AstroDave Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 Build or buy...??? It seems that the majority of folks tend to build their router tables or certainly the cabinets at least. I would love to do that but not sure my skills are up to the task yet. I have no router experience whatsoever. I am taking a router class at Woodcraft this month...However I am generally leaning towards purchasing a table. I have looked at General (Excalibur), Incra, Jessem and MLCS. My budget is sufficient so that's not an issue. Just looking for a long term solution. Quote
..Kev Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 I have the Jessem with the big PC router and have been super happy with it! Quote
Keggers Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 +1 on the Jessem. Mine works well. Quote
Eric. Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 Buy the table, build the cabinet. You can do it! You never get better if you don't take risks. Quote
Nestor Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 Build it. Table and cabinet. You can make it to suit your specific needs. It's a great way to hone your skills. And if you make a mistake, so what? It's unlikely you're working with expensive wood, and it's going to sit in your shop anyways. Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Buy a shaper! Sorry had to say it Quote
AstroDave Posted November 2, 2014 Author Report Posted November 2, 2014 PB I am considering that...so I've been educating myself on the pros and cons Quote
Eric. Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Router tables make more sense for hobbyists. Don't drink Don's Kool-Aid. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Router tables make more sense for hobbyists. Don't drink Don's Kool-Aid. Routers make more sense to hobbiest that don't know anything about shapers. Quote
Eric. Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Or don't wanna go broke buying expensive cutters they'll use once or twice in their lives... Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Or don't wanna go broke buying expensive cutters they'll use once or twice in their lives... Another myth perpetuated by lack of knowledge. Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 M'kay. Show me. To different round overs plus a bead $40 that three router bits. Quote
Eric. Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Let's compare apples to apples...you can get a 6 piece roundover set in Grizzly green for 20 bucks. Cheaper. Next? Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Two words: Raised Panel Raised pane $65 Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Let's compare apples to apples...you can get a 6 piece roundover set in Grizzly green for 20 bucks. Cheaper. Next? That's not apples to apples those are garbage bits. Look at Freud. The shaper cutter is going to cut circles around it even cheap shaper cutters and even the Freud . Again lack of knowledge. Quote
Eric. Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 What brand are the green ones you're posting? Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 $32.95 Next? Again lack of knowledge the shaper is going to perform better and longer. Pull up a Freud the cheap shaper cutter is going to cut better and longer even with the Freud. No cheap router bit is even close to a cheap shaper cutter. Apples to apples the shaper wins. Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 What brand are the green ones you're posting? Grizzly but it's the nature of the beast that gives it the performance. You can't get the performance with a router so you have to jump way up in quality to come even close to the worse shaper cutters. Quote
Eric. Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 So, apples to apples, like I said. They're manufactured in the same factory with the same metals and machines. Perform better and longer...of course, that's not in question. But at a cost. It's more expensive to buy the cutters, and the "better and longer" part usually doesn't matter in a hobbyist's shop. You can easily get through one kitchen's worth of cabinets with a router panel bit...dozens and dozens of kitchens? No. But that's not what hobbyists are doing. Again, you bring to the table the professional's opinion...which usually doesn't apply to hobbyist applications. Stop making people feel like they can't get things done if they don't have commercial grade equipment. It's unnecessary. 2 Quote
dwacker Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 So, apples to apples, like I said. They're manufactured in the same factory with the same metals and machines. Perform better and longer...of course, that's not in question. But at a cost. It's more expensive to buy the cutters, and the better and longer part usually doesn't matter in a hobbyists shop. You can easily get through one kitchen's worth of cabinets with a router panel bit...dozens and dozens of kitchens? No. But that's not what hobbyists are doing. Again, you bring to the table the professional's opinion...which usually doesn't apply to hobbyist applications. Stop making people feel like they can't get things done if they don't have commercial grade equipment. It's unnecessary. I don't make people think like they can't do things. Small,shapers are in NO way commercial equipment period. It's about bang for the buck. Again you don't know the first thing about shapers. Just because you don't have one does NOT mean they are not an option for others. Quote
Eric. Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 Yes, they're an option. I've looked into them and I wish I had one for the rare occasion that I need to create a big profile that taxes my router and feels a bit dangerous. No argument. But the cutters are more expensive than router bits...which we just proved...and the power that shapers offer is unnecessary about 99% of the time in most hobby shops. If you find yourself needing a shaper more often than that, either you're not a hobbyist or you do a specific type of work that requires a shaper, in which case the additional cost is justified. I have NEVER found myself in a situation where I said, "If only I had a shaper, I could do this." I've always found a way with either my router table or a workaround. BIGGER? Definitely. BETTER? Sometimes. NECESSARY? Rarely. MORE EXPENSIVE? Always. I'm done with this one. See ya next time. Quote
Janello Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 I'll jump in, albeit. A shaper is something I would not mind owning, but lets face it, a "decent" shaper is twice the price of a quality router table and 3hp router. If you're gonna own a shaper, you'd better invest in a auto stock feeder too. Even more money. It also takes up a lot more real estate, runs on 220v (another expense) if you need to run a line. That's before buying bits that you might already own for a hand held router. So in conclusion- The two Mentors both make solid arguments that one can be better than the other. Depends on how deep your pockets are, and really, what level you plan to take your woodworking to. I've owned over-kill all my life, but could not justify the extra 3k when I bought my router table at the time. If I were retired and didn't need to put kids through college, I'd probably have a shaper! 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.