AstroDave Posted November 2, 2014 Author Report Posted November 2, 2014 Alrighty then! Budget is certainly an issue as are smaller projects. So I will head down the RT route for now. Once both daughters are married and/or my projects dictate it I will pursue a Shaper.. Quote
Barron Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 I took a router class from the Woodcraft in Springfield, VA, and it was one of the most useful classes I have taken. I use techniques I learned there all the time. A base for a router table does not need to be a cabinet, though that is a great way to go. Really, just something stable supports the top is all you need. You don't even need a fancy top to start out. Quote
AstroDave Posted November 3, 2014 Author Report Posted November 3, 2014 Barron I will be taking that same class at the end of this month at that very Woodcraft Quote
customwood montrose Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 I found that a shaper is good for most types of cuts, I know, I have 7 shapers and 2 router tables. But there are times when a router table is still the best for a certain cut. You need to decide how much you want to spend and how heavy of cuts you think you might be doing. Heavy cuts with a router shorten the life significantly and probably be not the highest quality cut either, do lighter cuts progressively or get something with more ummmfff. You can find used shapers on some of the machine dealers for good prices. Another option to look at if this is a possible route, is the Amana Profile Pro cutter set. Aluminum cutter head with insert type knives that cost about $25 to $40 per set. Lots of choices to choose from to. I have about 40 to 50 sets of these to choose from, I have hundreds of router bits to choose from. Both have there places in any shop. Dustin Quote
bushwacked Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 If you want to build your skills. Build your table. Plenty of plans online and they are simple enough to follow. I'm in the same boat as you and I try to build everything so I can learn Quote
dwacker Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 I think these conversations always get blown way out of proportion. So much of it is complete lack of knowledge. We are not talking about giant shapers. We are talking about small hobby shapers. Its really no different than tablesaws or planers. So many start of with little dewalt or delta universal motor planers, they get the job done but are loud and don't really cut all that great. Most hobby folks itch to upgrade to the typical 15" four post, its quieter and performs better but is in no way a production class machine. The same goes for tablesaws, many start with universal motor job site saws. Hobby folks itch for that induction motor contractors saw or small cabinet saw. Again none of these machines are large nor are they production machines. The same theory goes to shapers. Here is were the complete lack of knowledge get things going the wrong direction. Nobody is suggesting anyone go out and buy a 12.9HP Martin or even a 5HP Powermatic. We are talking smaller 1.5HP hobby units. These units cost about the same as a quality 3.25hp router table setup with a good lift. Someone mentioned needing 220V power. These units run fine on 110V just like your contractor saws. Someone mentioned needing a power feed. This is ridiculous most don't have the table space for a feeder nor is it necessary. A small shaper is just a step up from a bigger router table. They take up the same amount of shop space as a free standing router table, use the same power and the cutters are affordable. These units don't spin big 7 pound moulder heads they only have 3/4" spindles. All your going to run is carbide cutters a few inches in diameter and nothing more. I have neighbor that has a little shop fox. He added a small right extension wing with a very inexpensive rockler router plate and a fixed base pc690 for the rare event the shaper can't get the job done. A router table is a good thing to have and is handy but once you have a small shaper you no longer need any fancy features or HP from a router table. I have a router table with one of the biggest lifts made and 3.25hp PC motor. I own maybe 4 router bits at most and have used it maybe half a dozen times at most and half of those was due to not wanting to swap out cutters on the shaper. The pro shops want to come into these conversations with input that is way over what a hobby guy could ever use and confuse the matter. I have a 5hp Powermatic and a 12.9HP 6 axis Martin this sort of information has no place in these conversations. I have a few dozen 5-10lb moulder heads and a few hundred sets of knives but really this is not hobby stuff and this is the sort of stuff that really confuses hobby folks when it comes to shapers. Small shapers with hobby class carbide cutters out perform routers easily even on little 1.5HP shapers. If all your running is these affordable carbides you in NO way need any more than 1.5HP. These