Recommended Posts

Posted

I have a crappy Craftsman miter saw that I only use for construction work. I have both a crosscut sled and 45º miter sled for my table saw that I built. For breaking down rough lumber I clamp the board to my UTS and cut with a circular saw which takes some time. This summer I'll have a bigger shop and wonder if a miter saw would be a useful addition? Is a good one accurate enough for 90 and 45 cuts or is the table saw still better for this with shorter boards? A miter saw would be quicker for breaking down rough lumber but I don't need accuracy for this. 

 

So how many of you use a miter saw for woodworking and what all do you use it for? I'm pretty sure if I got a new one it would be a slider but don't know if 10" or 12" would be better? 

 

What miter saws out there are accurate enough for woodworking? I'm sure the Festool is but also have been checking out the Bosch GCM12SD. 

 

http://www.amazon.com/Bosch-GCM12SD-120-Volt-12-Inch-Glide/dp/B004323NNC/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1395671827&sr=8-1&keywords=bosch+miter

 

Posted

i have a bosch 10" scms that i have had for 10 years. 90 and 45 cuts are fine. it is useful for cutting down stock and not always having to set up the cross cut sled is a nice convenience. That being said if I replace it will be with a 12" non slider. cheaper, more depth of cut, more rigid, and fewer moving parts to worry about.

Posted

I am convinced that any miter saw you can possibly purchase from a home center is dead weight in a woodworking shop. I spent $800 on my bosch and everytime i use it i feel like throwing it in the ocean.

Posted

Yes cochese, i use a shooting board. Not to ruffle feathers since people do use miter saws in their shops, the accuracy lacks entirely for my desired quality of work. The kapex seems to have a good reputation but i cant swing a 1400 dollar miter saw and justify it right now. But like i said, anything you can buy in lowes or hd these days is not going to please the meticulus crowd.

Posted

I have never owned a miter saw nor do I plan to own one in the future. All of my stock is broken down with a handsaw or bandsaw, milled, and then cut to final dimension on either the table saw or MFT/3. I have never really seen the need for a miter saw. If for some reason I felt like I had to have one, I would go with the Kapex.

Posted

I disagree... Accuracy is only as accurate as your layout, no matter how much the saw costs.

Better dust collection on the kapex, yes. Perhaps more repeatable for angles, I don't know... Never had an issue with mine.

Meticulous... That word may ruffle some feathers. I don't see how the cuts I made for my bench vise in soft maple would improve on a shooting board (even if you can shoot a 3" thick board). This past weekend I cut 30" pieces out of two ten foot boards of 8/4 hard maple. The cut ends are flawless. Smooth and shiny on every piece. And they are all the same size. I don't have the best setup either. The pieces were literally balanced between the saws table and an outfeed stand (also from HD).

So not to ruffle feathers, but accuracy is a product of proper marking. Not something a saw just does.

Posted

I've got my Hitachi pretty dialed in. However, if I wanted to sit there and dial a miter in I would appreciate the board. It's very hard to accurately shave off a hairs-width slice with the miter saw, no matter how accurate it is. I could sand, but I'd rather slice.

 

It's something I'll make in the future.

Posted

I have to agree with you Mel. There is no reason why you could not dial in the fit of a miter to be accurate within a few thousandths of an inch. The inaccuracies are probably the result of missed marked or miss measured board, a board not being properly milled or a number of other errors caused by the woodworker and not the tool itself.

  • Like 1
Posted

I disagree... Accuracy is only as accurate as your layout, no matter how much the saw costs.Better dust collection on the kapex, yes. Perhaps more repeatable for angles, I don't know... Never had an issue with mine.Meticulous... That word may ruffle some feathers. I don't see how the cuts I made for my bench vise in soft maple would improve on a shooting board (even if you can shoot a 3" thick board). This past weekend I cut 30" pieces out of two ten foot boards of 8/4 hard maple. The cut ends are flawless. Smooth and shiny on every piece. And they are all the same size. I don't have the best setup either. The pieces were literally balanced between the saws table and an outfeed stand (also from HD). So not to ruffle feathers, but accuracy is a product of proper marking. Not something a saw just does.

I have to agree with you Mel. There is no reason why you could not dial in the fit of a miter to be accurate within a few thousandths of an inch. The inaccuracies are probably the result of missed marked or miss measured board, a board not being properly milled or a number of other errors caused by the woodworker and not the tool itself.

I hope you guys arent insinuating what i think you guys are insinuating.

Posted

I hope you guys arent insinuating what i think you guys are insinuating.

 

I am not insinuating anything. I am stating that accuracy is the direct result of proper layout. I did give room for the Kapex to be more accurate and perhaps more repeatable with angles, but for straight 90 degree cuts, thats on the person using the saw. No matter if it is a handsaw or a SCMS.

