AcworthWW Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 I am a long time lurker looking for some advice on a new ROS. I want to get a new sander as I currently have a 5" Ryobi. The wife has blessed the idea so I am looking at the Festool ETS EC 150/3 or the Mirka Deros 6" 2.5 mm. I have read several reviews, but they did not offer any perspective after an extended period of use. Those of you that have used either or both, which is the better way to go? I plan to get a CT vac at the same time and add other Festool items as I go. How easy is it to attach the Mirka to a Festool vac? I do mostly furniture and the occasional box. I appreciate the feedback. Quote
shaneymack Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 I am a long time lurker looking for some advice on a new ROS. I want to get a new sander as I currently have a 5" Ryobi. The wife has blessed the idea so I am looking at the Festool ETS EC 150/3 or the Mirka Deros 6" 2.5 mm. I have read several reviews, but they did not offer any perspective after an extended period of use. Those of you that have used either or both, which is the better way to go? I plan to get a CT vac at the same time and add other Festool items as I go. How easy is it to attach the Mirka to a Festool vac? I do mostly furniture and the occasional box. I appreciate the feedback. Im not sure about the deros but i have an ets ec 150/5 and I love it. I was trying to decide between getting a deros and the festool and i went with the festool and dont regret it. I already had a bunch of festool stuff so that swayed my decision a bit. As well, festool service is amazing and I read about mirkas being questionable. Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk Quote
Eric. Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 The reason you can't find any "extended use" reviews is because they're both fairly new tools. The ETS EC is literally brand new and I think the Deros is only a year or two old. Not 100% on that but I'm pretty sure.I've never used either but I'm certain you wouldn't lose either way, they're both great units. From what I gather the Mirka is probably slightly better, but if you're planning to drink the green kool-aid I'd just stick with the ETS so all your stuff plays nice together without monkeying with hose fittings and what-not. Quote
Trip Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 My advice: visit your local Woodcraft, Rockler, etc and try each one for yourself... They are all good, but one may feel better in your hands -- that's what's really important... Quote
..Kev Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 When upgrading from a Ryobi, you can't go wrong either way. I've never used the Mirka so, won't even attempt to compare. To echo the words above, Festool customer service is awesome! Quote
d8nk Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 I know i will prob stir the green hornet nest but I have to throw this out there. I personally don't see why anyone spends so much on a sander. Perhaps I am missing something but I have used Porter Cable and Makita for 20+ years and have no complaints. What am I missing about these high end sanders? Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted December 10, 2015 Popular Post Report Posted December 10, 2015 Go use one for an hour and let us know if you change your mind. 3 Quote
Llama Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 I know i will prob stir the green hornet nest but I have to throw this out there. I personally don't see why anyone spends so much on a sander. Perhaps I am missing something but I have used Porter Cable and Makita for 20+ years and have no complaints. What am I missing about these high end sanders? Sent from my Nexus 5 using TapatalkIf you are happy with your sanders, then you are missing nothing. I was not happy with what I was using, so I upgraded to the Festool sanders for the superior dust collection and comfort of the sanders. I bought the CT, Rotex and a finish sander at pretty much the same time. I do not regret the purchase at all. I won't try to say sanding is fun, but it certainly better with the upgrades.Back to the OP... I am interested in understanding your thought process on deciding on the ETS sander from Festool as one of the candidates. Quote
Trip Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 (edited) ==>why anyone spends so much on a sanderIt may seem a bit silly to spend that much on a sander... And depending on your workflow, it just may be... Once you invest in a large-format panel sander, your performance requirements for a portable sander drop rather quickly... A great deal of the price goes into making the sander 'smooth' to use... Some sanders will cause you wrist to go numb after 30mins of use... Some you can use all day without fatigue... Once you get a stationary panel sander, you rarely use a portable sander for more than a few minutes at a time...But...I own (or have owned) several of each: Mirka, FT, PC, DeWalt, Makita, Dynabrade and one or two others -- so have some perspective... Additionally, I've owned just about every sander in FT's and Mirka's line and about a half-dozen Dynabrades...The best I've owned are the Dynabrade and Mirka pneumatic sanders... No question, no argument. But you need a good compressor and be prepared for some noise... These