little shapers are perfect for edge work and pattern work. Just like a router the cutter can be fitted with a bearing to trim your patterns but the shaper is going to do it better. There are smaller affordable aluminum spirals made by Amana that perform close to a Byrd Shelix. These spirals will cut better than any router bit even with William NG cutter and yes you can just free hand with a bearing just like a router. If you want to grow a little you can get affordable door sets again they outperform even the most expensive of router setups. Chances are pretty good that most folks already own a smaller router. Adding a little router wing to a small shaper to use your existing little router cost next to nothing, hell most tables are already drilled for extension wings all you have to do is make a little wing and bolt it on. Then we get argument like you can't cut dovetails or dados on a shaper. Like i already stated adding a little wing for these operations is nothing. Machine cut dovetails were actually started on shapers long before routers. Back in the early 1920's the dovetail jigs were cast iron and cut dovetails inverted on shapers just as you would a router table.There are a few cutters that work well at slow speed, dovetail bits are one of them. We don't need to get to deep into dust collection but its much easier to make a shaper collect dust than a router table. Again lets not confuse the hobby world with the pro stuff because it in no way compares. The idea is a real nice step up from that screaming, dust slinging router not doing production runs of moulding. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 PB makes a good point. The Grizzley 1.5HP shaper costs $550.00. A complete Woodpecker's Router table package (without a router I may add) costs you around $900.00 depending on where you buy. Just saying.... Quote
bushwacked Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 $900 seems like a lot just for a router table. You could build one yourself for nowhere near that price and use the savings to buy more tools 1 Quote
Vyrolan Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 Small shapers with hobby class carbide cutters out perform routers easily even on little 1.5HP shapers. If all your running is these affordable carbides you in NO way need any more than 1.5HP. These little shapers are perfect for edge work and pattern work. Just like a router the cutter can be fitted with a bearing to trim your patterns but the shaper is going to do it better. Do you have a particular small hobbyist shaper you'd recommend? I feel like the Grizzly Chet mentioned is a general price point often thrown around. As for the cutters, how do hobbyist even get into that? I feel like I know router bits enough to know certain brands (Whiteside, Freud, etc) are worthwhile and it's nice to know I can use them in the table or handheld. With shaper cutters, I wouldn't even know where to start and I don't feel like there's a lot of information (or maybe I'm just missing it). I would agree with you that there's a big lack of knowledge, but the knowledge seems harder to obtain than it should be. Thinking about why I want a router table, it's 99% to trim to patterns or to profile edges. I believe you would say that I really want a shaper if that's what I want to do...but where does the hobbyist go from there...the web is overflowing with info on router tables. Quote
dwacker Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 $900 seems like a lot just for a router table. You could build one yourself for nowhere near that price and use the savings to buy more tools Sort of. On average your going to spend over $600 on a 7518 motor and lift. Even if you build a table from shop scraps you will still not have even close to as nice of set up as you would a inexpensive shaper and pc690 router wing. Even if you bought a dedicated pc690 and router plate your in it just a little over what you would spend on a motor and lift alone. The difference is now you have two setups in one that are much more versatile and if you have an extra router no extra money. Quote
Vyrolan Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 $900 seems like a lot just for a router table. You could build one yourself for nowhere near that price and use the savings to buy more tools That setup probably does a lot more than just what a shaper does... I've priced out my "dream router table" and it would be $1200-1500 with the router. That's with a great lift, Incra fence/positioner, and good dust collection above and below... Sad but true I'd end up with this setup that could cut amazing joinery with Incra's precision and probably over 75% of its actual work would be roundovers on edges. Quote
