Da Hammer Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 Hello all I have stated before I am just getting started into "real" woodworking. Been tinkering for a few years and ready to go to the next level. I will have the DC finished and interior walls completed today. I am ready to purchase a planer and jointer. I have never used either. I am planning on getting the Dewalt 735 on sale from woodcraft seems like a solid purchase. I am running into decision problems on the jointer. I have plenty floor space for a jointer and am not 100% familiar with brand name in woodworking tool world. Seems like Grizzly and Jet tend to be a bit less expensive than other brands so have been looking at the 6" Grizzly cabinet jointer vs the Jet 6" jointer. The Grizzly is a few hundred cheaper than the Jet and they are cheaper than everything else. Being I have no experience with these machines will I make a mistake buying the cheaper Grizzly? I know you all have been through this before and any advice would be appreciated. Thanks! PS for now I am just going to get straight cutters in lieu of helical until I get better at all of this. Quote
Woodenskye Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 Without knowing your budget, I would offer this piece of advise, spend more for a invaluable tool, and go with 8". If you stick with this, your money will be better spent buying a life long tool, so look for used or just buy new powermatic. 1 Quote
minorhero Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 The major difference between jet and grizzly is that jet has better fit and finish compared to grizzly. This is just generally speaking of course. They both cut wood. A lot of folks build their first few projects using hand power tools before moving to floor models to see if they like the hobby or not. If this is possible for you I would recommend it. A planer and jointer are invaluable for milling your own lumber, but depending on your background and what you plan to build, you may be able to get a hardwood seller to mill your lumber and save you some time and expense unless you know for sure you plan to get into woodworking for the long haul. If the latter then we really need more information to give you better advice such as what you currently own, what you plan to build, and what is your budget ? And not your dream budget but what is your absolute max you are prepared to spend since one answer to this question will always be "spend more!" Quote
collinb Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 33 minutes ago, Woodenskye said: Without knowing your budget, I would offer this piece of advise, spend more for a invaluable tool, and go with 8". If you stick with this, your money will be better spent buying a life long tool, so look for used or just buy new powermatic. That brings up a point which makes me curious. I can see where on occasion something wider than 6" would be useful. But I suspect it depends on what is being built -- isn't that the nature of the work, getting the correct tool? For instance, if one were building dining room tables a 12" might be more suitable. But for, say, a dresser top or other furniture top a 6" would seem plenty wide. Of course if I were doing modern floor planks even a 4" could do that task. Then again a plank floor of repurposed lumber often seems to be 10" or wider. This became a question to me when I was chatting at WookWerks. I was told that hardly anyone buys an 8". It seems 6" is the ubiquitous machine. From my observations, albeit as a novice, it seems to cover a very high percentage of the work done. What remains is task-dependent, imnsho. Therefore, examine your tasks and your plans before spending money. Quote
Da Hammer Posted March 22, 2016 Author Report Posted March 22, 2016 So here is my reasoning on the jointer and Planer I have a barn full of pine and oak fence boards I tore out of my farm about 10 years ago. They were outside but are very nice boards rough cut boards. However to use them I need to nock the wear off them. I have probably 1,000 fence boards and posts so it would save me money in the long run to use these boards. I don't want to sound bad here but I really don't have a budget per say. I would like to keep the jointer under 1,500 but that's not firm if I am convinced I need something. Since I have never used a jointer I was hesitant to by the 8" and a year from now discover I didn't need it as much as I thought. As far as projects I am finishing the interior of my shop today so my first project will be to build shop cabinets for it. Then I have a coffee table and end table planned. I am really just going to start building things, not any one type of things just want the ability to build stuff that looks as good as I can make it and not be limited by what I have in the shop to get the desired result. Hope that makes sense? Quote