pneumatics are the gold standard reference against which all others are measured...The closest to the pneumatic sanders is the Mirka CEROS. Same. But the transformer can be a pain in the ass..Then you get to the FTs which are smooth and have the best DC. Same with DEROS, but not as good DC. I'd put the new FT and DEROS on the same level just ahead of the rest of FT's line.Then there's 3M... I don't own any 3M, but they are on my list when one of my Mirka's bites the dust... They have a good reputation, but can't really comment at this point...At this point there's a performance inflection point -- not huge, but it's there...The PC low-profile series. Which are good, have OK DC, but not as smooth as above... I've owned three, and gave two away when I got the Mirkas. I still keep one for DIY...It's at this point that there is a dramatic performance inflection point ...The rest of the BORG offerings... Edited December 10, 2015 by hhh 2 Quote
Cliff Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 I know i will prob stir the green hornet nest but I have to throw this out there. I personally don't see why anyone spends so much on a sander. Perhaps I am missing something but I have used Porter Cable and Makita for 20+ years and have no complaints. What am I missing about these high end sanders? Sent from my Nexus 5 using TapatalkMy dominant arm, the right, was severely damaged by sanding. Now you could easily argue improper technique or overuse. No question about it. But the fact remains, had I been using something that was more upscale, I would have been far better off. I still have tendonitis in one part of my forearm and nerve pain that runs down into my hand. I can no longer run my Dewalt sander for more than about 10 minutes. A Festool for me (one of the next few items on my to buy list) is no longer a luxury if I am going to continue this hobby. Quote
d8nk Posted December 10, 2015 Report Posted December 10, 2015 OK now I am intrigued, I am going to have to try some nice sanders out. It sounds like I don't know what I am missing! To OP, sorry for side tangent. It seems like you can't go wrong with the great advice here :) Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk Quote
AcworthWW Posted December 10, 2015 Author Report Posted December 10, 2015 My advice: visit your local Woodcraft, Rockler, etc and try each one for yourself... They are all good, but one may feel better in your hands -- that's what's really important...I live about 30 minutes from Highland Woodworking so I have been able to check out each of them in person. I guess it really comes down to the paddle switch on the Mirka vs. the push button on the Festool for me. they both feel good in my hands. Going to down there again today to check them out.If you are happy with your sanders, then you are missing nothing. I was not happy with what I was using, so I upgraded to the Festool sanders for the superior dust collection and comfort of the sanders. I bought the CT, Rotex and a finish sander at pretty much the same time. I do not regret the purchase at all. I won't try to say sanding is fun, but it certainly better with the upgrades.Back to the OP... I am interested in understanding your thought process on deciding on the ETS sander from Festool as one of the candidates. I decided on the ETS EC as an option after looking at what is available to me. I do not have a compressor large enough to run a pneumatic sander. I have tried some of the other offerings from PC, Bosch etc. and did not like them that much. I have been able to check out both the Mirka and the Festool at Highland. I like them both. I am also considering the Festool for the integration within the tool line. I am considering a domino and the TS55 in the near future. To me it makes sense to have a CT vac that I could leave a cord plugged into and not have to worry about it. Quote
ChiknNutz Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 I realize this is an older thread, but it seems pertinent to my question. I have been trying to find out which sander is better for rough sanding of large slabs. I have used (but don't own) the Festool RO150 and really like it for this application. I have seen many mentions of the Mirka 650 Deros, but I am not sure if it is in the same league as the Festool. I fully get that what I am asking about is NOT a finish sander. The sander will be used after initial drum sanding or perhaps even to remove some bandsaw marks on hard wood such as walnut and maple, NOT for final finish sanding (although Festool leads you to believe that you can with the RO150, but you really can't IMHO). So, would appreciate any words about the Mirka sanders for this purpose as compared to the Festool RO 150 if that is possible. Although I have a proper cyclone dust collector, I am also looking into the matching Dust Collectors for each or possibly a Fein. Many thanks! Quote
Pwk5017 Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 I use a RO150 for my post drum sander prep for counters, bars, table tops etc. Maybe not applicable to what you are doing, because i have my drum sander setup with 80 on the front and 120 on the back. 80-100 grit on the RO150 takes care of the linear lines off the DS in a few short minutes. Maybe 1-2 passes before i am ready to go to my ETS 150/5 with 120-220. It is fast work post drum sander. I havent used it, but the german belt sanders with a sanding frame seems like the ultimate panel sander. It will be tough to find one in the north american market, but it might be possible. I think bosch used to sell a sanding frame for their big belt sander. Let me know if you find something that is faster than the RO150, because i would be interested in trying it myself. Quote
