rodger. Posted February 12, 2017 Report Posted February 12, 2017 Where is Bill Nye when you need him Quote
Mark J Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 3 hours ago, Randy Thurman-Keup said: The constellations will appear in the same location at the same time once a year. If you want an experiment, consider yourself to be the earth, and your table saw to be the sun (assuming you have a table saw and assuming it is in the middle of your shop). Now orbit yourself around it making sure you always face away from it (as though it was always midnightish) and notice what parts of your shop you see (your shop being the stars). If you execute this maneuver without tripping over something, you should see different parts of your shop until you return to the place you started. Congratulations, you are one year older. and if you don't execute the maneuver without tripping you will "see stars". So it's win win. Actually I think this was an interesting question and I believe Randy Thurman-Keup is right. However, consider that there are actually 365.25 days in an earth year, but we let that fact go until leap year. So the position of the constellations will not be in the same place at exactly the same date and time each year, but should be so, give or take a few leap seconds, every 4 years. 1 Quote
Randy Thurman-Keup Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 and if you don't execute the maneuver without tripping you will "see stars". So it's win win. Actually I think this was an interesting question and I believe Randy Thurman-Keup is right. However, consider that there are actually 365.25 days in an earth year, but we let that fact go until leap year. So the position of the constellations will not be in the same place at exactly the same date and time each year, but should be so, give or take a few leap seconds, every 4 years. That's right. It would slip by approximately 1 degree over the 4 years between leap years. For reference, the full moon is 1/2 degree. 1 Quote
Randy Thurman-Keup Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 According to a group of modern "scientists", the universe is flat, a two-dimensional hologram, and there is no "above". Orion is not above your driveway, it never was, it never will be. One of the experimental tests of this was carried out at the national lab where I work. They didn't find any evidence for it. Quote
M Robertson Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 This is one of those things I would never worry about. Unless I lived in Australia. If you are in Australia and Orion is rising over your driveway, something is terribly wrong. 2 Quote
Marmotjr Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 On 2/9/2017 at 8:25 PM, Rex Edgar said: Is it correct to expect the constellations to be in the same place at the same time each year or season? The reason for my question is that a few years ago I noticed Orion (my most recognizable one) directly above my driveway when retrieving the morning paper at approximately 0500 in the morning. Now it appears in the same place, but at approximately 2000 hrs in the evening. I did notice a change when Daylight Saving went into effect. All the previous debate aside, as the technically correct answer is there, but yes, annually, to the naked eye, without precision instruments to notice the minute offset of the constellations, the constellations will line up in the same place every year, at the same day and time of day. This is how all those ancient calendars were made, they based the calendar off the movements and locations of celestial objects. You will notice Orion rising pre dawn late in the summer, early fall, and in winter it will be overhead during the late evening, as spring rolls around, it will rise later and later in the evening, eventually not rising (to the naked eye) again till the early fall. So it depends on the time of the year, and the time of day as to where Orion will be in the sky. Orion, and it's neighbor's, has always been one of my favorite things to observe, with and without a scope. The stars on the belt are all double stars, helping them standout against the rest of the star field. The middle star of his sword is actually a large nebula, bright red/purple in color, but it's too diffuse to be noticed with the naked eye. Get a good zoom lens and take a 30-60 second exposure of the sword and you'll see the nebula pop right out. And the Pleiades, aka The Seven Sisters, are right next door. They are a star cluster with 7 prominent stars in them, with a good clear sky, you can count all 7 with the naked eye, but they really shine with a small scope or good binoculars, the whole cluster pops then. On 2/9/2017 at 11:22 PM, Brendon_t said: For this reason Vega is not always our North Star. Sometimes it's Rigel and others is Beetlejuice. And most of the time in recorded history, it's been Polaris. 1 Quote
Marmotjr Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 4 hours ago, Randy Thurman-Keup said: Immortan D said: According to a group of modern "scientists", the universe is flat, a two-dimensional hologram, and there is no "above". Orion is not above your driveway, it never was, it never will be. 4 hours ago, Randy Thurman-Keup said: One of the experimental tests of this was carried out at the national lab where I work. They didn't find any evidence for it. They haven't found much evidence against it either. There are conflicting theories both ways, all with supporting data. In time, it will get worked out. "Above" is a relative term. If I have to raise my head to look at something, it is above me. If I have to look down, it is below me. As Ender said (or actually Bean did I think), "The enemie's gate is down". 7 hours ago, Mark J said: Actually I think this was an interesting question and I believe Randy Thurman-Keup is right. However, consider that there are actually 365.25 days in an earth year, but we let that fact go until leap year. So the position of the constellations will not be in the same place at exactly the same date and time each year, but should be so, give or take a few leap seconds, every 4 years. It's actually 365.241blahblahblah days. The Julian calendar (implemented in 45 AD I believe) had a leap year every four years to account for the drift. But Pope Gregory (et al), noticed that was causing the calendar to drift off some, even with the leap days, as they were adding too many days. So he installed the Gregorian calendar in 1582, and they skipped October 5 through the 14th to make up for lost time. England didn't use the calendar till 1752, and they skipped even more days that September, which is why George Washington's birthday is a little hazy. What made the Gregorian more effective than the Julian, is that years that are whole century marks, there is no leap day, unless the year is evenly divisible by 400. So the years 1800, 1900, and 2100 all do not have leap days, but the year 2000 did. 2 Quote
Timbo Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 Julian calendar was introduced in 46 BC and commenced in 45 BC...on the Tuesday, as the Monday was a Bank Holiday and Wednesday was Half Day Closing. 1 Quote
Pondhockey Posted February 14, 2017 Report Posted February 14, 2017 20 hours ago, M Robertson said: This is one of those things I would never worry about. Unless I lived in Australia. If you are in Australia and Orion is rising over your driveway, something is terribly wrong. Most probably too much Victorian Bitter last night. ;-) Quote
Brendon_t Posted February 14, 2017 Report Posted February 14, 2017 Nowe the you go. Breaking up a perfectly good bs fest with pseudo facts. 1 Quote
Pondhockey Posted February 14, 2017 Report Posted February 14, 2017 1 hour ago, Brendon_t said: Nowe the you go. Breaking up a perfectly good bs fest with pseudo facts. But don't you mean "alternative" facts ?-) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.