Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

HIPAA VS PUBLIC HEALTH

Featured Replies

I was told to seek out a new hire (never met him) to have him do some drafting work for me on Friday.  Couldn't find him, so I asked the secretary (administrative assistant, whatever) where he was.  She told me he was out sick, and it might be meningitis, I think he offered up this information to her.  Weekend goes by, I seek him out again, but first asked the secretary if he was in before looking for him.  She replies "Yes, he's in.  And he told me that his spinal tap did come back positive for viral meningitis"
 

At this point, I'm like "What the hell, why is he here."  Rumors circulate that people have seen him throwing up in the bathroom, and he looks like hell.  I ask the office manager if he's cleared to work, and it takes a day, but he gets a letter from the guy's doctor stating he can work (even though he's puking his guts out in the bathroom).  I decide to tell a few coworkers/friends to watch out for symptoms because this guy has viral meningitis.

Is there a violation of HIPAA here?  On whose part, everyones?  It seems to be what's considered a "newsworthy" situation under HIPAA and therefore OK to warn people.  

Thanks

Contacting your dept of insurance or Hippa directly to inquire is really the only way to go.

I've had a little (very little) training on handling HIPAA data.  As I understand it, HIPAA limits what health care providers can do with your health information.  If you want to take out a TV ad to broadcast your diagnosis, that's on you.  And if you tell someone who is not a healthcare provider, and that person blabs, that's between the two of you.  So, if the guy told a co-worker, and the co-worker tells the world, it's not a HIPAA issue.  Assuming that the co-worker was not also his health care provider.

But, I am not a lawyer or HIPAA expert.  I know enough about HIPAA so that when someone says, "HIPAA data", I say "Not on my machine."

[ Edit: it might be a violation of employment record confidentiality, if he was required to report his condition to his employer and that's how the co-worker knew of it. ]

Edited by Beechwood Chip

61466381.jpg

Edited by Sac

  • Popular Post

These kinds of posts always crack me up.  I understand the off topic posts about stuff that is tangentially related to woodworking (e.g., DIY, metal work, mechanical stuff), but there HAS to be someone in your life better suited to answering a legal question about HIPAA than strangers on a woodworking forum.

Not picking on you, all in good fun :)

Once he freely said what his condition was, you're most likely in the clear. There is a slight bit of issue if you would be considered a covered entity, but it doesn't sound like you are unless your company is providing the coverage.

You're right, when it comes to authorizations and consents, the patient's privacy rights take a bit of a backseat to public reporting and health. I wouldn't worry about it too much if you aren't a covered entity. If you are providing health care insurance of any sort, stop talking about a potential illness in terms of who has something - start talking about symptoms and leave individuals out of it.

These kinds of posts always crack me up.  I understand the off topic posts about stuff that is tangentially related to woodworking (e.g., DIY, metal work, mechanical stuff), but there HAS to be someone in your life better suited to answering a legal question about HIPAA than strangers on a woodworking forum.

Not picking on you, all in good fun :)

I am not here because I am a woodworker by trade. I am here because I am a woodworker by night. I am fairly certain some member of this forum can nail this legality down absolutely. That is what makes the forum fun. If some guys want to guess? That can be fun sometimes too.  Now, back to lunch. 

I am not here because I am a woodworker by trade. I am here because I am a woodworker by night. I am fairly certain some member of this forum can nail this legality down absolutely. That is what makes the forum fun. If some guys want to guess? That can be fun sometimes too.  Now, back to lunch. 

Yup, this stuff is what I do for a living. This is not paid legal advice, however.

  • Author

I am not here because I am a woodworker by trade. I am here because I am a woodworker by night. I am fairly certain some member of this forum can nail this legality down absolutely. That is what makes the forum fun. If some guys want to guess? That can be fun sometimes too.  Now, back to lunch. 

Thank you C Shaffer, I couldn't have expressed that any better.  These are my thoughts exactly and why I feel the Off-topic forum exists.  Yes, we talk about woodworking mostly, but is that all we can talk about?

Once he freely said what his condition was, you're most likely in the clear. There is a slight bit of issue if you would be considered a covered entity, but it doesn't sound like you are unless your company is providing the coverage.

You're right, when it comes to authorizations and consents, the patient's privacy rights take a bit of a backseat to public reporting and health. I wouldn't worry about it too much if you aren't a covered entity. If you are providing health care insurance of any sort, stop talking about a potential illness in terms of who has something - start talking about symptoms and leave individuals out of it.

Thanks Cochese, this is what I was hoping to hear and from someone who does this for a living.  I understand it's not paid legal advice.  I have prepaid legal, so if I need to I'll reach out to them.

 

These kinds of posts always crack me up.  I understand the off topic posts about stuff that is tangentially related to woodworking (e.g., DIY, metal work, mechanical stuff), but there HAS to be someone in your life better suited to answering a legal question about HIPAA than strangers on a woodworking forum.

Not picking on you, all in good fun :)

Bgreenb, I'm use to other forums' off-topic communities that talk about anything from sports to what beer you currently have in your fridge, to talk about STDs.  I've always viewed forums like a bunch of guys meeting up after group meet of some sort at a bar, maybe like a mustang owners group?  Yeah you mostly talk about mustangs, but occasionally a guy might ask/talk about something not related to mustangs.  And I bet the guy who shouts out "we're only here to talk about mustangs!" seems like a silly man who doesn't let people speak.  But just my opinion, not picking on you, all in good fun :) 

 

 

Brian wasn't giving you a hard time for bringing up something off-topic...after all, that's why we have the off-topic forum.  He was giving you a hard time about seeking legal advice from a bunch of termites.  LOL  All in good fun, of course.

On an unrelated health question....   Do men get PMS?   Because there seems to be a lot of it on the forum lately.  

Baskets, crying in my room, delete me its like Steel Magnolias over here.  

 

 

Good question...maybe check with comp over in the project journals section - I think he's doing firsthand research.

I'd love a current NCO to comment. My dad claimed his Vietnam era NCO training included discussions about hormonal cycles in men that occur in a similar type of fashion while not necessarily resembling closely. I think there may be merit in the question. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.