Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

HEPA filter Vs Non HEPA filter shop vacs

Featured Replies

I am curious in todays age how much difference there is in a HEPA filter vs normal filters?

 

I ask because the price that a HEPA filter vac is asking for is almost double the price of non HEPA filter vacs ...

 

I am looking at the Festool and Fein shop vacs. I wouldnt mind getting a Fein Turbo I with no HEPA filter if there is not too much of a difference in todays filters. However, I do not really want to wear a mask when I am vacuuming the shop or doing other tasks that would not normally need a mask if I had a HEPA filter. If that is the case, then I will just grab one with the HEPA filter in it and call it good.

A true HEPA filter must be able to filter 99.97% of all contaminates that is at least .3 microns in diameter out of the air.  To show how small a micron actually is, the human hair is about 70 microns in diameter, so you can imagine how small of particles a HEPA filter can take out.  HEPA filters are composed of a mat-like material that have fibers randomly arranged.  These fibers, however, do not let bigger particles pass by to a certian point as some people think.  They are designed to "seek out" smaller particles and pollutants to have them stick to these fibers in three separate ways.

Interception, where particles following a line of flow in the air stream come within one radius of a fiber and adhere to it.Impaction, where larger particles are unable to avoid fibers by following the curving contours of the air stream and are forced to embed in one of them directly; this increases with diminishing fiber separation and higher air flow velocity.Diffusion, an enhancing mechanism is a result of the collision with gas molecules by the smallest particles, especially those below 0.1 micron in diameter, which are thereby impeded and delayed in their path through the filter.

  • Author

Seems like their normal filter for Fein is not the greatest when it comes to filtering microns. Even though 1 micron is pretty good but still .7 better filtering with the HEPA.

Even with the added Hepa filter my little (quite old) Fein doesn't do as well as my Festool. The newer ones could be better .

  • Author

Even with the added Hepa filter my little (quite old) Fein doesn't do as well as my Festool. The newer ones could be better .

How old is your Fein?

  • Author

10 plus years I am guessing.

I would surely hope they have improved it [emoji12]

Although by how much? I have no idea .. Anyone have a newer version of the Fein?

A true HEPA filter must be able to filter 99.97% of all contaminates that is at least .3 microns in diameter out of the air.  To show how small a micron actually is, the human hair is about 70 microns in diameter, so you can imagine how small of particles a HEPA filter can take out.  HEPA filters are composed of a mat-like material that have fibers randomly arranged.  These fibers, however, do not let bigger particles pass by to a certian point as some people think.  They are designed to "seek out" smaller particles and pollutants to have them stick to these fibers in three separate ways.

Interception, where particles following a line of flow in the air stream come within one radius of a fiber and adhere to it.Impaction, where larger particles are unable to avoid fibers by following the curving contours of the air stream and are forced to embed in one of them directly; this increases with diminishing fiber separation and higher air flow velocity.Diffusion, an enhancing mechanism is a result of the collision with gas molecules by the smallest particles, especially those below 0.1 micron in diameter, which are thereby impeded and delayed in their path through the filter.

 

If this doesn't deserve best answer, I don't know what would.  :P

  • Author

If this doesn't deserve best answer, I don't know what would. :P

Haha yes I had to read it several times to retain all the information in there [emoji15]

I'm probably in the minority here because Bill Pentz has scared the bejeezus out of everyone with his Mein Kampf thesis on dust collection...

 

...but my position is kind of...who cares?  Unless you're able to collect 99.97% at the source, which you're not, there's still particulate in the air.  Where filters are concerned, better is...uh...better...but I'm not gonna stress out over it because it's like sticking your finger in a leak in the Hoover Dam.  If you're truly concerned about breathing dust particles, wear a respirator in your shop 100% of the time.  Otherwise, set up a reasonable DC system and accept the fact that you're breathing some particulates and yes it may shorten your life.  I'm not losing sleep.  YMMV.

If you're truly concerned about breathing dust particles, wear a respirator in your shop 100% of the time.  Otherwise, set up a reasonable DC system and accept the fact that you're breathing some particulates and yes it may shorten your life.

 

This...  Bill P says exactly that as well...that unless you have an incredible DC system and customized hoods for and around every tool to collect at the source, you are releasing too much dust into the air and should wear a mask.   Even with decent DC and a hanging air filter, you are still breathing dust without a mask.  

 

 

I do not really want to wear a mask when I am vacuuming the shop or doing other tasks that would not normally need a mask if I had a HEPA filter.

 

If you want to do HEPA filters and whatnot, go for it, but don't think that means you're not breathing stuff or that you don't need a mask.  Also if you do any cuts or sanding or routing, the dust is there for quite a while so you can't just wear the mask while you're doing the operation.  Vacuuming up the dust or even walking around the shop stirs up lots of settled dust as well.

 

Basically, wear a mask or just accept it like Eric.

  • Author

I'm probably in the minority here because Bill Pentz has scared the bejeezus out of everyone with his Mein Kampf thesis on dust collection...

...but my position is kind of...who cares? Unless you're able to collect 99.97% at the source, which you're not, there's still particulate in the air. Where filters are concerned, better is...uh...better...but I'm not gonna stress out over it because it's like sticking your finger in a leak in the Hoover Dam. If you're truly concerned about breathing dust particles, wear a respirator in your shop 100% of the time. Otherwise, set up a reasonable DC system and accept the fact that you're breathing some particulates and yes it may shorten your life. I'm not losing sleep. YMMV.

This... Bill P says exactly that as well...that unless you have an incredible DC system and customized hoods for and around every tool to collect at the source, you are releasing too much dust into the air and should wear a mask. Even with decent DC and a hanging air filter, you are still breathing dust without a mask.