Posted

You guys are heading way off track, and bringing user error and incompitance into the equation. If its necessary we can surely head down that road but thats not the topic of this discussion. I use miter saws in the field professionally, everyday. I know what they are capable of, and where they lack.

Posted

My $200 Dewalt home store miter saw does a dang fine job.  Built into a table, high tooth count blade, and about an hour fidgeting with the presets make a huge difference.  I stretched a section of Underarmor shirt over the back like so (http://www.keen-products.com/mitersaws.htm) and always have a shop vac hooked up.  I've used a Kapex a few times and I would put this hobbled together cheapo saw up against it in terms of accuracy of 90* cut and dust collection.  Not for capacity obviously but then again that's what the TS55 is for!

Posted

Like any tool it works good for its intended purpose. Mine gets a lot of use. breaking down rough stock. Cutting down scraps into firewood. Making miters for picture frames. I do see it is as more of a blunt tool, but within its range of capabilities it is very handy to have. I do miss it when I do not have it set up.

Posted

Everything in a shop setting. You deal with blade deflection, deflection in the slides. My old bosch 5312 was made in taiwan, and my new gcm12sd is china. This new 800 dollar saw haunts the living hell out of me. I would probably prefer 10" saw in the shop which would result in less chance of blade deflection.

Aside from arguements of whos right and whos wrong, it is common knowledge that miter saws lack the performance edge in a woodworking shop, and its the truth. The further you dive into the detail and overall qc of your work, the less you will rely on that tool.

It is a solid performer on jobsites for me however. I do a lot of ornate trim in high end homes. I know the behaviors of my saw, so i am able to compensate at times to achieve tight and clean work.

Posted

Aside from arguements of whos right and whos wrong, it is common knowledge that miter saws lack the performance edge in a woodworking shop, and its the truth. The further you dive into the detail and overall qc of your work, the less you will rely on that tool.

 

I disagree again, and I am not here to win an argument.

 

I am able to get accurate and repeatable 90 degree cuts that are very smooth with my SCMS. Why would I use the TS to crosscut an 8/4 board that is 5' long?

 

I can see if I was getting a bad cut, or had another gripe with the saw. My only gripe is that it is heavy, and I haven't made a home for it yet... Not the saws fault.

 

As far as quality of work goes, we can go back and forth and get off topic very quickly. I would rather not do that, but we can if you want to... 

Posted

I am not insinuating anything. I am stating that accuracy is the direct result of proper layout.

 

That's true for hand tool work, but not with machines.  You can lay out a perfectly square mark all day long, but if your saw isn't dead nuts, it ain't gonna matter.  If you're talking about sawing to a line with a hand saw, then yeah, accurate layout is everything.  Layout is far less important with machines...in fact, I'd argue layout means very little with machines...test cuts are the machine version of layout.

 

Not to stir the pot. :)

 

To address your question, bubba...Kapex good.

Posted

Don't stir the pot then leave the kitchen.

Layout is important no matter which tool is used. The point Freddie was trying to make was that one cannot get good results from a tool from lowes or HD. That is nonsense. Stating that anyone that uses a SCMS from a home center isn't meticulous is nonsense.

About test cuts, your blade either hits the mark or it doesn't. How can I make a test cut for a 90 degree cut on a ten foot board without a stop block? I either properly layout the cuts or I get frustrated. And every cut I made was right.

  • Like 1
Posted

I gotta chime in with Mel on this one.
I have a 10 year old Hitachi SCMS. It's the one with the rails going forward so you can stick it right up against the wall. I've cut 90's, 45's and a host of other angles that I simple can't get any more accurate. Which is not to say somebody else couldn't get them more accurate, but I certainly can't even if I use a shooting board or my TS with a sled what ever.

 

I recently did a project in which I needed a bunch of parts from 8/4 Walnut cut to 4 degrees. ... Bulls-eye.

I guess if pressed I can't promise you everything was precisely cut at 4.000000 degrees. I didn't have a NASA scientist handy to calibrate the cut out to 7 decimal places, but everything went together without a hitch and without any discernible gaps that I could find with any of the feeler gauges I own.

 

I should mention that mine is permanently ensconced to a table and has been for quite a while. I think I'd be happy to take the Pepsi Challenge with my saw vs. anyone's Kapex.

  • Like 2
Posted

About test cuts, your blade either hits the mark or it doesn't. How can I make a test cut for a 90 degree cut on a ten foot board without a stop block?

 

Uh...remove the stop block, sneak up on the cut, and put the stop block back on when you hit your desired length?  Using machines without doing test cuts is like using hand tools without layout lines.  I never just hope that "I'll either hit the mark or I won't."  Unless I'm framing a stud wall. :)

 

I'm not gonna get into the "crappy tools can't be used for fine work" argument...that's been disproved a million times.  That said, I do tend to avoid the box stores for important tools.  But not everyone has the budget for anything else, so I ain't judgin'.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 59 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined