Recommended Posts

Posted

I need the horsepower and aggressiveness of the Rotex 150/5 for my needs.  I had hoped that the Mirka had a similar offering, but it appears that they simply do not.  I cannot justify both at this point, so will likely end of going Festool for both the coarse and finish sanders.  I need excellent dust collection due to the overall size of my projects and have proven that my current efforts to abate the dust simply aren't working so far.  I have looked a bit into what Bosch and Makita have to offer in a large 6" sander, but am not yet convinced they will hold up over time.  Yes, they are less money up front, but I have grown to become a "buy once, cry once" kind of a person.  I am looking for an overall system and I know the Festool will do what I need.  What makes me want to look at the Mirka is that they have outstanding reviews when it comes to their finish sanders and seem to exceed customer satisfaction over Festool in that regard (not that Festool isn't good), but for what seems to be even money, would consider the Mirka if they had what I needed.

Posted

I am now having some second thoughts on the Rotex 150.  I have been reading a lot and see SO many glowing reviews of the ETS 150 sanders.  Now I realize these are finish sanders, but see that they can still be pretty aggressive if necessary.  Now I am kinda thinking maybe I go with a Bosch 1250 for the coarsest sanding and then get the ETS EC 150 (probably the 3 over the 5) for final work (along with a CT36 or 48 of course).  How much effort is it to use the Bosch with the Festool dust collectors?

But then if I go that route, the Mirka Deros 650 package comes back into consideration...

Posted
1 hour ago, ChiknNutz said:

I am now having some second thoughts on the Rotex 150.  I have been reading a lot and see SO many glowing reviews of the ETS 150 sanders.  Now I realize these are finish sanders, but see that they can still be pretty aggressive if necessary.  Now I am kinda thinking maybe I go with a Bosch 1250 for the coarsest sanding and then get the ETS EC 150 (probably the 3 over the 5) for final work (along with a CT36 or 48 of course).  How much effort is it to use the Bosch with the Festool dust collectors?

But then if I go that route, the Mirka Deros 650 package comes back into consideration...

 

Just a note re the Bosch and Makita dual mode sanders, when FWW tested them several years back the Makita removed significantly more wood in both modes and scored better in handling as well.   As I think I mentioned I have both the ETS EC 150/3 and Deros 650, I prefer the Deros but it is mainly the weight, size of the grip and the paddle switch the results are essentially the same but if I had just one ROS it would be a 5mm orbit, you have to drop down to near 2mm of orbit before I see much difference in finish.  In retrospect I would have gotten the 2.5mm Deros instead of the 150/3 but my dealer was OOS on the Deros when I wanted it so I decided to save $100 and go with the 150/3 and while it is a great sander it just isn't quite what I wanted... but I kept it.  

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, ChiknNutz said:

One concern I have about going this route is the Makita or Bosch will likely have sub-par dust extraction and that is an important aspect.

 

FWW collected dust collection data on all three as well.  Numbers are percentages with the coarse mode first then the fine, the second set of numbers is the grams of wood removed during the test again coarse then fine then the subjective handling in wide stock coarse/fine and narrow stock coarse/fine  

Bosch 92 84   32 06  poor/good  poor/fair

Makita 74 87   54 11  poor/fair  poor/fair

Festool 89 98  89 98  fair/very good  poor/good 

Note the handling scores are mostly low but they were tested along with single mode ROS like the ETS 150 et al so the dual mode sanders didn't handle very well in comparison.

All three had pretty similar sound pressure levels all in the mid 90s dB.

They did not award a Best Tool separately to the dual mode category but the Makita did garner a Best Value "prize".

They also tested a Metabo and Ridgid dual mode sander but both had very poor wood removal in both modes which doesn't fit your needs.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have both Mirka Deros and Ceros and had the older style Festool ETS 150.  All 3 gave good results but the ergonomics on the Mirka were much better.  The ETS with it's taller profiler just didn't feel as comfortable for me and I eventually sold it.  I've tried the newer EC models and they feel much better from quickly trying them out during demos but can't really comment much as I don't own one or have any extended use on them.   I also like the paddle switch but not everyone does.  Some people absolutely hate it.  So if you're thinking about getting one, I would seriously try it out first.   I use the Deros pretty much exclusively now since it doesn't have the power supply.  Also you can use both a 5" or 6" pad on the Deros.  But to be honest I never had a reason to buy a 5" pad.  If you get any of the MIirka sanders and wish to use a festool vac and don't want to permanently leave it on the sander you have to get an adapter.  Otherwise you have to thread the hose onto the sander.  Also if you use Abranet/Autonet make sure to get the pad savers/protectors.  It's much cheaper than getting a whole new pad.