dwacker Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 Do you have a particular small hobbyist shaper you'd recommend? I feel like the Grizzly Chet mentioned is a general price point often thrown around. As for the cutters, how do hobbyist even get into that? I feel like I know router bits enough to know certain brands (Whiteside, Freud, etc) are worthwhile and it's nice to know I can use them in the table or handheld. With shaper cutters, I wouldn't even know where to start and I don't feel like there's a lot of information (or maybe I'm just missing it). I would agree with you that there's a big lack of knowledge, but the knowledge seems harder to obtain than it should be. Thinking about why I want a router table, it's 99% to trim to patterns or to profile edges. I believe you would say that I really want a shaper if that's what I want to do...but where does the hobbyist go from there...the web is overflowing with info on router tables. Here is the thing shaper cutters even hobby level cut better than most router bits. You have a real good selection at Grizzly and MLCS. Infinity has some affordable cutters. Tools Today has all the higher end cutters. Woodworker.com, eagle america and so many others. Shapers sort of fell by the way side due to the fact that most of us had to have custom cutters made. So really only commercial shops used then.Today is so much different, carbide cutter are now easier than ever to come by at an affordable price. You can really just treat a small shaper just as you would a higher HP router table. Obviously keep you fingers out of the cutters. What I did not mention is that you can reverse the motor so if your doing pattern stuff you can change the cut direction easily to prevent blow out. With cutters the diameter is pretty standard meaning if you want to do pattern stuff with a straight carbide cutter you just select a cutter and a bearing the same diameter as the cutter. Your also using large bearings so they don't burn up like on router bit bearings. Quote
Vyrolan Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 Here is the thing shaper cutters even hobby level cut better than most router bits. You have a real good selection at Grizzly and MLCS. Infinity has some affordable cutters. Tools Today has all the higher end cutters. Woodworker.com, eagle america and so many others. Shapers sort of fell by the way side due to the fact that most of us had to have custom cutters made. So really only commercial shops used then.Today is so much different, carbide cutter are now easier than ever to come by at an affordable price. You can really just treat a small shaper just as you would a higher HP router table. Obviously keep you fingers out of the cutters. What I did not mention is that you can reverse the motor so if your doing pattern stuff you can change the cut direction easily to prevent blow out. With cutters the diameter is pretty standard meaning if you want to do pattern stuff with a straight carbide cutter you just select a cutter and a bearing the same diameter as the cutter. Your also using large bearings so they don't burn up like on router bit bearings. Thanks for this...did some browsing at Grizzly's selection. It's definitely a lot of food for thought. It seems their 1.5HP shaper (for $550 as Chet pointed out) is capable of all the edge-forming stuff you could throw at it and can also do all the basic panels. Is the shaper going to be able to do things in fewer passes than the router table? I assume you still can't just go nuts on a panel-raising cutter, but surely fewer passes than on the router? Am I reading it correctly that you can use the bearings (seemed to be called rub collars for shapers) however you'd like...put it below the cutter or above the cutter or both... I've always wondered why router bits aren't like that instead of having to buy both versions. Also, what's your opinion on their optional spindles that let you run 1/2" router bits in the shaper? Quote
dwacker Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 Thanks for this...did some browsing at Grizzly's selection. It's definitely a lot of food for thought. It seems their 1.5HP shaper (for $550 as Chet pointed out) is capable of all the edge-forming stuff you could throw at it and can also do all the basic panels. Is the shaper going to be able to do things in fewer passes than the router table? I assume you still can't just go nuts on a panel-raising cutter, but surely fewer passes than on the router? Am I reading it correctly that you can use the bearings (seemed to be called rub collars for shapers) however you'd like...put it below the cutter or above the cutter or both... I've always wondered why router bits aren't like that instead of having to buy both versions. Also, what's your opinion on their optional spindles that let you run 1/2" router bits in the shaper? With the smaller shapers you will need to take two passes with a panel raiser, with a bigger shaper you would just hit it in one pass with a power feed. Rub collars are friction collars. Bearing are sealed ball bearing. Bearing are the modern version of the older friction type collars. A few router bits run well on a shaper. Dovetail bits do real well. Many folks claim they use many router bits. I think its a personal opinion thing. I'd say mostly carbide cutters probably not spiral end mill type cutters. Quote
