

 

Note: As in Clogs, the lighting was all over the place – I normalized the lighting (where possible) and added a sepia tone.

 

 

Anyway, enjoy

 

PS. I like how he uses his whittling knife as a bench stop... :)

Posted

post-9382-0-38120900-1387539194_thumb.jp. I find YouTube's suggested offerings at the close of these shorts to be ironically inept...

Thank you for doing this work. I am sure many if us will enjoy the benefit while having no clue how to do it ourselves.

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

In retrospect, something didn't seem right about some of my time estimates, so reviewed the footage more closely --- and noticed more 'time shaving' slight-of-hand...

 

Essentially the original film editor concealed frame removal within action -- a very common technique because it's hard to notice (until someone points it out to you)... Happens in motion pictures all the time... Think of those internet reading tests where sentences are given to the reader, but the prepositions are removed -- the reader simple adds them subconsciously and never notices -- same thing with moving images -- the viewer simply adds the missing steps -- as long as they're not too far removed from the action...

 

Let's take the Spoon sequence... at 25sec, the stock is clearly a rectangle as the hatchet strikes the blank -- but at the stroke's end, the blank now has a discernible spoon shape... A clever (and very hard to notice) edit. But now that I've pointed it out to you, you'll see it every time -- and wonder why you didn't notice it before...

 

There are similar ripple cuts in the other sequences...

 

My original time estimate for 'Spoon' was 5 minutes, it's now closer to 7-10 minutes while 'Clogs' increases to 40 minutes. However, 'Chair' remains unchanged -- I still suspect that the film editor had no idea what was going on, so he/she couldn't creatively edit the footage. If you watch the 1932 edit, even a woodworker would have a hard time discerning what was going on -- the footage makes no sense at all...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.