If you want to do HEPA filters and whatnot, go for it, but don't think that means you're not breathing stuff or that you don't need a mask. Also if you do any cuts or sanding or routing, the dust is there for quite a while so you can't just wear the mask while you're doing the operation. Vacuuming up the dust or even walking around the shop stirs up lots of settled dust as well.

Basically, wear a mask or just accept it like Eric.

Ya going off both of these. That makes a lot of sense! My dust collection won't be super amazing so I won't be collecting 100% of the dust.

This makes it easier on the purchase though since I won't need HEPA. I can save money and go with a cheaper vac with more volume than the festool. Then just wear a mask most the time while in the shop.

This makes it easier on the purchase though since I won't need HEPA. I can save money and go with a cheaper vac with more volume than the festool. Then just wear a mask most the time while in the shop.

 

Yea I put on my mask before the first cut/whatever and wear it basically the whole time until I'm done cleaning up and about to head inside.  I've got the one that Marc recommended in his most recent safety update (the half mask one with quick release) and I find it to be super comfortable and not a bother.  That said, I do use a drywall dust bag in my shop vac and the best filter they make (it's HEPA-like), but that's mostly to keep visible dust to a minimum (same thing for my hanging air filter).

I'm probably in the minority here because Bill Pentz has scared the bejeezus out of everyone with his Mein Kampf thesis on dust collection...

 

...but my position is kind of...who cares?  Unless you're able to collect 99.97% at the source, which you're not, there's still particulate in the air.  Where filters are concerned, better is...uh...better...but I'm not gonna stress out over it because it's like sticking your finger in a leak in the Hoover Dam.  If you're truly concerned about breathing dust particles, wear a respirator in your shop 100% of the time.  Otherwise, set up a reasonable DC system and accept the fact that you're breathing some particulates and yes it may shorten your life.  I'm not losing sleep.  YMMV.

 

I typically light up a cigarette after I suck in a good amount of dust particulate. The tar grabs a hold of the dust spores and allows me to cough up and eject them a half hour later.

With hepa it gives you the chance to work in an area that would otherwise not be good to create a bunch of dust. This is where the Festool excels at a jobsite where you want to keep someones home or business clean. In a shop it really is not necessary there are to many other ways to deal with the issue of exhausting of fine dust particles. Any regular plain old cheap shop vac can be made to be just as clean. All shop vacs have an exhaust, this is where the excess fine particles find there way into your shop. A simple hose ducted outside eliminates that fine dust in the shop.  Simply connecting a hose to the exhaust and sticking it in a dust collector port or hose will do the same thing you don't even need to turn the dust collector on. Unless you need a good jobsite vac save your money.

 

 

Added: I forgot to mention you can use a router speed control on most any shop vac.

Why not check out the Ridgid vacuums?  The more powerful models have great volume & have HEPA filters available for them.  And they're pretty cheap & not too noisy.

  • Author

Why not check out the Ridgid vacuums? The more powerful models have great volume & have HEPA filters available for them. And they're pretty cheap & not too noisy.

Hmm I did not notice rigid had HEPA ... Going to search now for it.

$399 for rigids HEPA shop vac? 14 gal yes but seems like a lot for rigid..no? I guess it comes with the vacuuming attachments that make it a little more expensive.

I was thinking a Fein turbo I that's almost 6 gal for 299 but no HEPA

I have the Ridgid stainless steel canister vac $150 ish? and I use their best filter 3 micron I think.  I also run bags in the vac and RARELY have to clean the filter.  and usually I use my little shop vac for that with some compressed air.  I have had the same filter on the vac for 5 years now and it's as clean as a whistle.  Spend a few bucks for bags, $3 ea. but it's worth it for me to not have to clean and replace the filter every week and lose suction all the time.  I usually go through maybe 5 bags a year?  I also use a DC system for the tools but my vac is almost my favorite tool.  

Correction; the Ridgid vac I have (about $160) is not available with a HEPA filter, but a 1 micron filter.  Don't know if you can get a HEPA for it.

Added: I forgot to mention you can use a router speed control on most any shop vac.

 

Mind = Blown...  How did I never think of this?

 

 

Why not check out the Ridgid vacuums?  The more powerful models have great volume & have HEPA filters available for them.  And they're pretty cheap & not too noisy.

 

That's what I have...their 14-gallon one (http://www.homedepot.com/p/RIDGID-14-gal-Professional-Wet-Dry-Vacuum-WD1450/100081216). It's noise reduction thing is really good and helps keep it quieter, and I use a drywall dust bag and their level 5 HEPA filter (http://www.homedepot.com/p/RIDGID-5-Layer-Allergen-Filter-VF6000/100022800).

Hepa is mostly marketing hype. Unless your cleaning up biological messes or are filtering to prevent disease spread or maybe happen to be running a clean room its pretty much all marketing in a wood shop. Its not going to do much good to have a single vac with hepa and not have the rest of your shop equipped with absurd evacuation systems. I would call it more of a nice gesture if your working in someones home or business but definitely not needed.

  • Author

Mind = Blown... How did I never think of this?

That's what I have...their 14-gallon one (http://www.homedepot.com/p/RIDGID-14-gal-Professional-Wet-Dry-Vacuum-WD1450/100081216). It's noise reduction thing is really good and helps keep it quieter, and I use a drywall dust bag and their level 5 HEPA filter (http://www.homedepot.com/p/RIDGID-5-Layer-Allergen-Filter-VF6000/100022800).

I must of missed it but does this have a bag option as well for using it with the filter?

I must of missed it but does this have a bag option as well for using it with the filter?

Yes. I use a drywall dust bag in combination with the level 5 HEPA filter trying to minimize as much as possible how much makes it through into the exhaust.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.