Janello Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 59 minutes ago, collinb said: That brings up a point which makes me curious. I can see where on occasion something wider than 6" would be useful. But I suspect it depends on what is being built -- isn't that the nature of the work, getting the correct tool? I have a 6" jointer and really wish for an 8" and 12" would be even better if I had the room and budget. Here's one example why. I just paid big bucks for a 8" wide pc of cocobolo that I want to cut a veneer from. The veneer I need is only 2" wide at most, and if I had a larger jointer I would then still have a nice size usable veneer left over. Besides that, it's 8/4 and I wouldn't need to rip it down and lose 2 inches of potential width for another project (unforseen) just for 1 slice of veneer. I run into this kind of thing A LOT and it's discouraging that I can resaw 18", plane 20", drum sand 24" but my first step in milling kills me with a 6" max. My next machine is a bigger jointer! Quote
..Kev Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 I have a 6" PM and never want for an 8".. To me, all this whining over the extra 2 inches is hog wash.. 99% of the time, the 6 is plenty. On the rare occasion that I run into wider material, I have a drum sander, hand tools, etc to take care of it. Quote
minorhero Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 So this is really helpful and it does make sense. My first thought is to wonder if your wood is still good. Depending on the age of the barn, whether it was treated for termites, and how the wood has been stored will determine an awful lot. Assuming it's in good shape then you need a good hand held metal detector and a strong bristle brush. If a single nail goes through your planer or jointer it will ruin your whole day. Also that wood will be filthy, you will want to brush it pretty thoroughly before milling. The width of your boards will determine what jointer you buy. If they are under 6" wide then a 6" jointer is fine. If they are larger then 6 but generally less then 8 then the 8" is the way to go. Keep in mind you are going to need a dust collector no matter what you buy and budget accordingly. You are not going to want to cut these boards down to less then there present width of you can help it as it would be a real pain if they are all warpy. But ifor you do the best way to do it is on a bandsaw that has a fence. So if you go with a jointer narrower then most of your boards you may also wish to budget a 14" bandsaw as well. This could be done with a jigsaw as well but could get old real quick when processing a lot of lumber. Quote
Cliff Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 8 minutes ago, TIODS said: I have a 6" PM and never want for an 8".. To me, all this whining over the extra 2 inches is hog wash.. 99% of the time, the 6 is plenty. On the rare occasion that I run into wider material, I have a drum sander, hand tools, etc to take care of it. For us nooblets starting out though, we don't have drum sanders and hand tools to do it. I know eventually I will buy those things but I'm still at least a year away on a drum sander I think. I'm glad I got an 8" and wish I had 16. Cause why the heck not?! I have two boards I can't joint on my jointer now, so I have to find alternative means. Makes me sad. Quote
..Kev Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 Run both sides thru your planer and then square up the edges. 1 Quote
Cliff Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 4 minutes ago, TIODS said: Run both sides thru your planer and then square up the edges. This is probably what I'll do. I have a 13" planer, and the boards are 14", but I think it will come out to about 13" or less of usable width. If I end up wider - well.. been planning to get a router sled going for end-grain cutting boards anyway! Quote
..Kev Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 Just now, Cliff said: This is probably what I'll do. I have a 13" planer, and the boards are 14", but I think it will come out to about 13" or less of usable width. If I end up wider - well.. been planning to get a router sled going for end-grain cutting boards anyway! You're not thinking of running end grain cutting boards thru the planer are you? My point was that there's always a way to get those boards flat. If you're building a lot of large stuff and running those kinds of boards often then, yes the larger jointer makes sense. The bulk of us hobby folks rarely really have a need for a jointer that size. If you have the space and money and want it, go for it. Who am I to tell you how to spend your money. However, it isn't a "need" for most shops. Quote
Cliff Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 9 minutes ago, TIODS said: You're not thinking of running end grain cutting boards thru the planer are you? Heck no sir. That's what I was saying, going to build the router sled for end grain cutting boards anyway, so if I can get that set up right I can joint the face on my slabs with it. 1 Quote
