Seth Clayton Posted January 3, 2017 Report Posted January 3, 2017 I would love to have a jointer. I absolutely cannot afford a freestanding unit. Are the benchtop units worth having at all? I have a router table, table saw, and planer. I'm also getting a MFT. Should I just work on combining the features of those tools to joint boards instead of the benchtop jointer? Quote
gee-dub Posted January 3, 2017 Report Posted January 3, 2017 I would strongly recommend against the benchtop planer for anything other than very small hobby craft. I tried to make one work, thought that I was special and could wrangle some performance out of a benchtop jointer that others had been unable to accomplish . . . i was wrong and just lost money when I sold it ;-) You sir, are in luck. Since you have a planer, you can make a sled in a few hours and have the benefits of a jointer with much more capacity than a benchtop would give you. I made this one before lunch one Saturday, years ago, and still use it a few time a year when I over step my 8" jointer's capacity. The ShopNotes Issue 137 version is much more refined and not much more involved to make. I would still consider 60" to be the shortest I would bother with a sled unless I was going to have a 60" and a 30" or something like that. Certainly not as nice as a large jointer but, a lot better than a benchtop jointer. Quote
Llama Posted January 3, 2017 Report Posted January 3, 2017 Save your MFT dorrah, and buy teh Jointer. 1 Quote
Seth Clayton Posted January 3, 2017 Author Report Posted January 3, 2017 3 minutes ago, Llama said: Save your MFT dorrah, and buy teh Jointer. Received the MFT as a gift, so I'm gonna keep it! Quote
Llama Posted January 3, 2017 Report Posted January 3, 2017 Just now, Seth Clayton said: Received the MFT as a gift, so I'm gonna keep it! Well, that's different. Maybe you can scour Craigslist for a decent jointer. I bought a 60s Powermatic for around $300. Deals are out there if you know how things work. Most repairs are simple if needed. Quote
Seth Clayton Posted January 3, 2017 Author Report Posted January 3, 2017 11 minutes ago, gee-dub said: I would strongly recommend against the benchtop planer for anything other than very small hobby craft. I tried to make one work, thought that I was special and could wrangle some performance out of a benchtop jointer that others had been unable to accomplish . . . i was wrong and just lost money when I sold it ;-) You sir, are in luck. Since you have a planer, you can make a sled in a few hours and have the benefits of a jointer with much more capacity than a benchtop would give you. I made this one before lunch one Saturday, years ago, and still use it a few time a year when I over step my 8" jointer's capacity. The ShopNotes Issue 137 version is much more refined and not much more involved to make. I would still consider 60" to be the shortest I would bother with a sled unless I was going to have a 60" and a 30" or something like that. Certainly not as nice as a large jointer but, a lot better than a benchtop jointer. ShopNotes...is there a way to see those plans online, or do I need to find an old print issue? Thanks for the advice! I think I'll be making one of these sleds I did find this in my local Craigslist: http://indianapolis.craigslist.org/tls/5942967118.html Anyone used one of these? Quote
Llama Posted January 3, 2017 Report Posted January 3, 2017 14 minutes ago, Seth Clayton said: Anyone used one of these? Not that particular one... For the most part, it's very similar to anything in that price range. Take a look at it... Make sure you can buy replacement knives for it, make sure it's functional... Take a board with you to test... Quote
21meyer Posted January 3, 2017 Report Posted January 3, 2017 If you have the space, which it seems like you do if you are adding an MFT, do not even consider a bench top jointer. Keep checking your local market for a used floor standing model. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Quote
gee-dub Posted January 3, 2017 Report Posted January 3, 2017 39 minutes ago, Seth Clayton said: ShopNotes...is there a way to see those plans online, or do I need to find an old print issue? Check your messages ;-) Quote
Pete Staehling Posted January 4, 2017 Report Posted January 4, 2017 20 hours ago, Seth Clayton said: I would love to have a jointer. I absolutely cannot afford a freestanding unit. Are the benchtop units worth having at all? I have a router table, table saw, and planer. I'm also getting a MFT. Should I just work on combining the features of those tools to joint boards instead of the benchtop jointer? Are they worth it at all? As with most things the answer is a big "it depends". I find my 6" Shop Fox bench top to be perfect for my work. I put it on it's own stand rather than work on a bench top and I typically cut all my stock into shorter lengths before jointing. Since my work all involves short-ish (<5') pieces and I don't need to work wide stock. Given the size of my work, I don't even lust after bigger models. On the other hand if you need to work with long pieces that can't be first cut to shorter length or need to joint wider faces it may be frustrating to have the length/width restrictions of a bench top. Quote
Seth Clayton Posted January 4, 2017 Author Report Posted January 4, 2017 5 hours ago, Pete Staehling said: Are they worth it at all? As with most things the answer is a big "it depends". I find my 6" Shop Fox bench top to be perfect for my work. I put it on it's own stand rather than work on a bench top and I typically cut all my stock into shorter lengths before jointing. Since my work all involves short-ish (<5') pieces and I don't need to work wide stock. Given the size of my work, I don't even lust after bigger models. On the other hand if you need to work with long pieces that can't be first cut to shorter length or need to joint wider faces it may be frustrating to have the length/width restrictions of a bench top. What are the average widths of the faces that you're working with? Quote
Al Capwn Posted January 4, 2017 Report Posted January 4, 2017 I just sold an old Delta 6" 37-280 benchtop jointer. It was okay. It was belt driven, so that was nice. The newer ones are direct drive and sound about as loud as the lunchbox planers. The benchtop prevented me from working with any stock of significant length. Chest of drawers, tables, bedframes, bookshelves; anything large in scale was pretty much out of the question. If it wasn't for the fact that I got it for dirt cheap at the time, I would have been pretty upset. I recently just bit the bullet and purchased a 6" Powermatic. I can tell you from the extremely limited experience after setup and a few test pieces that the experience is MILES different. To me, the immediate feeling is like the difference between using a circular saw vs a table saw. Much quieter, no snipe, and much more stable due to more reference surface and mass. Save your money - get a full size jointer, even if is one of the smaller Grizzly units. A cheap benchtop is $250 - a budget Grizzly floorstander is ~$500-600 brand new. You may find used full-size jointers used for $300-$400 in your local Craigslist. Quote
Pete Staehling Posted January 5, 2017 Report Posted January 5, 2017 5 hours ago, Seth Clayton said: What are the average widths of the faces that you're working with? It varies, but generally 4-6" . I do often start with wider stock, but generally rip it to 6" or less first. My real work is travel sized mountain dulcimers that are most often about 4" wide. I do other projects like small boxes and other small projects. I build dulcimer stands, capos, and other small stuff for my customers. I do some wider book matched stuff, but then the halves of the pair are less than 6" Quote
gee-dub Posted January 5, 2017 Report Posted January 5, 2017 13 hours ago, Pete Staehling said: It varies, but generally 4-6" . I do often start with wider stock, but generally rip it to 6" or less first. My real work is travel sized mountain dulcimers that are most often about 4" wide. I do other projects like small boxes and other small projects. I build dulcimer stands, capos, and other small stuff for my customers. I do some wider book matched stuff, but then the halves of the pair are less than 6" This is a great example of where recommendations in general (buy an 8" or larger) do not apply. Consider the things you are going to make. Better yet, make a few items with work-arounds to get a better idea of what you really need to do what you want. The journey is half the fun. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.