weithman5 Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 I see that the grizzly shapers are about 600 delivered. I have not found sny others under 900. If these are as capable, flexible as a router table then they could be cost effective for an hobbyist Quote
Vyrolan Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 I see that the grizzly shapers are about 600 delivered. I have not found sny others under 900. If these are as capable, flexible as a router table then they could be cost effective for an hobbyist Yea I was thinking the same thing. If they are really that much better for edge profiling, panel raising, etc, then that seems like a viable way to go. Like PB suggested, you can still have a small router table if you like to use it for dadoes or sliding dovetails and whatnot. It's definitely worth thinking about. Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted November 3, 2014 Popular Post Report Posted November 3, 2014 Remember that a shaper doesn't have the RPMs to adequately spin smaller bits. So if you want to own both, great...that's certainly ideal. Otherwise you need to ask yourself what sized bits you'll be using the most. If you'll be using it mostly for joinery and small edge profiles, the router table makes more sense. If you'll be doing a bunch of raised panels or big profiles, then the shaper makes more sense. I know in my shop, I use smaller bits for joinery and small profiles the vast majority of the time, so a shaper would spend a good part of its life collecting dust. Of course it would be nice to have it when needed, but just like everything else...you have to ask yourself if the occasional convenience is worth the extra expense. But don't listen to me...my "lack of knowledge" precedes me. Since I don't own a shaper, I'm incapable of weighing the pros and cons for my own personal needs. 3 Quote
Vyrolan Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 Eric, if I remember the picture correctly, you have one of the highest end router table setups with the Incra positioner and fence. How do you like it? Do you get the value of being able to cut precise complex joinery...or has it mostly been a fancy way to do basic edge profiles? I ask honestly because I for one am totally the kind of person that would own the whole shebang because of all the stuff I could do with it in theory...and then never come close to tapping its potential. Quote
Eric. Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 I've used it for almost every function it's capable of performing, save for the goofy double-double dovetails and all the other gimmicky stuff it can do. But yes, I use it for joinery all the time, and it makes an appearance on nearly every project for one thing or another. 1 Quote
Vyrolan Posted November 3, 2014 Report Posted November 3, 2014 Well then I would say you most definitely made the right choice for your situation......which I think has been your point all along. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted November 4, 2014 Report Posted November 4, 2014 After assessing my personal router table use, and considering PB's well-written explanation of (small) shaper features, I would be inclined to dump my table in favor of a shaper. The concern about low rpm for small bits can be compensated for with a slower feed rate. Eric's comments about personal need are certainly valid, but I feel that a router in MY shop is best used by hand. Quote
Tpt life Posted November 4, 2014 Report Posted November 4, 2014 By that avatar I would guess one in each hand... Quote
wtnhighlander Posted November 4, 2014 Report Posted November 4, 2014 By that avatar I would guess one in each hand... What "Avatar"? That's my high school graduation photo! 1 Quote
weithman5 Posted November 4, 2014 Report Posted November 4, 2014 I think for my needs a router table would be first. then maybe a shaper if i really thought i would need one. I don't see myself making that many raised panels, if any other than for fun. after watching some of the shaper videos, primarily the grizzly pro mo video. i am not sure about the size of the shaper table, the machine weight, ease of changing bits etc. Quote
Tom Cancelleri Posted November 4, 2014 Report Posted November 4, 2014 I think a router table suits my needs versus a shaper. While I will be using it to do 1 kitchen worth of cabinets, for slot cutting tongue and groove, guitar building, and box/dovetail joints it's more than enough. 3.25 HP PC 7518 is powerful enough with the versatility to spin small bits fast and big bits slow. I could see using a shaper if I were cranking out moulding and things of that nature. I was recently at a tool auction that had 40 different shaper heads, cathedral panel templates and an old delta shaper. All the shaper cutters sold for 800 bucks, shaper for 200 which isn't bad for all the price, but again useless for my needs. It's really what you're gonna be doing. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.