ChiknNutz Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 I can't believe I've never heard of a sanding frame before. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 5 minutes ago, ChiknNutz said: I can't believe I've never heard of a sanding frame before. Yeah and the festool frame is supposed to be awesome. I keep forgetting the name of the damn german manufacturer that festool bought the rights to their sander after they went under. I think it starts with an H. In any case, something to find out to see if you can get their model on the used market. I believe the festool frame will fit it perfectly. They havent redesigned those two sanders, ever. Heres the problem with my belt sander solution to your problem. As you already know, the drum sander can leave behind pretty deep linear scratches. A handheld belt sander wont be nearly as bad, but still it leaves a uniform linear scratch pattern. To me, this is where the RO150 comes into play. Ultimately, this is why everyone ditches drum sanders, because widebelts allow you to change grits easily and sand at 150-180 grit without burning. In my experience, it is very difficult to sand a large surface(greater than 3') without loading the paper and burning at 180-220. You simply dont have the surface area on the drum paper to handle bigger surfaces. I think i would enjoy receiving projects off the machine at 150-180 grit instead of 120 grit with some remnant 80 grit scratches. I will let you know what the revelation is like when i step up to a widebelt one day. Quote
ChiknNutz Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 Ya I have a drum sander and use it a lot but it is undersized for some projects. I do not have the space or bank account for a big boy belt sander, but can have my larger stuff done by a somewhat local chap with one. Still, even with them using 150 grit, the linear lines still need to be removed as you can attest. That is a known fact. While I do appreciate this conversation and learning about sanding frames/shoes that seem to have gone the way of the dodo bird, I am mostly curious (at the moment anyway) about anyone's experience with the Mirka Deros 650 and if it is a competitor to the Festool RO 150. I have suspicions that it may not be, but may in fact fit my particular need. I would like to demo one, but cannot locate where they are sold locally (near Seattle, north of there if at all possible). Quote
Pwk5017 Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 I dont own a deros, but i considered a few ceros and deros in the past. Both, on the used market and buying new. I never compared the mirka offerings to the RO line, because i believe the Mirka offerings to be finish sanders. I could be off base here, but i have never heard 'rough stock removal' and 'deros/ceros' used in the same sentence. Lastly, compare the wattage for each tool. 350 for mirka, 720 for rotex. Grit is going to determine a lot, but you also want the power to drive that grit effectively. Quote
ChiknNutz Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 12 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said: I dont own a deros, but i considered a few ceros and deros in the past. Both, on the used market and buying new. I never compared the mirka offerings to the RO line, because i believe the Mirka offerings to be finish sanders. I could be off base here, but i have never heard 'rough stock removal' and 'deros/ceros' used in the same sentence. Lastly, compare the wattage for each tool. 350 for mirka, 720 for rotex. Grit is going to determine a lot, but you also want the power to drive that grit effectively. Got it. I did notice the power ratings for each and thought that would like be a factor, though Mirka claims their 350 watters work like a 500 watter (if that's a word ;-) But that still doesn't match the wattage of the Rotex. And, having put many hours behind the Rotex, I am very familiar with how beastly these guys are...and to me, that is what is needed for my application. I am not trying to shy away from the Rotex, but have heard so many complementary things about the Mirkas that I hoped they would have a comparable offering. