krtwood Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 Got into a debate on this one on youtube and it being youtube, well, never got a proper conclusion. So here goes, if you use a regular light switch rated for 15 amps is it okay to use that on say a 14 amp induction motor. Under NEC 430.109© it says: © Stationary Motors of 2 Horsepower or Less. For stationary motors rated at 2 hp or less and 300 volts or less, the disconnecting means shall be permitted to be one of the devices specified in (1), (2), or (3): A general-use switch having an ampere rating not less than twice the full-load current rating of the motor On ac circuits, a general-use snap switch suitable only for use on ac (not general-use ac–dc snap switches) where the motor full-load current rating is not more than 80 percent of the ampere rating of the switch A listed manual motor controller having a horsepower rating not less than the rating of the motor and marked “Suitable as Motor Disconnect” However this fellow, who claimed to be an electrical engineer, said it was perfectly fine to do it. I would guess the NEC doesn't necessarily apply here because if the switch goes to a plug then that is the disconnect and it's not a stationary motor, and yet the principle should be the same. I can find other examples of switch manufacturers talking about pure resistive loads vs motor loads and other types of loads and how to convert the rating from one to the other, but with wildly different conversion factors. I couldn't get an answer out of the fellow before I was accused of being a big meanie for suggesting that most people who would build their own router lifts, because they are too cheap to buy one, wouldn't call in an electrician to wire the 50 cent switch that they were using because they were too cheap to buy a proper switch, who would probably charge more than buying a real router lift in the first place. Now I'm confused and have no resolution, so I thought I would ask here where people have weird names but can take a joke. Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 I recently asked this question on two other forums when I was wiring a motor and got a plethora of answers. Many of the answers contradicted regardless of the qualification of the poster and some answers were so technical I couldn't figure out if it was a yes or no (I'm guessing it was neither). In the end I used a 15A light switch as I've known many others to do and it has been perfectly fine. Incidentally I've also had one on my router table for 15 years with no trouble. Quote
wdwerker Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 Be careful of the openings in your electrical box around woodworking machines. I have seen boxes full of sawdust and the cheap switches can create sparks under loads. 2 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 The light switch will start and stop the motor as well as any othe style of switch. However, it is designed for a lighting load ( resistive ), rather than a motor load ( inductive ). A motor will draw as much as 10 times its full load current during startup. Over time, the pounding that gives the switch will cause repeated thermal cycling in the contacts and result in premature failure. I would suggest using a switch rated for at least twice the motor full load current, as most off the shelf light switches are not of the 'snap action' type. The dust issue mentioned by wdwerker is a valid one as well. Quote
Trip Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 Electrics is one of those areas where saving $$ shouldn't be an over-riding goal. For example: I've read many posts on fused switches in a router table… Folks balk at the $24.95 for a purpose-made safety switch and use a lighting switch + convenience outlet for a 7518... Problem is: what happens if you’re raising a panel and have an issue --- you go to turn off the router and the switch fails to on? Sure you can open the router table’s access door and pull the plug from the outlet, but that’s not exactly best practice… Nor is it exactly safe… ‘Failing to On’ is only one of several safety issues. Granted, the more likely failure mode is ‘Fail to Off’, but it does happen. Other risks have been covered in previous posts. A fair percentage of home fires originate with electrics… It’s one area where DIY can have considerable down-side. So yea, a lighting switch+outlet will work – for a while. But the potential downside far outweighs spending the incremental $15 or $20 for a purpose-made solution. 2 Quote
wdwerker Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 I bought a purpose made switch for my PC 7518 router table. In addition to being sealed and having a safety ring around the on button there is a large off paddle switch which is easy to use in an urgent situation. The STOP paddle has to be pulled outwards before the On button will work again. I unplug the router from the switch before changing bits. Quote
krtwood Posted April 29, 2014 Author Report Posted April 29, 2014 I have a couple of those prewired boxes you can just plug the router into the short extension cord. It just makes sense to me to do that. I'll be darned if I'm going to cut the plug off the end of the router's power cord, which means in addition to the light switch, box and wire nuts I've got to buy a short extension cord to hack one end off. At that point when you factor in my time to wire everything how much money have I saved? This EE seemed like he was saying it wouldn't lead to premature failure of the switch, which is what I had heard and am hearing here. The guy was wiring the router and a vacuum together in the box so they would come on together. The combination was under 15 amps but it just seemed like a bad idea. The contacts welding in the on position is probably not going to lead to an injury, just a wtf moment and an annoyance. You shouldn't be putting yourself in a position where a switch failure is going to get you injured regardless. But if you KNOW you're setting yourself up to cause that situation sooner or later it just seems foolish to do it to save a few bucks. Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 Motor rated toggles can be had for about the same price as a 15A or 20A light switch. Quote
Trip Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 ==>same price as a 15A or 20A light switch Yea, but the same price as a good-quality light switch -- not the $1.49 jobs you get at the BORG. The last 20a motor-rated toggle that mounts in a std single-gang box cost me about $24.95... Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 No, you can buy motor rated toggles for a few bucks. The more expensive one are industrial. Just like light switches which also can be bought for industrial application, for a lot more money than home duty.Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using Tapatalk 2 Quote
Trip Posted April 29, 2014 Report Posted April 29, 2014 Thanks, I'll take a look... Don't have much call for them... Think my last purchase was for a router table... Actually, was for a garbage disposal... Quote
BuilderBill Posted May 7, 2014 Report Posted May 7, 2014 The code you're quoting is for stationary motors. A router with a 15A plug connection isn't a stationary motor, it's a portable tool. The 7518 has soft-start which means inrush current isn't really an issue. And inrush current is usually 2.5-3X rated current, not the 10x someone mentioned. If you were talking a table saw or other stationary tool I'd say go with a expensive motor-rated switch but for a soft-start router? Really??? Quote
krtwood Posted May 7, 2014 Author Report Posted May 7, 2014 I realize the code isn't directly applicable, but having a plug doesn't change what is happening to the switch. It just gives you another way to disconnect it if the switch fails on. Anyway they cut the plug off and wired it into the switch box which is attached to the router table. It's as stationary as a table saw at that point. In the situation that provoked the discussion, it was a cheap router (9 amp) and a vacuum (4 amp) being wired together into the switch. I don't know if the router in question had soft start. When you're putting up an instructional video people are going to copy what you are doing but with different equipment than what you used. Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted May 7, 2014 Report Posted May 7, 2014 If the guy had them plugged into a wall outlet that was switched I doubt anyone would raise an eyebrow.Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using Tapatalk 2 Quote
Ian Gagnon Posted May 12, 2014 Report Posted May 12, 2014 Be careful of the openings in your electrical box around woodworking machines. I have seen boxes full of sawdust and the cheap switches can create sparks under loads. A lot of people laugh when they see my shop because I have spring loaded snap covers on my outlets and switches. Sort of like this guy... It comes with a gasket that seals it against the electrical box as well. Call me crazy, but when switches and outlets aren't in use, they're just places for sawdust to call home. Sure it takes me a second more to flip a switch or plug in a tool, but that's fine with me. Quote
Trip Posted May 12, 2014 Report Posted May 12, 2014 ==>A lot of people laugh when they see my shop because I have spring loaded snap covers on my outlets and switches Don't knock it -- been doing that for years... Especially in/around the finishing space. HVLP or not, spray gets into everything... Quote
Ian Gagnon Posted May 12, 2014 Report Posted May 12, 2014 Great minds think alike! Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.