Da Hammer Posted March 22, 2016 Author Report Posted March 22, 2016 59 minutes ago, minorhero said: So this is really helpful and it does make sense. My first thought is to wonder if your wood is still good. Depending on the age of the barn, whether it was treated for termites, and how the wood has been stored will determine an awful lot. Assuming it's in good shape then you need a good hand held metal detector and a strong bristle brush. If a single nail goes through your planer or jointer it will ruin your whole day. Also that wood will be filthy, you will want to brush it pretty thoroughly before milling. The width of your boards will determine what jointer you buy. If they are under 6" wide then a 6" jointer is fine. If they are larger then 6 but generally less then 8 then the 8" is the way to go. Keep in mind you are going to need a dust collector no matter what you buy and budget accordingly. You are not going to want to cut these boards down to less then there present width of you can help it as it would be a real pain if they are all warpy. But ifor you do the best way to do it is on a bandsaw that has a fence. So if you go with a jointer narrower then most of your boards you may also wish to budget a 14" bandsaw as well. This could be done with a jigsaw as well but could get old real quick when processing a lot of lumber. All of the boards I kept are still good and no termites at this time, I treat the area regularly. They have been kept with stickers between and are in good shape and all under 6" so I think they are useable but they are dirty. I also pulled all of the nails out of them years ago. I already have DC covered I ran pipes for that in my wall when building over the last two weeks and have that ready to go just need the tools. So with a $1,500 budget (or so..) I don't think I need an 8" jointer but could be convinced otherwise. Is there a big difference in brands? (also I have options of either 220 or 110, would prefer 220). Hope I am providing enough info now? Quote
Guest Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 1 hour ago, TIODS said: I have a 6" PM and never want for an 8".. To me, all this whining over the extra 2 inches is hog wash.. 99% of the time, the 6 is plenty. On the rare occasion that I run into wider material, I have a drum sander, hand tools, etc to take care of it. I agree 100%. I have the same jointer and I never miss the extra 2". I won't be upgrading until I have the $ and space for a 12" jointer. Quote
..Kev Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 I have the Powermatic 6" with the long beds and have been super happy with it. It's also within your budget. Quote
collinb Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 1 hour ago, Janello said: I have a 6" jointer and really wish for an 8" and 12" would be even better if I had the room and budget. Here's one example why. I just paid big bucks for a 8" wide pc of cocobolo that I want to cut a veneer from. The veneer I need is only 2" wide at most, and if I had a larger jointer I would then still have a nice size usable veneer left over. Besides that, it's 8/4 and I wouldn't need to rip it down and lose 2 inches of potential width for another project (unforseen) just for 1 slice of veneer. I run into this kind of thing A LOT and it's discouraging that I can resaw 18", plane 20", drum sand 24" but my first step in milling kills me with a 6" max. My next machine is a bigger jointer! Gotcha. Equipment is chosen for the task. Quote
..Kev Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 2 hours ago, Janello said: I have a 6" jointer and really wish for an 8" and 12" would be even better if I had the room and budget. Here's one example why. I just paid big bucks for a 8" wide pc of cocobolo that I want to cut a veneer from. The veneer I need is only 2" wide at most, and if I had a larger jointer I would then still have a nice size usable veneer left over. Besides that, it's 8/4 and I wouldn't need to rip it down and lose 2 inches of potential width for another project (unforseen) just for 1 slice of veneer. I run into this kind of thing A LOT and it's discouraging that I can resaw 18", plane 20", drum sand 24" but my first step in milling kills me with a 6" max. My next machine is a bigger jointer! With the tools listed, there's still not a "need" for an aircraft carrier of a jointer. The drum sander would do just fine to clean up between cuts. Like I said, it you want it, can afford it, then it's your shop and your money. Go for it. Quote
Guest Posted March 22, 2016 Report Posted March 22, 2016 11 minutes ago, collinb said: Gotcha. Equipment is chosen for the task. Yes but most of us hobbyists do a wide range of tasks so our equipment can't be overly specialized. I build every thing from small end tables to full size dining tables and have a large armoire on my to-do list. We need to choose a suite of equipment that will handle most tasks. For most tasks, a 6" jointer is the minimum and that has worked for me. Lots of folks think an 8" is the minimum. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.