Posted
On 3/9/2017 at 2:50 PM, ChiknNutz said:

I am now having some second thoughts on the Rotex 150.  I have been reading a lot and see SO many glowing reviews of the ETS 150 sanders.  Now I realize these are finish sanders, but see that they can still be pretty aggressive if necessary.  Now I am kinda thinking maybe I go with a Bosch 1250 for the coarsest sanding and then get the ETS EC 150 (probably the 3 over the 5) for final work (along with a CT36 or 48 of course).  How much effort is it to use the Bosch with the Festool dust collectors?

But then if I go that route, the Mirka Deros 650 package comes back into consideration...

I had the Bosch 1250 for a very short time.  It simply had no place in my shop.  It was a powerful machine and hogged material off very quickly, but left a lousy surface even with finer grits and was hella hard to control.  I used the Bosch for one project and didn't want it but didn't feel I had grounds to return it, so I sold it on Ebay and picked up the Bosch ROS65.  It is MUCH easier to control, has excellent dust collection, and leaves a surface worthy of fine furniture.

That said, I have never used a Festool or Mirka sander.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted
On 3/9/2017 at 2:46 PM, HuxleyWood said:

Just a note re the Bosch and Makita dual mode sanders, when FWW tested them several years back the Makita removed significantly more wood in both modes and scored better in handling as well.   As I think I mentioned I have both the ETS EC 150/3 and Deros 650, I prefer the Deros but it is mainly the weight, size of the grip and the paddle switch the results are essentially the same but if I had just one ROS it would be a 5mm orbit, you have to drop down to near 2mm of orbit before I see much difference in finish.  In retrospect I would have gotten the 2.5mm Deros instead of the 150/3 but my dealer was OOS on the Deros when I wanted it so I decided to save $100 and go with the 150/3 and while it is a great sander it just isn't quite what I wanted... but I kept it.  

Question for you.  My plan is to get the RO150 for sure.  For a finish sander, I am leaning towards either the ETS EC 150/5 or /3.  I am curious why you recommend the /5 over the /3 for finish sanding?  Is that primarily due to it simply getting the job done faster with no appreciable finish difference?  Further, since the RO150 also is a ROS at 5mm, why is it not as good as the ETS in a 5mm orbit?  I imagine the /5 is faster, but if I use the RO150/5 for coarse and intermediate sanding, would I be better off with the smaller orbit of the /3 for finish sanding in the event I wanted a really pristine finish?  I don't do a whole lot of staining, but do on occasion so I know you will tend to see more swirl marks on a given piece when stained.  The bulk of my work will be tables and the like.  Hopefully that all makes sense what I am asking.

Posted
13 hours ago, ChiknNutz said:

Question for you.  My plan is to get the RO150 for sure.  For a finish sander, I am leaning towards either the ETS EC 150/5 or /3.  I am curious why you recommend the /5 over the /3 for finish sanding?  Is that primarily due to it simply getting the job done faster with no appreciable finish difference?  Further, since the RO150 also is a ROS at 5mm, why is it not as good as the ETS in a 5mm orbit?  I imagine the /5 is faster, but if I use the RO150/5 for coarse and intermediate sanding, would I be better off with the smaller orbit of the /3 for finish sanding in the event I wanted a really pristine finish?  I don't do a whole lot of staining, but do on occasion so I know you will tend to see more swirl marks on a given piece when stained.  The bulk of my work will be tables and the like.  Hopefully that all makes sense what I am asking.

 

I almost always use a 5mm orbit sander on bare wood for the exact reasons you guessed, it is faster with basically zero difference in finish quality.   The exceptions being veneered ply, commercial raw wood veneer, burnishing end grain (to reduce dye/stain uptake so it matches the long grain) and while building and finishing film finishes, then I use a 3mm or 2.5mm orbit sander.  

I find swirl marks on stained wood are usually a result of build up on the sanding disc.  Stain or dye needs to be completely dry or it is a mess to sand and you will go through discs like crazy.  

In the end I suggest a 5mm orbit if you just have one ROS especially if you do pieces with large flat areas like table tops.  

The RO125/150 are simply a handful (or 2) to control even in finish mode it just doesn't have the balance of the ETS EC sanders.  I just have never been a fan of any of the dual mode sanders for fine WWing.  

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.