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 1 hour ago, ChiknNutz said: I realize this is an older thread, but it seems pertinent to my question. I have been trying to find out which sander is better for rough sanding of large slabs. I have used (but don't own) the Festool RO150 and really like it for this application. I have seen many mentions of the Mirka 650 Deros, but I am not sure if it is in the same league as the Festool. I fully get that what I am asking about is NOT a finish sander. The sander will be used after initial drum sanding or perhaps even to remove some bandsaw marks on hard wood such as walnut and maple, NOT for final finish sanding (although Festool leads you to believe that you can with the RO150, but you really can't IMHO). So, would appreciate any words about the Mirka sanders for this purpose as compared to the Festool RO 150 if that is possible. Although I have a proper cyclone dust collector, I am also looking into the matching Dust Collectors for each or possibly a Fein. Many thanks! I owned a RO 150 (still have the 90) and a ETS EC 150/3 and a Mirka Deros 650 (had the Ceros in the past). The Deros is available in 8mm stroke but even then it isn't a match for the RO for your usage they are simply two different kinds of sanders. I have a 50" drum sander and that is the only reason I don't have the RO any more. The Deros is a direct competitor to the ETS EC and both are medium to finish ROS and neither have the heavy stock removal capability of the RO. That said both Makita and Bosch also make excellent two mode sanders similar to the RO for significantly less money and are viable options to the RO. BTW you really don't need multiple dust extractors if you work alone. Just connect the cord to the hose and switch out sanders, it is really quick. While I don't use a Festool dust extractor, I use a Oneida Dust Cobra plumbed as a full shop system with auto tool activation, I have hoses for both the Festool and Mirka world setup and just switch between them. Quote
ChiknNutz Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 Awesome, thank you for the info! I may have misspoke about the dust collection. I didn't mean I was going to get multiple DCs, was just looking to marry up a dust collector with the sander. Since I do already have a cyclone (not plumbed all over), is that sufficient in lieu of a Festool or Fein collector? Obviously, would need to have smaller more manageable hose than my 4" stuff I use for stationary tools. From what I have gathered so far, this is really not optimal as they produce very different suction characteristics. My shop is currently bathed in dust due to not having dust collection at the source for sanding so it is important for me. This is in spite of also having an overhead air cleaner in use. Sanding dust simply is very hard to control when not dealt with at the source. Preaching to the choir here I know as I am sure we've all experienced the same. Thanks for the tip about the Makita and Bosch offerings, will look into them. Just didn't know they did have something in the league as the Rotex. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted March 7, 2017 Report Posted March 7, 2017 Power hand sanding is a high static/low volume vacuum situation and a full sized cyclone is not a viable options. As I mentioned Oneida makes the Dust Cobra which is more like a super vacuum and I much prefer it to portable dust extractors but that is a different conversation. While there are a decent number of good vacuum options out there the Festool is the most flexible within their eco-system. The current Fein vacuums aren't as feature rich as the old Feins but are also an excellent choice if you want to save some money. Quote
Coop Posted March 8, 2017 Report Posted March 8, 2017 Dang, I thought trip was back but then saw date of the original thread Quote
sheperd80 Posted March 8, 2017 Report Posted March 8, 2017 I dont know much about the Mirka but if youre going festool, go festool. So everything can easily share the cord and hose with no extra stuff hangin around, its the coolest. I cant comment on long term use, but after a discussion over at festool admirers group, theres a few things worth noting. The ets ec 150/3 is identical to the ets ec 125/3 (which is $100 less) except a few totally insignificant internals. Same motor same body etc. The 125 can accept the 5" and 6" pads from festool, making it a combo sander like the deros. But doing so will void your warranty because they want people to buy the 150/3. Not sure how theyd know, but thats on your honor. So basically the 150/3 is a pointless existence and costs $100 over its 5" twin brother for no reason at all. That being said i recently grabbed a 150/5 and so far its excellent. As many have said, it seems to produce as fine a finish as the /3 sanders yet can be more aggressive if you want. I think the different strokes are less significant than they seem. Go for more power, and system integration imho. Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk Quote
andrew-in-austin Posted March 9, 2017 Report Posted March 9, 2017 I like and own lot of Festool, but just recently sold my ETS125 and RO90 sanders. They are really nice, but I discovered for the price of the ETS125, I could have a Makita 6" random orbit sander. I bought that and the 1/2 sheet Makita (because it was also rated extremely well and 1/2 the price of the Festool RS2). Without hesitation I would put them on equal footing with Festool. These two are made in Japan and are extremely well built. I have been using the 6" sander recently, and I can work with that thing for hours with no problems. When I used the ETS125, it required a bit more control, and I would get a bit of numbness from time to time (I would expect the ETS 150 to similar to the Makita, however, due to it's increased weight over the 125). I can't speak for their other sanders, most of which are probably made in China. I got rid of the RO90 because it is simply too weak for aggressive stock removal. For that I go to my porter cable belt sander. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.